Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Which jobs/careers WONT be done by AI?

93 replies

Wanttobeok · Today 15:58

Inspired by another thread about how we may become a jobless society because of AI.

But AI can't do everything.

What jobs will AI not be able to do?

Maybe we should be encouraging our children in that direction.

OP posts:
DinoLil · Today 16:44

Painting and decorating.
Electricians.
Plumbing.
Baking, cheffing, cooking.
Dog grooming and walking.
Bricklaying.
Chiropractors.
Gawd... the list is endless!!

wowwoeezowee · Today 16:45

Boreded · Today 16:42

No but we will be building social housing which needs…you guessed it, plumbing. And these things do break too.

I didn’t have my bathroom fitted by a plumber, it was by a bathroom fitter. But if I need a radiator changing or there is a leak, it wouldn’t matter whether I had money or not, I would be paying a plumber.

If people are doing less upkeep on their homes then things will break more regularly so plumbers will still be needed. It’s just the bathroom fitters that we may need less of.

If people can’t afford their mortgage they won’t be paying for plumbers. Every government continues to ignore the housing crisis. More plumbers won’t solve it.

Sirzy · Today 16:47

Teaching/education.

I work in early years and no AI could do it!

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about this subject:

DinoLil · Today 16:47

I'd love to see AI trim dogs' nails or fit a house alarm/security system. Or hang a gate. Or help someone who can't shower or bathe safely.
I'll shut up now!

wowwoeezowee · Today 16:48

Sirzy · Today 16:47

Teaching/education.

I work in early years and no AI could do it!

Perhaps not yet in schools but I’d expect nurseries and other childcare settings to close (unless funded by the government) as people won’t be able to afford to send their children.

Chersfrozenface · Today 16:49

But if I need a radiator changing or there is a leak, it wouldn’t matter whether I had money or not, I would be paying a plumber.

I'd be interested to know how you'd pay a plumber if you had no money.

I suppose you could pay with a credit card or get a loan, but that would depend on lenders judging that you have enough income to repay that debt.

Chersfrozenface · Today 16:50

DinoLil · Today 16:44

Painting and decorating.
Electricians.
Plumbing.
Baking, cheffing, cooking.
Dog grooming and walking.
Bricklaying.
Chiropractors.
Gawd... the list is endless!!

They all need paying. Which depends on other people having enough income to pay.

MellowSubmarine · Today 16:50

Hardly any are safe, even if AI won’t do them.

If there was mass unemployment, people aren’t going to be paying tradespeople for non-emergency work. And more people going into trades will push down prices.

Personal care is probably safest. Although will suffer from wages being pushed down (even more!) if lots of people move into it.

wowwoeezowee · Today 16:51

DinoLil · Today 16:47

I'd love to see AI trim dogs' nails or fit a house alarm/security system. Or hang a gate. Or help someone who can't shower or bathe safely.
I'll shut up now!

If you don’t have money from a job you can easily trim your dogs nails by yourself. Handymen will be a luxury only afforded by a few. You wouldn’t bother with fancy security systems. Care work would be government funded only

Boreded · Today 16:52

Chersfrozenface · Today 16:29

AI isn’t going to clean your house, and plumbers aren’t going to be replaced by AI either.
Is AI going to change your elderly parents dressings in the care home? No so carers are going to be ok too.

Cleaners, plumbers, carers need wages. Who is going to pay those wages if a large proportion of the population lose their jobs and therefore their incomes and stop paying tax and NI?

I take your point that people losing their jobs to AI may no longer be able to afford domestic cleaners, but I think you’re significantly overestimating the impact that would have on the occupation as a whole.

For a start, cleaners don’t exclusively clean private homes. They clean offices, hospitals, schools, hotels, shops, factories and countless other commercial and public buildings. Much of that demand is driven by necessity, not individual disposable income.

And even within domestic cleaning, there are competing factors.

We’re increasingly seeing employers requiring staff to return to the office. As AI reduces headcounts, businesses may have more space available for their remaining employees, making increased office attendance easier to accommodate.

That means more commuting, less time at home and potentially greater demand for domestic cleaners among those who remain employed.

It also means offices that previously had relatively low daily occupancy could require more frequent cleaning as employees spend more days there.

So while some domestic cleaners may lose customers as a result of unemployment, others could see increased demand, and much of the wider cleaning industry would continue to provide services that are necessary regardless of household spending.

I accept that there will be some knock-on effects, but I don’t think it’s been demonstrated that they’ll be particularly significant for cleaners overall, especially when there are factors that could offset some of that reduced demand.

dodobookends · Today 16:52

One thing's for sure, we won't be needing people to sit around in meetings all day talking about marketing.😂

SomethingFun · Today 16:52

Who’s paying for social housing to be built if loads of people haven’t got jobs and aren’t paying taxes? Who’s long term unemployed and also paying for their dog to be expensively groomed? I do highly skilled and well paid intelligent work and unless AI becomes more expensive to use than it is to employ me then I’m toast. As are millions of other people in this country and billions worldwide. So shortsighted to think because you can do nails or something you’ll be alright. I can see armies continuing to be funded by rich people who don’t want poor people rioting in their gated communities, but they’ll probably all fuck off to their private islands and wait for the world to burn.

Boreded · Today 16:55

Chersfrozenface · Today 16:49

But if I need a radiator changing or there is a leak, it wouldn’t matter whether I had money or not, I would be paying a plumber.

I'd be interested to know how you'd pay a plumber if you had no money.

I suppose you could pay with a credit card or get a loan, but that would depend on lenders judging that you have enough income to repay that debt.

People fall on hard times, they rely on debt, family, selling their things, going without food…but they wouldn’t be able to go without a working toilet, or ignore a leak running down the walls.

If people could manage to make do in wartimes then we would definitely be able to manage to cobble money together to pay for a plumber.

Boreded · Today 16:58

SomethingFun · Today 16:52

Who’s paying for social housing to be built if loads of people haven’t got jobs and aren’t paying taxes? Who’s long term unemployed and also paying for their dog to be expensively groomed? I do highly skilled and well paid intelligent work and unless AI becomes more expensive to use than it is to employ me then I’m toast. As are millions of other people in this country and billions worldwide. So shortsighted to think because you can do nails or something you’ll be alright. I can see armies continuing to be funded by rich people who don’t want poor people rioting in their gated communities, but they’ll probably all fuck off to their private islands and wait for the world to burn.

The government through debt and taxation. If people can’t work and taxation on wages is too low then they will introduce a new tax, on banks, on tech companies, on people using the AI themselves. That’s how it works.

The money the government are randomly giving people in a few weeks…how do you think that was funded? It was from a tax on banks.

In every society there are people who make money and profit, it is the governments job to identify who those people are and to increase their contributions to society.

moonraker0 · Today 16:59

Anything to do with utilities.

Sosorryaboutthis · Today 17:01

If people are thinking AI will lead to a complete breakdown in society, which it could, no one will be interested in plumbing.
They will be interested in stockpiling, hiding and aligning themselves with the strongest most well armed group that will let them join. You need pitchforks, knifes, and as many brothers or male cousins you can get your hands on.
Or I suppose to be beautiful and fertile.

Boreded · Today 17:01

wowwoeezowee · Today 16:45

If people can’t afford their mortgage they won’t be paying for plumbers. Every government continues to ignore the housing crisis. More plumbers won’t solve it.

Nobody said more plumbers would solve it. Only that it would be a largely unaffected industry.

Plumbers aren’t a luxury, they’re a necessity. So they would be fine. AI can’t take their jobs, and even if someone is poor they cannot live without a working toilet, or live with water running down their walls:

People have said that they would have less work because impacted people can’t afford to do home improvements, but generally it isn’t plumbers that fit your new bathroom or kitchen, it’s specialist fitters, so those would be the ones impacted.

Woodfiresareamazing2 · Today 17:02

wowwoeezowee · Today 16:35

I actually wish I was older than early 40s sometimes as I should have a couple of decades in the work place. Not at this rate. I actually feel guilty for having children. I love them and feel so happy I had them, but I would have thought harder had i knew how the world was changing for them.

When I had my kids (almost 40 years ago) there was no inkling of how society would change, so I don't feel guilty for that.

But I am very concerned for them all.

Boreded · Today 17:03

Sosorryaboutthis · Today 17:01

If people are thinking AI will lead to a complete breakdown in society, which it could, no one will be interested in plumbing.
They will be interested in stockpiling, hiding and aligning themselves with the strongest most well armed group that will let them join. You need pitchforks, knifes, and as many brothers or male cousins you can get your hands on.
Or I suppose to be beautiful and fertile.

Yeah it’s getting very ‘hunker down in your bunker’ in this chat now.

Society won’t be allowed to collapse because of AI. It’s use would ge banned before it ever got that far (if it actually looked like it could cause that much damage).

dodobookends · Today 17:03

If anyone could arrange for some AI to come and fix the potholes in our town I'd be eternally grateful.

SpottyAlpaca · Today 17:05

Pretty much all jobs which today don’t use a computer for their core functions. Anything & everything from consultant surgeon to bricklayer to hairdresser to nurse.

Driving jobs are an interesting question. Self-driving taxis are operating already, of course, but my strong suspicion is that it will be a very long time, if ever, before AI systems are independently driving 40 ton trucks or bus loads of passengers at 60mph on busy motorways.

FroggyNo · Today 17:07

Not convinced trades will be safe for that long as AI will be integrated into our homes- boilers will be able to diagnose their own faults, order the part and tell you where to put it. Of course it will take some time to feed through but demand will definitely decline and (given how many people se these jobs as safe) supply will go up.

Anything where the human interaction is part of the point is safer IMO, such as caring professions.

Chersfrozenface · Today 17:08

Boreded · Today 17:03

Yeah it’s getting very ‘hunker down in your bunker’ in this chat now.

Society won’t be allowed to collapse because of AI. It’s use would ge banned before it ever got that far (if it actually looked like it could cause that much damage).

I very much hope you're right.

DelurkingAJ · Today 17:08

I suspect many jobs that the public think can be done by AI will change rather than vanish.

When computers came in, everyone was sure most accountancy jobs would go. But they didn’t, because suddenly, rather than it taking a week to run a new scenario about how a change would impact a business it took a few hours. So the Board and the regulators wanted a dozen different possibilities modelled. And everyone is still busy.

Equally, I just got asked to trial AI in producing an accounting technical view. Suffice to say that attempt one was so bad that AI apologised when I said it was nonsense. Attempt two sounded plausible but was wrong. By which point I could have written the slides twice over.

Anonmousse · Today 17:11

I think there are 2 issues at play -

What can AI do - what industries/jobs are likely to be affected first, or soonest
What is AI less likely to be able to do...?

Whether the latter can be paid for/deemed necessary is a slightly different issue, but obviously linked.

As per pps a lot of practical jobs are potentially more difficult for AI...but would they survive if fewer people were earning money...but then you could say it will impact all jobs whether ai is physically doing them or not!

I make, repair and remodel jewellery. I hope its not taken over by ai, any time soon.. but its certainly not an essential so could be impacted