Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trying to understand why there is dislike towards trans people - discussion 2

1000 replies

Transperson · 10/11/2026 16:53

Cont

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
AccidentallyWesAnderson · 11/11/2026 08:13

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 07:08

Have you read the two threads and seen the way that pp's have vilified, dehumanised and taunted the OP? I hardly think the hate is "a narrative". We are well beyond "disagreement" here.

Edited

The OP admitted he would commit a sexual offence. That’s not a likeable trait (to put it mildly) and men like that should be vilified.

Why do you like and defend men like this?

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 08:14

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 07:02

And yet, no matter how many times you repeat that assertion, your certainty will never confer the knowledge, insight or authority to tell OP who she is, what it means to inhabit her body, or how she experiences herself.

You cannot assert your way into knowledge of another person’s lived reality through the sheer force of your conviction.
It don't work like that.

Nobody on this thread knows what it is like to be the OP, particularly as this is an anonymous forum.

Pretty much the only thing that seems likely is that he is male.

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 11/11/2026 08:15

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 08:10

Question - what about women with CAIS? Are they required to disclose their medical history before every sexual encounter or be prosecuted for rape?

Whataboutery. Whatashockery. 🙄

GreyskySexRealistsky · 11/11/2026 08:15

2021x · 11/11/2026 08:10

I have been thinking about how a transwoman would be able to tell that no one thinks that they are a woman.

I came up with what happens if a little girl needs to go to the toilet. Most people would be fine with a woman taking her, but they probably wouldn't ask a transwoman to take her.

To take this further - if the 'woman' who took her was actually a TW who passes perfectly, like the OP, and the parent only found out afterwards, would they be okay with it?

2021x · 11/11/2026 08:17

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 08:10

Question - what about women with CAIS? Are they required to disclose their medical history before every sexual encounter or be prosecuted for rape?

Women with CAIS don't feel the need to make other people responsible for their personal issues.

Only narcissists do that.

kitex · 11/11/2026 08:17

Why would a man want to use female single sex spaces when he knows women don’t want him to? Any decent man wouldn’t do this.

2021x · 11/11/2026 08:18

GreyskySexRealistsky · 11/11/2026 08:15

To take this further - if the 'woman' who took her was actually a TW who passes perfectly, like the OP, and the parent only found out afterwards, would they be okay with it?

It would be interesting to know.

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 08:18

Incidence of CAIS is estimated at 0.0005%

It's an irrelevance.

The existence of CAIS does not give men license to use women's spaces. (Or provide a mitigation for sex by deception).

2021x · 11/11/2026 08:19

kitex · 11/11/2026 08:17

Why would a man want to use female single sex spaces when he knows women don’t want him to? Any decent man wouldn’t do this.

There is only one type of man who ignores women when they say no. Not all transwomen do this.

SingleSexSpacesInSchools · 11/11/2026 08:21

SingleSexSpacesInSchools · 10/11/2026 17:01

@Transperson
I’m a man and the father of a daughter. I’m not speaking on behalf of all women, but I have a responsibility to look out for my daughter and take women’s concerns about privacy, dignity and safety seriously.

OP, your respectful tone is appreciated, as is your agreement about words such as mother and breastfeeding. But listening also means accepting that women’s answer may be no.

You ask why people dislike trans people.
I do not dislike people for being trans. I object when women’s boundaries are crossed and their objections are treated as hostility. Live and let live includes respecting women’s privacy, dignity and female-only intimate spaces. These are legitimate interests, not evidence of hatred.

You say nobody has noticed or objected.
You cannot know that. Women may remain silent because they are frightened, embarrassed or unwilling to risk confrontation—particularly while undressed. The power imbalance matters. A woman may hurry, leave or avoid returning rather than challenge you. No confrontation does not mean no objection. Assuming otherwise overlooks precisely the vulnerability women are explaining.

You say you behave respectfully and wear a swimsuit.
The boundary concerns your presence as a male in a female-only intimate space, not your clothes or intentions. Covering yourself does not protect another woman’s privacy while she changes. She does not have to prove you dangerous before her privacy matters. Respecting a boundary includes accepting that it applies to you.

You argue that medical transition changes your phenotype.
Medical treatment can change sex characteristics; it does not change reproductive sex. Appearance cannot provide a consistent basis for female-only provision. The Supreme Court confirmed that “sex”, “woman” and “man” in the Equality Act refer to biological sex, while trans people retain protection against gender-reassignment discrimination. Protecting one group does not erase the other’s protections. Supreme Court summary

You use small Scottish prisoner numbers to dismiss offending concerns.
Dividing trans prisoners by Scotland’s entire population does not calculate the imprisonment rate among trans people. A small population percentage is not a confidence interval, either.
The recent England and Wales figures deserve attention. On 31 March 2024, 151 of 245 recorded transgender prisoners whose legal sex was male had sexual-offence convictions: 61.6%. That category included people identifying as women, non-binary or gender-fluid. Ministerial answer
The corresponding sentenced-male prison table recorded 14,138 sexual-offence prisoners out of 68,204: 20.7%.61.6 ÷ 20.7 ≈ 3. That is the arithmetic behind the “three times” comparison. These differently defined prisoner groups cannot establish offending rates in the wider population, but the figures warrant serious scrutiny of prison safeguarding. MoJ table 1.Q.5

You argue that individual offenders should not determine access rules.
Safeguarding considers foreseeable risks, vulnerability and opportunity before harm occurs. Sex is relevant: men accounted for 97% of sentences for sexual offences in England and Wales in the year ending June 2024. Women cannot reliably assess each stranger’s intentions while undressed, and should not have to. Ministry of Justice
Failures have real victims: Karen White sexually assaulted female prisoners. Isla Bryson was convicted of two rapes committed before transition.
Where female-only provision meets the Equality Act’s conditions and is proportionate, it can exclude all male service users, including trans women, without proving each individual dangerous. Personal assurances of good behaviour do not override a justified sex-based boundary. EHRC guidance

You cite research as settling the safety question.
The Massachusetts study found no detectable increase in police-recorded incidents following inclusive access policies. That finding should be acknowledged. But incidents were rare, some locality data were incomplete, and the records could not distinguish trans from non-trans perpetrators. It did not measure women remaining silent, avoiding facilities or losing ordinary bodily privacy. Those limitations restrict what it answers; they do not reverse its finding. Original study
A Swedish cohort covering 1973–2003 found criminal-conviction rates among male-to-female participants higher than female controls and not statistically different from male controls. That historical finding cannot establish present-day UK risk either. Neither paper settles whether women should have female-only intimate provision.Original Swedish study

You describe trans people’s vulnerability and your own experiences of harassment.
Those experiences deserve sympathy and practical protection. Harassment should be addressed. It does not establish entitlement to female-only facilities or require women to surrender their privacy, security and dignity. Additional private and unisex provision can address competing needs. Women should not automatically bear the cost of resolving somebody else’s vulnerability.

You say you want to understand women.
Then what happens when women explain their boundary and their answer remains no? Do you respect it, or continue regardless?
Entering a female-only intimate space leaves objecting women to tolerate it, confront you or leave. That puts the burden on women. Taking access and then expecting women to justify their objections gives your wishes priority over theirs.

Treating women as equals means giving women’s privacy and autonomy real weight—including when that limits what you want. Are you listening to the boundaries women are explaining, or only for an answer that permits you to cross them?

Live and let live must work both ways. Women’s boundaries do not become hatred because somebody dislikes being bound by them.

@Transperson - still waiting for a response.

if you have the moral high ground, why can’t you answer these points?

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 08:23

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 08:08

No you're not getting it.
We are all the authority on our own individual experience.
None of us in an authority on the experience of someone else.
I can tell you who I am, I can't tell you who you are.

From asking the meter reader to show ID at the door to doing due diligence on a client to asking volunteers in a school to get DBS checked to checking that a doctor is registered to requesting evidence of age to get a bus pass to requesting evidence of disability to get a blue badge to showing your passport to enter the country there are countless times every day that we judge who other people are.

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 08:24

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 08:18

Incidence of CAIS is estimated at 0.0005%

It's an irrelevance.

The existence of CAIS does not give men license to use women's spaces. (Or provide a mitigation for sex by deception).

Edited

What's the prevalence of the condition got to do with legal principles regarding sexual consent and definitions of rape? There are 10s of 1000s of women with CAIS , are they all committing rape if they fail to disclose their medical history before each sexual encounter?

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 08:24

For those concerned about people with CAIS: tell the NHS to stop telling children that 'some girls don't get periods'.

That is likely to lead to missed diagnoses.

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 08:25

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 08:24

What's the prevalence of the condition got to do with legal principles regarding sexual consent and definitions of rape? There are 10s of 1000s of women with CAIS , are they all committing rape if they fail to disclose their medical history before each sexual encounter?

It's not 'medical history', its their sex. Anyway, go and ask them? It's nothing to do with me, and nothing to do with this thread.

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 11/11/2026 08:26

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 11/11/2026 08:13

The OP admitted he would commit a sexual offence. That’s not a likeable trait (to put it mildly) and men like that should be vilified.

Why do you like and defend men like this?

No response to this?

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 08:26

This thread is about men who call themselves women, as per OP. Nothing to do with DSDs or CAIS.

CoolforKats · 11/11/2026 08:27

Verisregina · 11/11/2026 08:03

I think for me, the biggest issue I have is that @Transperson uses women’s toilets and women’s showers at the swimming pool (but keeps his swimsuit on to ensure he doesn’t upset the women around him) without, he argues their knowledge that he is a man …

Nearly two threads full of women patiently and knowledgeably (on the whole) explaining why men should stay out of single sex spaces and his response (paraphrased) is; I pass, the women whose single sex space I am invading don’t know, so ‘I don’t really care’.

@Lacksie @CoolforKats you are correct that some posters have been provoked into regrettable language (and they have apologized for this), but that does not negate the fact that @Transperson uses women’s single sex spaces by deceit and doesn’t see that this is wrong.

Its not illegal for trans women to use women's toilet's only possibly for service providers that don't prevent them so there is no access by deceit.

Until case law clarifies such matters TP isn't in the wrong legally or morally & in fact is mitigating any personal discomfort some women may feel.

Toseland · 11/11/2026 08:28

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:25

Let's ground things, all I do is use single sex spaces without people being aware of what's going on, that inherently means I am not traumatising people.

The trauma comes from when people sexually assault women, in spaces that are meant to be safe, but I am not doing that. I'm being respectful and mindful. Or at least trying my best to. I do empathise with victims of SA or otherwise been put in danger (again I experienced harassment and SA).

I've popped in and seen this, which I find absolutely astonishing. The lack of consideration, respect or understanding of women, women's spaces or women's experience.
"All I do", "...without people being aware of what's going on..." and telling women where the "trauma comes from..."
Of course women and children are aware of what's happening. Sneaking around pretending you haven't been noticed is laughable if it wasn't so dangerous. You are not being respectful or mindful you are a petty-minded creep and if you are in a woman's space then you are a predator and deserve to be treated as such. Keep out of women's spaces.

NimbleTaupeTiger · 11/11/2026 08:29

I find this whole thread, this whole attitude quite disturbing tbh. We have here a person who lives as a woman which I don't think anyone would bat an eyelid at. Lots of people do it and that's fine. However, this person who lives like a woman but who is, in fact, a man, wants to have access to women only spaces. Well, I do understand, OP believes that they pass as a woman and, therefore, can use these spaces with nobody knowing.

Problem is, women generally do know and while they may not say anything they will glance at other women in the washroom mirror and it will be understood by all the women in the facility that he/she is biologically male. Sorry, but it's a fact, a raised eyebrow will be exchanged or an expression or a glance, it's a code, it's understood by women.

Then we come to the "sex" part. This really is quite vile. To have intimate relations with another human being without divulging your biological sex is absolutely heinous. Once your partner uncovers the truth they could be mentally scarred and need therapy. This is an act of utter selfishness and I cannot express how totally unacceptable I find it.

Live like a woman by all means but don't ride roughshod over groups of people while doing it, it's not right and it's not fair. And don't have sex with people who don't know, it's abhorrent.

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 08:29

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 08:25

It's not 'medical history', its their sex. Anyway, go and ask them? It's nothing to do with me, and nothing to do with this thread.

How do you come to that conclusion? You are the one arguing that failure to disclose information about "sex" before a sexual encounter makes a person a rapist. Repeatedly on this thread. That is your assertion.
So do you apply this principle to women with CAIS or not?

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 11/11/2026 08:33

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 08:29

How do you come to that conclusion? You are the one arguing that failure to disclose information about "sex" before a sexual encounter makes a person a rapist. Repeatedly on this thread. That is your assertion.
So do you apply this principle to women with CAIS or not?

Edited

It’s the LAW. Are you actually on the internet defending this? Are you seriously OK?

thirdfiddle · 11/11/2026 08:33

You wonder why women don't like you, while spending two whole threads wanging on about how you prioritize your needs over ours and don't care what we think about it. If there is one sure way to show you are not a woman and have no empathy with women, that's it.

Maybe you're the most perfectly passing TW ever. I doubt it, there are so many who think they pass and don't even slightly. But even if you are. Any rule that says you can be there also says that every other man can go in. Every other man, doesn't even need to sincerely identify as there's no way of checking that. It is not possible to give you what you want, a space with women and you and not Dave the sexual predator. Any rule that lets you in lets Dave in too. So no you may not.

And if you enter regardless you will not know how many women are upset. The sort of women who are discomfited have probably learned to act really really well. And even if not one woman notices, hiding meat in a vegetarian's food and getting away with it is nasty disrespectful behaviour. The rules say stay out so stay out and campaign for whatever third or fourth spaces you need for your comfort. Then we can be friends.

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 08:33

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 08:10

Question - what about women with CAIS? Are they required to disclose their medical history before every sexual encounter or be prosecuted for rape?

The OP does not have CAIS.

I can’t think of a reason why somebody with CAIS would not be legally female from birth or comparable to a man born with a male body.

Theonebutnotonly · 11/11/2026 08:34

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 06:41

hi @BunnyBunbunbun You’re a stranger to OP, not an authority on her person.
You have no idea what it’s like to be @Transperson . You will never inhabit her body, live her life, or experience the world as she does.
Holding a belief- however dogmatically- about someone else’s identity , doesn’t equip you with the insight necessary to define it for them.
That’s not a matter of opinion , it’s just reality.

Edited

Hi @Lacksie

Thanks for giving, in your defence of @Transperson , a framework for me to use.

You have no idea what it’s like to be a woman. You will never inhabit a woman's body, live her life, or experience the world as she does.
Holding a belief - however dogmatically - about the opposite sex's identity doesn’t equip you with the insight necessary to define it for them.
That’s not a matter of opinion , it’s just reality.

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 08:36

AccidentallyWesAnderson · 11/11/2026 08:33

It’s the LAW. Are you actually on the internet defending this? Are you seriously OK?

I'm fine . Why is it you are struggling to answer the question do you think?

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.