To ask for your mascara recommendations...

[QueenArnica]

Boring but necessary thread! I just want to find a reliable, non clumpy, mid price range mascara for every day use. It's become a mission, can anyone help me please?!

I'm a mascara fiend. I buy at least one a month and genuinely, the best one I've had for a long time is Boots Natural Collection - £1.99.

Failing that, Max Factor False Lash (although it's a bit stabby on the eyelids)

Boots no.5

Loreal telescopic - love it.

I love Maybelline Great Lash.

Bellapierre - buy it from eBay and you can get it delivered for around £5 or £6: it's recently been included in various beauty boxes etc, so there's usually a fair few for sale from private sellers (Ditto for Eyeko)

They're real! Benefit .

I've got the Benefit Roller Lash mascara, and it really is fantastic.

Not sure how much it is though because I got it for my birthday.

Revlon Fabulash.

I don't use mascara - I have eyelash extensions and they're bloody lovely! They look very natural and it's brilliant to stumble out of bed, comb my hair and look vaguely presentable with barely any effort.

Watching. I'm a Dior fan but would like brown or navy without breaking the bank.

Ysl babydoll... Ok not mid range but it's AMAZING!

Clinique do the best mascaras IMO. And they don't irritate eyes :) can't remember how much they are, as mine has lasted for ages!!

Max factor false lash effect. Amazing.

Maybelline and L'Oreal are owned by the same company and have some of the best mascaras around.

I used Benefit They're Rael but wouldn't recommend it - it smudged on my browbone really quickly, for no reason that I could ascertain but was difficult to remove.

Clinique High Impact is my favourite, costs about £20 I think.

Max factor masterpiece max

They're Real! Benefit.

Rimmel waterproof. Non-clumpy, doesn't smudge, easy.

Avon Supershock mascara

I did one eyelash with Avon Supershock and one with benefit They're Real and DS said he preferred the Avon disclaimer he may have just said that to get a biscuit

Avon like to do limited edition packaging so it means they sell them off in the sale regularly

Max Factor waterproof false lash effect is bombproof, and you do need an oil based remover.

If a nuclear bomb drops on me I'm sure my eyelashes will be left intact

TheSeptemberIssue which Natural Collection mascara is it?

Max Factor masterpiece max is my holy grail - I was very disappointed by Benefit They're Real. My eyelashes are long and blonde, but fine, and it just stuck them all together!

Pandarific - it's the LashLength one. White tube.

I got the new Glamour mag with the free Clinique mascara. I'm a bit meh, tbh. It's ok but I certainly wouldn't rush out buy a full sized one.

Benefit's They're Real gets my vote.

I cannot wear any mascaras except the tubing ones. No idea why. My particular annoyance was Bobbi Brown's 'No smudge' which did just that within 10 mins. Not a particularly oily faced person. In the cheaper end I can highly recommend the No7 one in the gold tube. It has even overtaken Estee Lauder double wear in my affections. Very, very good.