Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Chat

Join the discussion and chat with other Mumsnetters about everyday life, relationships and parenting.

Is my mum allowed to pay for my weekly food shop?

181 replies

Smilingpeacock · Today 10:17

Hi,

my elderly mum has become obsessed with ‘off loading money ‘ before the government takes it. She gifts me 3k year etc, to be clear I don’t expect or need anything I am very grateful.

She now wants to start paying for my weekly food shop which is about £150 per week. We go shopping together every week and the plan from next week is for her to just pay both hers and mine shopping at the checkout. She seems to think that nobody will ever question this??

i’m always anxious about breaking the rules when it comes to. Money. Is her plan flawed?

OP posts:
Vulturesoverhead · Today 10:58

Wellwellwellwhatsallthisthen · Today 10:41

As PP have said, because this is out of surplus income & doesn't impact her quality of life, it won't count for IHT purposes.

But even so, there's no way this would/could ever be investigated or traced - how would anyone ever be able to prove where her supermarket shop went once she left the store and how much of it she consumed?

Good on her. Enjoy!

To be honest HMRC could see a change in spending and request bank statements if they investigate an estate. I doubt it would ever come to that, but ‘how would they know’?: the digital footprint you leave.

KilkennyCats · Today 11:00

Vulturesoverhead · Today 10:58

To be honest HMRC could see a change in spending and request bank statements if they investigate an estate. I doubt it would ever come to that, but ‘how would they know’?: the digital footprint you leave.

Nobody will ever question a weekly Tesco shop in the context of deliberate deprivation of assets, the very notion is farcical.

tommyhoundmum · Today 11:01

KilkennyCats · Today 10:20

Who would question how she spends her money?!
Unless it’s a benefits thing? Is it? What “rules” are you referring to?

Inheritance laws

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

Bavariamaria · Today 11:01

I would start by checking if she will be liable for IHT in the first place, as noted by a poster up thread.

Vulturesoverhead · Today 11:03

KilkennyCats · Today 11:00

Nobody will ever question a weekly Tesco shop in the context of deliberate deprivation of assets, the very notion is farcical.

They look until they find something - I have had clients investigated and you'd be shocked at what they know about you. However, as I clearly said I doubt it would come to that, or indeed even matter.

JoeTheDrummer · Today 11:03

KilkennyCats · Today 10:20

Who would question how she spends her money?!
Unless it’s a benefits thing? Is it? What “rules” are you referring to?

It’s called deprivation of assets and it would be the Council who would investigate. However they would only do this if they suspected funds had been diverted purely to avoid care fees, and nobody will query something like a Tesco bill. The Council are looking out for people who do things like transfer their house into their childrens’ names, giving away large amounts of money etc, and then saying that they can’t afford care costs so the Council need to pay.

They also have to prove that the person was giving away money purely to avoid future care costs, and that is hard for them to prove if the person is currently in good health.

dandelionfluffy · Today 11:04

Maybe try and get her to treat you to other things like clothes, winter boots, or a meal out and to treat HERSELF.
We have been left with a large inheritance from my DM who would NEVER spend money on herself as she thought she was poor. She had huge assets and savings yet would never get a taxi or eat out which is so sad, I think.

Tel12 · Today 11:04

It's her money, of course she can spend it how she wants. Even if there's a iht issue regular gifts are allowed as long as it's not affecting her standard of living. If she lives more than 7 years it's irrelevant.

Vulturesoverhead · Today 11:04

FalseSpring · Today 10:55

This is not an IHT issue so not sure why so many are commenting on that.

It is unlikely to be deprivation of assets for care home fees as it would be regular spending out of income.

The only impact would be if you are claiming benefits as it could be taken into account in your own assessments. However, if she is just adding stuff for you to her own shopping, nobody is ever going to know.

If there was an IHT liability it is an IHT issue how you spend your money. This however is very very unlikely to matter but the comments around this scenario are incorrect in law

Ethelrogers · Today 11:08

My dh uncle is 75.

He withdraws cash every week for his fictitious drug and gambling habits.

You prove he’s been giving it to his family and not the local weed dealers.

allhailtheeyeballsinthesky · Today 11:09

Im a care assessor, and i would query a tesco bill of £150 per week as that is not usual for a single pensioner. However, I wouldn't ask for the money to be repaid, just note it and ask that it stop

Ethelrogers · Today 11:10

dandelionfluffy · Today 11:04

Maybe try and get her to treat you to other things like clothes, winter boots, or a meal out and to treat HERSELF.
We have been left with a large inheritance from my DM who would NEVER spend money on herself as she thought she was poor. She had huge assets and savings yet would never get a taxi or eat out which is so sad, I think.

My dad lived like that too.

He scrimped and saved all his life but then ended up with dementia so it all went on care home fees.

RigsbysCat · Today 11:10

lavendervibes · Today 10:25

Of course she can do this, not sure who you think would question it.
My mum is similar and wants to do it. After all, you can’t take it with you.

Inheritance Tax rules mean that how you've gifted money in the 7 years before you die is important when it comes to settling an estate. Money someone is giving away has to be sourced from "surplus income" (ie not savings) or else it can be added back into a person's estate and be liable for IHT if that person's estate is liable. It is absolutely ridiculous that the state can affect how normal people use their own money, in their later years, while the super wealthy avoid tax by clever accounting!

The OP is being very sensible in questioning this. I think the shopping solution is probably quite a good one although if somehow HMRC decided to do a in depth review of her mum's estate questions could be asked as to how her living expenses had suddenly gone up so much.

OP my parents were in a similar position and started drawing extra cash out every month and giving it to family. It is very difficult for anyone to say what a person is doing with cash!

RoundedRobin · Today 11:11

Octavia64 · Today 10:26

Ok, so there are a couple of situations where this might be an issue:

one she’s on benefits and has received an inheritance or other lump sum that will take her off benefits and she may have to go back on them in future

two she expects to pay inheritance tax and if she dies then transfers of money to other people within seven years of death will be looked at.
(eg if she gave you money to buy a house and then died but her estate was subject to IHT then the gift might also be).

if not on benefits/no IHT expected it is fine

I think when it's a case of £150 per week paid to Sainsbury's who exactly is it going to be 'looked at' by?

HMRC don't have the resources to comb through the bank statements of everyone who dies, let alone to investigate any transactions they think might fall foul of the IHT rules.

Ethelrogers · Today 11:12

allhailtheeyeballsinthesky · Today 11:09

Im a care assessor, and i would query a tesco bill of £150 per week as that is not usual for a single pensioner. However, I wouldn't ask for the money to be repaid, just note it and ask that it stop

I’d tell you I’d developed a binge eating disorder. What would you do about that?

Winter2020 · Today 11:12

You have said your mum is not on benefits.

She could give you her entire estate today if she wanted to. The only things to consider (if she gave you her entire estate and assuming no rental properties/business/shares where capital gains might be due) would be some inheritance tax may be payable if she dies within 7 years. If she needs care the financial assessment may find deliberate deprivation of assets and treat her as if she still has that money. Of course I'm not suggesting she gives away all her worldy goods - I'm just saying that she is perfectly allowed to do it - and she is perfectly allowed to pay for your shopping!

LadyLapsang · Today 11:13

Three potential issues -
Deprivation of assets for her. If it could be reasonably be for seen she will need to pay for care.
Are there siblings on others who are mentioned in her will who may think you are depleting the estate while she is alive, especially if there could be a question of her competence, e.g. dementia.
Your financial position. If you are claiming means tested benefits and they see you are not buying food, but are paying for holidays, clothes etc. they may investigate, e.g. if you are a single parent, they may think you have reconciled or got a new partner who is cohabiting and paying for shopping.

Winter2020 · Today 11:15

allhailtheeyeballsinthesky · Today 11:09

Im a care assessor, and i would query a tesco bill of £150 per week as that is not usual for a single pensioner. However, I wouldn't ask for the money to be repaid, just note it and ask that it stop

Yes but you would only be involved to give that advice if the OPs mum wanted to claim public money help towards her care wouldn't you?

If the OPs mum is financially independent with no state help it's not a relevant consideration is it? Unless there is reason to believe needing care is imminent?

francobrit · Today 11:15

Ethelrogers · Today 11:08

My dh uncle is 75.

He withdraws cash every week for his fictitious drug and gambling habits.

You prove he’s been giving it to his family and not the local weed dealers.

Cash is king.

CousinBette · Today 11:16

Vulturesoverhead · Today 10:19

Not if she is using excess income. Perfectly legit, but proving that may become more difficult.

Will you DM even have an IHT issue? Will this matter?

This is rubbish. I hope you’re not in the financial advice business. If the OP’s mum wants to buy her weekly food shop, there is absolutely no problem in doing this.

Waffleswithhothoney · Today 11:17

What I don’t understand is this part ‘you can spend the income but as long as you aren’t using capital it’s fine’. So if I have £500k in a savings account when I’m elderly, and it’s all my own savings gathered over my working life I can only depend the interest and not dip into the capital? If I’m retired and decide that I want to have smoked salmon and champagne for breakfast everyday, I can’t because I’ll be spending £150 a week in Waitrose and someone might say I’m trying to avoid inheritance tax?
I tell my DM to spend her money and to enjoy her retirement but should I be telling her to live more frugally incase she spends any of her capital?

RigsbysCat · Today 11:17

JoeTheDrummer · Today 11:03

It’s called deprivation of assets and it would be the Council who would investigate. However they would only do this if they suspected funds had been diverted purely to avoid care fees, and nobody will query something like a Tesco bill. The Council are looking out for people who do things like transfer their house into their childrens’ names, giving away large amounts of money etc, and then saying that they can’t afford care costs so the Council need to pay.

They also have to prove that the person was giving away money purely to avoid future care costs, and that is hard for them to prove if the person is currently in good health.

How people gift money in the 7 years before they die is also relevant to HMRC if the person's estate falls within Inheritance Tax thresholds.

charliehungerford · Today 11:20

dandelionfluffy · Today 11:04

Maybe try and get her to treat you to other things like clothes, winter boots, or a meal out and to treat HERSELF.
We have been left with a large inheritance from my DM who would NEVER spend money on herself as she thought she was poor. She had huge assets and savings yet would never get a taxi or eat out which is so sad, I think.

Yes, how lovely to have a Mum who wants to treat you. My PIL live like paupers and see any expense aside from food as a ‘waste of money’. Moth eaten carpets, 50 year old kitchen and everything falling to bits. They’re in their 90’s and will die with hundreds of thousands of pounds in the bank. I wish they’d spent it giving themselves a nicer retirement.

Rosesandthorns66 · Today 11:22

ThisWiseRobin · Today 10:21

Let her do it. As we get older we need less things around us. It makes her feel needed and wanted. If she's ever in trouble you have the money she gave you to help out.
I'm 70 next birthday, my kids earn 4x what I did in my life but I still like to pay my way. Its feeling needed.
Just put tge 3k away and it's there if she needs it.
She's also not wrong about unloading. This government would have the last drop of blood from her veins if they could.

I agree with this.
It's your mom showering you with her love.
(Even though it's money).
I think parents do that.
My parents did this.
And I only understand their love behind this now, when there's no one here to do it anymore.

Octavia64 · Today 11:22

Waffleswithhothoney · Today 11:17

What I don’t understand is this part ‘you can spend the income but as long as you aren’t using capital it’s fine’. So if I have £500k in a savings account when I’m elderly, and it’s all my own savings gathered over my working life I can only depend the interest and not dip into the capital? If I’m retired and decide that I want to have smoked salmon and champagne for breakfast everyday, I can’t because I’ll be spending £150 a week in Waitrose and someone might say I’m trying to avoid inheritance tax?
I tell my DM to spend her money and to enjoy her retirement but should I be telling her to live more frugally incase she spends any of her capital?

No.

it’s about the rules that give exemption from inheritance tax.

you can spend your money how you want. But the government can have the tax rules they want.

if you want to spend your money on smoking you pay tax on cigarettes. If you want to just spend it you pay vat.

the advice given is for if you want to spend it and pay minimum tax.

if you just want to spend it and don’t care about tax then it doesn’t matter