Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider a deferral for dc1 because it is unfair for her to be the youngest in her year while her little sister will be the oldest in her year?

402 replies

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 10:42

Hello
I have two dcs, one born in 19/7/2020 and the other in 2/9/2022.
First dc is due to enter Reception in Sept 2024 at 4 +2 months due to state cut off, and the second will be due in Sept 2027 at 5 yo.

I feel like it is unfair for dc1 to be expected to act/ achieve at a level of 3 years ahead of dc2 when she is practically only 2 years older than dc2. Dc1 has ASD while dc2 is very likely NT, which adds to that.

I am considering a deferral for dc1 mainly because of this reason, which DH thinks is ridiculous.

Any ideas on whether I should defer dc1?

For some context both dcs are academically bright, but dc1 is really babyish compared to other 3 yo and dc2 seems more mature than other 1yo.

OP posts:
Namechangenoidea · 26/09/2023 14:41

I actually think if you held your eldest back you are doing them a disservice in life and taking away a whole year from them. A whole year of making money/building their career.

CarrotsAndCheese · 26/09/2023 14:42

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 13:53

Well of course she didn't read them all by herself; I read them to her and she gives me reactions like she understands

😂 Erm, that's not reading!

And calling a 12 month old mature is ridiculous!

FWIW, I was the youngest in my year. I was actually ahead academically throughout school. I found it hard to socialise but I think that was for other reasons than my age. For example, I didn't go to nursery, so missed out on joining the friendship groups that were formed there. So I'm not convinced that deferring would help with socialisation and might make it worse.

I also think that personality is a big factor in how easily children settle in and make friends.

Personally, I would have been annoyed if I'd been held back as I was ready to do more academically challenging work. I would hope that good teachers would be able to set tasks that can be differentiated according to different abilities within the class, thereby stretching the most able while supporting the least able to catch up. That's what happens in secondary schools, at least.

Are you 100% sure that the primary schools near you will allow you to defer and still enter Reception? Our local primary school will allow you to defer but then your child absolutely must enter Year 1.

Fair enough, defer if you think it is best for your child (without comparing to siblings) but do it based on a sound reason such as the ASD you mentioned and be as sure as you can be that the extra year will actually make it easier for them.

seashellsocean · 26/09/2023 14:43

Namechangenoidea · 26/09/2023 14:41

I actually think if you held your eldest back you are doing them a disservice in life and taking away a whole year from them. A whole year of making money/building their career.

A whole year of childhood on the other hand

FrizzledFrazzle · 26/09/2023 14:52

I think people are being distracted by the idea that you would defer DD1 because it is not fair to her in some way compared to her sister to be one of the youngest in the year.

From reading your posts, I think it is more that by looking at your two children, you can see that DD1 is struggling with social learning and communication compared with her sister?

In your position, I think I would defer her. Her nursery have said that they don't feel she is socially ready for school and you have noticed that she generally plays alone, is very shy and that her communication skills are similar to those of her 1yo sister. I think by deferring her, she will have more time to develop the social/emotional/language skills needed to thrive both socially and academically in school, and to gain confidence in a safe environment (her nursery school) so that the transition to reception feels less overwhelming for her.

To posters saying an extra year won't make her grow out of having ASD - no, of course it won't. But autism doesn't mean that she won't continue to progress with developing (say) emotional regulation and communication skills over the next year. And if that means the skills gap between her and her peers is reduced when she does start reception, that will only help her thrive in the school environment.

BrieAndChilli · 26/09/2023 15:00

No - I think if she had been held back in nursery for another year she would have got bored.

My eldest has ASD and is one of the eldest in his year. he is also extremely clever eg when he was 4 he was assessed by the educational psychologist as having a reading age of 14+. being the oldest and more able than the others has meant he struggled even more socially as he did not want to run around the playground etc. - he would probably have been better to have been a younger one in the year as he would have kept up academically and been with children more mature than him.

But every child is different so my experiences wont apply to other children.

Whilst being the youngest and struggling with the school work is not fun for anyone it doesnt sound like your DD would struggle so holding her back another year will mean she will be even less stretched at school, be very bored and possibly then coast and not learn to work hard - which will not serve her well at secondary school.

Prinnny · 26/09/2023 15:07

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 12:06

dc1 won't be missing reception even if she had deferred

What year will she miss then? As surely she’ll have to be placed with her actual age group at some point?

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 15:08

Prinnny · 26/09/2023 15:07

What year will she miss then? As surely she’ll have to be placed with her actual age group at some point?

No she would stay with her actual age group

OP posts:
sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 15:08

Prinnny · 26/09/2023 15:07

What year will she miss then? As surely she’ll have to be placed with her actual age group at some point?

sorry I meant the younger age group

OP posts:
Prinnny · 26/09/2023 15:10

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 15:08

No she would stay with her actual age group

She won’t stay in the year group below forever, she will have to join the class she is meant to be in at some point?

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 15:10

BrawnWild · 26/09/2023 14:22

Does she have friends? I think she will be sad seeing them going to school and perceiving herself as left behind. She will also have to make a load of new friends and see her original friends in Year 1.

She will also be the oldest in a nursery setting and may want more/older/adult engagement, which they cant be expected to do whilst looking after lots of small ones.

When she is older she might have friends asking why she was kept behind or speculating about why shes older than the rest of the class.

I think you are creating a lot of additional transition periods for her and need to really carefully weigh that up.

No unfortunately she doesnt have any friends and doesnt care about what others are doing

OP posts:
DragonFly98 · 26/09/2023 15:24

Prinnny · 26/09/2023 15:10

She won’t stay in the year group below forever, she will have to join the class she is meant to be in at some point?

No that's not true children stay in the cohort when they love to secondary , they don't just miss a year.

lwaxana · 26/09/2023 15:41

I am very glad that my parents didn't do this with me despite strongly considering it because I was born very prematurely in late July. My partner was in similar situation and also glad to have not have been held back. Other than the issue of arranging for kids to attend summer holiday birthday parties (much easier now with social media!!) there wasn't really a downside for us but lots of upsides (including avoiding several ill-advised curricula changes that affected the year below mine!) I was one of the higher performers academically so age didn't impact that either.

I'd be a little concerned about making a decision that would impact every academic milestone for an entire childhood based on the apparent maturity of a 3 year old with a 1 year old in the house, especially as you say she is academically bright. There is still plenty of time for her to develop and prepare for big school. Perhaps being around kids of her same age and older will help her maturity, as well as being away from the younger sibling for part of the day.

It's worth talking to the school about the range of options, e.g. if she can start with her cohort but later be deferred if it's not working out, or any other options. Or if there is anything you can be doing now to help prepare her. However, teachers are well aware of differences amongst all children due to age and other reasons and know how to differentiate classwork and support. So she won't have to act/achieve at an arbitrary level of 5 year olds. Apparently August is the most common birth month, so she probably won't be the youngest and there will likely be many in her situation.

I understand that you think it's not fair that she has to act older, but conversely she might eventually think it's unfair that her milestones are late, that she wasn't allowed to progress as much beyond her younger sibling (they even might end up in the same classroom if it is a small school that has two year groups in one room; not a problem per se, of course, but wouldn't be expected usually with that age gap and is something a child could resent if they find out it wasn't how it was 'meant' to be), and even a risk that she might eventually take it to mean that you didn't believe in her from an early age. I know that's not it at all, but a teenager might not.

Of course you know your child best, but as others have said it should be completely based on that child and not the relative age or development compared to her sibling. Is it possible to arrange a meeting with the teacher so you don't have this weighing on your mind for so long and you can find out what the range of options are?

mehtivation · 26/09/2023 15:42

DC1 turned 16 last week and is flying in Year 11. DC2 turned 14 in late summer and just started year 10. When they were little I wouldn't have considered deferring no.2 but now I see the detriment of being so young and relatively immature I might do differently if I could - but I think it just means joining school in year 1, not deferring to become the oldest in the following reception class 😥

DC2 will be 15 taking exams whereas DC1 will be 16 and 9 months and it feels really quite unfair but nothing I can do now.

ImInACage · 26/09/2023 15:55

I have two summer borns. My eldest was deferred by a year and started in Reception at age five, because they were very much not ready before then. My youngest was not deferred and thrived. Every child is different. For both of ours, the decision to defer or not was the best decision for them individually. As it is now, eldest is the oldest child in the school and youngest is one of the youngest in their year, yet the youngest is actually working way ahead of where the eldest was at the same stage. If I'd have deferred DC2 just because DC1 was the oldest in their year, I'd have done him a massive disservice.

Sandysandwich · 26/09/2023 15:56

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 15:10

No unfortunately she doesnt have any friends and doesnt care about what others are doing

If she is academically bright, but doesn't care about what others are doing I would be inclined to leave her in her proper year group.
It can be hard having to be held back academically, I was one of the oldest in my year and spent all of primary bored and understimulated and there is no option to skip forwards a year.
And if she isn't noticing or caring what others are doing she is unlikey to notice or care about being less emotionally mature.
Emotional maturity is something she is likely to catch up on and if it does affect her, it will only be for reception. Whereas she will be held back for the entire rest of her education.

Bear2014 · 26/09/2023 15:56

@mehtivation don't feel bad. I took GCSEs at 15, A Levels at 17, graduated with a BSc at 20 and a MSc at 21. It literally never occurred to me that this was anything other than normal until I had kids and encountered all this absolute angst about summer borns and every other middle class family trying to game the system!

ImInACage · 26/09/2023 15:58

mehtivation · 26/09/2023 15:42

DC1 turned 16 last week and is flying in Year 11. DC2 turned 14 in late summer and just started year 10. When they were little I wouldn't have considered deferring no.2 but now I see the detriment of being so young and relatively immature I might do differently if I could - but I think it just means joining school in year 1, not deferring to become the oldest in the following reception class 😥

DC2 will be 15 taking exams whereas DC1 will be 16 and 9 months and it feels really quite unfair but nothing I can do now.

Not necessarily, many start in reception at age five now, they don't just miss that year altogether.

ImInACage · 26/09/2023 16:11

@Prinnny they won't have to miss a year at all. DC1 is the in they year below his chronological cohort and will be moving up to high school next September with them. We double checked and got it in writing from every high school in the area, to be on the safe side. We also had it in writing from admissions when his delay was first approved for Reception. A blanket policy to say that they would have to move up a year at some point is actually be against the law.

Ownedby2kidsandadog · 26/09/2023 16:19

I did this for my youngest. Birthday is a similar time to your dc’s.
Best decision we ever made she is thriving in the year she is in. She was in no way ready to start school at 4. We have just had approval for the deferral to continue into secondary school. I don’t think you can ever regret sending them to school a bit later.

VivaLaVolvo · 26/09/2023 16:19

Lookingforasilverlining · 26/09/2023 10:55

You need to decide what is in the best interests of DD2. For most summer born children deferral is in their best interests.

Have a read of this

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/182664/DFE-RR017.pdf

Would you like to provide any research evidence to back up that view?

DiscoBeat · 26/09/2023 16:21

Having been in that situation, I wouldn't. Our youngest (July birthday) had hearing issues when younger so speech was delayed, we also are pretty sure he has autism (although we've never had a diagnosis). We wanted to defer him starting school but the primary school said if he did he would have to skip Reception and start in Y1. We thought Reception was such an important step that we reluctantly went for starting just after his 4th birthday. He caught up really quickly and ended up leaving with excellent 11+ results. He won the top Excellence prize in Science last year at secondary school out of 200 boys and has never had any issues with starting so young.

ChristopherTalken · 26/09/2023 16:23

VivaLaVolvo · 26/09/2023 16:19

Would you like to provide any research evidence to back up that view?

Its linked.....

letloz · 26/09/2023 16:29

I was the youngest in my year (end aug) but v bright- my mum had thought about deferring, but was really glad she didn't ql as said I would have been bored stiff! So something to consider if you think your eldest is bright
As an aside, how do u have a clue whether a 1 year old is bright or not?!

Mamaduck1978 · 26/09/2023 16:31

Have you spoken with the school and local authority about deferring and what year your daughter would start in? I know for a fact that when I looked into it for my daughter if I’d deferred for a year, when she started the following year it would be into year 1. Also her pre-school wouldn’t take her any longer as she was technically school age. Sending her when she was due to start was the best thing I did.

superninny101 · 26/09/2023 16:35

You really need to look at each child - please don't compare them - that doesn't help. You also need to understand the implications further along the line. A mother who deferred near me has hit a problem at secondary transition where the school she wants her DD to go will not accept deferrals and the DD will have to go in a higher year apparently.

However, with the diagnosis, I would almost certainly delay for a year as your DC1 already has so many challenges ahead of them.