Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trying to understand why there is dislike towards trans people - discussion 2

1000 replies

Transperson · 10/11/2026 16:53

Cont

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
SingleSexSpacesInSchools · 10/11/2026 18:00

This reply has been withdrawn

Post withdrawn at author's request

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 18:00

FinchiePink · 10/11/2026 17:59

Well at the least I'd expect it not to descend into goading, insults, and troll hunting.

Hardly the crimes of the century are they, compared to men openly boasting about using women’s spaces.

Margaritaaahhh · 10/11/2026 18:00

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 17:58

Again, it's got nothing to do with consent.

Do you ask the other service users for their personal consent before using a facility?

If not, why do you think they require yours?

It's a tad worrying that you don't understand consent.

And I don't need to ask other women for consent to use female only spaces because I am a woman.

AstonCanKissMyArse · 10/11/2026 18:01

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 17:49

OP being trans has nothing whatsoever to do with your bodily autonomy.

Your posts are so disingenous.

I will spell it out.

No, the OP 'being trans' doesn't affect my bodily autonomy, you're quite correct, have a sticker.

However, if the OP insists on using women's spaces where women are vulnerable and I (or another objecting woman) was present then it would.

I do not consent to being naked or vulnerable around unknown males.

The OP being present like this by stealth (they believe; I doubt) or coercion invalidates any consent of the other women present, therefore infringing their bodily autonomy.

I know you personally don't mind. But I do, and you don't get to consent for other women.

The OP asked what people have against them - I answered.

brownbootsandhats · 10/11/2026 18:01

You take away our options for single sex spaces

but you don’t care about that so you don’t understand that anyone else does

i retract my original statement. I no longer think OP is transgender. I think he’s GC and wanting to convert people to GC by being so obviously unreasonable and bullying

FinchiePink · 10/11/2026 18:01

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 18:00

Hardly the crimes of the century are they, compared to men openly boasting about using women’s spaces.

I didn't say they were did I.

What I'd like to avoid is MNHQ zapping the whole thing.

SingleSexSpacesInSchools · 10/11/2026 18:02

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 17:51

Do you care about OP's "boundaries" or are your "boundaries" the only ones that matter?

You have misunderstood what it means by boundaries. My boundaries are I will not lie about somebody’s sex someone else is able to claim that they are female when they are actually male, but I do not have to agree with or concede that opinion the OP is by their own admission a trans woman, a go, a biological male, and pointing that out is not transgreting anybody’s boundaries at all

RareGoalsVerge · 10/11/2026 18:02

Why the 2nd thread? What more is there to say?

You already established in your first thread that you are disingenuous, do not actually want to understand anyone and do not accept that your behaviour is abhorrent.

I reached my tolerance limit when you declared that a reasonable solution was for you to continue using female facilities despite women's objections because you reckon you pass so well that no one could possibly know.

This is abhorrent because of the intrinsic narcissism and contempt for the integrity and dignity of other human beings because you presume that you have perfect knowledge of what other people know (yes people know you are actually male. You have been told lots of reasons why you aren't challenged) and because you actually think that you can overrule someone's right to withold their consent if they are ignorant that their consent is being violated (they are not actually ignorant, but your belief that if they are theur consent doesn't matter is sickening). This is misogyny. It's part of patriarchy and rape culture. You are guilty of promoting upholding male desires over women's integrity, dignity and right to consent. You should be ashamed of yourself.

We women have been fighting misogyny for many centuries now. We are not going to stop. We are not going to let you redefine our fight as bigotry and hatred. Men tried to make us stop fighting in the 90s by pretending that the fight was won and we could stop now, and that didn't work. Now they are trying to make us stop by redefining words to make it difficult to talk about the oppression of female people by male people and that's not going to work either. We do not hate or even dislike trans people. We reject misogyny. There are trans people who are not misogynists. You are not one of them @Transperson. Disagreement with your repellent views are not evidence of hatred or dislike of trans people. A reasonable person would not have reached the end of the first thread and still not get it.

user1424j023948 · 10/11/2026 18:02

I sometimes wonder if the loose use of terminology is part of the problem

Trans as a word is used to refer to men who have fully transitioned (surgery, removal of penis and testicles, hormone therapy) and those who have genetic conditions where they are medically men (XY chromosomes) but have external female genitalia and internal male reproductive organs.

Trans is used too to refer too to men who like dressing up as women and accessing female spaces who still have penises and no intention to fully transition at all.

Some people may object to penises in female spaces but not those who have fully transitioned to live as women with no penises. I wonder if calling them both the same thing can confuse arguments and attitudes?

Transperson · 10/11/2026 18:03

Margaritaaahhh · 10/11/2026 17:59

Why wouldn't he be safe using the men's toilets?

I have asked him but he didn't respond.

If you really wanna know why I stopped using the mens, a year into my transition I was still using the mens and incident occurred in a remote train station loo in Inverness station, relatively late at night. There was no one around and my safety was at risk.

Said incident was directly related to my transition, which made me realise it was no longer safe me for me to use the mens.

The reason I was using the men until then is because at the time I didn't fully pass and didn't want to cause distress or alarm to others.

OP posts:
SingleSexSpacesInSchools · 10/11/2026 18:03

SingleSexSpacesInSchools · 10/11/2026 17:01

@Transperson
I’m a man and the father of a daughter. I’m not speaking on behalf of all women, but I have a responsibility to look out for my daughter and take women’s concerns about privacy, dignity and safety seriously.

OP, your respectful tone is appreciated, as is your agreement about words such as mother and breastfeeding. But listening also means accepting that women’s answer may be no.

You ask why people dislike trans people.
I do not dislike people for being trans. I object when women’s boundaries are crossed and their objections are treated as hostility. Live and let live includes respecting women’s privacy, dignity and female-only intimate spaces. These are legitimate interests, not evidence of hatred.

You say nobody has noticed or objected.
You cannot know that. Women may remain silent because they are frightened, embarrassed or unwilling to risk confrontation—particularly while undressed. The power imbalance matters. A woman may hurry, leave or avoid returning rather than challenge you. No confrontation does not mean no objection. Assuming otherwise overlooks precisely the vulnerability women are explaining.

You say you behave respectfully and wear a swimsuit.
The boundary concerns your presence as a male in a female-only intimate space, not your clothes or intentions. Covering yourself does not protect another woman’s privacy while she changes. She does not have to prove you dangerous before her privacy matters. Respecting a boundary includes accepting that it applies to you.

You argue that medical transition changes your phenotype.
Medical treatment can change sex characteristics; it does not change reproductive sex. Appearance cannot provide a consistent basis for female-only provision. The Supreme Court confirmed that “sex”, “woman” and “man” in the Equality Act refer to biological sex, while trans people retain protection against gender-reassignment discrimination. Protecting one group does not erase the other’s protections. Supreme Court summary

You use small Scottish prisoner numbers to dismiss offending concerns.
Dividing trans prisoners by Scotland’s entire population does not calculate the imprisonment rate among trans people. A small population percentage is not a confidence interval, either.
The recent England and Wales figures deserve attention. On 31 March 2024, 151 of 245 recorded transgender prisoners whose legal sex was male had sexual-offence convictions: 61.6%. That category included people identifying as women, non-binary or gender-fluid. Ministerial answer
The corresponding sentenced-male prison table recorded 14,138 sexual-offence prisoners out of 68,204: 20.7%.61.6 ÷ 20.7 ≈ 3. That is the arithmetic behind the “three times” comparison. These differently defined prisoner groups cannot establish offending rates in the wider population, but the figures warrant serious scrutiny of prison safeguarding. MoJ table 1.Q.5

You argue that individual offenders should not determine access rules.
Safeguarding considers foreseeable risks, vulnerability and opportunity before harm occurs. Sex is relevant: men accounted for 97% of sentences for sexual offences in England and Wales in the year ending June 2024. Women cannot reliably assess each stranger’s intentions while undressed, and should not have to. Ministry of Justice
Failures have real victims: Karen White sexually assaulted female prisoners. Isla Bryson was convicted of two rapes committed before transition.
Where female-only provision meets the Equality Act’s conditions and is proportionate, it can exclude all male service users, including trans women, without proving each individual dangerous. Personal assurances of good behaviour do not override a justified sex-based boundary. EHRC guidance

You cite research as settling the safety question.
The Massachusetts study found no detectable increase in police-recorded incidents following inclusive access policies. That finding should be acknowledged. But incidents were rare, some locality data were incomplete, and the records could not distinguish trans from non-trans perpetrators. It did not measure women remaining silent, avoiding facilities or losing ordinary bodily privacy. Those limitations restrict what it answers; they do not reverse its finding. Original study
A Swedish cohort covering 1973–2003 found criminal-conviction rates among male-to-female participants higher than female controls and not statistically different from male controls. That historical finding cannot establish present-day UK risk either. Neither paper settles whether women should have female-only intimate provision.Original Swedish study

You describe trans people’s vulnerability and your own experiences of harassment.
Those experiences deserve sympathy and practical protection. Harassment should be addressed. It does not establish entitlement to female-only facilities or require women to surrender their privacy, security and dignity. Additional private and unisex provision can address competing needs. Women should not automatically bear the cost of resolving somebody else’s vulnerability.

You say you want to understand women.
Then what happens when women explain their boundary and their answer remains no? Do you respect it, or continue regardless?
Entering a female-only intimate space leaves objecting women to tolerate it, confront you or leave. That puts the burden on women. Taking access and then expecting women to justify their objections gives your wishes priority over theirs.

Treating women as equals means giving women’s privacy and autonomy real weight—including when that limits what you want. Are you listening to the boundaries women are explaining, or only for an answer that permits you to cross them?

Live and let live must work both ways. Women’s boundaries do not become hatred because somebody dislikes being bound by them.

@Transperson - still waiting for your response to this.

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 18:04

Margaritaaahhh · 10/11/2026 17:59

Why wouldn't he be safe using the men's toilets?

I have asked him but he didn't respond.

Because OP is a passing trans woman.

Are you really so lacking in imagination that you need this spelled out to you?

AstonCanKissMyArse · 10/11/2026 18:04

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 17:55

Do you care about the safety of OP at all? And what's your obsession with policing what toilet she uses?

No, I genuinely really don't.

I really dislike your misogynistic scolding that women are somehow responsible for men's treatment of other males.

WTF has that got to do with me?

I'm not their mum.

Margaritaaahhh · 10/11/2026 18:04

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:59

I don't take away from your bodily autonomy, I don't tell you what to do with your body or where to go. So don't try to take mine away.

You do, though.

Every time a man tells us he's using our spaces, women - particularly those of us with a history of sexual assault or DV - feel less safe to use those spaces. By your rationale you absolutely are removing our autonomy and telling us where to go. Or, to be more accurate, where not to go.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 18:04

FinchiePink · 10/11/2026 18:01

I didn't say they were did I.

What I'd like to avoid is MNHQ zapping the whole thing.

I’m not sure it would be much of a loss to anyone if this second thread got zapped. I think we did “I don’t care what you think ner ner ner” in every possible permutation on the last thread.

callmeLoretta1 · 10/11/2026 18:04

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 18:04

Because OP is a passing trans woman.

Are you really so lacking in imagination that you need this spelled out to you?

There is no such thing as a passing transwoman. Nothing hides the male skeletal structure. Nothing in this world.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 10/11/2026 18:05

Here you are OP - here's a trans identified man who decided to violate women's boundaries by repeatedly walking through female changing rooms when elite girl swimmers were naked & struggling to get into their swimming gear. After parents complained (their daughters were too scared to speak for fear of being attacked as bigots) British Swimming swiftly changed the rules to bar him.

Is that the kind of "breaking the social contract / construct" that you say you're so keen on?

https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-12350741/Parents-raised-concerns-transgender-pool-official-using-womens-changing-room-time-young-girls.html

Parents' concerns over trans pool official using women's changing room

Anne Coombes, 65, who last week blasted a hotel spa for not giving her a key to a female changing room,  was volunteering as an official at the British Summer Championships in Sheffield.

https://www.dailymail.com/news/article-12350741/Parents-raised-concerns-transgender-pool-official-using-womens-changing-room-time-young-girls.html

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 18:05

Margaritaaahhh · 10/11/2026 18:04

You do, though.

Every time a man tells us he's using our spaces, women - particularly those of us with a history of sexual assault or DV - feel less safe to use those spaces. By your rationale you absolutely are removing our autonomy and telling us where to go. Or, to be more accurate, where not to go.

Exactly. It’s really misogynistic behaviour.

BackToLurk · 10/11/2026 18:05

Transperson · 10/11/2026 18:03

If you really wanna know why I stopped using the mens, a year into my transition I was still using the mens and incident occurred in a remote train station loo in Inverness station, relatively late at night. There was no one around and my safety was at risk.

Said incident was directly related to my transition, which made me realise it was no longer safe me for me to use the mens.

The reason I was using the men until then is because at the time I didn't fully pass and didn't want to cause distress or alarm to others.

So a man attacked a man, therefore you need to use women as human shields.

Margaritaaahhh · 10/11/2026 18:05

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 18:04

Because OP is a passing trans woman.

Are you really so lacking in imagination that you need this spelled out to you?

So if he passes as a woman, men pose a risk to him?

By George, I think she's got it!

BackToLurk · 10/11/2026 18:06

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 18:04

I’m not sure it would be much of a loss to anyone if this second thread got zapped. I think we did “I don’t care what you think ner ner ner” in every possible permutation on the last thread.

Isn't this just a big old vanity thread?

Wowthatwasabigstep · 10/11/2026 18:06

Transperson · 10/11/2026 18:03

If you really wanna know why I stopped using the mens, a year into my transition I was still using the mens and incident occurred in a remote train station loo in Inverness station, relatively late at night. There was no one around and my safety was at risk.

Said incident was directly related to my transition, which made me realise it was no longer safe me for me to use the mens.

The reason I was using the men until then is because at the time I didn't fully pass and didn't want to cause distress or alarm to others.

You are a man, use the male toilets. Nothing further to say.

Transperson · 10/11/2026 18:07

RareGoalsVerge · 10/11/2026 18:02

Why the 2nd thread? What more is there to say?

You already established in your first thread that you are disingenuous, do not actually want to understand anyone and do not accept that your behaviour is abhorrent.

I reached my tolerance limit when you declared that a reasonable solution was for you to continue using female facilities despite women's objections because you reckon you pass so well that no one could possibly know.

This is abhorrent because of the intrinsic narcissism and contempt for the integrity and dignity of other human beings because you presume that you have perfect knowledge of what other people know (yes people know you are actually male. You have been told lots of reasons why you aren't challenged) and because you actually think that you can overrule someone's right to withold their consent if they are ignorant that their consent is being violated (they are not actually ignorant, but your belief that if they are theur consent doesn't matter is sickening). This is misogyny. It's part of patriarchy and rape culture. You are guilty of promoting upholding male desires over women's integrity, dignity and right to consent. You should be ashamed of yourself.

We women have been fighting misogyny for many centuries now. We are not going to stop. We are not going to let you redefine our fight as bigotry and hatred. Men tried to make us stop fighting in the 90s by pretending that the fight was won and we could stop now, and that didn't work. Now they are trying to make us stop by redefining words to make it difficult to talk about the oppression of female people by male people and that's not going to work either. We do not hate or even dislike trans people. We reject misogyny. There are trans people who are not misogynists. You are not one of them @Transperson. Disagreement with your repellent views are not evidence of hatred or dislike of trans people. A reasonable person would not have reached the end of the first thread and still not get it.

I fight will continue to fight against misogyny.

No one described how I, as an individual actually causes harm. Saying things like if I go to the women's then cis men would too. Do you think I bring them along?

And no you can't tell, stop trying to tell me about my own lived experience, it's annoying.

OP posts:
AstonCanKissMyArse · 10/11/2026 18:07

Margaritaaahhh · 10/11/2026 18:04

You do, though.

Every time a man tells us he's using our spaces, women - particularly those of us with a history of sexual assault or DV - feel less safe to use those spaces. By your rationale you absolutely are removing our autonomy and telling us where to go. Or, to be more accurate, where not to go.

Absolutely.

Those males are saying "I only care about myself and my wants, I don't GAF about abused women, anxious women, religious women or women who just say no and don't owe me a frigging explanation!"

"I don't care that they can no longer access this place/ service - I am more important"

RareGoalsVerge · 10/11/2026 18:07

You don't have to use shared mens loos if you don't feel safe there @Transperson. There are plenty of fully enclosed single-user loos everywhere, where you can't possibly be in any danger

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.