Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

943 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
Perenelle · Yesterday 22:27

Well, it seems that you indeed can’t feed cookies to a rock.

inkymoose · Yesterday 22:43

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · Yesterday 18:39

This ought to be pinned at the top of this board. Especially the Just stop your nonsense bit. 😂

Thanks @kitex
"Just stop your nonsense. You will never be a woman. You don’t know what it is to be a woman because you are a man. Being a woman isn’t a feeling. We are all fed with this ridiculous notion that TIMs can become women."
🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 22:52

caprioska · Yesterday 22:17

Relevance to what?

Well if people can’t know what sex à baby is without these tests, how does anyone know what sex they are unless they get these tests? You’re the one saying sex is sooooooo complicated.

Transperson · Yesterday 22:52

BlueLegume · Yesterday 21:00

I’m so close to asking if the gender vs sex thing are people in the first camp who actually do not or have not ever actually had sex or intimacy. Not being cruel or bigoted.

Some comments just sound so immature akin to kids not liking what someone said at school and claiming ‘you are bullying me’.

Have you considered that some people aren't bigoted like yourself?

TheHereticalOne · Yesterday 22:53

caprioska · Yesterday 21:49

Under age accompanied males in women's toilets?

Yes, fair point - my initial wording may have been slightly too strong to allow for the rare exceptions where flexibility actually benefits the sex class of women for whom the spaces are designed.

On the letter of the law you could certainly have a go at arguing the inclusion of young male children with their mothers in single sex spaces constitutes indirect discrimination against women.

However, assuming that one of the justified reasons for having the single sex space in the first place (let's say a swimming pool changing room to borrow from the code of practice) was to increase the uptake of women using the service, though, you would be likely to lose and this would instead constitute a tolerated and lines departure from the baseline rule (the exception that proves it, if you like). This is on the basis that allowing young male children in actually contributes to that benefit for the sex class of women for whom the service is in place because allowing them to bring their children with them will likely increase female uptake if the service. It would also be unlikely to affect women's safety, women's sense of privacy and dignity etc. though all those things could be legally argued. This is why I said "likely" to be direct and indirect discrimination in my original post.

Those things would take you no further at all in arguing that males with a characteristic of gender reassignment should be included because it in no way furthers the original aim and reason for having the single sex space in the first place. That is, permitting men with the protected characteristic of gender reassignment in the space for women had no benefit to the women, is likely to decrease rather than increase their uptake, pose a threat to their safety (not only from those men who genuinely consider themselves women but because it in effect allows all men in, defeating the purpose; conversely including every single young male child in existence in with his mother would not increase the threat to women) and undermine their sense of privacy and dignity.

Another thing people struggle with there is that the focus of the analysis would have to be what benefits it brings to women, not the sub-section of men who want to be included. Not a natural formulation for many people to centre women!

I suppose you could also have a crack at arguing that allowing young boys in with their mothers constitutes direct discrimination against other, older males on the basis of age. I'm a bit too knackered to consider and set out the legal reasons why that would be likely to fail but I think the judge would also resent having to write anything more than "oh fuck offffff" for his or her legal reasoning!

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 22:55

Transperson · Yesterday 22:52

Have you considered that some people aren't bigoted like yourself?

Like the people who issue rape threats, death threats and violence to people who don’t agree with them? The ones who try to “cancel” people for not going along with their beliefs? You’re right, I'm not bigoted like them. Now you get it. Well done. Have a participation trophy 🏆

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 22:55

Genderism is sexism, pure and simple. It starts with an assumption that one way of thinking is right for women but not for men and vice versa.

How could it be anything but sexist?

TheHereticalOne · Yesterday 22:55

Oh fuck, I've just realised what thread this is on.

HOW DOES IT FEEL TO BE GENDER CRITICAL?

Transperson · Yesterday 22:59

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 22:55

Genderism is sexism, pure and simple. It starts with an assumption that one way of thinking is right for women but not for men and vice versa.

How could it be anything but sexist?

No one is saying any of these?

Gender identity is how you feel about how you want to be precieved, interact with society, and see yourself - it doesn't dictate anything about anything thought process.

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 23:03

Transperson · Yesterday 22:59

No one is saying any of these?

Gender identity is how you feel about how you want to be precieved, interact with society, and see yourself - it doesn't dictate anything about anything thought process.

Edited

So if gender identity is internal, it is not relevant to anyone or anything external. So one can think they’re a “laydee” all they like, they still have to use the gents. This may make them sad. I don’t care.

Transperson · Yesterday 23:05

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 23:03

So if gender identity is internal, it is not relevant to anyone or anything external. So one can think they’re a “laydee” all they like, they still have to use the gents. This may make them sad. I don’t care.

Hormones have biological changes. Passing trans people exist.
I know it's hard for you to swallow but I don't care.

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 23:07

Transperson · Yesterday 23:05

Hormones have biological changes. Passing trans people exist.
I know it's hard for you to swallow but I don't care.

All medication has biological changes. What’s your point? Moobs do not maketh woman. Otherwise half the men over 30 in Scotland would be classed as women.

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 23:07

Today it feels like standing in sturdy boots on a solid base watching someone flailing madly around on a patch of ice trying to keep their balance and failing miserably. Just as you think they're about to get their feet underneath them WHoops! away they go again 😂

OldCrone · Yesterday 23:10

Transperson · Yesterday 22:59

No one is saying any of these?

Gender identity is how you feel about how you want to be precieved, interact with society, and see yourself - it doesn't dictate anything about anything thought process.

Edited

Why would a man want to be perceived as a woman and interact with society as he thinks a woman would and see himself as a woman?

I thought we were told this is because he thinks he feels like a woman and thinks he thinks like a woman. Is there some other reason for him wanting this?

StealthTroublemaker · Yesterday 23:10

OldCrone · Yesterday 23:10

Why would a man want to be perceived as a woman and interact with society as he thinks a woman would and see himself as a woman?

I thought we were told this is because he thinks he feels like a woman and thinks he thinks like a woman. Is there some other reason for him wanting this?

Rhymes with lettuce? If you squint?

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 23:12

Transperson · Yesterday 22:59

No one is saying any of these?

Gender identity is how you feel about how you want to be precieved, interact with society, and see yourself - it doesn't dictate anything about anything thought process.

Edited

It's not though is it? Because you are not saying "I want to be seen like this", you are saying "I want to be seen as one of them". Your identity as a trans person depends on something you perceive in other people to be the same as you.

What is the difference between men and women that you are perceiving when you recognise yourself as one rather than the other?

GriseldaandMike · Yesterday 23:32

caprioska · Yesterday 22:14

If sex and gender aren't the same thing why the need to insist we can't determine the sex of a newborn or indeed a fetus?

I never said that. What I said was gametes & chromosomal tests were not routinely done at birth that's why some people use the term 'assigned sex at birth'. In other words the context of the discussion was about a preference in terms not that reproductive sex wasn't real.

Oh do come on, we all know that the whole 'assigned at birth' isnt a matter of semantics. It is an attempt to suggest that sex at birth is something given randomly and therefore sometimes incorrectly hence trans people.

Transperson · Yesterday 23:39

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 23:12

It's not though is it? Because you are not saying "I want to be seen like this", you are saying "I want to be seen as one of them". Your identity as a trans person depends on something you perceive in other people to be the same as you.

What is the difference between men and women that you are perceiving when you recognise yourself as one rather than the other?

Edited

I can't speak for other trans people but that's not the case for me.

For me it's coming from how I want to express myself, I transitioned for myself and I don't have a specific box I put myself in.

GreyskySexRealistsky · Yesterday 23:39

FlirtsWithRhinos · Yesterday 23:07

Today it feels like standing in sturdy boots on a solid base watching someone flailing madly around on a patch of ice trying to keep their balance and failing miserably. Just as you think they're about to get their feet underneath them WHoops! away they go again 😂

Ouch

Animation Winter GIF
GriseldaandMike · Yesterday 23:40

Transperson · Yesterday 23:39

I can't speak for other trans people but that's not the case for me.

For me it's coming from how I want to express myself, I transitioned for myself and I don't have a specific box I put myself in.

I don't have a specific box I put myself in.

Yeah you do, it's a box marked ladies toilet.

Transperson · Yesterday 23:43

OldCrone · Yesterday 23:10

Why would a man want to be perceived as a woman and interact with society as he thinks a woman would and see himself as a woman?

I thought we were told this is because he thinks he feels like a woman and thinks he thinks like a woman. Is there some other reason for him wanting this?

Again this is not a 'think' thing

It's people having an innate feelings about their gender identity and wanting to express that.

OldCrone · Yesterday 23:51

Transperson · Yesterday 23:43

Again this is not a 'think' thing

It's people having an innate feelings about their gender identity and wanting to express that.

So you're a man who just likes to express yourself in a certain way.

No problem. Express yourself any way you want to. As long as you don't think your self expression makes you some sort of woman. Because that's not what you are.

Transperson · Yesterday 23:53

GriseldaandMike · Yesterday 23:40

I don't have a specific box I put myself in.

Yeah you do, it's a box marked ladies toilet.

I don't tell anyone what women are meant or aren't meant to look like.

Peace, no war, live and let live, and all of other other slogans about respecting and recognising our own and others bodily autonomy, and how they often don't clash even if we don't understand or agree.

YouGov's survey about trans people found that most people aren't impacted by trans issues in their day to day life.

Go focus on establishing laws to mandate women to be included in medical research and training. Women are more likely to die because of a heart attack because men are afraid of giving chest compressions because they don't train with women in mind.

That sounds like a much better usage of your time than arguing about hypotheses regarding the impact of trans people.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · Today 00:00

caprioska · Yesterday 06:08

Your analogy is irrelevant because no one is suggesting reproductive sex doesn't exist because 'assigned' is used. Its just a technically accurate description of what actually happens in most cases: sex is assumed & recorded based on an assumption that's just a surface level observation.

Deal.

"Assign" is what my boss does when he gives me a task to do. It's his choice, as he could choose to assign it to someone else at his discretion.

The sex of a neonate is a recorded observation. Midwives do not use their discretion when observing and recording a neonate's sex. If they see a penis and scrotum, they cannot tick the "female" box and must tick the "male" box. Failure to record accurate observations is clinical negligence.

In situations where external genitalia are ambiguous, the child is referred to appropriate specialists to diagnose the disorder of sexual development because at least one of those disorders ([https://www.ijsr.net/getabstract.php?paperid=SR25830182821 salt-wasting CAH]) is life-threatening.

GriseldaandMike · Today 00:02

Transperson · Yesterday 23:53

I don't tell anyone what women are meant or aren't meant to look like.

Peace, no war, live and let live, and all of other other slogans about respecting and recognising our own and others bodily autonomy, and how they often don't clash even if we don't understand or agree.

YouGov's survey about trans people found that most people aren't impacted by trans issues in their day to day life.

Go focus on establishing laws to mandate women to be included in medical research and training. Women are more likely to die because of a heart attack because men are afraid of giving chest compressions because they don't train with women in mind.

That sounds like a much better usage of your time than arguing about hypotheses regarding the impact of trans people.

Edited

You have no idea what I do or don't do for world peace or improving women's lives. You do know that however much you want to be you are not a woman and that means there are a few select places you are excluded from to protect the safety, dignity and /or privacy of women. If you feel you aren't safe or happy in mens spaces then you need to champion acceptance from men or campaign for 4th spaces not whine on the internet that if women should make way for you.

Swipe left for the next trending thread