Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

What on earth is going on with young people?

137 replies

nedip · Today 17:46

What is causing such enormous rates of mental health struggles? I absolutely 100% that these are real, but what’s behind it? I’d think it was the miserable economic picture, but that’s been miserable for college and university leavers since 2008 and was difficult for school leavers in the 80s. Is it Covid?

OP posts:
Talkingtomyhouseplants · Today 18:34

ohmaaaan · Today 17:53

Unpopular view but I think there is an element of it all being a bit contagious.

I remember when there was a self harm storyline on Hollyoaks which was quite controversial at the time and a lot of girls started self harming. That was over twenty years ago too so not recent.

I was at secondary school around then - there absolutely was a time when it was almost fashionable to self harm!

Manifesto · Today 18:34

I manage a large team. The members who are late or have dramas preventing working in a straightforward manner from 9-5 are frustratingly the 19-29 group. The older ones have loads more obvious responsibilities. however they don’t impact their employment in such a significant way. It’s exhausting to everyone around them. Btw I’m a huge advocate of appenticeships etc

Rustybike · Today 18:34

bookdook · Today 18:30

Also people seem to get confused looking at the past. We have had higher unemployment rates amongst the young. But unemployment is increasing due to losing entry level jobs & things like NI increases.

Reeves made it more expensive to hire people by whacking up NI, Rayner by creating various new rules around ability to fire & hire. Then, as the predictable impact on the job market began to manifest, they tried to reverse the damage they did in the first place, by creating a set of new carve outs an exceptions in the tax and benefit system.

Our brilliant Labour government.

Yourchildrenwillbegiants · Today 18:35

nedip · Today 18:12

This was exactly the same when I left university 16 years ago. It is soul destroying, but it didn’t leave us with such a mental health crisis.

It’s harder to get a graduate job now than it used to be.

Absobeautely · Today 18:37

Being alive isn't affordable, there are no jobs, there are only enough nutrients in UK soil for another 60 years of crops, there's going to be millions of climate refugees in upcoming decades, and water shortages.

What is there to look forward to if you're young? Struggle, climate catastrophe and being mocked by some older people for being weak.

placemats · Today 18:37

nedip · Today 17:50

Maybe but social media has been with us over 20 years. Phones and screens longer. They’re not the first generation to grow up with too much screens and social media - and in the past the dangers were lesser known and it was less regulated.

Not the same thing though. Social media is addictive. As is gaming.

Pretending to be in New Zealand, booking leave and buying consoles - the lengths fans are going to for GTA 6

www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm4gn9xnn1ppo

Mondaytuesdayhappydays · Today 18:38

NormasArse · Today 18:14

I’ve seen this first hand. Also becoming gay then changing their mind (girls).

The girl- to- boy trans phenomenon just after Covid where young girls , most likely gay or gender non conforming, cut all their hair, changed their name to ‘Star’ or ‘Diesal’ or such like and stared wearing JD sports tracksuit and pierced their eye brows was 💯 social contagion. I’m an adolescents social worker and haven’t come across it since.
These girls have all ‘transitioned’ back now and some are gay or bi - even the asexual/pan/ poly identities have tailed off as it’s no longer particularly on trend.
All about perceived emotional trauma now; as well as poor emotional health, cutting and self-imposed labels for PTSD, ADHD and ASD. School refusal is also contagious in my view
I miss good old days of teens sneaking around shagging, drinking and smoking, getting high/ stoned, bunking off and trying desperately
to hide from parents if I’m honest.
The level supervision, hovering, interfering in their relationships and tracking of young folks is bonkers..except ironically where that is most required - ONLINE which is a wild Wild West

Absobeautely · Today 18:38

Yourchildrenwillbegiants · Today 18:35

It’s harder to get a graduate job now than it used to be.

It's something like 100,000 graduate job roles a year, between 800,000 graduates.

bookdook · Today 18:40

Being told that Father Christmas still exists when they're nearly 13 years old

Seriously

Rustybike · Today 18:40

Yourchildrenwillbegiants · Today 18:35

It’s harder to get a graduate job now than it used to be.

Who knew that crippling overtaxation used to fund welfare to pay people to stay at home, and migrants to pour into the country so they could also be paid to do nothing, would lead to unemployment and economic contraction?

bookdook · Today 18:41

Rustybike · Today 18:40

Who knew that crippling overtaxation used to fund welfare to pay people to stay at home, and migrants to pour into the country so they could also be paid to do nothing, would lead to unemployment and economic contraction?

Oh you’re one of those but remember where most of the welfare is spent, on older people.

Also this may blow your mind but nearly half of those NEETs don’t claim benefits.

Fingeronthebutton · Today 18:41

SirChenjins · Today 17:48

Social media, screens and not enough face to face interaction.

It’s not rocket science, is it. A doctor friend said to me history will look back on this time and say: you gave children what 😱
Dont get me wrong, I love technology but the whole industry wasn’t policed properly from the start.

Rustybike · Today 18:43

bookdook · Today 18:41

Oh you’re one of those but remember where most of the welfare is spent, on older people.

Also this may blow your mind but nearly half of those NEETs don’t claim benefits.

Not really the same is it? Pensioners, most of whom have worked and contributed. Nice try though.

Meanwhile, perhaps you can explain how Burnham’s plan to renegotiate freedom of movement for people from the EU to come here and work will improve job opportunities for the NEETS?

Emilesgran · Today 18:43

nedip · Today 17:50

Maybe but social media has been with us over 20 years. Phones and screens longer. They’re not the first generation to grow up with too much screens and social media - and in the past the dangers were lesser known and it was less regulated.

Yes but social media available 24/7 on mobile phones is a more recent development - mid 2010s, so more like 10-15 years. So this is the first generation that grew up on social media apps from babyhood.

bookdook · Today 18:44

@placematstbf that article talks about taking annual leave for GTA, my brother is. This thread is about those not working…

Lazylaura · Today 18:44

Why I bought my first home ..3 bedroom garage big garden age 24 ,for £53,000..in 1998 ..there was hope ..I had a normal job ,and I bought a nice house ,I didn't do particularly well at school ..but there was jobs available and from there I got a mortgage...I was able to have children and take time of work to look after them because my husband could pay the mortgage by himself..
Had we of decided not to buy a home ,we could of gone on the council house list and been given a flat ,there wasn't a huge waiting list for property.

Fast forward to my 24 year old son today ...a three bedroom home costs £400,000 for the same amount of space ,no parking,no garage small garden..
He won't be able to pay that mortgage by himself,they won't be able for her to take time of work to raise any children,they won't be able to pay an extra £2000 a month for a nursery place for one child
They can't ever decide to go on the council waiting list , because it is absolutely horrendous and only people in desperate need get temporary accommodation here ..
My son did so much better at school than me ,and is able to buy the more expensive house ..but for his friends who didn't secure a graduate job ,there is no hope at 24 of getting their own home ,no hope of a council flat ,no hope of a decent job ,with average qualifications,like I got ..
I imagine if I was 24 now ,with my job then and my education then ,there would be no home ,no babies ,no nice life .
The hope has gone ,young people with average qualifications don't stand a hope in hell of getting a mortgage and becoming an adult in their own home
Out of my son's friendship group of 24 year olds ..1 person out of a group of 10 has their own home ,like I was able to do at 24 ..
How are you meant to grow up ,be independent when you have no chance of getting your own home .
And the cost of everything is horrendous,the bills ,the electric,the water ,all horrendous.
These 24 year olds ..none of them have disability..god help the ones with a disability and no decent education and now about to have their benefits removed.
Yet still people think huge amounts of immigration is a good thing
Pushing up property prices beyond what normal wages can afford
Pushing down wages because of demand for every job
The only people winning here ,are the landlords and buissnes owners ...who incidentally are also often politicians..the very people driving high rates of immigration,and actively encouraging more alyslum seekers by the handouts ..and not putting limits on house prices,or food or electric.
And now so many will lose benefits as well ..
Wonderful..but we always have benefits for new arrivals

SultanaPud · Today 18:44

Not playing out as children.

Children need to play freely with one another, outdoors in all weathers, away from adults.

This has been the case for all human societies since the dawn of time.

It is how humans develop resilience, social skills, conflict resolution, friendships, and a love of life and the natural world and all it has to offer.

The shift to an "indoor" childhood with constant parental supervision and so much screen time/social media is unnatural. No wonder young people's minds aren't healthy.

Daily play in the fresh air for children should be central to any government plan to address this issue.

nedip · Today 18:44

napody · Today 18:24

No it wasn't exactly the same.
There was a sudden drop in graduate jobs and schemes then.
Now it's difficult to get ANY job.

That is simply untrue. It was difficult to get any job. As a cleaner, as a call centre worker, in shops. It was extremely difficult.

OP posts:
DuchesseChou · Today 18:45

I think it’s mostly social media. I moved from uk to France and there is considerably less phone/social media amongst teens here.

Also less choice, as teens/yp you just eat what the adults eat, go to local school, don’t have latest iPhone.

They hang out with mates at the shops without a phone in front of their face.

No uni fees or ‘RG’ uni pressure.

Yes they had the riots recently but they were hijacked by (take your pick) idiots.

I just see less pressure on yp here all round. They seem happier overall.

Crinkle77 · Today 18:45

Rustybike · Today 18:00

Missing backbone, grit, resilience.

Yep this. Kids aren't taught that sometimes you win, sometimes you lose. Competitions where are all kids are given a prize for example. Parents doing everything for them. When I was younger I remember having to ring a company or something. Can't remember what it was but I wanted my mum to do it for me and she said no and that I needed to do it. At the time I thought she was mean but I now realise she was teaching me valuable life skills. When I was looking at uni and going to open days she didn't go with me. I went up to Newcastle with my friend on the train. My mum was a teacher and she couldn't mark their maths as wrong. So kids are never learning how to deal with setbacks and challenges or do do things for themselves.

BigAnne · Today 18:45

Maybe a small thing but no Saturday jobs for the under sixteen. It's the first time they have their own money thanks to their own hard work. It's the first time learning how to manage money and to be part of a team and to take instructions from someone other than parents or teachers.

bookdook · Today 18:46

Rustybike · Today 18:43

Not really the same is it? Pensioners, most of whom have worked and contributed. Nice try though.

Meanwhile, perhaps you can explain how Burnham’s plan to renegotiate freedom of movement for people from the EU to come here and work will improve job opportunities for the NEETS?

It’s not a nice try, it’s a fact. The vast majority of pensioners have not contributed anywhere near enough for their state pension & the NHS Demographics matter when you have pyramid schemes. Although please feel free to share something that shows otherwise.

Why on earth do I need to comment on Burnhams plans, it’s not something I have even mentioned!

nedip · Today 18:47

Lunalara · Today 18:25

The financial crashes were awful, but there could have been a sense of things getting better in the future (correct me if I am wrong, I was a child in 2008). If companies are laying off thousands of employees and AI is constantly replacing those jobs, there is a lot less certainty as to how anyone can improve the situation.

No, there was no sense of that. We had the Tories arrive in 2010 to tell us all that we would all have to take the pain of expenditure cuts and a contracting economy. It hasn’t changed since then.

OP posts:
Rustybike · Today 18:48

Crinkle77 · Today 18:45

Yep this. Kids aren't taught that sometimes you win, sometimes you lose. Competitions where are all kids are given a prize for example. Parents doing everything for them. When I was younger I remember having to ring a company or something. Can't remember what it was but I wanted my mum to do it for me and she said no and that I needed to do it. At the time I thought she was mean but I now realise she was teaching me valuable life skills. When I was looking at uni and going to open days she didn't go with me. I went up to Newcastle with my friend on the train. My mum was a teacher and she couldn't mark their maths as wrong. So kids are never learning how to deal with setbacks and challenges or do do things for themselves.

Absolutely.

I was always taught (and I still adhere to it) - own it. You can blame exogenous events, but what does it achieve?

Two options - give up, or fight.

Dollymylove · Today 18:48

Social media, lack of boundaries, gentle parenting, lack of discipline. Parents wanting to be their kids "best friends"