Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

What on earth is going on with young people?

137 replies

nedip · Today 17:46

What is causing such enormous rates of mental health struggles? I absolutely 100% that these are real, but what’s behind it? I’d think it was the miserable economic picture, but that’s been miserable for college and university leavers since 2008 and was difficult for school leavers in the 80s. Is it Covid?

OP posts:
TeaCupTinsel · Today 18:48

I've worked with teens for over 20 years and I don't think there's been a sudden upsurge in mental health struggles... I just think they are much more widely talked about and reported. I remember when I first started working, teens were ashamed to admit they were struggling with their mental health or anxiety.
Nowadays, teens widely discuss their mental health, encourage each other to seek treatment, seek 'self-care' to minimise stress etc.
When I was at school, decades ago, I knew lots of people with mental health issues, we just didn't necessarily use the labels in the same way. I remember friends calling the childline number as their parents weren't supportive when they had panic attacks etc.

DrMorbius · Today 18:49

Rustybike · Today 18:00

Missing backbone, grit, resilience.

^ ^ This with bells on. My Granded pulled artillery around the battlefields of WW1 (on a horse). My uncle was a prisoner of war at 20. My dad grew up,in 1930's poverty and was was working a manual job at 14. Non of them had mental health issues and went on to live happy fulfilling lives.

The problem is the modern woke UK society that shields kids from any hurdles and hardships. Parents that shield kids from adversity (even down to mundane tasks, like walking to school. I was walking to school at 6 years old). Schools that tell kids "it the taking part, that counts. Not the winning". Really!!! Do you think kids in China or India are being told the same?
In short preventing the vitally important lessons in life, that are essentially all gained through adversity or failure.

Uricon2 · Today 18:49

I'm end of the baby boom and came of age in the very early 1980s and the past was not the paradise some seem to think it was, there was huge unemployment then and plenty of other bad things. I believe a far greater degree of resilience was automatically expected from us, but I think society has changed enormously in terms of what is churned out on the screens day after day.
We compared ourselves to those around us, not some nonsensical influencer. Also, we were made to go to school. Opting out was not an option.

I do not know the answer to what is happening now, tbh.

Rustybike · Today 18:50

TeaCupTinsel · Today 18:48

I've worked with teens for over 20 years and I don't think there's been a sudden upsurge in mental health struggles... I just think they are much more widely talked about and reported. I remember when I first started working, teens were ashamed to admit they were struggling with their mental health or anxiety.
Nowadays, teens widely discuss their mental health, encourage each other to seek treatment, seek 'self-care' to minimise stress etc.
When I was at school, decades ago, I knew lots of people with mental health issues, we just didn't necessarily use the labels in the same way. I remember friends calling the childline number as their parents weren't supportive when they had panic attacks etc.

At an event to launch his report, Mr Milburn said: “Mental ill health has become one of the defining causes of youth economic inactivity.

“The health system is not solving the problem, it is exacerbating it. Rather than helping young people access help quickly, its ‘diagnosis, wait, treat’ model leads to too many waiting and not working, and ending up on welfare. And once people end up in welfare, they find it very hard to get out.”

Rustybike · Today 18:51

DrMorbius · Today 18:49

^ ^ This with bells on. My Granded pulled artillery around the battlefields of WW1 (on a horse). My uncle was a prisoner of war at 20. My dad grew up,in 1930's poverty and was was working a manual job at 14. Non of them had mental health issues and went on to live happy fulfilling lives.

The problem is the modern woke UK society that shields kids from any hurdles and hardships. Parents that shield kids from adversity (even down to mundane tasks, like walking to school. I was walking to school at 6 years old). Schools that tell kids "it the taking part, that counts. Not the winning". Really!!! Do you think kids in China or India are being told the same?
In short preventing the vitally important lessons in life, that are essentially all gained through adversity or failure.

Great post.

GiaGia16 · Today 18:51

Happyindevon · Today 17:55

Terrified parents not letting them foster any independence, have relationships or make mistakes. Keeping them cooped up on screens because it’s easier for them.

This.

bookdook · Today 18:51

Crinkle77 · Today 18:45

Yep this. Kids aren't taught that sometimes you win, sometimes you lose. Competitions where are all kids are given a prize for example. Parents doing everything for them. When I was younger I remember having to ring a company or something. Can't remember what it was but I wanted my mum to do it for me and she said no and that I needed to do it. At the time I thought she was mean but I now realise she was teaching me valuable life skills. When I was looking at uni and going to open days she didn't go with me. I went up to Newcastle with my friend on the train. My mum was a teacher and she couldn't mark their maths as wrong. So kids are never learning how to deal with setbacks and challenges or do do things for themselves.

Do you have dc? They have assessments all the time and know if they are doing well or not. And plenty of competitions with only 1.2,3.

TheSnappyBluePoster · Today 18:51

Manifesto · Today 18:07

Parents. Being entitled and never thinking their child might be in the wrong. Demanding unseasonable special treatment from schools and employers.

This. All of them having a bad case of main character syndrome. They've played a starring role in their parents eyes and life in then found to be one heck of a disappointment. No one really cares about them and they arent all that.

SkateHaddockCod · Today 18:53

This will be unpopular but I think parenting has gotten steadily worse.

Multiple blended families with complex issues never really dealt with, with the kids being expected to just accept new partners leading to unstable home lives.

Men walking away from their families at the drop of a hat.

The stable family unit is increasingly rarer these days which leads to an unsettled and anxious child and later young adult. In my child's school mum and dad being together seems to be the minority.

That will be unpopular to say but I think is closer to the truth.

Add on top of that social media and unrealistic material life expectations, it becomes a toxic and lonely mix for youngsters.

ohmaaaan · Today 18:53

TheSnappyBluePoster · Today 18:51

This. All of them having a bad case of main character syndrome. They've played a starring role in their parents eyes and life in then found to be one heck of a disappointment. No one really cares about them and they arent all that.

Hmm, did you watch the X Factor at all circa 2006? Plenty of delusional singers on there.

tobee · Today 18:53

I don’t think it’s over indulgent parenting so much as over fearful parenting from our generation. We’re constantly bombarded by news 24/7 and then places like Mumsnet where people pass on fears to one another. There’s a natural desire to protect any harm coming to our children but then we pass on the concern to our kids. We’re more informed about the fears and dangers, real or exaggerated.

Then there’s the rest like pressure to do well at school (league tables and results and tests which are a feature of these generations which are quite recent). Then student debt, more and more expensive and unaffordable housing and fewer and fewer jobs. And prospects of job security.

Then news about world events constantly. How many articles have there been about 3 day blackouts? The war in Ukraine? How many articles speculating about Russia starting WW3? Or terrorism? Climate change? Then before that Covid. There was so much aggressive doom mongering on here about Covid. It all makes for uncertainty and is cumulative.

And yes the internet feeds this narrative. “We’re all gonna die!”

Tumbleweed101 · Today 18:54

Children are highly regulated, supervised environments for most of their childhoods now. They are in nursery from babyhood, after school clubs, breakfast clubs, holiday clubs and then they have to stay in education until they are 18 regardless of whether this is suitable for them whereas in the past you could leave school earlier and find a job. They don’t get the freedom to just follow their own desires and creativity in the way other generations could.

Too much knowledge of the wider world - they know the problems globally that they can’t do anything about and it can worry children.

Screen times and social media. Less family time if both parents are out longer at work, grandparents also needing to work later into life. Cost of living stresses can worry children of their family are worried.

Food that is more processed than in previous generations.

Young adults find it hard to get work that pays enough to meet the current cost of living meaning they find it harder to move out and start their own lives. Deciding not to have children and families of their own because of the costs and feeling like they are stuck in their parents home. No positive future.

WaneyEdge · Today 18:54

1dayatatime · Today 18:33

I fully agree with previous posters on social media and other suggestions.

But as a slightly random addition, a reduction in the number of young people going to the pub doesn't help. In a pub young people learn to socialise face to face and most importantly talk.

I think that there is a really strong case to increase taxation on supermarket alcohol and decrease it on pub alcohol so that they are parity priced

I’ve said this for ages. Not saying it was great but my generation (I’m late 40s) were going to pubs from the age of 14/15. We mixed with adults and knew we had to behave like them or be pulled up pretty sharpish and slung out. Same with work, 16 year old apprentices were taken on and taken out on a Friday by their workmates, bunged in a corner the landlord couldn’t see round and had a few drinks. We learned how to behave like adults in social settings and wanted to be asked to go out with them. As pp said, you now have kids of 11/12 still believing in Santa.

Bobblygreenjumper · Today 18:54

My DS is so much more knowledgeable about the world than I was at that age. Frankly, with that, there is a lot to be depressed about - climate change, AI, wealth inequalities, far right movements, dodgy sexual stuff. I think there is a general lack of hope for the future.

MushMonster · Today 18:55

SirChenjins · Today 18:00

What about the ones who do have jobs though, who are constantly caught up in dramas and trauma and being triggered and spiralling...as a manager, it's exhausting dealing with them.

Yeah..... I do not get those. I do know some like this. They baffle me.
But most I know, they try hard, they do.

noblegiraffe · Today 18:56

Do you remember post-Covid when Sir Kevan Collins was hired by the government to come up with a package of recommendations to help children recover from the effects of the pandemic, both academically, socially and mentally? And he recommended a comprehensive £15 billion program of activities, interventions and resources?

And then the government said 'No, we're not going to do that' and he resigned in disgust?

I do wonder whether the £15 billion package he proposed would have worked out cheaper than trying to sort out the mess we are now in.

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2021/jun/02/education-recovery-chief-kevan-collins-quit-english-schools-catch-up-row

Education recovery chief quits in English schools catch-up row

Sir Kevan Collins said to be dismayed that his long-awaited £15bn proposals were watered down to a £1.4bn package

https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2021/jun/02/education-recovery-chief-kevan-collins-quit-english-schools-catch-up-row

Blackcat2026 · Today 18:56

Social media.

Previous generations have suffered through far worse economic times and didn't all have 'mental health issues'.

I believe it's a lack of actual hardship, coupled with an enormous gap between the reality of life and the life 'influencers' are selling that's mostly to blame. In the past, luxurious lifestyles were the preserve of the very wealthy and was completely unattainable. Watching or reading about them was just a nice daydream. These days it's all champagne lifestyle on lemonade money and you're 'nobody' if you don't have x,y or z, a mug fill of fillers or goin' Doooobaiiiiiii hun. You can never 'make it', because there's always more to want.

ilovebrie8 · Today 18:57

SkateHaddockCod · Today 18:53

This will be unpopular but I think parenting has gotten steadily worse.

Multiple blended families with complex issues never really dealt with, with the kids being expected to just accept new partners leading to unstable home lives.

Men walking away from their families at the drop of a hat.

The stable family unit is increasingly rarer these days which leads to an unsettled and anxious child and later young adult. In my child's school mum and dad being together seems to be the minority.

That will be unpopular to say but I think is closer to the truth.

Add on top of that social media and unrealistic material life expectations, it becomes a toxic and lonely mix for youngsters.

Agree !

Sunshineheres · Today 18:57

DrMorbius · Today 18:49

^ ^ This with bells on. My Granded pulled artillery around the battlefields of WW1 (on a horse). My uncle was a prisoner of war at 20. My dad grew up,in 1930's poverty and was was working a manual job at 14. Non of them had mental health issues and went on to live happy fulfilling lives.

The problem is the modern woke UK society that shields kids from any hurdles and hardships. Parents that shield kids from adversity (even down to mundane tasks, like walking to school. I was walking to school at 6 years old). Schools that tell kids "it the taking part, that counts. Not the winning". Really!!! Do you think kids in China or India are being told the same?
In short preventing the vitally important lessons in life, that are essentially all gained through adversity or failure.

My Grandad was in North Africa in WW1 and always refused to talk about that time. By the time I knew him, it appeared that he was living a normal life unscathed, but long after his death my Dad did some real research about his time in the Army and the years that followed.

It turned out he had been medically discharged in 1919, well after the war had ended, and lived with his sister, with no record of any paid work for nearly a decade afterwards. Yes, what he faced was much worse than most of our current young people (although we don't really know what trauma some have faced) but as a young man he was faring no better than some of this "lost generation", people just didn't ever mention it.

ETA the family story was always that he'd left the Army in 1918 and gone to work for the paper mill, but that didn't actually happen until much later, so what you think you know about your family members might not be what actually happened, just as today's young people might not tell their DGC they didn't work for years because of MH issues.

JustAnotherWhinger · Today 18:58

I think it’s social media, 24/7 news and the inability to escape anything amplifying everything really doesn’t help.

The lack of independence and freedom also keeps young people immature for longer. So many don’t play out or walk to school so they’re not learning any problem solving skills. They’re either with parents, at school or in childcare so they’re not learning to resolve issues, they don’t even learn how to be bored.

One of the biggest ones is that they don’t have the Saturday jobs or paper rounds like previous generations. They take a huge step in maturity with their first job. That used to happen for many many at 13/14/15. They’d be more mature and in turn that would spread among their group. Then after school or college another big step would come in their first ‘proper’ job. Now many aren’t getting anywhere near a job until 18/19/20.
my DD1 (late twenties)was asked to babysit for someone next week whose children are 14 and 15. DD was the babysitter at that age.

I also think a lot of parents are very inconsistent as well. So many have heavy heavy rules the whole way through school and then they’re surprised when their child struggles at uni or college. If you want them to mature into an adult you have to guide it step-by-step, not infantilise them massively until 17.5 and expect full on adult maturity at 18.

nedip · Today 18:59

Rustybike · Today 18:43

Not really the same is it? Pensioners, most of whom have worked and contributed. Nice try though.

Meanwhile, perhaps you can explain how Burnham’s plan to renegotiate freedom of movement for people from the EU to come here and work will improve job opportunities for the NEETS?

Ah don’t start banging on about immigrants in what was an interesting discussion.

OP posts:
gymavoidant2027 · Today 19:00

nedip · Today 17:50

Maybe but social media has been with us over 20 years. Phones and screens longer. They’re not the first generation to grow up with too much screens and social media - and in the past the dangers were lesser known and it was less regulated.

I think social media became a lot more toxic and insidious since the advent of Instagram and TikTok, with all of the photoshop and editing apps, which also work for videos. When SM had just began and it was just Facebook, people were just posting pictures of their nights out and holidays, or at weekend.

nedip · Today 19:00

bookdook · Today 18:44

@placematstbf that article talks about taking annual leave for GTA, my brother is. This thread is about those not working…

It’s not at all about those not working. It’s about the mental health crisis amongst the young, working or not.

OP posts:
gymavoidant2027 · Today 19:01

nedip · Today 18:59

Ah don’t start banging on about immigrants in what was an interesting discussion.

Certain people are just obsessed with immigration, sadly.

ilovebrie8 · Today 19:01

Blackcat2026 · Today 18:56

Social media.

Previous generations have suffered through far worse economic times and didn't all have 'mental health issues'.

I believe it's a lack of actual hardship, coupled with an enormous gap between the reality of life and the life 'influencers' are selling that's mostly to blame. In the past, luxurious lifestyles were the preserve of the very wealthy and was completely unattainable. Watching or reading about them was just a nice daydream. These days it's all champagne lifestyle on lemonade money and you're 'nobody' if you don't have x,y or z, a mug fill of fillers or goin' Doooobaiiiiiii hun. You can never 'make it', because there's always more to want.

Yep social media is a huge problem!

insta, tik tok and the whole influencer malarkey needs to end! it’s not normal …tweens posing with pumped up lips, fake eyelashes etc just no. The whole fake lifestyle wannabies!

Morals and sensibility has gone out the window big time.