Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Which jobs/careers WONT be done by AI?

87 replies

Wanttobeok · Today 15:58

Inspired by another thread about how we may become a jobless society because of AI.

But AI can't do everything.

What jobs will AI not be able to do?

Maybe we should be encouraging our children in that direction.

OP posts:
topcat2014 · Today 16:07

Trades. All the indoor office middle class jobs are at risk

thecatneuterer · Today 16:12

Cat rescue. There's no money in it though. Anything to do with animal rescue really. Vets, vet nurses, animal care staff, rescue workers. Maybe some of the admin work, but not much, as it's all so delicate and nuanced.

Besidemyselfwithworry · Today 16:12

I hope they get rid of lots of the endless levels of high up management in the nhs it’s so top heavy with some idiots without the right experience and knowledge being paid to “manage” stuff!!!
bands 5 possibly 6’s although that’s questionable in some areas - and below are the ones who do the work
there is a lot of people sat in offices on a lot of money doing not a lot

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

Octavia64 · Today 16:13

vet.

care home staff - physically moving patients
hairdresser
beautician

Chersfrozenface · Today 16:14

topcat2014 · Today 16:07

Trades. All the indoor office middle class jobs are at risk

What kind of people have sufficient income to pay tradespeople now?

What happens in the future if/when those people lose their jobs to AI and therefore their incomes?

teaandtoastwithmarmite · Today 16:15

Remember though that if the other jobs go people won’t have money to go to the hairdresser/ beautician. Even mechanics. People won’t be able to afford cars

lifeturnsonadime · Today 16:16

Sports coaching

Arewethereyetarewe · Today 16:20

Care roles

SomethingFun · Today 16:20

No job is immune to the impact of AI and it’s very short sighted to assume plumbers will be sitting pretty whilst bank managers will be in the gutter. I suppose being some kind of dogsbody for a tech billionaire might be a job that survives?

RPRegionalPosh · Today 16:21

Police officer, prison officer, social worker

Boreded · Today 16:22

topcat2014 · Today 16:07

Trades. All the indoor office middle class jobs are at risk

This.

We will always need SOME office jobs, but one person with AI when it gets good, will be able to do the work of many. It’ll just mean that those in the industry find themselves made redundant, and only a comparatively small number remaining, whilst new jobs in the market will be incredibly difficult to get.

I mean…would you hire the 40 year old with 20 years experience in the field but who got made redundant, or the unproven 20 year old who is fresh out of uni. The more redundancies that happen, the harder it will be for new grads to get any roles that do come up because they’ll be competing with people who have so much more experience that wouldn’t normally be applying for a junior position but have to.

But, much like when we had the tech boom and many people lost their jobs, new things will take their place, I feel confident of that…it’s just wondering how bad the damage will be before it starts to heal.

I’m in a position now where many of the people I work with will be made redundant because AI can do huge chunks of their role (and by that I mean that a person using AI can get through soooo much more work now) so not as many are needed. So far I have been untouched directly, but at some point in the next couple of years I’ll be on the chopping block myself.

I just pray it doesn’t come for me until I get significantly closer to retirement.

Sosorryaboutthis · Today 16:25

Prison officer is definitely one that AI could do. A prison could be operated remotely for the most part. I mean it would be rubbish but I don't think many people would care.

Boreded · Today 16:25

SomethingFun · Today 16:20

No job is immune to the impact of AI and it’s very short sighted to assume plumbers will be sitting pretty whilst bank managers will be in the gutter. I suppose being some kind of dogsbody for a tech billionaire might be a job that survives?

Some jobs are immune. AI isn’t going to clean your house, and plumbers aren’t going to be replaced by AI either.

Is AI going to change your elderly parents dressings in the care home? No so carers are going to be ok too.

AI may make some efficiencies in those roles, such as note taking and reminders for certain activities. But that kind of enhancement doesn’t directly reduce roles through redundancy measures, you just may see any gains being covered with regular staff attrition

Sunseekers · Today 16:27

Fire fighters
RNLI/coastguard/mountain rescue
Foresty workers
Fishermen
Zoo keepers
Childcare workers
Firearms officers
Pet sitters/dog walkers

Rural, outdoor, practical jobs are less at risk than those already requiring a significant amount of digital input.

But I guess no job is immune.

wowwoeezowee · Today 16:28

Boreded · Today 16:25

Some jobs are immune. AI isn’t going to clean your house, and plumbers aren’t going to be replaced by AI either.

Is AI going to change your elderly parents dressings in the care home? No so carers are going to be ok too.

AI may make some efficiencies in those roles, such as note taking and reminders for certain activities. But that kind of enhancement doesn’t directly reduce roles through redundancy measures, you just may see any gains being covered with regular staff attrition

People won’t be paying for cleaners though. Plumbers will only be used when in dire need. You certainly won’t be paying for home improvements if you don’t have a job either.

Chersfrozenface · Today 16:29

AI isn’t going to clean your house, and plumbers aren’t going to be replaced by AI either.
Is AI going to change your elderly parents dressings in the care home? No so carers are going to be ok too.

Cleaners, plumbers, carers need wages. Who is going to pay those wages if a large proportion of the population lose their jobs and therefore their incomes and stop paying tax and NI?

Woodfiresareamazing2 · Today 16:33

There are already robots/machines carrying out operations.

Supermarkets are almost all self checkout now. As is Zara , and probably many more shops will introduce it, before they're phased out and we buy everything on line.

New tech and AI is going to affect almost every job.

There are driverless taxis, robot waitstaff in our local Chinese, online teaching delivered by one teacher to countless students.
'Going to school/Uni' could become a thing of the past...

I think we can give it our best guess, but we don't really know the full capability of AI and new tech yet.

Most days I'm glad I'm old...

PaisleyElephant · Today 16:34

@Besidemyselfwithworry That's unfair to say it's just Band 5/6s or lower that do the work and higher grades just sit in offices.

You get clinicians at 8B/C offering clinical work, clinical consultations and supervision of bands 4 upwards, working very hard for a lot less than they would get in the private sector and are feeling very burned out. They stay because they believe in the NHS

Medicolegal/expert witness work is safe for a good while I think. There was a recent case where a judge has criticised the use of generative AI and there is guidance about when it should and shouldn't be used. So it looks as those case law is on the side of human experts not AI. Also lots of literature about the damaging impact of AI therapy, so people will always want a highly skilled and experienced clinician for this sort of thing.

wowwoeezowee · Today 16:35

Woodfiresareamazing2 · Today 16:33

There are already robots/machines carrying out operations.

Supermarkets are almost all self checkout now. As is Zara , and probably many more shops will introduce it, before they're phased out and we buy everything on line.

New tech and AI is going to affect almost every job.

There are driverless taxis, robot waitstaff in our local Chinese, online teaching delivered by one teacher to countless students.
'Going to school/Uni' could become a thing of the past...

I think we can give it our best guess, but we don't really know the full capability of AI and new tech yet.

Most days I'm glad I'm old...

I actually wish I was older than early 40s sometimes as I should have a couple of decades in the work place. Not at this rate. I actually feel guilty for having children. I love them and feel so happy I had them, but I would have thought harder had i knew how the world was changing for them.

SomethingFun · Today 16:35

I earn a lot of money doing a job that will go with ai unless ai starts being taxed significantly and/or the ai companies start charging actual costs instead of cheap rates. If I get made redundant my higher rate tax stops going in the pot to pay for the public sector and I have no money of my own to pay cleaners or hairdressers or anyone other than those I need to, to keep a roof over my head.

Me and all the other people made redundant are now competing with everyone else for the little work that is still available that the independently wealthy are willing to fund which depresses any money to be made further, however skilled those roles are. We are all dependent on each other - no one is insulated from the impact of ai.

FancyKitten · Today 16:37

Chersfrozenface · Today 16:14

What kind of people have sufficient income to pay tradespeople now?

What happens in the future if/when those people lose their jobs to AI and therefore their incomes?

Good point. Where I live it’s retired so-called Boomers who hire guys to do various house jobs that don’t really need doing. They just have lots of spare cash. I see lines of white vans in my parents’ road all the time. Most of my peers are struggling to keep the show on the road (most are WFH mid-level office jobs) but if we cease to exist / work, then what…

wowwoeezowee · Today 16:38

I remember being able to get a job in a shop 25 years ago, there would be a sign on the door and you’d walk in and fill out an application form. Interview, and you’d likely get it. Now it’s AI screening, hardly any staff needed. Just miserable for young people.

Besidemyselfwithworry · Today 16:39

PaisleyElephant · Today 16:34

@Besidemyselfwithworry That's unfair to say it's just Band 5/6s or lower that do the work and higher grades just sit in offices.

You get clinicians at 8B/C offering clinical work, clinical consultations and supervision of bands 4 upwards, working very hard for a lot less than they would get in the private sector and are feeling very burned out. They stay because they believe in the NHS

Medicolegal/expert witness work is safe for a good while I think. There was a recent case where a judge has criticised the use of generative AI and there is guidance about when it should and shouldn't be used. So it looks as those case law is on the side of human experts not AI. Also lots of literature about the damaging impact of AI therapy, so people will always want a highly skilled and experienced clinician for this sort of thing.

I’m not on about clinical staff I mean admin

we have LOADS of band 6,7,8a,8b,8c managers who do NOT manage

They never stay very long, usually going off sick for about 6 months (on full pay) then resigning and then the cycle starts again because they don’t seem to recruit people who know the areas, the services and then they don’t do well.

dodobookends · Today 16:41

Pointe shoe maker
Shepherd
Tree surgeon
Police dog handler
Washing machine installer
Gas fitter
Household Cavalry
Prime Minister
Rescue helicopter winch operator
Slapstick comedy
Scaffolding riggers
Thatcher
Farrier
Physiotherapist

Boreded · Today 16:42

wowwoeezowee · Today 16:28

People won’t be paying for cleaners though. Plumbers will only be used when in dire need. You certainly won’t be paying for home improvements if you don’t have a job either.

No but we will be building social housing which needs…you guessed it, plumbing. And these things do break too.

I didn’t have my bathroom fitted by a plumber, it was by a bathroom fitter. But if I need a radiator changing or there is a leak, it wouldn’t matter whether I had money or not, I would be paying a plumber.

If people are doing less upkeep on their homes then things will break more regularly so plumbers will still be needed. It’s just the bathroom fitters that we may need less of.