Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

742 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
BackToLurk · 13/11/2026 07:18

When you’re trying to train a dog to stop demand barking, the advice is to ignore it as any interaction is seen, by the dog, as a reward. Just saying.

2021x · 13/11/2026 07:19

caprioska · 13/11/2026 07:17

As I said I'm supportive of exclusion of trans women if the context & tradeoffs call for it. I have issues discussing my more nuanced views with absolutist extremist activists on either side of this issue.

So my frustration is more about the inflexibility in accepting fair compromise which I believe hurts everyone in the long run rather than one of social denial & complicity.

But that's in activist social media circles. In everyday life most people understand a practical compromise is necessary for everyone's sake & to uphold general egalitarian principles.

How do you feel about being Gender Critical?

OP posts:
LlynTegid · 13/11/2026 07:22

I believe in women having safety and dignity. And support the Supreme Court decision, which in my opinion should never have been needed, as the government ten years ago could have made it clear that sex is biological sex.

Gender critical is probably not the best term, whilst I understand its meaning. Supporting basic human rights for women, and fair competition in sport, is not being critical in any way.

caprioska · 13/11/2026 07:27

2021x · 13/11/2026 07:19

How do you feel about being Gender Critical?

I'm not gender critical per se because I believe socially constructed gender stereotype categories exist that have implications on how people form their identities. Identity & social associations are inextricably linked so that's not something I can logically deny as gender critical feminists do.

In any case, a practical structuring of society resources & rights isn't really gender critical exclusive rather a general principle that has long existed.

2021x · 13/11/2026 07:28

So why are you on this thread?

OP posts:
caprioska · 13/11/2026 07:33

2021x · 13/11/2026 07:28

So why are you on this thread?

See my first comment. You & others seem to be frustrated as to why others were 'aiding & abetting' a 'fantasy' so I offered my assistance in clarifying the matter for you. Misinformation & misunderstanding are interlinked so you’re welcome.

This may come as a shock but discussion threads aren't meant to be echo chambers.

TheHereticalOne · 13/11/2026 07:36

If I may add an addendum to my original answer to the OP's original question that has, for some unknown reason, popped into my mind after catching up with this thread:

How does it feel to be Gender Critical? Frequently, it also feels like being deathly, deathly bored.

I'm so bored. SO bored.

I'd liken it to being employed to do high-volume data entry for some vital system like healthcare or child protection but the system being partially wiped day after day after day. I won't stop doing the data entry because it's really, really important to have, and it seems to wipe a little bit less each day but I have to keep drawing on an ever decreasing well of patience to continue doing it and not despair. I know a lot of my colleages in slightly different roles are also chipping away at improving the infrastructure to stop the daily deletions, too. I imagine they face similar emotions.

OH and weary anger (if you can imagine such a thing) at the people responsible for the daily deletions who seem in large part to be, not nefarious actors intent on destroying the systems (though there after certainly those), but people wandering into the data warehouse each day twirling their Sledgehammer Of Kindness convinced that they are helping and with absolutely no awareness that they are bashing the severs.

As you were.

BlueLegume · 13/11/2026 07:39

caprioska · 13/11/2026 07:17

As I said I'm supportive of exclusion of trans women if the context & tradeoffs call for it. I have issues discussing my more nuanced views with absolutist extremist activists on either side of this issue.

So my frustration is more about the inflexibility in accepting fair compromise which I believe hurts everyone in the long run rather than one of social denial & complicity.

But that's in activist social media circles. In everyday life most people understand a practical compromise is necessary for everyone's sake & to uphold general egalitarian principles.

Sadly you seem to be missing the OP thread title. Most people respond explaining that they understand trans people exist in the world and are civilised towards them. They do not ‘dislike’ all trans people just as they do not ‘dislike’ all people from other walks of life. That would be extremely odd. What most sex realists do dislike is the extra privileges some trans people want - such as men using women’s spaces and competing in sport. Are you familiar with William ‘ Lia’ Thomas @caprioska ?

We are not extremists. We believe in the truth and reality of biological sex. We acknowledge people will present in all manners. For the most part we just want men out of our spaces and sports and when we say this people like you tell us we are bigots or transphobic. Feel free to pick apart my post and please do point out where I am wrong in terms of how I want myself, my daughters and granddaughters to feel safe.

TheHereticalOne · 13/11/2026 07:44

Manyanamanyana · 13/11/2026 03:57

Now I need to watch The Cruciable- not sure I ever saw it

I've never seen the film, come to think of it, but I would highly recommend reading the play or finding a good theatre production of it! There may be an excellent film of it too - I'll take it as homework.

I find it oddly comforting to see that this sort of madness has come and gone before, with all its attendant bit-players of people who earnestly think they're doing good, people using the nonsense for their own cynical ends, irrascible stick-in-the muds who refuse to go along, people who see the light part-way through, and people having to make difficult choices between what is right/principled vs what is easy/pragmatic. Witch trials, McCarthyism, lobotomisation...

Miller captured a lot of it really well in a short script.

caprioska · 13/11/2026 07:44

BlueLegume · 13/11/2026 07:39

Sadly you seem to be missing the OP thread title. Most people respond explaining that they understand trans people exist in the world and are civilised towards them. They do not ‘dislike’ all trans people just as they do not ‘dislike’ all people from other walks of life. That would be extremely odd. What most sex realists do dislike is the extra privileges some trans people want - such as men using women’s spaces and competing in sport. Are you familiar with William ‘ Lia’ Thomas @caprioska ?

We are not extremists. We believe in the truth and reality of biological sex. We acknowledge people will present in all manners. For the most part we just want men out of our spaces and sports and when we say this people like you tell us we are bigots or transphobic. Feel free to pick apart my post and please do point out where I am wrong in terms of how I want myself, my daughters and granddaughters to feel safe.

Are you familiar with William ‘ Lia’ Thomas

Both my son & daughter played in mixed football teams when they were between the ages of 5 to 7 where the girls were bigger, stronger & more talented than the boys until they weren't so no biggie. Context & nuance matters that extremists always seem to miss.

2021x · 13/11/2026 07:47

OK we have established caprioska has no intention to describe how it feels to be gender critical- so we can leave them alone now.

If they wish to carry on their discussion they can start a new thread.

So how does it feel to be Gender Critical?

OP posts:
napody · 13/11/2026 07:53

caprioska · 13/11/2026 07:44

Are you familiar with William ‘ Lia’ Thomas

Both my son & daughter played in mixed football teams when they were between the ages of 5 to 7 where the girls were bigger, stronger & more talented than the boys until they weren't so no biggie. Context & nuance matters that extremists always seem to miss.

Edited

Context includes historical context, though.

If we had gone directly from a place where single sex spaces were for everything, you'd have a point arguing for 'nuance' (not really the right word) e.g. mixed sex under 7s sports- although that doesn't hold as it's mixed sex and completely fine- it's not pretending to be boys or girls only.

However, we have had 16 years since the equality act and after the early progress it allowed for gay people, the past decade's regressive backlash of gender identity has undone generations of feminist progress for women. The Scottish govt creating a context where a female only rape crisis centre was impossible.

'Nuance'/case-by-case decisions have already shown not to be feasible as we live in a patriarchy and men as a group have an overwhelming interest in overriding women's rights.

That's the context the Supreme Court ruling intervened in.

If you do want to start a thread discussing context, I suggest you include a list of situations that should and shouldn't be allowed to be female only, and also your previous usernames so your own context can be seen. I'm guessing it's less consistent than the eternally patient GC posters here.

BlueLegume · 13/11/2026 07:53

2021x · 13/11/2026 07:47

OK we have established caprioska has no intention to describe how it feels to be gender critical- so we can leave them alone now.

If they wish to carry on their discussion they can start a new thread.

So how does it feel to be Gender Critical?

It feels the right way to think to be honest @2021x

I know in the future when the inevitable medical issues or scandal happens that I stood my ground rather than just going along with the live and let live/be kind approach.

I am not an authoritarian, I do live and let live for the most part and I am kind. Just checked that with my husband who for the record thinks all this gender stuff is madness.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 13/11/2026 07:55

TheHereticalOne · 13/11/2026 07:44

I've never seen the film, come to think of it, but I would highly recommend reading the play or finding a good theatre production of it! There may be an excellent film of it too - I'll take it as homework.

I find it oddly comforting to see that this sort of madness has come and gone before, with all its attendant bit-players of people who earnestly think they're doing good, people using the nonsense for their own cynical ends, irrascible stick-in-the muds who refuse to go along, people who see the light part-way through, and people having to make difficult choices between what is right/principled vs what is easy/pragmatic. Witch trials, McCarthyism, lobotomisation...

Miller captured a lot of it really well in a short script.

I did the crucible for A level and loved it. Sadly so much of that witch hunting approach in societies seems eternal. I'm reminded of Dominic Sandbrook on Triggonometry

https://youtube.com/shorts/ERK17DGnhhE?si=_ningRBlNY1gNXQ4

"the biggest killers in the world are utopian idealists"

Before you continue to YouTube

https://youtube.com/shorts/ERK17DGnhhE?si=_ningRBlNY1gNXQ4

2021x · 13/11/2026 07:55

BlueLegume · 13/11/2026 07:53

It feels the right way to think to be honest @2021x

I know in the future when the inevitable medical issues or scandal happens that I stood my ground rather than just going along with the live and let live/be kind approach.

I am not an authoritarian, I do live and let live for the most part and I am kind. Just checked that with my husband who for the record thinks all this gender stuff is madness.

Thanks for the future view.

I feel that expecting people to act as if nothing is wrong is not sustainable in the long term.

OP posts:
TheHereticalOne · 13/11/2026 07:56

Manyanamanyana · 13/11/2026 04:15

I would say that being aware of sexism is a good start to identifying the unfairness of this ideology. And being aware of sexism is probably pretty strongly correlated to being less agreeable 😂Not sure which come first though!
I remember becoming aware of sexism in early high school because of double standards, and general attitudes from everyone about girls, what we were capable of, responsible for, the way we were spoken to, and feeling the injustice of it. Knowing that in primary school my friends and I were sitting in a circle one day when the subject of sexual abuse came up and every single girl in my circle of friends had a previously untold story to share. There were about 10 of us.
I think once you see sexism and notice the patterns of male dominance, you can't unsee it, and you see it everywhere, like another poster said upthread.
And because this ideology has all of the tells of sexism, male dominance and violence, silencing of women and abuse of children, it doesn't take long for 2+2=4.
In Australia I like to believe that the public is generally with us, but the lanyard class has enormous control, and the TRAs got in at the top, fast and early. There is definitely a culture of women who won't risk being called the wrong kind of feminist (i.e. happy to focus on equal pay, but none of the dirty issues like porn and prostitution, the kind of feminism that the left can support without impinging on men's rights to womens bodies).
Aussies are not really known for their political activism though, once they get past about 15 years old, and until it actually touches people, they'll just keep watching the cricket.

Thanks for the thoughts about Aus. It's so depressing - my condoloences. I think I was instinctively able to reconcile the Canada and New Zealand situation better due to the nicey-nicey, touchy-feely culture that seems to largely pride itself on never hurting anyone's feelings no matter what. But my erstwhile broad impression of Australian culture was of a bunch of pretty tough nuts who bluntly call things as they see them, so I've found that one tougher to understand. It's interesting to hear an opinion from on the ground!

I wonder if, where there's a more blokey (sexist?) culture, it makes more sense for people to accept the idea that if a man's a bit effeminate it makes sense that he's not 'really' a man. Maybe that doesn't apply to Australia, but just musing out loud!

2021x · 13/11/2026 07:58

Theeyeballsinthesky · 13/11/2026 07:55

I did the crucible for A level and loved it. Sadly so much of that witch hunting approach in societies seems eternal. I'm reminded of Dominic Sandbrook on Triggonometry

https://youtube.com/shorts/ERK17DGnhhE?si=_ningRBlNY1gNXQ4

"the biggest killers in the world are utopian idealists"

I saw an experts talking about cults who said the people most likely to fall for extreme ideology are the ones who think that they would never.

I have compassion especially for the young people who will eventually pay the price with their health.

But I am so angry with the health system for not resisting it!

OP posts:
Imdunfer · 13/11/2026 08:00

caprioska · 13/11/2026 04:25

You are not compelled to use pronouns because you can use names.

Gyms have cubicles for those who those prefer privacy changing.

There are exemptions for sport & also feature explicit exceptions for welfare services, crisis accommodation, and specialised support programs targeted at specific sexes or vulnerable demographics

Gyms have cubicles for those who those prefer privacy changing.

My gym has 3 of those.

Classes often attract 25 women who all have the same start time.

Do you propose that women arrive and change for their class ahead of time in order to ensure there is a private cubicle in case there is a man in their single sex facility?

And if so, WHY do you believe the rights of one man override the rights of all those women not to have to waste their time?

You are not compelled to use pronouns because you can use names.

That works so well, doesn't it? If I wanted to be perceived as a nut case of a manager, I could always write someone's appraisal this way:

"Robin has had a good year achieving all Robin's objectives. Robin was particularly successful in completing Project Shoehorn. Robin's colleagues report that Robin is a pleasure to work with and that Robin can be relied on to produce accurate work on time. Provided Robin continues this progress then Robin should be considered for promotion in 2027. "

Pronouns were invented for a reason!

caprioska · 13/11/2026 08:02

TheHereticalOne · 13/11/2026 07:56

Thanks for the thoughts about Aus. It's so depressing - my condoloences. I think I was instinctively able to reconcile the Canada and New Zealand situation better due to the nicey-nicey, touchy-feely culture that seems to largely pride itself on never hurting anyone's feelings no matter what. But my erstwhile broad impression of Australian culture was of a bunch of pretty tough nuts who bluntly call things as they see them, so I've found that one tougher to understand. It's interesting to hear an opinion from on the ground!

I wonder if, where there's a more blokey (sexist?) culture, it makes more sense for people to accept the idea that if a man's a bit effeminate it makes sense that he's not 'really' a man. Maybe that doesn't apply to Australia, but just musing out loud!

Australia is distinct from the UK as there's no long history of social hierarchies or class structure or victorian prudish mores. In other words its culture is very egalitarian & openness conscious so equality & anti discrimination are natural conclusions.

2021x · 13/11/2026 08:06

TheHereticalOne · 13/11/2026 07:56

Thanks for the thoughts about Aus. It's so depressing - my condoloences. I think I was instinctively able to reconcile the Canada and New Zealand situation better due to the nicey-nicey, touchy-feely culture that seems to largely pride itself on never hurting anyone's feelings no matter what. But my erstwhile broad impression of Australian culture was of a bunch of pretty tough nuts who bluntly call things as they see them, so I've found that one tougher to understand. It's interesting to hear an opinion from on the ground!

I wonder if, where there's a more blokey (sexist?) culture, it makes more sense for people to accept the idea that if a man's a bit effeminate it makes sense that he's not 'really' a man. Maybe that doesn't apply to Australia, but just musing out loud!

The Australian problem was actually instigated by Julia Guilliard the same
prime minister who made the famous speech about misogyny (it is really good) wrote away women’s rights!

NZ is just staying away from the issue. Most people don’t like it, but it is shocking we have a Ministry for Women that isn’t doing anything about it.

OP posts:
Imdunfer · 13/11/2026 08:06

caprioska · 13/11/2026 07:44

Are you familiar with William ‘ Lia’ Thomas

Both my son & daughter played in mixed football teams when they were between the ages of 5 to 7 where the girls were bigger, stronger & more talented than the boys until they weren't so no biggie. Context & nuance matters that extremists always seem to miss.

Edited

But the nuance there is between pre-pubescent and adult.

The nuance you are arguing for, to let the genuine trans males in while keeping the predators and perverts out is not possible.

There is nothing extremist about wanting single sex spaces to be single sex.

BlueLegume · 13/11/2026 08:08

2021x · 13/11/2026 07:55

Thanks for the future view.

I feel that expecting people to act as if nothing is wrong is not sustainable in the long term.

To be honest @2021x the future view is possibly or probably why I will not waiver on my view of sex realism. There will be case of a man who says he is a woman needing treatment for prostate cancer at some point. That is a cancer only men get. He needs to be treated as the man he is and that will possibly include catheterisation. A man is catheterised differently than a woman. Will he insist he is a woman? Probably.

There will be a woman who currently says she is a man who will get a disease only women get. She will need to be treated as a woman. Will she insist she is a man?

These situations are how I retain my sex realism stance.

Oh and the fact there will be a medical scandal about the whole thing at some point. I am pretty sure of that.

Oh and the fact the whole business is tawdry and the flags and banners do not hide very well the fetish side of this now being played out in front of kids - see ‘pups’ at Pride.

Oh and the resurgence of meek and mild looking Peter Tatchell on our screens who whilst he did plenty to support gay rights - rightly so - still has a whiff of PIE and MAPs in the way he speaks. Akin to the speech Stephen Fry did at the Oxford Union where the age of consent got giggled about in a ‘look at me I am so clever way’ by using the Classics to justify what we now know is child abuse.

2021x · 13/11/2026 08:10

BlueLegume · 13/11/2026 08:08

To be honest @2021x the future view is possibly or probably why I will not waiver on my view of sex realism. There will be case of a man who says he is a woman needing treatment for prostate cancer at some point. That is a cancer only men get. He needs to be treated as the man he is and that will possibly include catheterisation. A man is catheterised differently than a woman. Will he insist he is a woman? Probably.

There will be a woman who currently says she is a man who will get a disease only women get. She will need to be treated as a woman. Will she insist she is a man?

These situations are how I retain my sex realism stance.

Oh and the fact there will be a medical scandal about the whole thing at some point. I am pretty sure of that.

Oh and the fact the whole business is tawdry and the flags and banners do not hide very well the fetish side of this now being played out in front of kids - see ‘pups’ at Pride.

Oh and the resurgence of meek and mild looking Peter Tatchell on our screens who whilst he did plenty to support gay rights - rightly so - still has a whiff of PIE and MAPs in the way he speaks. Akin to the speech Stephen Fry did at the Oxford Union where the age of consent got giggled about in a ‘look at me I am so clever way’ by using the Classics to justify what we now know is child abuse.

Edited

Well like I said men supporting males disrespecting female boundaries is going to be the “hiding in plain sight” of our time.

SF will be having a mental health episode of his own soon I suspect.

OP posts:
TheHereticalOne · 13/11/2026 08:12

Imdunfer · 13/11/2026 08:00

Gyms have cubicles for those who those prefer privacy changing.

My gym has 3 of those.

Classes often attract 25 women who all have the same start time.

Do you propose that women arrive and change for their class ahead of time in order to ensure there is a private cubicle in case there is a man in their single sex facility?

And if so, WHY do you believe the rights of one man override the rights of all those women not to have to waste their time?

You are not compelled to use pronouns because you can use names.

That works so well, doesn't it? If I wanted to be perceived as a nut case of a manager, I could always write someone's appraisal this way:

"Robin has had a good year achieving all Robin's objectives. Robin was particularly successful in completing Project Shoehorn. Robin's colleagues report that Robin is a pleasure to work with and that Robin can be relied on to produce accurate work on time. Provided Robin continues this progress then Robin should be considered for promotion in 2027. "

Pronouns were invented for a reason!

Edited

I quite enjoy a puzzle and writing a good letter, so would enjoy the challenge of putting things like this into passive voice and otherwise avoid pronouns in ways not too obvious as a one-off brainteaser.

I suppose I could do it for every single communication in life and work too, so long as no-one minds it taking me five times as long to get anything done as I navigate around the ordinary use of my naive language, nor my completing a fraction of my work for the same pay. Perhaps we could also implement the 'Yes/No' game on Tuesdays and avoid using the letter 'E' on Fridays.

Robin has had a good year achieving all Robin's objectives. Robin was particularly The successful in completing Project Shoehorn should be particularly acknowledged as should Robin's colleagues' reports that Robin is a pleasure to work with. and that Robin can be relied on to It has particularly been noted that produce accurate work produced is accurate and on time. Provided Robin continues this progress then Robin promotion should be considered for promotion in 2027

2021x · 13/11/2026 08:15

Imdunfer · 13/11/2026 08:00

Gyms have cubicles for those who those prefer privacy changing.

My gym has 3 of those.

Classes often attract 25 women who all have the same start time.

Do you propose that women arrive and change for their class ahead of time in order to ensure there is a private cubicle in case there is a man in their single sex facility?

And if so, WHY do you believe the rights of one man override the rights of all those women not to have to waste their time?

You are not compelled to use pronouns because you can use names.

That works so well, doesn't it? If I wanted to be perceived as a nut case of a manager, I could always write someone's appraisal this way:

"Robin has had a good year achieving all Robin's objectives. Robin was particularly successful in completing Project Shoehorn. Robin's colleagues report that Robin is a pleasure to work with and that Robin can be relied on to produce accurate work on time. Provided Robin continues this progress then Robin should be considered for promotion in 2027. "

Pronouns were invented for a reason!

Edited

I am sensing you are also feeling a little
like Elmo?

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread