Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

740 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:37

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 13/11/2026 06:35

Funny how these "trade offs" benefit men at the expense of women.

Luckily, our Supreme Court saw sense.

There's no case law yet so its early days given the clarification as it applies to specific contexts leaves a lot of questions unanswered.

OldCrone · 13/11/2026 06:37

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:35

As I already said depends on the context & tradeoffs involved that this thread isn't about.

So if there's a "trade off" involving men using women's spaces, there must be a benefit for women in allowing this.

How do women benefit from having men in their spaces?

If there's no benefit to women, it's not really a trade off, is it?

2021x · 13/11/2026 06:38

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:35

As I already said depends on the context & tradeoffs involved that this thread isn't about.

Again why are YOU deciding the terms about what this thread is about?

What is so special about YOU?

OP posts:
napody · 13/11/2026 06:38

To answer the OP, when discussing it on here I feel like Bill Murray in Groundhog Day. Thanks to capioska for illustrating this as a case in point.

I'm not a fan of AI assisted posts, but perhaps TRAs could submit their wide eyed posts to Claude beforehand and ask "has anyone made this substantive point before on Mumsnet?". The answer will always be yes. We are doomed to repeat ourselves infinitely. However, many of us have raised toddlers- we know patient repetition yields long term benefit.

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:41

2021x · 13/11/2026 06:38

Again why are YOU deciding the terms about what this thread is about?

What is so special about YOU?

Edited

You decided the terms already with your initial post that wasn't about the context for special exemptions or why other countries considered tradeoffs remember?

Maybe be more specific next time if that's what you wanted.

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 06:41

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:35

As I already said depends on the context & tradeoffs involved that this thread isn't about.

You brought it up. Are you saying you can’t explain your comments…..

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:44

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 06:41

You brought it up. Are you saying you can’t explain your comments…..

No, I'm just balancing answering questions without derailing. Please feel free to start a new thread regarding tradeoffs & I'll be happy to contribute but they are pretty much self explanatory anyway.

napody · 13/11/2026 06:46

I do think it helps to remember that at the beginning of this year TRAs wouldn't be talking in terms of trade offs- it was 100% entitlement and fury that anyone would question transwoman access to any female space. Maybe it's more like later in groundhog day when he starts to learn something about how other people exist and matter too. Joking. It's just obfuscation and manipulation to try and ignore women's rights after foot stamping didn't work so well.

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 06:47

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:44

No, I'm just balancing answering questions without derailing. Please feel free to start a new thread regarding tradeoffs & I'll be happy to contribute but they are pretty much self explanatory anyway.

They’re obviously not. Otherwise people wouldn’t be asking for clarification. We have room on the thread so you can do a post explaining…. Can’t you?

2021x · 13/11/2026 06:50

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:41

You decided the terms already with your initial post that wasn't about the context for special exemptions or why other countries considered tradeoffs remember?

Maybe be more specific next time if that's what you wanted.

Edited

Why do YOU get to determine what is spoken about on this thread?

Why do YOU think that the people on this thread need any explanation about anything from you?

OP posts:
caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:50

napody · 13/11/2026 06:38

To answer the OP, when discussing it on here I feel like Bill Murray in Groundhog Day. Thanks to capioska for illustrating this as a case in point.

I'm not a fan of AI assisted posts, but perhaps TRAs could submit their wide eyed posts to Claude beforehand and ask "has anyone made this substantive point before on Mumsnet?". The answer will always be yes. We are doomed to repeat ourselves infinitely. However, many of us have raised toddlers- we know patient repetition yields long term benefit.

'Ive answered this before' isn't a particularly valid argument given the level of illogical incoherence these 'answers' usually result in.

The unearned arrogance is breathtaking.

NotBadConsidering · 13/11/2026 06:52

without derailing

😂😂😂

OldCrone · 13/11/2026 06:54

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:50

'Ive answered this before' isn't a particularly valid argument given the level of illogical incoherence these 'answers' usually result in.

The unearned arrogance is breathtaking.

So perhaps you could answer the question about trade offs.

What's in it for women? Or is the trade-off just about the benefits for men and women knowing their place?

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:55

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 06:47

They’re obviously not. Otherwise people wouldn’t be asking for clarification. We have room on the thread so you can do a post explaining…. Can’t you?

As I said I'm happy to continue this discussion on a relevant thread otherwise threads tend to dissolve into the same old uni polar discussions rather than maintain their uniqueness of their angle which is why commenters choose to engage. I think the OP made an interesting observation & I'm interested in that so I'm not going to be the one to distract from it.

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:58

2021x · 13/11/2026 06:50

Why do YOU get to determine what is spoken about on this thread?

Why do YOU think that the people on this thread need any explanation about anything from you?

I don't. I'm not compelling you or others to discuss anything. Setting my boundaries for discussion has no consequences on yours or others.

For someone who is triggered by compelled speech you certainly seem quite willing to engage in it

2021x · 13/11/2026 06:58

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:55

As I said I'm happy to continue this discussion on a relevant thread otherwise threads tend to dissolve into the same old uni polar discussions rather than maintain their uniqueness of their angle which is why commenters choose to engage. I think the OP made an interesting observation & I'm interested in that so I'm not going to be the one to distract from it.

Stop dictating the terms of engagement and answer the reasonable question.

OP posts:
caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:59

2021x · 13/11/2026 06:58

Stop dictating the terms of engagement and answer the reasonable question.

"compelled speech" 🤔

2021x · 13/11/2026 06:59

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:58

I don't. I'm not compelling you or others to discuss anything. Setting my boundaries for discussion has no consequences on yours or others.

For someone who is triggered by compelled speech you certainly seem quite willing to engage in it

Oh so now you want people to respect your boundaries.

Ironic.

This thread is about how people feel when discussing their gender critical views. How do you feel when discussing your gender critical views?

OP posts:
BlueLegume · 13/11/2026 07:03

Transperson · 13/11/2026 02:06

"I am in NZ and the theme is "peoples feelings- no matter how delusional they are- are the reality" and if anyone disagrees they are "bad" people." Rejecting people's lived reality isn't really a nice thing to do yk

What about the lived reality of a woman suffering a menstrual flood and needing to clean herself up at the sinks feeling terrible? Her feelings are superseded by a delusional man are they?

BlueLegume · 13/11/2026 07:06

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:55

As I said I'm happy to continue this discussion on a relevant thread otherwise threads tend to dissolve into the same old uni polar discussions rather than maintain their uniqueness of their angle which is why commenters choose to engage. I think the OP made an interesting observation & I'm interested in that so I'm not going to be the one to distract from it.

Then start a thread of your own and engage in some common sense not word salad nonsense. We see posters patterns on all sorts of threads. They deny the reality of what being female is and they denigrate women as harridans who are bigots because we will not acquiesce to men who tells us they are women.

Stay out of our spaces and sports.

BackToLurk · 13/11/2026 07:10

napody · 13/11/2026 06:46

I do think it helps to remember that at the beginning of this year TRAs wouldn't be talking in terms of trade offs- it was 100% entitlement and fury that anyone would question transwoman access to any female space. Maybe it's more like later in groundhog day when he starts to learn something about how other people exist and matter too. Joking. It's just obfuscation and manipulation to try and ignore women's rights after foot stamping didn't work so well.

Interesting point, and one that may explain the constant name changes. Much easier to try and disguise the fact that your position has had to change.

Comtesse · 13/11/2026 07:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Yes it feels that way. Arguing to drive revenue is at least somewhat productive….

napody · 13/11/2026 07:14

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:50

'Ive answered this before' isn't a particularly valid argument given the level of illogical incoherence these 'answers' usually result in.

The unearned arrogance is breathtaking.

The irony.
I'm not the least bit interested in the fact you can't answer the question on trade offs. It's crystal clear you can't.
The thread title is 'how does it feel to be gender critical?' Even more delicious irony that you have not only posted but feel you are the one sticking to the theme. Perhaps you know what it feels like to be GC in the same way a man know what it feels like to be a woman?

caprioska · 13/11/2026 07:17

2021x · 13/11/2026 06:59

Oh so now you want people to respect your boundaries.

Ironic.

This thread is about how people feel when discussing their gender critical views. How do you feel when discussing your gender critical views?

As I said I'm supportive of exclusion of trans women if the context & tradeoffs call for it. I have issues discussing my more nuanced views with absolutist extremist activists on either side of this issue.

So my frustration is more about the inflexibility in accepting fair compromise which I believe hurts everyone in the long run rather than one of social denial & complicity.

But that's in activist social media circles. In everyday life most people understand a practical compromise is necessary for everyone's sake & to uphold general egalitarian principles.

napody · 13/11/2026 07:17

BackToLurk · 13/11/2026 07:10

Interesting point, and one that may explain the constant name changes. Much easier to try and disguise the fact that your position has had to change.

Yes, it's a bit of "we have always been at war with eastasia" to add to the 2+2=5.

Swipe left for the next trending thread