Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trying to understand why there is dislike towards trans people - discussion 2

1000 replies

Transperson · 10/11/2026 16:53

Cont

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
Transperson · 10/11/2026 20:02

Catiette · 10/11/2026 19:57

Wow.

I don't usually come in so strongly on threads like this, but... seriously? Seriously i?!?

"I don't consent to your lack of consent,"...

...said Russell Brand once at the Comedy Club.

Well, that's that, then.

QED, case closed, the jury was wrong, we can all go home.

Even as a play on words (especially as a play on words?), that's a supremely disturbing phrase to read. Regardless of context and what one may / may not think about trans rights.

Another thought...

One thing trans rights activists appear to love to cling to is the tenuous absolute. I've not seen much of the thread, but glimpsed some early on - "No one's complained," - and we have more now - "Assault is 'being dismissed as irrelevant'".

There's at best a superficial understanding and at worst a cynical avoidance of nuance here. Either way, it reveals the weakness of the arguments being made.

I'd have SO much more respect for and interest in a visitor who posted not "No one's complained," but instead something like, "I'm not aware of anyone having had concerns. I'm conscious, however - of course! - that women have their own interior reality and may not have voiced how they feel due to fear or even just politeness. Nevertheless, I still feel my argument for access to their spaces holds, because..."

Or how about, instead of the pathetically absurd "Assault is 'being dismissed as irrelevant'" (yeah, totally, no one on this feminist forum gives a shit about assault... er... ahem... very gently, do you think, perhaps, just maybe, you may have missed a very little of the rhetorical nuance in use here? 🤦‍♀️) I'd be quite excited (as it's so unusual!) to see an honest and intelligent, "Well, I can see your point in using such uncomfortably direct terms to argue that the presence is, itself, a form of assault, and thereby also inferring the associated physical risks inherent in opening female spaces to males; however, I do find the phrasing somewhat distasteful because... and in any case refute that argument, as..." etc.

Honestly, sometimes you just want to take over and help out...

Edited

Context here is about me going to pee. They don't consent to me peeing in public toilets.

"I'm not aware of anyone having had concerns. I'm conscious, however - of course! - that women have their own interior reality and may not have voiced how they feel due to fear or even just politeness. "

I have literally said most of this? That if I became aware that it made someone uncomfortable and they could tell, I would have to have a think.

OP posts:
Lacksie · 10/11/2026 20:02

TheHereticalOne · 10/11/2026 19:59

I applaud your patience.

@Lacksie are you actually ignorant of this most basic of facts? What do you think the difference is between a) safeguarding and b) punishing a crime that has been committed?

Recognising the distinction between someone’s mere presence and an actual assault does not mean waiting until an assault occurs before taking preventive action.

My objection was to the claim that this distinction is irrelevant. By treating the difference between someone who has violated another person’s consent and bodily autonomy and someone who has not as inconsequential, you are fundamentally devaluing the very concepts you claim to be safeguarding.

That you apparently cannot see why a survivor of sexual violence might find this profoundly disturbing, and to dismiss it as "ignorance of facts", is extraordinary.

ArabellaScott · 10/11/2026 20:03

MrsTerryPratchett · 10/11/2026 20:00

This is tiresome. It's simply not true. Unless every bone in your body was reaaranged, every scent producing gland. Every muscle messed with. It's not true.

I have a friend who was in a cubicle, froze because she know a man was in the sink area. He didn't speak, she didn't see him, and she never 'batted an eyelid' as far as he was concened. But she knew.

We aren't just concerned when we're currently being attacked. Your goodwill isn't tattooed on your forehead. Every man is Schrodingers rapist. And women have to act accordingly. Including well natured small talk in a loo.

Fawn, freeze, fight or flight.

kitex · 10/11/2026 20:03

It my first time having a post removed. The truth will do that!

callmeLoretta1 · 10/11/2026 20:03

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 19:24

As a survivor of CSA/ rape I find this incredibly disturbing that this level of transphobia is being passed off as "feminism".

that you are so blinded by your dislike of trans people that you are prepared to declare assault itself to be "irrelevant"??

Edited

How many times do we have to say, it's not about 'trans' people, it's about MALES. M.A.L.E.S. You don't get to take 1% of males, put them in a dress, and rebadge them as 'trans', then ask us to take these males at their word.

They are male! And we don't want males in female spaces. No one who is a victim of rape or CSA does.

Catiette · 10/11/2026 20:04

ArabellaScott · 10/11/2026 20:00

You are a man just like any other.

Saying things like if I go to the women's then cis men would too. Do you think I bring them along?

Oh, boy. Can I step in here and help out? Please?

I realise that it would be comically foolish to say No one described how I, as an individual actually causes harm. You don't know me, after all! Saying things like if I go to the women's then cis men would too. Do you think I bring them along? is, however, a fair point, in that you're perceiving me and others as collectively degrading an important social contract. However, my counter-argument would be...

There you go.

The question is, of course, how to end the sentence above. I'd love to hear what goes there.

Keepingthingsinteresting · 10/11/2026 20:04

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:00

Being trans is already breaking a social contract, as not limiting myself to a box that was arbitrary put on me in terms of how I meant meant to present myself in society.

Breaking social constructs is kinda of the idea, so we can be more free as individual to be ourselves.

So you admit it’s all about you, and you don’t care about the impact your behaviour has on others? Can you not see how selfish that is and why women would not trust someone who behaves in such a way in their spaces?

ArabellaScott · 10/11/2026 20:04

Transperson · 10/11/2026 20:02

Context here is about me going to pee. They don't consent to me peeing in public toilets.

"I'm not aware of anyone having had concerns. I'm conscious, however - of course! - that women have their own interior reality and may not have voiced how they feel due to fear or even just politeness. "

I have literally said most of this? That if I became aware that it made someone uncomfortable and they could tell, I would have to have a think.

It does. We are telling you, here and now. Because we couldn't and wouldn't in real life. Because you are male.

callmeLoretta1 · 10/11/2026 20:05

Feminists foresaw this back in the 1970s.

Trying to understand why there is dislike towards trans people - discussion 2
Transperson · 10/11/2026 20:05

Keepingthingsinteresting · 10/11/2026 20:04

So you admit it’s all about you, and you don’t care about the impact your behaviour has on others? Can you not see how selfish that is and why women would not trust someone who behaves in such a way in their spaces?

What? Where did I say that?

I said that im not aware of any impact.

OP posts:
Catiette · 10/11/2026 20:05

Transperson · 10/11/2026 20:02

Context here is about me going to pee. They don't consent to me peeing in public toilets.

"I'm not aware of anyone having had concerns. I'm conscious, however - of course! - that women have their own interior reality and may not have voiced how they feel due to fear or even just politeness. "

I have literally said most of this? That if I became aware that it made someone uncomfortable and they could tell, I would have to have a think.

If I became aware.

AKA, their interior reality has validity only if I perceive it through mine.

The unconscious irony demonstrated in your response to my post is painful.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 20:06

He’s just going to sit here saying “but I’m a woman” like Upton’s “biological sex is just a nebulous dog whistle”. Zero credibility and zero respect for women and girls. It’s not possible to argue against this level of fatuous disingenuousness. If you engage, keep that front of mind. Also compare it to the faux naive tone of the OP last night.

Catiette · 10/11/2026 20:06

Transperson · 10/11/2026 20:02

Context here is about me going to pee. They don't consent to me peeing in public toilets.

"I'm not aware of anyone having had concerns. I'm conscious, however - of course! - that women have their own interior reality and may not have voiced how they feel due to fear or even just politeness. "

I have literally said most of this? That if I became aware that it made someone uncomfortable and they could tell, I would have to have a think.

I'm not sure of the relevance of the context to my comment. Seeing it as relevant would appear to support my perspective.

So far, your arguments against my points seem to be... arguments for them...?

Transperson · 10/11/2026 20:07

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 20:06

He’s just going to sit here saying “but I’m a woman” like Upton’s “biological sex is just a nebulous dog whistle”. Zero credibility and zero respect for women and girls. It’s not possible to argue against this level of fatuous disingenuousness. If you engage, keep that front of mind. Also compare it to the faux naive tone of the OP last night.

I mean people just piled on it, there were few good replies that I enjoyed and wish I could have focused on.

OP posts:
Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 20:07

callmeLoretta1 · 10/11/2026 20:05

Feminists foresaw this back in the 1970s.

Wow. Not seen that quote before. Germaine Greer was ahead of it all.

FiveEightNine · 10/11/2026 20:08

Transperson · 10/11/2026 19:58

I mean I had a disclaimer under it, it was an example to show how absurd the logic used by the poster is.

And what was suppposed to be absurd about profoundly female people not consenting to your presence which you base on your very specific definition of sex?

Not that definition of sex for the purpose of this kind of rules should be up to debate, but...

lifeturnsonadime · 10/11/2026 20:09

Transperson · 10/11/2026 20:07

I mean people just piled on it, there were few good replies that I enjoyed and wish I could have focused on.

Pile on = women telling you the truth.

a) that you are a man, and

b) that you have no right to enter single sex spaces reserved for women.

Yawn.

RubyTrees · 10/11/2026 20:09

Transperson · 10/11/2026 20:02

Context here is about me going to pee. They don't consent to me peeing in public toilets.

"I'm not aware of anyone having had concerns. I'm conscious, however - of course! - that women have their own interior reality and may not have voiced how they feel due to fear or even just politeness. "

I have literally said most of this? That if I became aware that it made someone uncomfortable and they could tell, I would have to have a think.

That if I became aware that it made someone uncomfortable and they could tell, I would have to have a think.

You don't have to go to the trouble of "having a think" OP. Just stay out of female-only spaces.

TheHereticalOne · 10/11/2026 20:10

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 20:02

Recognising the distinction between someone’s mere presence and an actual assault does not mean waiting until an assault occurs before taking preventive action.

My objection was to the claim that this distinction is irrelevant. By treating the difference between someone who has violated another person’s consent and bodily autonomy and someone who has not as inconsequential, you are fundamentally devaluing the very concepts you claim to be safeguarding.

That you apparently cannot see why a survivor of sexual violence might find this profoundly disturbing, and to dismiss it as "ignorance of facts", is extraordinary.

Edited

"Recognising the distinction between someone’s mere presence and an actual assault does not mean waiting until an assault occurs before taking preventive action."

The preventative action is preventing the man's "mere presence". What would you suggest as the alternative safeguarding step that would not rely on waiting for an assault (which, incidentally does not requiring touching of any kind in criminal law) to take place?

ArabellaScott · 10/11/2026 20:12

I do feel sorry for reasonable trans identifying people. Just trying to get on with life, while some sections of the 'community' feel the need to deliberately taunt and upset women.

It does the movement overall no favours at all.

CohensDiamondTeeth · 10/11/2026 20:13

Transperson · 10/11/2026 19:58

I mean I had a disclaimer under it, it was an example to show how absurd the logic used by the poster is.

I can read.

That poster's logic was not absurd at all.

Yet you still used the phrase "I don't consent to your lack of consent"
Here on MN FWR, you a male person, to us a majority female group.

Interesting that was the sentence that presented itself, and passed your inner bar for "passes for acceptable", for you to fire at the women here, but then it's clear your bar for what passes as acceptable is very different to mine.

Supposedly ironic statements about women's consent being of no importance to you, a man, are definitely not acceptable as far as I'm concerned. It comes across as really rape-y.

Do you tell women unprompted that you're a Nice Guy too?

Catiette · 10/11/2026 20:14

While acknolwedging I've not read all of your posts, I am actually sympathetic to your situation, TP.

But your response to this, even from what little I've read here, so often does feel like an argument for "our side".

Between the rude, the ridiculous and the superficially reflective visitors we see visiting here, posts arguing for transwomen's inclusion in female spaces probably have done somewhat more to persuade me against this than "TERFs'" counter-arguments.

This is one of the many tragedies of the form of activism and argument your cause appears to favour. I really mean that - it's upsetting to see, as people are being hurt by it on both sides.

NannyOggsFavouriteJug · 10/11/2026 20:15

Trying to understand why there is dislike towards trans people

I wonder if the OP has managed to reach enlightenment on this yet? I think they’ve illustrated it beautifully.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 20:15

Catiette · 10/11/2026 20:14

While acknolwedging I've not read all of your posts, I am actually sympathetic to your situation, TP.

But your response to this, even from what little I've read here, so often does feel like an argument for "our side".

Between the rude, the ridiculous and the superficially reflective visitors we see visiting here, posts arguing for transwomen's inclusion in female spaces probably have done somewhat more to persuade me against this than "TERFs'" counter-arguments.

This is one of the many tragedies of the form of activism and argument your cause appears to favour. I really mean that - it's upsetting to see, as people are being hurt by it on both sides.

I suggest reading all his posts, and you might lose some of that sympathy.

Transperson · 10/11/2026 20:16

Catiette · 10/11/2026 20:06

I'm not sure of the relevance of the context to my comment. Seeing it as relevant would appear to support my perspective.

So far, your arguments against my points seem to be... arguments for them...?

Yeah I don't specifically disagree with what I directly quoted, just aware of how the sentence looks out of context.

I'm always trying my best to not cause distress and alarm and I wouldn't want to cause that to anyone. I'm trying my best to be receptive and aware day to day.

I don't see, hear, or can logically see that I'm currently causing harm, if that changes, that's important to me.

OP posts:
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread