Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To consider a deferral for dc1 because it is unfair for her to be the youngest in her year while her little sister will be the oldest in her year?

402 replies

sunflowerdaisiesroses · 26/09/2023 10:42

Hello
I have two dcs, one born in 19/7/2020 and the other in 2/9/2022.
First dc is due to enter Reception in Sept 2024 at 4 +2 months due to state cut off, and the second will be due in Sept 2027 at 5 yo.

I feel like it is unfair for dc1 to be expected to act/ achieve at a level of 3 years ahead of dc2 when she is practically only 2 years older than dc2. Dc1 has ASD while dc2 is very likely NT, which adds to that.

I am considering a deferral for dc1 mainly because of this reason, which DH thinks is ridiculous.

Any ideas on whether I should defer dc1?

For some context both dcs are academically bright, but dc1 is really babyish compared to other 3 yo and dc2 seems more mature than other 1yo.

OP posts:
MeandT · 27/09/2023 22:47

With my NT August born, that age gap was pronounced in YR and he held on by his fingertips to the pace of the curriculum until about Y3 when he started to take it in his stride a bit more & the differences between oldest & youngest started to become less apparent.
It's a long school day at that age & a lot of concentrating & doing exactly what you're told.

Depends entirely on how your ASD child presents & what they find challenging though. But broadly, would suggest dropping down a year (rather than just deferring to a Y1 start) would probably benefit socially & having skills to take it in their stride a bit more. Your 2nd child birthday is irrelevant & don't mention this in any application to LA for change of start date.

If it's a very nurturing, small infant school, they might get on fine in actual year group. If it's an 'Outstanding' SATS sausage factory, more likely they'll get streamrollered & spat out in their natural year group & a later start into YR would benefit. Do you have an options to choose between more than 1 school locally? I would say setting & approach to ASD children is probably twice as important as year group!

But yes, September born 2nd child has had a completely different primary experience & flown through.

Josieangel21 · 27/09/2023 22:49

Haven't read all posts, apologies in advance. It's more noticeable come Yr11/Yr12. Listen to your instincts and do what feels right. Only you know... and my advice is you already know. Sending love and you are making a good decision, whatever you decide. When they get to key stage 4,5 the maturity in learning in discernable and worth thinking about,(it leaps, to be honest, and is astonishing in it's maturity) please keep back, in regard to this and you have my vote for that future. Social group etc is also what matters but it changes massively when entering secondary. Big friendships made and changed in that time.

BambamD · 27/09/2023 23:01

Don’t hold them back from being with their peers as soon as the can. They come on so much better in school. My eldest is an August baby, he went to school in nappies (we’re in Wales so he went at 3) he is now in Year 10 and in top sets in High school and a very mature boy.
They will learn so much more being with other children for that year and as they get older the gap makes less difference.
For context too my son is also autistic xx

likethislikethat · 27/09/2023 23:21

My daughter was a July birth and having just finished GCSEs, I can tell you that I should have kept her back and had her start a year later, not in year 1 but in reception.

However, as she was born overseas where records are less reliable, I would, if I had my time again, simply made her birthday 01/09 whatever the real date was.

TheRealShatParp · 28/09/2023 08:54

crowisland · 27/09/2023 22:46

  1. as a matter of urgency, you need to get your asd daughter to a qualified therapist ASAP! I've seen kids with very noticeable asd get lots of excellent therapy (including equine therapy) and their lives were turned around. Have become loving, productive and brilliant adults.
  2. Best friend's son was premature, youngest in class, and it's a key factor that has destroyed his and his parents' lives. He's 25 now. Drugs, crime, no moral compass, two babies. He never got the academic attention he needed (despite being in a good primary), and he always thought he was 'thick' and there was something wrong and inferior about himself. Also had dyslexia that was not dealt with. The therapeutic interventions were too little, too late. They tried to defer, but the local educational authority refused--even though his 40 week birth date SHOULD have landed him in the following year. I've watched this tragedy since he was born. Heartbreaking.
  3. you are the only advocate for your child--you know her best, and trust yourself! good luck

I imagine there were a number of factors at play in relation to your second point.

Spaceman101 · 28/09/2023 09:27

Sorry if this has been mentioned before but I would join the FB group flexible school admissions for summer borns. There is a huge amount of information on there which may help you make a decision.

Pliudev · 28/09/2023 10:13

I haven't read all of this, so apologies if this has already been said. There is well established research to show that children who enter school at the lower end of their age group take a very long time to catch up with their peers. In fact, this can effect their academic achievements for years. Defer and allow you DD to mature and enter school when she is better prepared. Use the year to enhance her social skills and enjoy her time with you and her sibling.

Lalalalala555 · 28/09/2023 11:14

I was a kid, young in the year, not NT.

Don't defer. Yes it may be a bit uncomfortable going, but it's good to adapt and learn from a younger age than spend another year of the comfort of being home.

The plus side is I think younger brains really can soak up and learn better than older ones.
Also being not NT, she may benefit from extra time later in life.

Ie finishing school a year early means can take more time to figure out direction in life.
Also if she goes to uni and struggles and has to repeat or take a year out, it will impact her less.

As a small child, she will most likely benefit more from going to school sooner, because she will be educated sooner, socialised sooner and gains an extra year ready to hit the world running.

I am so grateful my parents didn't hold me back a year. I think my mum would have liked to. I think also as a kid I was quite particular so they may have worried about me going to school.

I am really glad that I am not a year behind now. Plus that feeling of being the odd one, you get when you're not nt, would be worse through school if you were older than all the other kids. You'd already feel incapable and different.

Lalalalala555 · 28/09/2023 11:23
  • would like to add

Depends on the individual.

From my own personal experience, I didn't suffer academically. I did very well academically, usually top or topish in class, carried that through secondary too, and got into a top uni, did a stem subject, got to work in an interesting field. The academic stuff - not so hard if you're lucky to have good teachers and be a bit lucky with your own inherent ability.

What is absolutely hard, as a non neurotypical, is executive functioning skills, rsd and managing stress/pressure.
^^
These are where your daughter will most benefit from help. If she's bright she'll be fine with getting her head around learning content.
But she will really benefit with you helping her in executive functioning.
Don't rely on a school to understand or teach these skills.
She will benefit from being assessed and learning these from young age. These are what I would argue are the big challenge between nt and non nt.
Not the academic stuff.

If the primary school has a lot of homework, thats going to be more of a challenge for her than one that doesn't. But gradually building up skills to manage executive disfunction, and also helping her see that finding environments that rely less on having great executive functions are a recipe for success. :)

pollymere · 28/09/2023 13:19

My Mum did this for me... And I ended up having to skip a whole year later on leaving all my friends in the year below me.

StillStandin · 28/09/2023 14:17

I deferred my son (end of August baby) he will start reception class when he’s 5. I think it gives them equal opportunities to their peers as opposed to ‘being held back’. It also means he will sit GCSE’s and leave school aged 16 not aged 15. How could it not be a bonus to their education, childhood, social status? We are in the minority of nations that sends our children to school at such a young age. Don’t be so quick to push them out the door, they are only young once and early years are a very important time in a child’s development.

JosieJasper · 28/09/2023 14:39

My DC2 is 31st Aug, right on the cut off. Her brother was 3 school years ahead of her (3 and a half in age). We had the option to defer but she would have missed reception completely and gone straight to year one when she joined the next year, this felt wrong as she would have been with the same kids but a year behind the others in experience of school and settling in. She’s now in secondary and although she’s always been the youngest, she has loved school and is thriving. Every kid is different but she was so keen to go to school with her big brother 🥰

WeightoftheWorld · 28/09/2023 14:50

pollymere · 28/09/2023 13:19

My Mum did this for me... And I ended up having to skip a whole year later on leaving all my friends in the year below me.

I'm very sorry this happened to you. However assuming you are now an adult, the context has changed a lot over the past decade or so and there is no reason for this to happen anymore. The department for education's guidance is now very clear that they expect children to remain in their adopted cohorts throughout their education.

RavenofEngland · 28/09/2023 19:10

When my son was due to start school he had only turned 4 at the end of Aug. I made an appointment with the head teacher of the school as I was worried about him not being ready. She watched him interact with toys in her office and other children round the school as she gave us a tour. She felt that he would be fine. I would suggest making an appointment with the head teacher and speak to them about any concerns

pollymere · 28/09/2023 20:59

@WeightoftheWorld Yes, that was the DoE theory when my Mum did it too...

LiveatCityHall · 28/09/2023 21:05

You can apply to defer but actually the decision ultimately lies with the school. I'm a governor and we have had 3 applicants for deferral for summer born children in the 2 years I've been serving. Only 1 has ever been approved and that was because the child was born at the tail end of August and hadn't been at any educational setting (pre school or nursery) due to Covid.
My son is in year 5 and I know of many summer born children in his year who are academically better than some of his classmates who are the eldest in the year.

JessicaBrassica · 28/09/2023 21:13

Dc1 started reception at 4+2w. Dc2 started at 4y +11mo.
Dc1 friends with oldest in year throughout primary and straight top sets in high school.

Dc2 came to hate preschool because they didn't teach him to read. He eventually asked them to, they did, and he's not stopped reading since. He has sen (likely adhd) and has needed support throughout primary, although strangely seems to be thriving at high school.

No way would keeping DC1 back have had any benefit.

I did feel smug at the end of reception and she met the standards expected of a 5yo when she was still 4!

VeraMay · 28/09/2023 21:35

My youngest was born 6th June. I kept her at pre-school for an extra year. When she started school she was streets ahead of the children who had been at school for a year already. Best thing for her.

Josieangel21 · 28/09/2023 22:33

👋

Muthaofcats · 28/09/2023 23:14

But the summer born policy is relatively new as is the DofE guidance, so wouldn’t have existed when you were at school.

WeightoftheWorld · 29/09/2023 12:59

pollymere · 28/09/2023 20:59

@WeightoftheWorld Yes, that was the DoE theory when my Mum did it too...

The guidance in place now wouldn't have existed when you were a child though. So completely different context to now.

Ffion21 · 29/09/2023 13:25

Consider them as individuals. What is right for each of them. Don’t compare them or their journeys.

Summer born sometimes struggle more but not always. It often levels out too after the first year or so. 3 of the brightest kids in my sons year group are all August born. You’d never know they were younger either so maturity wise they were all ready.

Daisychainsandglitter · 29/09/2023 13:58

DD1 is autistic and DD2 is NT. DD1 was born at the end of August and DD2 was born in October.
DD1 has caught up now academically but reception was really rocky to the point her school wanted to move her to a special school. She just wants ready and didn't understand any of the expectations and was frightened by reception despite having attended nursery. (She was unable to follow the rules there too). She's in year 5 now but she's noticeably behind her class socially and in terms of maturity. If I'd had my time again I would have held her back.

VeraMay · 29/09/2023 16:52

Muthaofcats · 28/09/2023 23:14

But the summer born policy is relatively new as is the DofE guidance, so wouldn’t have existed when you were at school.

Rules haven't changed much. Your child doesn't have to start school until the term after they are 5.
The issue might be getting your child into your preferred school later on.

To consider a deferral for dc1 because it is unfair for her to be the youngest in her year while her little sister will be the oldest in her year?
Muthaofcats · 30/09/2023 06:39

Lalalalala555 · 28/09/2023 11:14

I was a kid, young in the year, not NT.

Don't defer. Yes it may be a bit uncomfortable going, but it's good to adapt and learn from a younger age than spend another year of the comfort of being home.

The plus side is I think younger brains really can soak up and learn better than older ones.
Also being not NT, she may benefit from extra time later in life.

Ie finishing school a year early means can take more time to figure out direction in life.
Also if she goes to uni and struggles and has to repeat or take a year out, it will impact her less.

As a small child, she will most likely benefit more from going to school sooner, because she will be educated sooner, socialised sooner and gains an extra year ready to hit the world running.

I am so grateful my parents didn't hold me back a year. I think my mum would have liked to. I think also as a kid I was quite particular so they may have worried about me going to school.

I am really glad that I am not a year behind now. Plus that feeling of being the odd one, you get when you're not nt, would be worse through school if you were older than all the other kids. You'd already feel incapable and different.

Goodness me - the sheer ignorance in your post ! perhaps you should have had a delayed start - it may have afforded you the opportunity to develop critical reasoning skills.

Everything you have said is at odds with a huge body of research - but I suspect you are not one to do much reading…