Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Which jobs/careers WONT be done by AI?

93 replies

Wanttobeok · Today 15:58

Inspired by another thread about how we may become a jobless society because of AI.

But AI can't do everything.

What jobs will AI not be able to do?

Maybe we should be encouraging our children in that direction.

OP posts:
Arewethereyetarewe · Today 17:12

Sirzy · Today 16:47

Teaching/education.

I work in early years and no AI could do it!

Sadly the birth rate is going down

Chersfrozenface · Today 17:13

Driving jobs are an interesting question. Self-driving taxis are operating already, of course, but my strong suspicion is that it will be a very long time, if ever, before AI systems are independently driving 40 ton trucks or bus loads of passengers at 60mph on busy motorways.

Interestingly, Waymo has temporarily suspended its driverless vehicles from operating on all US freeways.

It's after several driverless Waymo vehicles entered an active construction zone on US Route 101 and another incident where apparently a Waymo car tried to overtake patrol vehicles that were deliberately slowing the pace of traffic on a San Francisco highway.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cmy86pp336qlo

SomethingFun · Today 17:14

Loads of the things we take for granted - clean drinking water, healthcare, education etc etc have been put in place because a healthy workforce was needed by the people who own and run the country. If AI can do lots of jobs then a healthy workforce is actually a negative as healthy and educated and underemployed people can organise and rise up against the few that now have power. So yes AI can’t deliver your baby or fix your toilet but unless someone somewhere needs you to safely deliver a baby or requires you to have access to hygienic toileting then you won’t have them as you have no automatic entitlement to those things. And if you can’t pay for them yourself then you will have to do without. People all over the world die of preventable diseases and malnutrition everyday because no one who could help them needs those people to be healthy and survive. Which is completely and utterly awful when you actually think about it.

If say only 50% of the current workforce is needed what is the benefit of funding the other 50% to be economically inactive in our current capitalist systems? I’d love to spend all day learning musical instruments and writing my book whilst AI generates income for me on my behalf or my government pays me ubi from AI taxes, but it’s highly unlikely that will happen. And how would all the cleaners feel as they trudge past people like me to their non AI-able job?

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

notimagain · Today 17:15

@SpottyAlpaca

Driving jobs are an interesting question. Self-driving taxis are operating already, of course, but my strong suspicion is that it will be a very long time, if ever, before AI systems are independently driving 40 ton trucks or bus loads of passengers at 60mph on busy motorways.

FWiW there deep misgivings in aviation about the use of AI in really safety critical areas/functions and there's no sign of even the most technically keen manufacturer (e.g Airbus) moving away from two pilot airliners any time in the foreseeable (which given lead times for new designs is decades).

Bigger threat to the pilot job short term is people not being able to afford to fly.

Truinio · Today 17:16

Handjob technician for a tech billionaire.

Boreded · Today 17:17

Chersfrozenface · Today 17:08

I very much hope you're right.

Hopefully more right than my SPAG on that last one…it’s instead of its. I’m blaming autocorrect 😆

But seriously though, we wouldn’t let world economies fall over this, something would be done to block it, though I really don’t think it will get this bad

UserNameWalkingShoes · Today 17:19

Revolution organiser.

Supersimkin7 · Today 17:22

archaeologists
book researchers and historians
crafters

RedTagAlan · Today 17:29

dodobookends · Today 17:03

If anyone could arrange for some AI to come and fix the potholes in our town I'd be eternally grateful.

Well, silicon is just sand. SiO2.

caringcarer · Today 17:30

Undertaker

HelpMyBlackLabradorVotesReform · Today 17:33

Planetary Habit Designer, Carbon Restructurer, Organ printing specialist, Nodule Configurator, Arthimis banana consultant.

Just like when people said computers will take every ones jobs there will be a whole raft of new jobs that come up for people to do.

RedTagAlan · Today 17:34

caringcarer · Today 17:30

Undertaker

Not a dying trade then ?

wowwoeezowee · Today 17:36

caringcarer · Today 17:30

Undertaker

Direct cremations are becoming more popular. No need for undertakers if you have no money for a fancy funeral.

BoldlyLeaningPanda · Today 17:38

Stage performance (anything onscreen can be AI generated, but not live shows)

Anything that involves using hands - physiotherapy, massage, podiatrist, optician, dentist, painter&decorator, kitchen fitter, care assistant, nurse.

Besidemyselfwithworry · Today 17:39

wowwoeezowee · Today 16:48

Perhaps not yet in schools but I’d expect nurseries and other childcare settings to close (unless funded by the government) as people won’t be able to afford to send their children.

re childcare
I got 30 hrs for mine when they got to 3 and nothing before that

The funding from 9months onwards is excellent, but I feel more should be done with regards to funded hours for over 4’s for wraparound care and holiday childcare too. child care doesn’t stop when kids go to school and to my mind there should be some help for this as the number of people who work 9:15-2:45 Monday to Friday and not in the holidays are minimal.
I feel there needs to be more support for this as this could be a barrier for people working.

They spoke about rolling out some free breakfast clubs but where we are only a couple of schools do this and the paid wraparound school club is from 7:30am to 8:45 (until morning play before registration) and then the “free” provision is 8:15-8:45 in a separate area which isn’t much good if you want to drop off at 7:30am to go to work. I have colleagues with kids at one of the schools doing it - it’s organised chaos!!!!!!

Sunflowersandmulberries · Today 17:40

SomethingFun · Today 17:14

Loads of the things we take for granted - clean drinking water, healthcare, education etc etc have been put in place because a healthy workforce was needed by the people who own and run the country. If AI can do lots of jobs then a healthy workforce is actually a negative as healthy and educated and underemployed people can organise and rise up against the few that now have power. So yes AI can’t deliver your baby or fix your toilet but unless someone somewhere needs you to safely deliver a baby or requires you to have access to hygienic toileting then you won’t have them as you have no automatic entitlement to those things. And if you can’t pay for them yourself then you will have to do without. People all over the world die of preventable diseases and malnutrition everyday because no one who could help them needs those people to be healthy and survive. Which is completely and utterly awful when you actually think about it.

If say only 50% of the current workforce is needed what is the benefit of funding the other 50% to be economically inactive in our current capitalist systems? I’d love to spend all day learning musical instruments and writing my book whilst AI generates income for me on my behalf or my government pays me ubi from AI taxes, but it’s highly unlikely that will happen. And how would all the cleaners feel as they trudge past people like me to their non AI-able job?

Thanks for this post, I think it's spot on! This is all very scary stuff.

wowwoeezowee · Today 17:40

Besidemyselfwithworry · Today 17:39

re childcare
I got 30 hrs for mine when they got to 3 and nothing before that

The funding from 9months onwards is excellent, but I feel more should be done with regards to funded hours for over 4’s for wraparound care and holiday childcare too. child care doesn’t stop when kids go to school and to my mind there should be some help for this as the number of people who work 9:15-2:45 Monday to Friday and not in the holidays are minimal.
I feel there needs to be more support for this as this could be a barrier for people working.

They spoke about rolling out some free breakfast clubs but where we are only a couple of schools do this and the paid wraparound school club is from 7:30am to 8:45 (until morning play before registration) and then the “free” provision is 8:15-8:45 in a separate area which isn’t much good if you want to drop off at 7:30am to go to work. I have colleagues with kids at one of the schools doing it - it’s organised chaos!!!!!!

You only get the 30 hours if both parents are working though. If Ai takes jobs no can afford to pay it.

ChristmasShumper · Today 17:40

Chersfrozenface · Today 16:14

What kind of people have sufficient income to pay tradespeople now?

What happens in the future if/when those people lose their jobs to AI and therefore their incomes?

What a ridiculous comment! I would say the vast majority of people still need plumbers, electricians etc etc etc.

Tradespeople can pretty much pick and choose their work still.

Clearinguptheclutter · Today 17:42

anything that isn’t office based will basically still be there
trades, healthcare etc.

most office jobs will still be there but I predict there will be a lot less of us.

I will encourage my sons into practical jobs where possible.

onyourway · Today 17:43

I think the biggest challenge is how governments tax AI. If there is a smaller workforce, paying less tax, the monies available for public services will be smaller. They need to work out how to tax the positions now completed by AI.

horseplay12 · Today 17:45

Cooks/chefs as well

Besidemyselfwithworry · Today 17:46

wowwoeezowee · Today 17:40

You only get the 30 hours if both parents are working though. If Ai takes jobs no can afford to pay it.

Yes but if both parents aren’t working you don’t “need” childcare to be able to go to work

if people don’t have a job they can take their own kids to school, and not have to worry about wraparound that’s my point

not all jobs will go to AI and people who work will STILL need childcare

pointyshoes · Today 17:46

Taking the example of plumbers - my (office based ) DH recently managed a fairly complicated toilet repair which in the past would have needed a plumber. He was able to use AI to give him a diagnosis of the problem and a step by step guide to fixing it. One quick trip to Screwfix for a specific part and an hour or so of work (no specialist tools) , job all done.
Admittedly he is always interested in the practical side of things but he works in finance so has no experience of any kind of practical trade. But the instructions were very clear , so that’s one job that we would previously needed a plumber for but no longer.
obviously there will always bigger / complicated issues that do need a qualified plumber but there is now so much info available that anyone who is happy to have a go will be able to.
in the past he’s also used AI to install a dishwasher and sort out a boiler problem

Chersfrozenface · Today 17:48

ChristmasShumper · Today 17:40

What a ridiculous comment! I would say the vast majority of people still need plumbers, electricians etc etc etc.

Tradespeople can pretty much pick and choose their work still.

The vast majority of people may need tradespeople, certainly.

But will the vast majority of people be able to afford to pay them? Plumbers etc are hardly going to work for nothing.

wowwoeezowee · Today 17:49

Besidemyselfwithworry · Today 17:46

Yes but if both parents aren’t working you don’t “need” childcare to be able to go to work

if people don’t have a job they can take their own kids to school, and not have to worry about wraparound that’s my point

not all jobs will go to AI and people who work will STILL need childcare

Yes I know that but it also means less nursery/childcare staff needed in general. No jobs are immune