Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

How does it feel to be Gender Critical?

730 replies

2021x · 12/11/2026 06:26

I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity, or having a conversation about why males shouldn't compete in female categories...

Anyone else have examples of what it is like trying to engage with people who believe TRAs more than their own eyes?

OP posts:
2021x · 13/11/2026 01:24

Manyanamanyana · 13/11/2026 00:53

How it feels to me this week: at work, a job I love and am very good at, we have recently had the "respect at work" framework released, to much drum-rolling and fanfare.
The "gender affirmation guidelines" infuriate me, because, in Australia, men are women if they say they are, and women must simply accept those delusional men in anything that we might quietly want as female-only.
I find myself with very little respect for the people who nod along with this, despite the impacts on women and this feeling does not sit well with me. People who I enjoy working with otherwise and have enormous professional respect for. They will probably never know that I hold something that tastes like contempt, but isn't, because I otherwise genuinely like them.
I have no faith in my government, or any media outlet, organisation or service provider that supports this. I feel politically homeless. I can't believe the scale of the dismissal of womens rights. It has left me feeling deeply distant from huge parts of my cultural environment. In Australia the social, professional and legal threat to people who hold gender critical views is real, and it is depressing.
That's me being as honest as I'm willing to be.

I am in NZ and the theme is "peoples feelings- no matter how delusional they are- are the reality" and if anyone disagrees they are "bad" people.

It isn't even law, there hasn't been a test case, but when I found myself in a changing room with a woman at the gym I wrote to my local MP who supported "trans-rights".

During her recent campaigning I wanted to go out with big speech-bubble stickers for her posters, say I think it is fine if men enter womens changing rooms.

OP posts:
caprioska · 13/11/2026 01:30

2021x · 13/11/2026 01:24

I am in NZ and the theme is "peoples feelings- no matter how delusional they are- are the reality" and if anyone disagrees they are "bad" people.

It isn't even law, there hasn't been a test case, but when I found myself in a changing room with a woman at the gym I wrote to my local MP who supported "trans-rights".

During her recent campaigning I wanted to go out with big speech-bubble stickers for her posters, say I think it is fine if men enter womens changing rooms.

Balancing the consequences of legislation is a core responsibility in lawmaking, as nearly every policy creates both intended benefits and unintended trade-offs.

"New Zealand Law Commission: In September 2025, the Law Commission recommended that transgender people should have access to single-sex public facilities matching their gender identity, noting that restricting access based on sex assigned at birth is difficult to police and that concerns are outweighed by the harm of exclusion. 1]"

Ban housing and hiring discrimination for transgender Kiwis – Law Commission

The independent Law Commission has advised changes to protect transgender and intersex people from discrimination in housing and hiring

https://newsroom.co.nz/2025/09/04/ban-housing-and-hiring-discrimination-for-transgender-kiwis-law-commission/

2021x · 13/11/2026 01:42

caprioska · 13/11/2026 01:30

Balancing the consequences of legislation is a core responsibility in lawmaking, as nearly every policy creates both intended benefits and unintended trade-offs.

"New Zealand Law Commission: In September 2025, the Law Commission recommended that transgender people should have access to single-sex public facilities matching their gender identity, noting that restricting access based on sex assigned at birth is difficult to police and that concerns are outweighed by the harm of exclusion. 1]"

There you go again, asserting superiority by forcing a technical discussion in the middle of a casual information exchange.

OP posts:
caprioska · 13/11/2026 02:01

2021x · 13/11/2026 01:42

There you go again, asserting superiority by forcing a technical discussion in the middle of a casual information exchange.

There you go again correcting misinformation.

Transperson · 13/11/2026 02:06

2021x · 13/11/2026 01:24

I am in NZ and the theme is "peoples feelings- no matter how delusional they are- are the reality" and if anyone disagrees they are "bad" people.

It isn't even law, there hasn't been a test case, but when I found myself in a changing room with a woman at the gym I wrote to my local MP who supported "trans-rights".

During her recent campaigning I wanted to go out with big speech-bubble stickers for her posters, say I think it is fine if men enter womens changing rooms.

"I am in NZ and the theme is "peoples feelings- no matter how delusional they are- are the reality" and if anyone disagrees they are "bad" people." Rejecting people's lived reality isn't really a nice thing to do yk

2021x · 13/11/2026 02:58

Transperson · 13/11/2026 02:06

"I am in NZ and the theme is "peoples feelings- no matter how delusional they are- are the reality" and if anyone disagrees they are "bad" people." Rejecting people's lived reality isn't really a nice thing to do yk

I care as much about a transwoman's lived reality as they care about mine.

OP posts:
Manyanamanyana · 13/11/2026 03:17

caprioska · 13/11/2026 01:24

No you aren't. Respecting people's right to their own identity isn't the same as agreeing with it. The only potential consequences you would face would need to be based on behaviour that rises to the level of harassment or discrimination in the work place as you would for any other group.

I didn't say agree, thankfully they are not yet going clockwork orange on us. But I am absolutely compelled, as a Government employee to use pronouns which I object too, and quietly accept men in the bathroom. Should a man decide to use the female changing room at my gym, I must accept that. Likewise should I be unlucky enough to require any of the previously female-designated services for women survivors of male violence, or simply wish to go to a breastfeeding group or join a female sports team. It is entirely dictatorial. You may turn a blind eye to that, but you can't make it untrue.

2021x · 13/11/2026 03:23

Manyanamanyana · 13/11/2026 03:17

I didn't say agree, thankfully they are not yet going clockwork orange on us. But I am absolutely compelled, as a Government employee to use pronouns which I object too, and quietly accept men in the bathroom. Should a man decide to use the female changing room at my gym, I must accept that. Likewise should I be unlucky enough to require any of the previously female-designated services for women survivors of male violence, or simply wish to go to a breastfeeding group or join a female sports team. It is entirely dictatorial. You may turn a blind eye to that, but you can't make it untrue.

It is essential that women are able to identify a person who is male using language that everyone understands. Taking away a woman's ability to correctly identify a male who is acting in a way that indicates he might cause harm - like entering spaces where females get undressed- is an appalling attack on her rights.

OP posts:
Manyanamanyana · 13/11/2026 03:24

caprioska · 13/11/2026 01:30

Balancing the consequences of legislation is a core responsibility in lawmaking, as nearly every policy creates both intended benefits and unintended trade-offs.

"New Zealand Law Commission: In September 2025, the Law Commission recommended that transgender people should have access to single-sex public facilities matching their gender identity, noting that restricting access based on sex assigned at birth is difficult to police and that concerns are outweighed by the harm of exclusion. 1]"

"Noting that maintaining sex-defined boundaries had worked quite well in the past, before entitled men decided that womens boundaries were negotiable and that useful idiots would feel sympathy for these ridiculous men if they were "educated" correctly, and if a culture of fear was introduced to shut the objectors up".
There, fixed it for you.

Manyanamanyana · 13/11/2026 03:27

2021x · 13/11/2026 03:23

It is essential that women are able to identify a person who is male using language that everyone understands. Taking away a woman's ability to correctly identify a male who is acting in a way that indicates he might cause harm - like entering spaces where females get undressed- is an appalling attack on her rights.

Yes it is. It is an appalling attack on female rights. That TRAs and thier allies deliberately fail to see this is beyond infuriating.
I will never accept that TWAW.
TW are something, that's for sure.

Manyanamanyana · 13/11/2026 03:34

caprioska · 12/11/2026 21:02

But that's not what the OP is complaining about:

"I was watching a compilation of Elmo dealing with the fact that everyone is treating Rocco like a living being rather than a rock- especially regarding the cookie!

I felt this is how it feels to be talking to people who wish to validate transgender ideology as a valid identity"

Their grievance is because they don't share other people's understanding of the world they shouldn’t validate it as an identity & implies there’s something wrong in doing so.

Identity being the unique combination of your individual traits, personal values & life experiences as a self concept. Validation of another's self concept is not agreement to it. You can recognise and respect that someone has a distinct internal experience or feeling without agreeing with their perspective or endorsing their behaviour.

And while its true atheists think theists are delusional, they generally don't reject their right to their own individual self concept as theists don't of them. Nor do atheists declare others who respect religious identity as pretending to agree with them.

Why the invalidation of identity particularly when it involves competing rights?
Here's some interesting insight:

"When people deny the validity of another group's identity because they view their rights as competing, it is most commonly described as identity invalidation driven by a zero-sum mindset (or zero-sum bias).
Depending on the context—whether psychological, sociological, or political—several specific terms capture different layers of this behavior:

1. Core Psychological Concepts
Zero-Sum Mindset (or Zero-Sum Bias): The belief that rights, status, or resources are strictly limited. In this view, granting recognition or rights to one group automatically takes something away from another, creating a perceived threat that motivates the denial of the out-group's identity.
Identity Invalidation (or Identity Denial): The active refusal to recognize, accept, or legitimize another person's or group's self-defined identity, lived experience, or existence.
Competitive Victimhood: A dynamic where groups compete to prove they have suffered more or are the "true" marginalized group. To protect their own claim to victimhood or resources, one group may invalidate the oppression or identity of the other.

2. Sociological & Political Concepts
Gatekeeping: Controlling who gets access to a particular identity, community, or set of rights. Groups may rigidly define criteria to exclude others whom they see as competitors for legal protections or social support.
Erasure: The systematic ignoring, removing, or denying of a specific group's existence, history, or identity. When driven by competing rights, erasure serves to remove the "rival" group from the political or legal conversation entirely.
Ontological Security Threat: A sociological term describing the anxiety people feel when their worldview or social standing is challenged. Denying a competing group's validity is often a defense mechanism to protect one's own sense of place and entitlement in society.

How These Concepts Work Together
In practice, these terms describe a chain reaction. A group perceives a zero-sum conflict over finite legal protections, social status, or resources. To protect their own standing, they engage in gatekeeping or identity invalidation, framing the other group's identity as illegitimate or fabricated rather than acknowledging a legitimate conflict of interests."

What a load of self- serving nonsense. You invalidate womens rights by claiming they also belong to you, rendering sex-based rights to nothing.

Manyanamanyana · 13/11/2026 03:57

TheHereticalOne · 12/11/2026 12:34

100% this, for me.

Significant psychosis plus psychological/social pressure as the dark underbelly of the human need for community.

I have acquired a newfound appreciation for The Crucible, in particular. I do sometimes wonder how much I was primed for rejecting all this by reading that sort of literary warning early in life.

Either way: 'More weight'.

Now I need to watch The Cruciable- not sure I ever saw it

2021x · 13/11/2026 04:06

I have been watching all this RB and DW go down. One of the repeated themes as to why men in their 30s were around female teenagers is "it was the culture at the time".

I believe that tolerance of transgender ideology by organisations such as Stonewall in the UK and the Law Commission here in New Zealand is the current "culture" that is permitting males to be close to vulnerable women.

That and grown men talking about their horoscopes...

OP posts:
Manyanamanyana · 13/11/2026 04:15

TheHereticalOne · 12/11/2026 14:53

Could be, although I've been heartened to see prominent younger women (Maeve Halligan springs to mind) pick up the mantle too (and I suspect I'd also fall outside the age bracket you're thinking of).

Like you, I do wonder what is the common trait or experience that causes some people to reject this sort of attempt at authoritarian enforcement of patent nonsense. It has been suggested to me that they would all score lower than average on the trait of agreeableness, which may well be right, but I don't expect that can be the whole story (and even if it were, what causes that?)

The phenomenon of Terf Island is another interesting angle. Why have we had a more successful pushback than Australia and Canada so far, for example? Is it purely structural or is it linked to the types or volume of people with the necessary traitsto resist it? There are a few books on my shelf waiting to be read on that topic!

I would say that being aware of sexism is a good start to identifying the unfairness of this ideology. And being aware of sexism is probably pretty strongly correlated to being less agreeable 😂Not sure which come first though!
I remember becoming aware of sexism in early high school because of double standards, and general attitudes from everyone about girls, what we were capable of, responsible for, the way we were spoken to, and feeling the injustice of it. Knowing that in primary school my friends and I were sitting in a circle one day when the subject of sexual abuse came up and every single girl in my circle of friends had a previously untold story to share. There were about 10 of us.
I think once you see sexism and notice the patterns of male dominance, you can't unsee it, and you see it everywhere, like another poster said upthread.
And because this ideology has all of the tells of sexism, male dominance and violence, silencing of women and abuse of children, it doesn't take long for 2+2=4.
In Australia I like to believe that the public is generally with us, but the lanyard class has enormous control, and the TRAs got in at the top, fast and early. There is definitely a culture of women who won't risk being called the wrong kind of feminist (i.e. happy to focus on equal pay, but none of the dirty issues like porn and prostitution, the kind of feminism that the left can support without impinging on men's rights to womens bodies).
Aussies are not really known for their political activism though, once they get past about 15 years old, and until it actually touches people, they'll just keep watching the cricket.

caprioska · 13/11/2026 04:25

Manyanamanyana · 13/11/2026 03:17

I didn't say agree, thankfully they are not yet going clockwork orange on us. But I am absolutely compelled, as a Government employee to use pronouns which I object too, and quietly accept men in the bathroom. Should a man decide to use the female changing room at my gym, I must accept that. Likewise should I be unlucky enough to require any of the previously female-designated services for women survivors of male violence, or simply wish to go to a breastfeeding group or join a female sports team. It is entirely dictatorial. You may turn a blind eye to that, but you can't make it untrue.

You are not compelled to use pronouns because you can use names.

Gyms have cubicles for those who those prefer privacy changing.

There are exemptions for sport & also feature explicit exceptions for welfare services, crisis accommodation, and specialised support programs targeted at specific sexes or vulnerable demographics

2021x · 13/11/2026 04:27

caprioska · 13/11/2026 04:25

You are not compelled to use pronouns because you can use names.

Gyms have cubicles for those who those prefer privacy changing.

There are exemptions for sport & also feature explicit exceptions for welfare services, crisis accommodation, and specialised support programs targeted at specific sexes or vulnerable demographics

Being forced to use someone's name rather than a pronoun of their sex is still compelled speech.

Cubicles are still in the single sex space.

OP posts:
caprioska · 13/11/2026 04:30

2021x · 13/11/2026 03:23

It is essential that women are able to identify a person who is male using language that everyone understands. Taking away a woman's ability to correctly identify a male who is acting in a way that indicates he might cause harm - like entering spaces where females get undressed- is an appalling attack on her rights.

Stop exaggerating. The words natal/reproductive or biological male haven't been wiped from the face of the earth just because preferred pronouns exist in Australia.

Manyanamanyana · 13/11/2026 04:38

caprioska · 13/11/2026 04:25

You are not compelled to use pronouns because you can use names.

Gyms have cubicles for those who those prefer privacy changing.

There are exemptions for sport & also feature explicit exceptions for welfare services, crisis accommodation, and specialised support programs targeted at specific sexes or vulnerable demographics

Mate, you don't care and you have 0 respect for actual women. I'm done replying to you. It's men like you who create feminists.

2021x · 13/11/2026 04:38

caprioska · 13/11/2026 04:30

Stop exaggerating. The words natal/reproductive or biological male haven't been wiped from the face of the earth just because preferred pronouns exist in Australia.

x

Sesame Street Elmo GIF
OP posts:
caprioska · 13/11/2026 04:39

2021x · 13/11/2026 04:27

Being forced to use someone's name rather than a pronoun of their sex is still compelled speech.

Cubicles are still in the single sex space.

By this flawed logic dictionary definitions are now 'compelled speech' given their meanings have been broadened via social usage.

Whether you approve or not 'woman' & 'man' now encompass gender identity & by extension so do pronouns. So if you consider dictionary accepted descriptors as 'compelled speech' that would mean just about everything. 😂

2021x · 13/11/2026 04:44

caprioska · 13/11/2026 04:39

By this flawed logic dictionary definitions are now 'compelled speech' given their meanings have been broadened via social usage.

Whether you approve or not 'woman' & 'man' now encompass gender identity & by extension so do pronouns. So if you consider dictionary accepted descriptors as 'compelled speech' that would mean just about everything. 😂

x

Sesame Street Elmo GIF
OP posts:
StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 05:55

caprioska · 13/11/2026 01:30

Balancing the consequences of legislation is a core responsibility in lawmaking, as nearly every policy creates both intended benefits and unintended trade-offs.

"New Zealand Law Commission: In September 2025, the Law Commission recommended that transgender people should have access to single-sex public facilities matching their gender identity, noting that restricting access based on sex assigned at birth is difficult to police and that concerns are outweighed by the harm of exclusion. 1]"

So what material benefit do women get from making all spaces mixed sex? À trade off usually implies both parties get something. What do women get?

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 05:58

caprioska · 13/11/2026 04:25

You are not compelled to use pronouns because you can use names.

Gyms have cubicles for those who those prefer privacy changing.

There are exemptions for sport & also feature explicit exceptions for welfare services, crisis accommodation, and specialised support programs targeted at specific sexes or vulnerable demographics

So people really don’t believe TIM are women, and the fact there are exemptions prove it doesn’t it? Why would they be excluded from female spaces if everyone truly believes they are women? Surely if they are women they should be allowed anywhere a woman is allowed to be? So do please explain why there have to be exceptions…..

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:00

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 05:55

So what material benefit do women get from making all spaces mixed sex? À trade off usually implies both parties get something. What do women get?

Who said anything about all spaces providing a trade off?

caprioska · 13/11/2026 06:04

StealthTroublemaker · 13/11/2026 05:58

So people really don’t believe TIM are women, and the fact there are exemptions prove it doesn’t it? Why would they be excluded from female spaces if everyone truly believes they are women? Surely if they are women they should be allowed anywhere a woman is allowed to be? So do please explain why there have to be exceptions…..

That trans women are natal women? Of course not. That's a convenient GC 'zero sum' story.