Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trying to understand why there is dislike towards trans people - discussion 2

1000 replies

Transperson · 10/11/2026 16:53

Cont

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
Mountainlarch · 11/11/2026 07:25

I'm always puzzled by the lack of insight in moving from the personal perspective to the general rules. I'm sure that many trans people are very nice and behave in an impeccable way in toilets.

However, there's never an acknowledgement of the fact that there has to be a rule that safeguards single sex spaces. This can't be self-id for obvious reasons. This can't be "passing" for other, I think obvious, reasons: how is it "passing" determined? Is it discrimination towards other trans people that don't pass equally well? Where does "passing" stop (eg ok in a toilet, not ok in a changing room where people are naked, not ok in sport, not ok in a rape crisis centre)?

nutmeg7 · 11/11/2026 07:26

Transperson · 10/11/2026 23:07

"Throughout, Scott addresses several blind bends in sexual consent law. In particular, one example illustrates how deception in law is differentiated. She quotes a Scottish appeal case concerning a man who led his female partner to understand he had undergone a vasectomy so there was no need to use a condom. The judgment explained the difference between sexual deception relating to outcome and sexual deception relating to performance; only the latter was prosecutable"
https://www.scottishlegal.com/articles/review-deception-consent-and-the-limits-of-rape-law

Because trans people aren't lying about their gender, ethnicity, name, etc. Fraud has to be performative here.

I think you will find sex is about sex.
Not “gender”.

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 07:27

murasaki · 10/11/2026 23:37

apart from his boundaries, which are, of course, of extreme importance.

Male boundaries are sacrosanct.

Womens boundaries are a quaint idea - maybe we could call them decorative?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/11/2026 07:28

Igneococcus · 11/11/2026 06:25

At this point the question for me is: why should I like someone who is giving no thought whatsoever to women and their safety and wishes? Why do you require me to like someone who, based on his contribution on this thread, is deeply unpleasant and self-centered to the extreme? What is there to "like"?

An excellent question.

FrippEnos · 11/11/2026 07:30

Transperson

The sad thing about all of this is that you seem to have difficulty in making this anything other than about you.

You can't see that your choices are having a negative affect on many women and girls.

GriseldaandMike · 11/11/2026 07:31

If I'm dating John and in a sexual relationship with him is it OK for his identical twin brother David to slip into my bed instead one night? After all I wouldn't know would I?

GriseldaandMike · 11/11/2026 07:32

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 07:27

Male boundaries are sacrosanct.

Womens boundaries are a quaint idea - maybe we could call them decorative?

Just like we can't possibly know what it is to be trans but a man can know what it is to be a woman. The traffic is all one way.

Shedmistress · 11/11/2026 07:33

Is this going to just be a presursor to 10 more threads about a man 'baffled' as to why he is 'disliked' in womens spaces whilst also saying 'nobody knows I'm a man really but I'm still going to use women's spaces'.

And instigating more and more furious responses that end up getting one or more woman banned or suspended?

He knows full well why women dislike him in their spaces.

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 07:34

Transperson · 10/11/2026 23:07

"Throughout, Scott addresses several blind bends in sexual consent law. In particular, one example illustrates how deception in law is differentiated. She quotes a Scottish appeal case concerning a man who led his female partner to understand he had undergone a vasectomy so there was no need to use a condom. The judgment explained the difference between sexual deception relating to outcome and sexual deception relating to performance; only the latter was prosecutable"
https://www.scottishlegal.com/articles/review-deception-consent-and-the-limits-of-rape-law

Because trans people aren't lying about their gender, ethnicity, name, etc. Fraud has to be performative here.

This post suggests sex by deception is a legal argument.

Again - what is the moral position?

If you deliberately deceive someone as to your sex, this is rape.

I've long been astonished that some (not many, I'd like to add) trans activists are so keen to argue to the effect that if someone gets away with it, its not rape.

The vast majority of people care what sex their sexual partner is. This forms an important part of many people's identity. To suggest otherwise is, I would say, a form of forcible 'conversion'. It seems in the same class to me as corrective rape.

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 07:36

FrippEnos · 11/11/2026 07:30

Transperson

The sad thing about all of this is that you seem to have difficulty in making this anything other than about you.

You can't see that your choices are having a negative affect on many women and girls.

He can or he can't. Neither option is a good one.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/11/2026 07:37

Shedmistress · 11/11/2026 07:33

Is this going to just be a presursor to 10 more threads about a man 'baffled' as to why he is 'disliked' in womens spaces whilst also saying 'nobody knows I'm a man really but I'm still going to use women's spaces'.

And instigating more and more furious responses that end up getting one or more woman banned or suspended?

He knows full well why women dislike him in their spaces.

Yep.

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 07:37

Mountainlarch · 11/11/2026 07:25

I'm always puzzled by the lack of insight in moving from the personal perspective to the general rules. I'm sure that many trans people are very nice and behave in an impeccable way in toilets.

However, there's never an acknowledgement of the fact that there has to be a rule that safeguards single sex spaces. This can't be self-id for obvious reasons. This can't be "passing" for other, I think obvious, reasons: how is it "passing" determined? Is it discrimination towards other trans people that don't pass equally well? Where does "passing" stop (eg ok in a toilet, not ok in a changing room where people are naked, not ok in sport, not ok in a rape crisis centre)?

I think this also puzzled the Supreme Court.

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 07:37

Shedmistress · 11/11/2026 07:33

Is this going to just be a presursor to 10 more threads about a man 'baffled' as to why he is 'disliked' in womens spaces whilst also saying 'nobody knows I'm a man really but I'm still going to use women's spaces'.

And instigating more and more furious responses that end up getting one or more woman banned or suspended?

He knows full well why women dislike him in their spaces.

Well, fine if it is. It has given us the chance to discuss some issues - such as sex by deception - that people often claim nobody is arguing.

Thanks, OP, for laying out your arguments so clearly.

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 07:39

FrippEnos · 11/11/2026 07:30

Transperson

The sad thing about all of this is that you seem to have difficulty in making this anything other than about you.

You can't see that your choices are having a negative affect on many women and girls.

Doesn’t seem to be considering other trans people either, which does suggest a lack of sincerity given the title of the thread.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 11/11/2026 07:39

FrippEnos · 11/11/2026 07:30

Transperson

The sad thing about all of this is that you seem to have difficulty in making this anything other than about you.

You can't see that your choices are having a negative affect on many women and girls.

minus “can’t see”

plus “don’t care”

GreyskySexRealistsky · 11/11/2026 07:40

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 07:02

And yet, no matter how many times you repeat that assertion, your certainty will never confer the knowledge, insight or authority to tell OP who she is, what it means to inhabit her body, or how she experiences herself.

You cannot assert your way into knowledge of another person’s lived reality through the sheer force of your conviction.
It don't work like that.

You cannot assert your way into knowledge of another person’s lived reality through the sheer force of your conviction.

Yes! You're getting it!
This is how many women feel.
We do not matter less than him.

Datun · 11/11/2026 07:42

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 05:34

But I take the position of refusing to abdicate my responsibility to truth & decency by allowing this forum to continue being a hot bed of hate

I hear you. I feel the same,

There's not a person on this thread that thinks you're doing it out of a sense of duty.

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 07:42

You cannot assert your way into knowledge of another person’s lived reality through the sheer force of your conviction.

Agree, Lacksie! Thanks for summing up women's argument so succinctly. OP cannot assert himself into women's lived reality.

Datun · 11/11/2026 07:44

*Trying to understand why there is dislike towards trans people - discussion 2

I've been mentally channeling my inner Ben Cooper a lot lately 😁

WomanXXWorldsOriginsofMothersofAllNations · 11/11/2026 07:45

Transperson · 10/11/2026 21:03

There isn't really space for it at all, if I don't get assaulted I get harassed, if I don't get harassed I get fetishized, if I don't get fetishized I am dismissed. And on top of that there are the men who ridicule trans people. I can't really share a space with them.

But you expect us to.

Shedmistress · 11/11/2026 07:46

WomanXXWorldsOriginsofMothersofAllNations · 11/11/2026 07:45

But you expect us to.

He says that nobody knows he is trans though.

Its all bollocks.

GriseldaandMike · 11/11/2026 07:50

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 05:34

But I take the position of refusing to abdicate my responsibility to truth & decency by allowing this forum to continue being a hot bed of hate

I hear you. I feel the same,

I hope you have reported all this hate - I reported SSSSs unpaletable comment to you (but not the one where the OP called me a gorilla, I quite like that one and hope it sticks around).

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 07:50

I'm tickled that 'truth & decency' is apparently arguing that it's legal (- ish) to deceive sexual partners as to one's sex. A bold assertion, that's for fucking sure.

TheKeatingFive · 11/11/2026 07:53

@Transpersonif you would be assaulted and harassed by men, in men’s spaces - why is the focus not tackling this awful behaviour of men?

Why are you (and other TRAs) ignoring that in favour of trying to bully women into giving you access to their spaces?

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 07:54

Transperson · 10/11/2026 21:12

I'm glad that you the council of all of women everywhere decided that trans people should continue getting harassed and assaulted rather than accommodate for them. If women won't no one will.

‘If women won’t no one will’

If you are being harassed and assaulted by men, that is the responsibility of the men.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread