Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

What on earth is going on with young people?

137 replies

nedip · Today 17:46

What is causing such enormous rates of mental health struggles? I absolutely 100% that these are real, but what’s behind it? I’d think it was the miserable economic picture, but that’s been miserable for college and university leavers since 2008 and was difficult for school leavers in the 80s. Is it Covid?

OP posts:
Rustybike · Today 18:25

napody · Today 18:24

No it wasn't exactly the same.
There was a sudden drop in graduate jobs and schemes then.
Now it's difficult to get ANY job.

If we think it’s bad now, wait until AI really makes its presence felt…

Lunalara · Today 18:25

nedip · Today 18:17

I am currently job hunting. It is difficult with experience. It was very difficult in 2010 too following the financial crash as a new graduate. Almost impossible. It was soul destroying. But the lack of opportunity for young people has been a theme for almost 20 years now, and there are clear differences now with regards to younger people’s mental health.

It cannot just be the economic problems which no politician has resolved for young people in nearly two decades.

The financial crashes were awful, but there could have been a sense of things getting better in the future (correct me if I am wrong, I was a child in 2008). If companies are laying off thousands of employees and AI is constantly replacing those jobs, there is a lot less certainty as to how anyone can improve the situation.

bookdook · Today 18:25

I don’t buy the less resilient argument, I wasn’t particularly resilient as a young people but I didn’t face that many challenges.

socialworkme · Today 18:26

Huge amounts of kids getting to their teens with undiagnosed autism and ADHD. Neurodivergent kids (and adults) struggle in the world if their needs aren’t met and aren’t understood. This is a huge issues and causes significant mental health difficulties, high incidents of self harm and suicidal ideation.
People wang on about over diagnosis but actually what we’re seeing is a pattern of under diagnosis until kids are in full on burn out and in crisis.

Schools just aren’t meeting lots of kids needs. Education is so process driven and isn’t inspiring lots of kids who aren’t traditionally academic. Some of the restrictive rules and expectations just disenfranchise kids and set them up to fail.

Systemic issues such as financial difficulties, parental mental health problems, abuse and conflict.

Yes social media and tech access is a huge issue but not necessarily in isolation and often indicates wider issues. What they’re seeing is horrific, kids are being groomed and seeing live suicides online. Parents need to have more control and awareness of what their kids are accessing.

MxCactus · Today 18:26

Personally I'd say it's: social media (being exposed to it since birth, screens, and full time group childcare for the majority since birth.

0-3 years is a critical time for attachment and brain development - if this is disrupted during this critical window, people tend to have big mental health problems their entire life.

In most families, both parents have to work now. Wasn't the case in the past - you also say we've had social media and screens for 20 years... Well yes, but this is the first generation to be exposed to them since birth. And we know all that impacts mental health massively

Sunshineheres · Today 18:26

I'm really surprised how few people have mentioned Covid. People in their 20s now were massively affected by that.

shihtzuu · Today 18:26

MH affects people v differently so not exactly sure what you mean specifically :)? TBH I don't think the way we lump all behaviours and thoughts under 'mental health' helps!

I felt demotivated with job rejection after job rejection but I just kept going because I didn't have a choice? It was either stop or never get a job but there are only so many jobs you can apply to - you start seeing the same ones on Indeed being advertised and so it does get incredibly demotivating.

If you don't have anything to do/responsibilities I can see how people spend ages or hours on their phone and feel depressed. But depression is different eg clinically bed bound etc

Other things like self harm, addiction though are different with different causes but also MH issues.

Canape · Today 18:26

Too much tracking, helicopter parenting, no independence for a start

bookdook · Today 18:27

Rustybike · Today 18:24

Sorry, but you cannot pass the buck to the state.

Own it as a parent/guardian.

It’s the state responsibility to invest in its people, that’s what I pay taxes for. That’s different to my responsibility as a parent.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · Today 18:27

nedip · Today 17:46

What is causing such enormous rates of mental health struggles? I absolutely 100% that these are real, but what’s behind it? I’d think it was the miserable economic picture, but that’s been miserable for college and university leavers since 2008 and was difficult for school leavers in the 80s. Is it Covid?

I don’t believe that in previous generations, many of these ‘MH’ issues, would be seen as a reason for not working.

The sad fact is, too many people are now lacking in resilience, and think that feeling e.g. the sort of anxiety that used to be deemed normal - e.g when starting a new job - counts as grounds for giving up.

It’s been stated time and again by people who are supposed to know, that milder MH conditions are not helped at all by staying at home, and it may well make matters worse.

nedip · Today 18:28

WilyKitOrWilyKat · Today 18:17

I think it's going to get worse. I have a primary school age child with anxiety and struggles to attend school.

There is no help for him. At. All.

GP says speak to school. School says they are doing what they can (not much). CAMHS won't help unless he's suicidal. Charity we were referred to won't help because it's anxiety so see CAMHS.

No-one will help.

We do what we can through educating ourselves on the internet but it's not enough. We aren't experts.

He is one of many in the school system like this.

That is awful. I hope you find some help. What is causing his anxiety, if you don’t mind me asking?

OP posts:
discombobulado · Today 18:28

Young people are much more savvy than they’re given credit for.….they’re completely aware that the climate crisis and AI are threatening their futures and nobody is listening to them on that. There is a sense of futility amongst the teenagers I know who are all keen to make something of their lives but can’t see how that will look.

I have only skim read the replies here but I haven’t seen that mentioned.

bookdook · Today 18:28

I wouldn’t say the above 50s are particularly resilient

Periperi2025 · Today 18:29

Parental armchair diagnosing and private assessment confirmation of every normal difficultly of childhood and difference of personality, learning style, achievement level ect.

Obsession with affirmation and validation of these differences rather than accpetance, trouble trouble shooting and adaptation.

MalloryApple · Today 18:29

ohmaaaan · Today 17:53

Unpopular view but I think there is an element of it all being a bit contagious.

I remember when there was a self harm storyline on Hollyoaks which was quite controversial at the time and a lot of girls started self harming. That was over twenty years ago too so not recent.

I agree with this, and normalising mental health struggles. People are too quick now to allow themselves to be depressed/anxious etc. and sit with that.

I’m human, I feel depressed and anxious at times but I don’t dwell on it, don’t take a mental health day off; I get up go for a run, eat some fruit and get to work.

Rustybike · Today 18:30

bookdook · Today 18:27

It’s the state responsibility to invest in its people, that’s what I pay taxes for. That’s different to my responsibility as a parent.

How’s that working out for you? The tax you pay, and the investment in people?

bookdook · Today 18:30

Also people seem to get confused looking at the past. We have had higher unemployment rates amongst the young. But unemployment is increasing due to losing entry level jobs & things like NI increases.

Queenieoh · Today 18:31

Children are being overprotected in the real world and underprotected in the digital world.
They are growing up with less freedom, independence, outdoor play, physical activity and face-to-face social interaction than previous generations. Many have fewer opportunities to explore, take risks, make mistakes, resolve conflicts and socialise without constant adult supervision.
Meanwhile, they are exposed to a relentless 24/7 news cycle, global crises, doomscrolling, addictive algorithms, unrealistic expectations and a culture of constant comparison and online validation.
We monitor their whereabouts, track their movements and increasingly remove opportunities for independent play and unsupervised socialising, yet hand them devices that offer almost unrestricted access to the adult world.
How can children develop resilience if they're never given the freedom to navigate challenges independently? How can teenagers develop confidence, autonomy and meaningful relationships when so much of their social lives takes place behind screens or under adult supervision?
Of course, the youth mental health crisis is complex and has multiple causes. But we need to seriously question why we've made the physical world so restrictive for children while allowing the digital world such extraordinary access to them.
We've confused protecting children with controlling them, while failing to protect them where they may need it most.

Happyjoe · Today 18:31

I think the biggest thing is social media. Then parenting styles have shifted, children ferried everywhere, problems solved for them, being online a large proportion of time. Being afraid of failure, both parents and children. I also think theres more parents now who just give in for the easy life, missing the important but very hard parts of parenting. Maybe a little bit of suggestion too, sometimes these things can go in waves.

ginasevern · Today 18:32

Not enough social interaction. Not enough independence or the encouragement of independent thought. Being cosseted at every turn instead of being guided to get up and dust themselves off because life is sometimes very hard and not fair. Being treated like 12 year olds well into their 20's and being far more a part of their parents' lives than previous generations. Far more emphasis on materialism than ever before. Being told that Father Christmas still exists when they're nearly 13 years old. Social media obviously has a lot to answer for. And contagion. Yes, teenagers are always looking for badges to wear. I did when I was one. So if having mental health struggles is a badge that gets them recognised or treated differently, then they'll definitely wear it.

bookdook · Today 18:32

Rustybike · Today 18:30

How’s that working out for you? The tax you pay, and the investment in people?

I don’t understand your comment? All I know is my tax keeps going up. And as I said we haven’t invested in the young for years.

Monstermissy36 · Today 18:33

Dicedpumpkin · Today 18:09

I read a book called the Anxious Generation which looked at actual research into this area. I cant remember what it said though or whether its conclusions are contested

Im pretty sure it was smart phones/less unsupervised play.

my takeaway from that was when he said the kids are over protected in the real world and under protected in the online world! So true…

SplishSplash123 · Today 18:33

nedip · Today 17:50

Maybe but social media has been with us over 20 years. Phones and screens longer. They’re not the first generation to grow up with too much screens and social media - and in the past the dangers were lesser known and it was less regulated.

But social media wasnt always accessible on phones, and phones didn't always have so many apps.
Social media content has changed a lot - videos weren't much of a thing before tiktok.

I worry that the impact of lockdown has made leaving the house and going to work seem like optional activities (even for adults, if some of my colleagues - who act like being expected to work in the office is against their human rights - are anything to go by).

I am sympathetic to young people in so far as lockdowns did have a huge impact on their development at crucial times during their childhood, but at the same time they need to be encouraged by society to stand on their own two feet now and accept that no one owes them a living and life doesn't promise an easy ride.

1dayatatime · Today 18:33

I fully agree with previous posters on social media and other suggestions.

But as a slightly random addition, a reduction in the number of young people going to the pub doesn't help. In a pub young people learn to socialise face to face and most importantly talk.

I think that there is a really strong case to increase taxation on supermarket alcohol and decrease it on pub alcohol so that they are parity priced