Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trying to understand why there is dislike towards trans people - discussion 2

1000 replies

Transperson · 10/11/2026 16:53

Cont

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 07:54

And activists wonder why the general public is losing sympathy.

My honest advice, if any trans activists are reading this thread - you are going to have to get your most extreme advocates to consider what damage they are doing to your cause.

This board, contrary to Reddit myth, consists of largely liberal minded, live-and-let-live people from various bits of the political spectrum.

The general public is never likely to think that 'sex by deception' is okay, or that 'stealthing' is justified.

Most of the women you so vociferously demonise and attack are not in fact 'anti trans'. Most of us don't give a hoot about your identity.

All women want is women's rights. And those are, as we know, based on biological sex. Men cannot have women's rights. The more you try to claim you can, the firmer we stand.

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 07:56

TheKeatingFive · 11/11/2026 07:53

@Transpersonif you would be assaulted and harassed by men, in men’s spaces - why is the focus not tackling this awful behaviour of men?

Why are you (and other TRAs) ignoring that in favour of trying to bully women into giving you access to their spaces?

Good question. It almost looks like bullying women is the whole entire point, doesn't it?

Datun · 11/11/2026 07:56

Shedmistress · 11/11/2026 07:46

He says that nobody knows he is trans though.

Its all bollocks.

Personally, it wouldn't at all surprise me if this person was just thinking about being trans. And testing the waters here. So much of it doesn't ring true.

Ray Blanchard was of the opinion that any adult man who transitions, gay or straight, was doing it for the sex. Straight men who are AGP, and gay men who are internally homophobic and want to attract straight men (see India Willoughby).

Given there's not a man on social media, entertainment, or in show business of any description who I would say genuinely passes in real life, a lot of the OP's story sounds fake to me.

I also don't think this person is mid 20s. It's such an odd way to say it. You'd say 26. I'm sure a lot of older cross dressing men wish they were in their mid 20s though.

GriseldaandMike · 11/11/2026 07:58

Datun · 11/11/2026 07:56

Personally, it wouldn't at all surprise me if this person was just thinking about being trans. And testing the waters here. So much of it doesn't ring true.

Ray Blanchard was of the opinion that any adult man who transitions, gay or straight, was doing it for the sex. Straight men who are AGP, and gay men who are internally homophobic and want to attract straight men (see India Willoughby).

Given there's not a man on social media, entertainment, or in show business of any description who I would say genuinely passes in real life, a lot of the OP's story sounds fake to me.

I also don't think this person is mid 20s. It's such an odd way to say it. You'd say 26. I'm sure a lot of older cross dressing men wish they were in their mid 20s though.

I don't think the middle aged "girls" aim that high tbh.

TheKeatingFive · 11/11/2026 07:58

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 07:56

Good question. It almost looks like bullying women is the whole entire point, doesn't it?

Quite

Chersfrozenface · 11/11/2026 08:00

I'm sure a lot of older cross dressing men wish they were in their mid 20s though.

Well, India Willoughby (61) says he looks as though he's in his 30s.

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 08:01

Datun · 11/11/2026 07:56

Personally, it wouldn't at all surprise me if this person was just thinking about being trans. And testing the waters here. So much of it doesn't ring true.

Ray Blanchard was of the opinion that any adult man who transitions, gay or straight, was doing it for the sex. Straight men who are AGP, and gay men who are internally homophobic and want to attract straight men (see India Willoughby).

Given there's not a man on social media, entertainment, or in show business of any description who I would say genuinely passes in real life, a lot of the OP's story sounds fake to me.

I also don't think this person is mid 20s. It's such an odd way to say it. You'd say 26. I'm sure a lot of older cross dressing men wish they were in their mid 20s though.

Seems quite young to have had such major surgery.

Datun · 11/11/2026 08:01

Chersfrozenface · 11/11/2026 08:00

I'm sure a lot of older cross dressing men wish they were in their mid 20s though.

Well, India Willoughby (61) says he looks as though he's in his 30s.

It's so weird.

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 08:02

It's very weird that men spend time trying to mock women for being old. Especially when they are considerably older than many of the women they mock.

kitex · 11/11/2026 08:02

There are so many depraved men. Leave women and our single sex spaces alone! I’m so fed up of women being treated so badly by men.

GriseldaandMike · 11/11/2026 08:02

Chersfrozenface · 11/11/2026 08:00

I'm sure a lot of older cross dressing men wish they were in their mid 20s though.

Well, India Willoughby (61) says he looks as though he's in his 30s.

And that's why someone us are disinclined to believe TIMs who claim they pass, the claims from those we have seen with our actual eyes are a bit rich.

Verisregina · 11/11/2026 08:03

I think for me, the biggest issue I have is that @Transperson uses women’s toilets and women’s showers at the swimming pool (but keeps his swimsuit on to ensure he doesn’t upset the women around him) without, he argues their knowledge that he is a man …

Nearly two threads full of women patiently and knowledgeably (on the whole) explaining why men should stay out of single sex spaces and his response (paraphrased) is; I pass, the women whose single sex space I am invading don’t know, so ‘I don’t really care’.

@Lacksie @CoolforKats you are correct that some posters have been provoked into regrettable language (and they have apologized for this), but that does not negate the fact that @Transperson uses women’s single sex spaces by deceit and doesn’t see that this is wrong.

Alisonsy · 11/11/2026 08:04

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 07:02

And yet, no matter how many times you repeat that assertion, your certainty will never confer the knowledge, insight or authority to tell OP who she is, what it means to inhabit her body, or how she experiences herself.

You cannot assert your way into knowledge of another person’s lived reality through the sheer force of your conviction.
It don't work like that.

The op is a man and will always be male as he has male chromosomes.

There is no conviction needed. It’s a simple biological fact.

Datun · 11/11/2026 08:04

And all the sex by deception posting? He had to google it? There's no way it wouldn't have come up during any normal socialising. It would come up in some shape or form on the first date, on any date.

Nah, not buying it.

Datun · 11/11/2026 08:05

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 08:02

It's very weird that men spend time trying to mock women for being old. Especially when they are considerably older than many of the women they mock.

And look it

TheKeatingFive · 11/11/2026 08:05

Verisregina · 11/11/2026 08:03

I think for me, the biggest issue I have is that @Transperson uses women’s toilets and women’s showers at the swimming pool (but keeps his swimsuit on to ensure he doesn’t upset the women around him) without, he argues their knowledge that he is a man …

Nearly two threads full of women patiently and knowledgeably (on the whole) explaining why men should stay out of single sex spaces and his response (paraphrased) is; I pass, the women whose single sex space I am invading don’t know, so ‘I don’t really care’.

@Lacksie @CoolforKats you are correct that some posters have been provoked into regrettable language (and they have apologized for this), but that does not negate the fact that @Transperson uses women’s single sex spaces by deceit and doesn’t see that this is wrong.

I expect Transperson completely understands this is wrong. He just doesn’t care.

nicepotoftea · 11/11/2026 08:05

Verisregina · 11/11/2026 08:03

I think for me, the biggest issue I have is that @Transperson uses women’s toilets and women’s showers at the swimming pool (but keeps his swimsuit on to ensure he doesn’t upset the women around him) without, he argues their knowledge that he is a man …

Nearly two threads full of women patiently and knowledgeably (on the whole) explaining why men should stay out of single sex spaces and his response (paraphrased) is; I pass, the women whose single sex space I am invading don’t know, so ‘I don’t really care’.

@Lacksie @CoolforKats you are correct that some posters have been provoked into regrettable language (and they have apologized for this), but that does not negate the fact that @Transperson uses women’s single sex spaces by deceit and doesn’t see that this is wrong.

This week really isn’t the week to argue that women’s silence is women’s consent.

PeachOctopus · 11/11/2026 08:07

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:43

I am not blind, I would notice if they did.
If people started whispering, were shook, or left suddenly. Even more subtle things if they no one did small talk with me or so on. It's things I would pick up on, I don't bury my head in the sand.

We don’t know you.
We can’t know if you pass as a woman or not. We know that lots of transwomen say they do when they don’t.
What we see is behaviour designed to eliminate single sex spaces. A world without them would be worse for us, more women would be predated on by men in womens refuge centres, prisons and other facilities.
Would you allow all transwomen to use women’s spaces, such as Eddy Izard?
Saying yes to you would make the law meaningless wouldn’t it?

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 08:08

GreyskySexRealistsky · 11/11/2026 07:40

You cannot assert your way into knowledge of another person’s lived reality through the sheer force of your conviction.

Yes! You're getting it!
This is how many women feel.
We do not matter less than him.

No you're not getting it.
We are all the authority on our own individual experience.
None of us in an authority on the experience of someone else.
I can tell you who I am, I can't tell you who you are.

BlueLegume · 11/11/2026 08:09

I am beginning to sense we are entering a new phase of the trans ‘situation’ which has exploded over the past decade. There have been the years we have sort of accepted it as a thing in society as a ‘live and let live’ doesn’t affect me stage. Then the sinister side emerged. We hear that children have been told they might have been born in the wrong body etc. Sam Hall and Helen Webberly doling out medication to kids surgeons carrying out mutilation surgery etc etc.

Collectively we have woken up and gone STOP!. We have ‘been kind’ and it has not worked. Women’s spaces and rights are being eroded to accommodate men. If these men were decent they would live as they want but stay out of women’s spaces.

This is a new phase and as yet I am not sure how it will play out. All I do know is those men and women who have bought into or been indoctrinated to believe in the gender madness probably feel they have to stick to the gender bingo card to save face. Otherwise they will have to admit they were duped. What a decade to reflect on.

As previously said this is not the week to defend the indefensible. We are reflecting on watching Russell Brand warp women’s boundaries 20 years ago in plain sight on TV - he is now in prison. We need to be aware of deception. However nice the trans person you know is they have a illness in their head that needs to be treated.

2021x · 11/11/2026 08:10

I have been thinking about how a transwoman would be able to tell that no one thinks that they are a woman.

I came up with what happens if a little girl needs to go to the toilet. Most people would be fine with a woman taking her, but they probably wouldn't ask a transwoman to take her.

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 08:10

ArabellaScott · 11/11/2026 07:34

This post suggests sex by deception is a legal argument.

Again - what is the moral position?

If you deliberately deceive someone as to your sex, this is rape.

I've long been astonished that some (not many, I'd like to add) trans activists are so keen to argue to the effect that if someone gets away with it, its not rape.

The vast majority of people care what sex their sexual partner is. This forms an important part of many people's identity. To suggest otherwise is, I would say, a form of forcible 'conversion'. It seems in the same class to me as corrective rape.

Question - what about women with CAIS? Are they required to disclose their medical history before every sexual encounter or be prosecuted for rape?

Seymour5 · 11/11/2026 08:12

I’m a volunteer. A couple of weeks ago, there was a new person in the staffroom when I arrived. Tall, long haired, slim and broad shouldered, deep voice, dressed in a man’s shirt and jeans. There was no way anyone would assume ‘woman’. But he uses a very feminine name, which is difficult to equate with his persona. I wonder what has prompted him to choose to be known by a female name, when it is such a mismatch to how he looks and sounds? Perhaps this is just the start for him.

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 08:13

Verisregina · 11/11/2026 08:03

I think for me, the biggest issue I have is that @Transperson uses women’s toilets and women’s showers at the swimming pool (but keeps his swimsuit on to ensure he doesn’t upset the women around him) without, he argues their knowledge that he is a man …

Nearly two threads full of women patiently and knowledgeably (on the whole) explaining why men should stay out of single sex spaces and his response (paraphrased) is; I pass, the women whose single sex space I am invading don’t know, so ‘I don’t really care’.

@Lacksie @CoolforKats you are correct that some posters have been provoked into regrettable language (and they have apologized for this), but that does not negate the fact that @Transperson uses women’s single sex spaces by deceit and doesn’t see that this is wrong.

you are correct that some posters have been provoked into regrettable language

Ooo lovely display of minimisation and victim blaming there.

GriseldaandMike · 11/11/2026 08:13

Lacksie · 11/11/2026 08:08

No you're not getting it.
We are all the authority on our own individual experience.
None of us in an authority on the experience of someone else.
I can tell you who I am, I can't tell you who you are.

The medieval French king who thought he was a window was he right? After all we are all experts on ourselves? The people who claim to be Napoleon are they all correct, they are all the same person? The white woman who 'feels' black is she right? The adults who say they are children should they be welcomed into junior schools up and down the land.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread