Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider a deferral for dc1 because it is unfair for her to be the youngest in her year while her little sister will be the oldest in her year?

402 replies

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 10:42

Hello
I have two dcs, one born in 19/7/2020 and the other in 2/9/2022.
First dc is due to enter Reception in Sept 2024 at 4 +2 months due to state cut off, and the second will be due in Sept 2027 at 5 yo.

I feel like it is unfair for dc1 to be expected to act/ achieve at a level of 3 years ahead of dc2 when she is practically only 2 years older than dc2. Dc1 has ASD while dc2 is very likely NT, which adds to that.

I am considering a deferral for dc1 mainly because of this reason, which DH thinks is ridiculous.

Any ideas on whether I should defer dc1?

For some context both dcs are academically bright, but dc1 is really babyish compared to other 3 yo and dc2 seems more mature than other 1yo.

OP posts:
Sarahi1234 · 26/09/2023 16:40

Game the system 🤯🤯🤯 or maybe just give their child a chance to thrive instead of just about getting by?!

if a system is so fundamentally flawed that it uses a line in the sand so to speak to determine which year a child goes into, then of course parents should take any opportunity they can for their kid to perform at their best.

Ultimately I don’t care if my kid ends up in a highly academic profession, or the corporate world, or in a trade, so long as they are happy. And deferring gave her the chance to interact with her peers, not be fighting both socially and academically tp keep up, and make friends and therefore start the formative years of her life off happy. Which is so definitely the most important thing for her.

But it’s totally individual. From my nct cohort (all aug born) 4 went to school age just 4. 2 did amazingly. 2 really struggled. And 2 of us deferred and wouldn’t ever have done differently.

but NOONE is trying to game the system. We just want happy kids.

MargaretThursday · 26/09/2023 16:40

I have 3 dc. At the time of starting:
Dd1 (winter baby) was ready to start school; it was pretty much the right time for her.
DD2 (winter baby) I felt would have been better in the year above. She could have done with the challenge sooner, and then was bored.
Ds (summer baby) was probably about ready to start school around Easter in year 1.

They all started at the right time.

If I'd been able to choose then I would have put dd2 in early, and ds in at least a year late.
They're now 6th form or older and I can tell you that it would have been the wrong decision.

Bertiesmum3 · 26/09/2023 16:42

Send her when she’s meant to go, or she’ll be behind the rest of her age group

LuluBlakey1 · 26/09/2023 16:43

DS1 (Dec baby) was ready for school, and loved it from day 1. Is doing really well.
DD (April baby) worried me because she was quite a challenging toddler - wouldn't wear anything but shorts or dungarees from aged 2, fussy eater, outright refuser where it suited her. I thought we'd not even get her into a uniform. Has loved being at school- not refused to do a single thing.
DS2 (End of July baby) really worried us and we considered deferring his place for a year. He seemed so much younger than the other 2 were, much less independent and needed much more support while at nursery. We let him go because his friends were going in the end and held our breath, expecting phone calls, tears possibly meltdowns, teacher at gate wanting to talk to us. So far the only issue has been he likes a nap sometimes and has twice taken himself off for a nap on the reading rug. Apart from that there have been no issues and he has really developed in the last almost 4 weeks. He's noticeably more independent. I'm not worried about him academically- he likes to learn things and it's very early days. He's made new friends, has settled well and likes it. That's all that matters just now. We're not comparing him with DS1 and DD.

anomaly2 · 26/09/2023 16:51

Lookingforasilverlining · 26/09/2023 10:55

You need to decide what is in the best interests of DD2. For most summer born children deferral is in their best interests.

Have a read of this

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/182664/DFE-RR017.pdf

Doesn't this effectively just move the cut off earlier in the year meaning just a different group born in an earlier month who are now the youngest? There will always be those who are the youngest

jazzyfips · 26/09/2023 17:03

I have august and September children and they just went into the year group they were supposed to.

Bunnycat101 · 26/09/2023 17:04

Ignore your second child. There is enough of a gap that they’re unlikely to be comparing. But, I would seriously consider it for an immature July born child with ASD.

I have one summer and one spring. The summer born was more than ready for school, very tall, very bright etc but she was in a year where 70% of the children were autumn born with 90% of the girls September to November. She really felt the difference especially for things like colouring, fine motor skills. A really little 4yo would have really struggled with confidence in that cohort for a few years.

My spring born child has just started and while she is older she’s actually much littler and the transition to school has been harder. However, her cohort is evenly distributed re birthdays and actually she fits in absolutely perfectly so she doesn’t really stand out as being any different to the others.

So.. I think it’s important to consider the individual child but also consider the cohort if that is possible (not sure at what point the decision would need to be made).

ChateauMargaux · 26/09/2023 17:05

So many replies... I am probably repeating what others have said. ..

My DS was an August born... no deferral possible. Bright child was but has always been younger than everyone else. He is now at university and Is still very young compared to all of his peers. Starting primary school was really hard.. as was starting secondary. University went well.

DD is October born, being a girl and being second born all work in her favour. Being a girl.... not so much in her subjects of choice, Maths and Science, despite girls outperforming boys overall until quite recently but she is doing very well.

Statistics show that autumn borns outperform summer borns into and beyond university and all the way through school.

PlateLady · 26/09/2023 17:05

Based on personal experience I think it’s a good idea to defer.

I am summer born and autistic too… my mum decided against holding me back a year and has always regretted it as I really struggled through school. (I remember hating every single day and left feeling I was stupid. Although went on to do very well at University.)

My ASD daughter was Feb born so we couldn’t defer (I think the earliest is a May born child.) Anyway she really struggled and we had to remove her from school to Home Ed in the end.

I was always emotionally and developmentally behind due to the ASD and being the youngest in the case really added to that.

I’ve a few friends who have deferred over the years and not one of them has regretted it. Yet some who didn’t do it now regret not doing it.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 26/09/2023 17:07

I would make your decision as though dc2 isn’t in the picture. Imagine she’s an only child and make your decision on that basis.

If it’s any help, she won’t be the youngest in her class born mid July. There’ll likely be a good two or three children younger than her, born late July or in August.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 26/09/2023 17:09

But in the end yanbu to consider it - or do it - if it’s the right thing for your child.

I always wished I could have send my October born dc1 to school a year earlier!

Buttercupsdaisiesdandelions · 26/09/2023 17:09

In the same situation, we deferred DC1 and didn't regret it. That said, although both DC1 and DC2 were bright, DC1s fine motor skills were below average. Even with deferring he struggled with writing, so it was better for him to be deferred.

ThanksItHasPockets · 26/09/2023 17:10

There are plenty of valid reasons to defer a summer-born child but honestly OP I don't see any in your posts. Stop comparing your children. Do not underestimate how dull it is for a reasonably able child to be held back for another year of pre-school.

StillWantingADog · 26/09/2023 17:11

If you think one child has a specific need for deferring then fine but don’t do it just because the older child is the oldest in her year!

loads of us have a mix of children older and younger in their years

fwiw I considered deferring my august born but I am so glad I didn’t. It’s very difficult to make the call when they are not yet 4 but a good proportion of them will be absolutely fine. I throughly believe that my ds who was tiny and socially quite immature when he started school, would have eventually found it disadvantageous to be held back

stichguru · 26/09/2023 17:12

Considering deferral for DC1 is quite possibly a good idea. However it should be absolutely NOTHING to do with her sister. DC1 and DC2 will achieve what they are capable of in their own time at their own pace. If DC1 needs more time to get to where she is going that is fine, but it is nothing to do with how much time DC2 needs to get to where she is going.

Tryingmybestadhd · 26/09/2023 17:14

deferring is almost the norm here in Scotland in that situation . In fact there is only one child that went to p1 who was born before February after their 4 th birthday and she is in fact behind the others . Personally I would defer

StillWantingADog · 26/09/2023 17:16

Tryingmybestadhd · 26/09/2023 17:14

deferring is almost the norm here in Scotland in that situation . In fact there is only one child that went to p1 who was born before February after their 4 th birthday and she is in fact behind the others . Personally I would defer

While it comes up on these boards a lot it is still very rare in England.
I’m not aware of a single child in our primary school who is deferred.

Downtherivers · 26/09/2023 17:16

There were 2 children at my secondary school who should have been in the year above but their parents held them back a year (as you are suggesting). I cannot recall their names, or even really what they looked like, but I can remember they were ridiculed daily for not being in the right year. I would not inflict that on my children, and definitely not without very good reason (which yours aren't)

Ohhbaby · 26/09/2023 17:16

I always advise parents to defer, you deprive your child of a year of play and all the crucial development that comes with it.

I think your phrasing might come off as weird. As if you're keeping one back because of the other.
I think the way your dc were born just made you think about it more, like it brought the difference of what 1 year can mean to light.

Maybe rephrase for dh?

TiredyMcTired · 26/09/2023 17:16

I would advise deferring. My DS is a very late August birthday, so he had only just turned 4 when he had to start school. He’s also neurodivergent, and immature for his age.

We wanted to defer his school place but we were strong armed into it by the LA (very very long story) who said they wouldn’t hold his place for him. Given everything that has happened since and how much he has struggled throughout school, I wish we had stood our ground. He’s in year 11 now and has never caught up with his peers.

Do what is best for your daughter, only you know what will be the right course of action.

ThinWomansBrain · 26/09/2023 17:18

@HowcanIhelp123 makes a fair point about A levels - although that probablt seems a long way offy
I wasn't deferred on starting reasons, but effectively missed a year when I left home at 16. I then did a 2 year course at an FE college for O levels, A levels and a BTEC - I had to pay tuition fees for the second year because I was a "mature student"
Being told you're old hurts at any age - let alone at 19, as did paying fees.

OliveWah · 26/09/2023 17:25

If you're not going to ensure your child is in the correct year group for their age before Year 3, you need to be much more aware of the issues that will arise for them. Imagine as a 16 year old they feel pissed off with you (and the whole situation), because they could have been finished with their GCSEs, but still have to do another year? They'll always be known by their peers as "the kid who was kept back a year", and as much as you might like to hope it won't happen, the other kids will think it's strange. Because it is. It's like you're putting their lives on pause for a year.

BlippiIsAnnoying · 26/09/2023 17:28

I find this very interesting. First born was 8 weeks premature, should have been October born. We didn't defer but I wish we had as he's so anxious compared to his peers. School say that's improving but I feel so sad for him when I see the older more confident kids ignoring him.

AimeeD13 · 26/09/2023 17:28

I think it would be a huge mistake, my birthday is also July and I excelled in school. If anything, I think it’ll benefit her to be around older children and as you say she’s bright it seems incredibly odd to make a life altering decision now.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 26/09/2023 17:29

StillWantingADog · 26/09/2023 17:16

While it comes up on these boards a lot it is still very rare in England.
I’m not aware of a single child in our primary school who is deferred.

Scotland is very different to England though, as the usual cut off is half way through the school year, as I understand it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread