Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trying to understand why there is dislike towards trans people - discussion 2

1000 replies

Transperson · 10/11/2026 16:53

Cont

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
CohensDiamondTeeth · 11/11/2026 08:36

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 08:24

What's the prevalence of the condition got to do with legal principles regarding sexual consent and definitions of rape? There are 10s of 1000s of women with CAIS , are they all committing rape if they fail to disclose their medical history before each sexual encounter?

Instead of leveraging a vanishingly rare DSD, how about you explain why you seem to think that the OP would not be committing a moral, or legal crime by obtaining sex by deception with an intimate partner who was only consenting to sex with what they thought was a biologically female person.

You said earlier that you were a SA survivor IIRC. Your stance on this is another example of why I, and I assume others, view you as not a genuine poster.

I find this male OP's assertion that his consent (informed and enthusiastic) is the only one that matters when it comes to sexual intercourse absolutely fucking horrifying.

Why do you not?

Why is this not sexual assault / rape in your opinion?

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 11/11/2026 08:38

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 11/11/2026 08:26

No response to this?

For the third time, why don’t you answer this @Lacksie

nutmeg7 · 11/11/2026 08:39

Heggettypeg · 11/11/2026 06:04

Ah yes. Converting The Heathen. A very popular game for people with an uncritical sense of their own cultural and moral superiority and a belief that it is their destiny to be the Right Side of History. Usually goes with colonising somebody else's space.

My thoughts exactly. A degree of self righteousness is required.

Datun · 11/11/2026 08:39

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 08:29

How do you come to that conclusion? You are the one arguing that failure to disclose information about "sex" before a sexual encounter makes a person a rapist. Repeatedly on this thread. That is your assertion.
So do you apply this principle to women with CAIS or not?

Edited

Ffs. I have no idea how you manage to get through life pretending you take the moral high ground, and then using a medical condition to back up an argument for sex by deception.

Women with CAIS are indistinguishable from women without. But yes, given they have no female internal organs and therefore can't get pregnant, I would suggest it is a conversation that should happen before sex. Is it rape if it doesn't, no it isn't, in my opinion. I have no idea if that's the case legally. Many women with CAIS don't even know they've got it.

Despite the presence of an X chromosome, I would absolutely treat a woman with CAIS as a woman in terms of changing rooms and toilets.

This level of gotcha is so fucking depressing. It's like being in a room with six formers who've just discovered the word debate.

But you said green! You meant blue, but you said green! You're wrong, ha ha.

Grow up.

brownbootsandhats · 11/11/2026 08:40

CAIS is a well documented and incredibly rare condition which is completely unrelated to transgender identities and there are various other things such a person may need to disclose before entering a relationship - impact on fertility being one

why don’t you answer the question about the phenological type of a solider who has lost his genitals and why that doesn’t make him a transgender woman ?

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 08:40

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 08:36

I'm fine . Why is it you are struggling to answer the question do you think?

I answered your question if that is any help.

If you are registered as female at birth you are legally female.

Helleofabore · 11/11/2026 08:41

I think it shows just how little respect a person has that they cannot even respect that a person who they are about to engage in sex with is has full information about what sex category they are.

That some other people also support this position of not disclosing adds moral weight in the eyes of the person not disclosing. However, all that means is that other people support the disrespect for reasons of their own. Maybe because their philosophical belief must support that because all
their other arguments need that as a foundation.

It really says a lot about a person who doesn’t understand the fundamental concepts of consent.

It reminds me of the barrister who was interviewed on national TV with Maya Forstater after the FWS decision. He told the world effectively that he never disclosed to a sex partner that he was male until well after the first sexual encounter. And he was proud of that fact. To me that indicated a man who had no care for his intimate partner. To me, that was a good indication of whether anyone can ever believe that he respects someone when he says he does. Because that is the opposite to respect in my opinion. There are other terms though that would apply to a person treating people in that way.

When a person so clearly shows you who they are, believe them.

Grammarnut · 11/11/2026 08:42

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:00

Being trans is already breaking a social contract, as not limiting myself to a box that was arbitrary put on me in terms of how I meant meant to present myself in society.

Breaking social constructs is kinda of the idea, so we can be more free as individual to be ourselves.

Social constructs is one thing - so do the washing up as well as empty the bin. Breaching boundaries is quite another and nothing to do with social constructs but is connected with biological reality and the social contract we all adhere to if we are decent human beings. Don't come whingeing here that you want to break social constructs when, in fact, everything you do either reinforces gender stereotypes or breaches the social contract. Go away and sin no more, or, if that trouble be too great, go away at any rate. (And I really feel for Caroline of Brunswick, the butt of those lines, but not at all for transpeople who say they just want to pee when what they really want is to wear their fetish in public and force everyone else to participate.)

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 08:43

Helleofabore · 11/11/2026 08:41

I think it shows just how little respect a person has that they cannot even respect that a person who they are about to engage in sex with is has full information about what sex category they are.

That some other people also support this position of not disclosing adds moral weight in the eyes of the person not disclosing. However, all that means is that other people support the disrespect for reasons of their own. Maybe because their philosophical belief must support that because all
their other arguments need that as a foundation.

It really says a lot about a person who doesn’t understand the fundamental concepts of consent.

It reminds me of the barrister who was interviewed on national TV with Maya Forstater after the FWS decision. He told the world effectively that he never disclosed to a sex partner that he was male until well after the first sexual encounter. And he was proud of that fact. To me that indicated a man who had no care for his intimate partner. To me, that was a good indication of whether anyone can ever believe that he respects someone when he says he does. Because that is the opposite to respect in my opinion. There are other terms though that would apply to a person treating people in that way.

When a person so clearly shows you who they are, believe them.

He told the world effectively that he never disclosed to a sex partner that he was male until well after the first sexual encounter. And he was proud of that fact.

Ironically, revealing a very male coded attitude.

Verisregina · 11/11/2026 08:44

@CoolforKats

’there is no access by deceit.’ Yet that is exactly what @Transperson said is happening - women don’t know he is a man so who is it hurting? I would say it is hurting all those women who don’t wish to share single sex spaces with men.

@Lacksie you may call it victim
blaming if you feel it furthers your argument. But your response failed to address the fact that TP said he accesses women’s single sex spaces by deceit and that he doesn’t care if women don’t like it, want it or try to stop it.

Men do not belong in women’s single sex spaces.

Edited to correct typo.

TheKeatingFive · 11/11/2026 08:49

It’s very simple …

Either you think women deserve to have their single sex rights upheld - or you don’t.

Either you think a potential sexual partner should know the truth about your sex for meaningful consent - or you don’t.

Its pretty obvious which side has the moral high ground here

Heggettypeg · 11/11/2026 08:51

I experience myself as a witty raconteur. You experience me as a crashing bore. How dare you avoid my anecdotes! So unkind.

I experience myself as a wonderful singer. You experience me as an assault on your ears. How dare you pass over me and hire another singer for your concert! I am very offended.

I experience myself as a woman. You experience me as a male in a space for the female sex. How dare you say I am making you feel uncomfortable! You are a bigot.

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 08:53

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 08:40

I answered your question if that is any help.

If you are registered as female at birth you are legally female.

So sex is really about registration at birth- a social and legal act. Not about chromosomes and gametes after all then?

Datun · 11/11/2026 08:54

Also, this nonsensical defence that I'm not hurting anyone, because they don't know?

I've mentioned this before. But there was a woman on here from a rape crisis centre who said they make a lot of provision for the women there around perception.

The women know there are no men there. This worker said it's like a witness protection program. You don't know where it is, there's no address to be found, they will meet a victim/survivor elsewhere.

They carpet all the floors. They talk in a quiet voice. They don't laugh out loud. They don't make sudden movements. They don't slam doors.

They do all of these things because some women find loud voices, heavy footfalls, slamming doors, etc, incredibly triggering. It can petrify a woman.

The idea that a man invading a woman's space isn't hurting anyone is risible.

There's a woman, here, on Mumsnet, who said she cannot be behind a closed door if she knows there's a man on the other side. That's the extent of her trauma.

Men pretending that no one notices their invading presence are wrong on every level.

I have no doubt that this sort of predatory and domineering attitude will have to be made criminal. Trans ideology has given far too many men the disgusting idea that they can get their kicks this way.

That is going to have to change.

CoolforKats · 11/11/2026 08:54

Verisregina · 11/11/2026 08:44

@CoolforKats

’there is no access by deceit.’ Yet that is exactly what @Transperson said is happening - women don’t know he is a man so who is it hurting? I would say it is hurting all those women who don’t wish to share single sex spaces with men.

@Lacksie you may call it victim
blaming if you feel it furthers your argument. But your response failed to address the fact that TP said he accesses women’s single sex spaces by deceit and that he doesn’t care if women don’t like it, want it or try to stop it.

Men do not belong in women’s single sex spaces.

Edited to correct typo.

Edited

Your exact words were "access by deceit" so discomfort is irrelevant because the access is determined by law.

Like many women I personally feel discomfort in open change rooms regardless of sex but that discomfort doesn't entitle me to separate accomodations. And TP isn't even making anyone uncomfortable let alone harming anyone by her presence.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 11/11/2026 08:56

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 08:53

So sex is really about registration at birth- a social and legal act. Not about chromosomes and gametes after all then?

Edited

🙄

Come on. Even you can do better.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 11/11/2026 08:57

Some people will leverage anything to get men into women's spaces, or deny female people the right to define for ourselves who we are and what matters to us.

In every other aspect of life, a 0.00005% exception to the very clear and obvious general rule does not render a human of mental capacity unable to understand the rule.

Only when it comes to a respecting women.

Very weird and disappointing.

Datun · 11/11/2026 08:57

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 08:53

So sex is really about registration at birth- a social and legal act. Not about chromosomes and gametes after all then?

Edited

Here you go Lacksie, men should not be in women's spaces, no that doesn't include women with CAIS.

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 08:58

CoolforKats · 11/11/2026 08:54

Your exact words were "access by deceit" so discomfort is irrelevant because the access is determined by law.

Like many women I personally feel discomfort in open change rooms regardless of sex but that discomfort doesn't entitle me to separate accomodations. And TP isn't even making anyone uncomfortable let alone harming anyone by her presence.

Jessica Yaniv claimed much the same thingm

MagpiePi · 11/11/2026 08:58

Before the thread fills up, I'd really like to get one of the swimming costumes that @Transperson has that prevents women from realising he is a man.

Everyone would see me as a 6' willowy, 25 year old supermodel, because thats what I want to be, rather than a dumpy, a bit saggy round the edges, menopausal woman.

TheKeatingFive · 11/11/2026 08:59

CoolforKats · 11/11/2026 08:54

Your exact words were "access by deceit" so discomfort is irrelevant because the access is determined by law.

Like many women I personally feel discomfort in open change rooms regardless of sex but that discomfort doesn't entitle me to separate accomodations. And TP isn't even making anyone uncomfortable let alone harming anyone by her presence.

TP has absolutely no idea who is being made uncomfortable by his presence. He is in no position to judge that.

And of course it’s access by deceit if he is entering female spaces while trying g to disguise his male sex.

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 08:59

Magic swimming costumes could be a big seller.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 11/11/2026 08:59

The end of the world thread is nigh, and we are still waiting for the 'engagement' from the OP that was promised a long while ago

Wonder if he'll start thread 3 to do it?

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 08:59

But men still need to stay out of women's spaces.

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 09:00

Men need to respect womens boundaries and consent.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.