Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

740 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
2021x · 13/11/2026 06:12

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:04

That trans women are natal women? Of course not. That's a convenient GC 'zero sum' story.

.

Sesame Street Elmo GIF
OP posts:
OldCrone · 13/11/2026 06:14

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:00

Who said anything about all spaces providing a trade off?

You did.

Can you not even keep up with your own posts?

Anyway, why do you think all spaces have to be "policed"? Are TIMs really so antisocial that they can't be trusted to stay out of spaces where they're not supposed to be?

You're really not doing a good job of painting TIMs as decent, respectful, law-abiding citizens.

OldCrone · 13/11/2026 06:17

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:04

That trans women are natal women? Of course not. That's a convenient GC 'zero sum' story.

So they're women but at the same time they're not women? What sort of a woman is a woman who isn't actually a woman?

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:18

OldCrone · 13/11/2026 06:14

You did.

Can you not even keep up with your own posts?

Anyway, why do you think all spaces have to be "policed"? Are TIMs really so antisocial that they can't be trusted to stay out of spaces where they're not supposed to be?

You're really not doing a good job of painting TIMs as decent, respectful, law-abiding citizens.

Never said any of that.

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:18

OldCrone · 13/11/2026 06:17

So they're women but at the same time they're not women? What sort of a woman is a woman who isn't actually a woman?

Gender has already been explained upthread.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 13/11/2026 06:18

HPFA · 12/11/2026 06:57

It's not easy.

Nobody actuslly believes you can change sex which is why the argument has to be shut down so viciously.

There was an incident recently where three transwomen living together had a big falling out and one of them went on Twitter to blast off about one of the others. They pointedly refused to use the preferred pronoun and interacted normally with posters who were misgendering. Clearly they had never genuinely believed that the rejected lover was actually a woman.

Imagine a similar situation with the trans element removed - you don't ever start referring to your cheating ex husband as "she" do you? Your family and friends would think you'd gone insane.

There are so many examples like this.

Was this the Aberdeen polycule?

OldCrone · 13/11/2026 06:19

caprioska · 13/11/2026 01:30

Balancing the consequences of legislation is a core responsibility in lawmaking, as nearly every policy creates both intended benefits and unintended trade-offs.

"New Zealand Law Commission: In September 2025, the Law Commission recommended that transgender people should have access to single-sex public facilities matching their gender identity, noting that restricting access based on sex assigned at birth is difficult to police and that concerns are outweighed by the harm of exclusion. 1]"

You never said any of this?

OldCrone · 13/11/2026 06:20

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:18

Gender has already been explained upthread.

"A man is a woman if he says he's a woman, even though he isn't actually a woman because he's a man."

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:21

OldCrone · 13/11/2026 06:19

You never said any of this?

Yes but that's not related to anything you are implying I said.

Are you ok?

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 06:22

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:04

That trans women are natal women? Of course not. That's a convenient GC 'zero sum' story.

So if they are not women, why should they be allowed in Women’s spaces? Do tell….

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:23

OldCrone · 13/11/2026 06:20

"A man is a woman if he says he's a woman, even though he isn't actually a woman because he's a man."

Your posts aren't coherent or representative of my posts.

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 06:24

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:21

Yes but that's not related to anything you are implying I said.

Are you ok?

caprioska · Today 01:30
Balancing the consequences of legislation is a core responsibility in lawmaking, as nearly every policy creates both intended benefits and unintended trade-offs.
"New Zealand Law Commission: In September 2025, the Law Commission recommended that transgender people should have access to single-sex public facilities matching their gender identity, noting that restricting access based on sex assigned at birth is difficult to police and that concerns are outweighed by the harm of exclusion. about:blank 1]"

Just posting without comment

OldCrone · 13/11/2026 06:24

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:21

Yes but that's not related to anything you are implying I said.

Are you ok?

I'm not "implying" you said anything. I'm quoting you. You talked about trade offs and policing spaces.

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:26

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 06:22

So if they are not women, why should they be allowed in Women’s spaces? Do tell….

Firstly, they are trans gender women.
Secondly, 'women's spaces' don't technically exist only special exemptions that are context dependant not sex dependant.

OldCrone · 13/11/2026 06:27

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:23

Your posts aren't coherent or representative of my posts.

How can they not be representative of your posts when I quote your actual posts?

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 06:28

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:23

Your posts aren't coherent or representative of my posts.

Both coherent and representative of your posts. Your posts however….

bur you know the good thing. Mumsnet gets revenue based on users and engagement, so all the TRA peeps coming to argue and “own” Mumsnet to tell them how awful they are and how bad the site is are actually contributing to its success. Well played sirs ,well played. 🤣🤣🤣🤣

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 13/11/2026 06:28

caprioska · 12/11/2026 07:30

The priors mistakenly being sex instead of gender identity. It's trans gender identification not transexual. While I appreciate some people don't agree gender is a legitimate identity, identity is a personal perspective on the world. That others don't agree with that perspective doesn't invalidate it.

All men hold power over all women. Just the lifelong absolutely certainty that he can never be made pregnant by a rapist is a form of power that women lack. Even infertile women, as most of them grew up thinking that pregnancy was a possibility for them, even if the doctors later told them otherwise.

Additionally, most men are born with the means to force a woman to become pregnant against her will, which is a profound form of power over women. All men embody the threat of a forced pregnancy just by being present where a woman is. This embodied threat is also a form of power. Even infertile men hold this power, as women don't know who amongst men is fertile and who isn't, so we have to treat you as though you are all fertile.

No man can identify out of holding that power.

These are the "priors", the undeniable truths, that inform both my defence of women's rights and the very meaning of the word "woman" as referring only to female human beings.

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 06:29

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:26

Firstly, they are trans gender women.
Secondly, 'women's spaces' don't technically exist only special exemptions that are context dependant not sex dependant.

so are you saying gender and sex are different? I’m which case, why should someone’s gender affect which sex based services and facilities they use?

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:29

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 06:24

caprioska · Today 01:30
Balancing the consequences of legislation is a core responsibility in lawmaking, as nearly every policy creates both intended benefits and unintended trade-offs.
"New Zealand Law Commission: In September 2025, the Law Commission recommended that transgender people should have access to single-sex public facilities matching their gender identity, noting that restricting access based on sex assigned at birth is difficult to police and that concerns are outweighed by the harm of exclusion. about:blank 1]"

Just posting without comment

By virtue of saying trade offs matter doesn't mean all spaces should be shared just the opposite.

OldCrone · 13/11/2026 06:29

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:26

Firstly, they are trans gender women.
Secondly, 'women's spaces' don't technically exist only special exemptions that are context dependant not sex dependant.

What are the qualifying criteria for someone to be a "transgender woman"?

Apart from being a man , that is?

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 06:31

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:29

By virtue of saying trade offs matter doesn't mean all spaces should be shared just the opposite.

so Are you saying we should exclude some women from Women’s services and facilities? Which women do you think should be excluded from Women’s sports and prisons and RCC?

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:31

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 06:29

so are you saying gender and sex are different? I’m which case, why should someone’s gender affect which sex based services and facilities they use?

Trade offs.

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 06:34

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:35

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 06:31

so Are you saying we should exclude some women from Women’s services and facilities? Which women do you think should be excluded from Women’s sports and prisons and RCC?

As I already said depends on the context & tradeoffs involved that this thread isn't about.

selffellatingouroborosofhate · 13/11/2026 06:35

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:31

Trade offs.

Funny how these "trade offs" benefit men at the expense of women.

Luckily, our Supreme Court saw sense.