Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trying to understand why there is dislike towards trans people - discussion 2

1000 replies

Transperson · 10/11/2026 16:53

Cont

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
Transperson · 10/11/2026 19:50

lifeturnsonadime · 10/11/2026 19:46

I'm a woman who was brought up to believe that I'm not constrained by gender roles.

It is my sex that binds me.

You have no idea because you are male.

Have you missed my quotes around role?
Obviously gender roles are BS but most of society still enforces them.

Again, phenotypic sex isn't something I invented, I could use the same argument for myself (that my female sex binds me) but it's restrictive so I'd rather not for myself.

OP posts:
titchy · 10/11/2026 19:51

Transperson · 10/11/2026 19:12

I'm not hurting anyone, not causing distress or alarm, and phenotypically it makes the most sense. (Also safest)

It’s not our fucking job to keep you safe. OK - NOT OUR JOB TO KEEP YOU OR ANY OTHER VULNERABLE PERSON SAFE.

And I can absolutely guarantee that 99% of women can spot that you are male. Men aren’t so good at it, but there’s a little bit of the female brain (that you won’t have) that can detect a male. You may think their lack of response and lack of rumour means no-one knows - they do. They absolutely do. Women are extremely good at pretending. Millions of years of evolution has ensured it.

YOU DO NOT PASS.

Would it make any difference to you though, if you overheard Barbara from accounts saying to Sarah that she always avoids the loo when you’re there because she feels awkward knowing you’re male? Somehow I think we all know the answer to that one!

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 19:51

Transperson · 10/11/2026 19:50

Have you missed my quotes around role?
Obviously gender roles are BS but most of society still enforces them.

Again, phenotypic sex isn't something I invented, I could use the same argument for myself (that my female sex binds me) but it's restrictive so I'd rather not for myself.

You don’t have the female sex, but nice try.

RareGoalsVerge · 10/11/2026 19:51

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 19:33

Actually- That would be the posters declaring it doesn't matter whether women are actually being assaulted or not!!

Again, nobody asks for the personal consent of other service users before using a public facility.

Consent is important if you are going to touch someone however!!! But apparently that's irrelevant in this dystopian new variety of "feminism"

the "it doesn't matter" is insofar as "but I did't touch you" is no excuse. Obviously an actually physical assault is even more serious, but the physical presence of a male person, even if they have a feminine gender identity, even if they are wearing a really cunning disguise, even if they have had surgery and hormones, is still a violation of consent even if their only action is go go into a cubicle, do a wee, wash hands and leave. They have imposed themselves into a physical space, being male, because they believe themselves to be more important than the women's lack of consent. That is misogyny and patriarchy.

The consent in a public facility is on the doors - where it says this is a space for women. If a woman goes in there and takes her undies off she is doing so consenting to do so in the presence of other female people. Male people going in there are there without consent.

CohensDiamondTeeth · 10/11/2026 19:53

Transperson · 10/11/2026 19:29

If that wasn't clear I was being ironic. You don't get a vote on my bodily autonomy, and I don't get one on yours.

Oops I accidentally told on myself... again! Back peddle! Back Peddle!

"I was being ironic"

It's just banter! Where's your sense of humour? Women don't get to say no to me, a man, because I don't consent to their lack of consent... what? It was just a joke! I was being IrOnIc!

nicepotoftea · 10/11/2026 19:53

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 19:44

Why? Because I profoundly reject your version of “safeguarding”, in which whether women and children are actually assaulted is apparently irrelevant and inconsequential. A conception of safeguarding that fails to distinguish between someone merely being present in a space and someone actively harming another person?

It's the only version of safeguarding.

You have blanket rules that cover everyone, so e.g. schools limit who can enter the building and how much contact they can have with children, even if they are a parent of one of the children, and facilities sometimes exclude all men.

The goal is to prevent the assault or abuse before it happens.

lifeturnsonadime · 10/11/2026 19:53

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 19:50

I’m very sorry that you share this experience.

But surely you can understand that it is profoundly disturbing to suggest that the opportunity to commit an assault is equivalent to actually committing one, and that the distinctionbetween someone merely being present and someone violating another person’s consent and bodily autonomy is "irrelevant " ??

My concern is not with centring men. It is with centring/ understanding actual harm, consent and bodily autonomy

Edited

Only I'm not suggesting that.

I am saying that all men should kept out of spaces where women are vulnerable because some men are a risk.

Decent men (even those who identify as women) KNOW this.

It's fundamental to safeguarding women that there are no exceptions. You are arguing for the exception which I find profoundly disturbing.

kitex · 10/11/2026 19:54

@Transperson “(that my female sex binds me)”

You made a mistake there. You meant MALE!

RareGoalsVerge · 10/11/2026 19:55

CohensDiamondTeeth · 10/11/2026 19:46

There are words which society uses to describe men who "don't consent to women's lack of consent".

Well done! Operation Let Them Speak strikes again.

Yes this. @Transperson does not consent to women having the right to say no. That is misogyny and patriarchy due to the male socialisation which says "I am more important than this person's objection"

nicepotoftea · 10/11/2026 19:55

Transperson · 10/11/2026 19:50

Have you missed my quotes around role?
Obviously gender roles are BS but most of society still enforces them.

Again, phenotypic sex isn't something I invented, I could use the same argument for myself (that my female sex binds me) but it's restrictive so I'd rather not for myself.

You aren't phenotypically female unless you have a very rare DSD.

You are a male who has had plastic surgery and taken medication, but none of this can create a female body.

ArabellaScott · 10/11/2026 19:55

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:00

Being trans is already breaking a social contract, as not limiting myself to a box that was arbitrary put on me in terms of how I meant meant to present myself in society.

Breaking social constructs is kinda of the idea, so we can be more free as individual to be ourselves.

Yes, you can be more free. By taking the freedoms of others. Its an entirely self centered movement.

Pingponghavoc · 10/11/2026 19:56

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 19:44

Why? Because I profoundly reject your version of “safeguarding”, in which whether women and children are actually assaulted is apparently irrelevant and inconsequential. A conception of safeguarding that fails to distinguish between someone merely being present in a space and someone actively harming another person?

There you go, scarequoting again.

Safeguarding is about trying to reduce risks. Safeguarding has failed once a person is attack.

We justify and design single sex spaces, in part to avoid women and girls being assaulted, by men, when they are vulnerable.

Allowing men to use the space negates that. Its gives men access to women and girls when they are vulnerable.

We dont know which men will abuse women and girls, so we dont let any of them use the space.

Its not as difficult as you seem to think it is.

NimbleTaupeTiger · 10/11/2026 19:56

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

lifeturnsonadime · 10/11/2026 19:56

Transperson · 10/11/2026 19:50

Have you missed my quotes around role?
Obviously gender roles are BS but most of society still enforces them.

Again, phenotypic sex isn't something I invented, I could use the same argument for myself (that my female sex binds me) but it's restrictive so I'd rather not for myself.

Nothing about you is of the female sex.

If you are taking HRT it doesn't make you female.

If you have had surgery to augment your breasts that doesn't make you female.

If you've had your penis removed you are not female,

Believing you are female does not make you female.

You are living your life by your impression of gender roles.

It's like going back in time.

Women must submit to the wishes of males even if it harms us.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 19:56

We really are going to have to get it written into law eventually that men who deliberately use women’s spaces are committing the criminal offence of voyeurism/indecent exposure/sexual harassment. I previously thought we could rely on men including “trans women” to be decent and respect women. Hilarious I know.

Catiette · 10/11/2026 19:57

Transperson · 10/11/2026 19:21

I don't consent to your lack of consent.

(An example of how your logic doesn't really work)

Wow.

I don't usually come in so strongly on threads like this, but... seriously? Seriously i?!?

"I don't consent to your lack of consent,"...

...said Russell Brand once at the Comedy Club.

Well, that's that, then.

QED, case closed, the jury was wrong, we can all go home.

Even as a play on words (especially as a play on words?), that's a supremely disturbing phrase to read. Regardless of context and what one may / may not think about trans rights.

Another thought...

One thing trans rights activists appear to love to cling to is the tenuous absolute. I've not seen much of the thread, but glimpsed some early on - "No one's complained," - and we have more now - "Assault is 'being dismissed as irrelevant'".

There's at best a superficial understanding and at worst a cynical avoidance of nuance here. Either way, it reveals the weakness of the arguments being made.

I'd have SO much more respect for and interest in a visitor who posted not "No one's complained," but instead something like, "I'm not aware of anyone having had concerns. I'm conscious, however - of course! - that women have their own interior reality and may not have voiced how they feel due to fear or even just politeness. Nevertheless, I still feel my argument for access to their spaces holds, because..."

Or how about, instead of the pathetically absurd "Assault is 'being dismissed as irrelevant'" (yeah, totally, no one on this feminist forum gives a shit about assault... er... ahem... very gently, do you think, perhaps, just maybe, you may have missed a very little of the rhetorical nuance in use here? 🤦‍♀️) I'd be quite excited (as it's so unusual!) to see an honest and intelligent, "Well, I can see your point in using such uncomfortably direct terms to argue that the presence is, itself, a form of assault, and thereby also inferring the associated physical risks inherent in opening female spaces to males; however, I do find the phrasing somewhat distasteful because... and in any case refute that argument, as..." etc.

Honestly, sometimes you just want to take over and help out...

Transperson · 10/11/2026 19:58

CohensDiamondTeeth · 10/11/2026 19:53

Oops I accidentally told on myself... again! Back peddle! Back Peddle!

"I was being ironic"

It's just banter! Where's your sense of humour? Women don't get to say no to me, a man, because I don't consent to their lack of consent... what? It was just a joke! I was being IrOnIc!

I mean I had a disclaimer under it, it was an example to show how absurd the logic used by the poster is.

OP posts:
nicepotoftea · 10/11/2026 19:58

ArabellaScott · 10/11/2026 19:55

Yes, you can be more free. By taking the freedoms of others. Its an entirely self centered movement.

Women managed to break out of the box by wearing trousers and going to university.

It's not clear why men breaking out of the box seems to depend on using women's toilets.

TheHereticalOne · 10/11/2026 19:59

nicepotoftea · 10/11/2026 19:53

It's the only version of safeguarding.

You have blanket rules that cover everyone, so e.g. schools limit who can enter the building and how much contact they can have with children, even if they are a parent of one of the children, and facilities sometimes exclude all men.

The goal is to prevent the assault or abuse before it happens.

I applaud your patience.

@Lacksie are you actually ignorant of this most basic of facts? What do you think the difference is between a) safeguarding and b) punishing a crime that has been committed?

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 19:59

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 19:56

We really are going to have to get it written into law eventually that men who deliberately use women’s spaces are committing the criminal offence of voyeurism/indecent exposure/sexual harassment. I previously thought we could rely on men including “trans women” to be decent and respect women. Hilarious I know.

But for now I’ll settle for pressuring service providers and workplaces to make it clear to men that they aren’t welcome in women’s spaces, and to tell them to fuck off out of them if they use them.

ArabellaScott · 10/11/2026 20:00

Transperson · 10/11/2026 18:07

I fight will continue to fight against misogyny.

No one described how I, as an individual actually causes harm. Saying things like if I go to the women's then cis men would too. Do you think I bring them along?

And no you can't tell, stop trying to tell me about my own lived experience, it's annoying.

You are a man just like any other.

GoddammitDonut · 10/11/2026 20:00

You’ve never once in your life been abused or harassed or dismissed because of being female. Because you’re not.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 20:00

Catiette · 10/11/2026 19:57

Wow.

I don't usually come in so strongly on threads like this, but... seriously? Seriously i?!?

"I don't consent to your lack of consent,"...

...said Russell Brand once at the Comedy Club.

Well, that's that, then.

QED, case closed, the jury was wrong, we can all go home.

Even as a play on words (especially as a play on words?), that's a supremely disturbing phrase to read. Regardless of context and what one may / may not think about trans rights.

Another thought...

One thing trans rights activists appear to love to cling to is the tenuous absolute. I've not seen much of the thread, but glimpsed some early on - "No one's complained," - and we have more now - "Assault is 'being dismissed as irrelevant'".

There's at best a superficial understanding and at worst a cynical avoidance of nuance here. Either way, it reveals the weakness of the arguments being made.

I'd have SO much more respect for and interest in a visitor who posted not "No one's complained," but instead something like, "I'm not aware of anyone having had concerns. I'm conscious, however - of course! - that women have their own interior reality and may not have voiced how they feel due to fear or even just politeness. Nevertheless, I still feel my argument for access to their spaces holds, because..."

Or how about, instead of the pathetically absurd "Assault is 'being dismissed as irrelevant'" (yeah, totally, no one on this feminist forum gives a shit about assault... er... ahem... very gently, do you think, perhaps, just maybe, you may have missed a very little of the rhetorical nuance in use here? 🤦‍♀️) I'd be quite excited (as it's so unusual!) to see an honest and intelligent, "Well, I can see your point in using such uncomfortably direct terms to argue that the presence is, itself, a form of assault, and thereby also inferring the associated physical risks inherent in opening female spaces to males; however, I do find the phrasing somewhat distasteful because... and in any case refute that argument, as..." etc.

Honestly, sometimes you just want to take over and help out...

Edited

I was going to make that comparison too. Very stark.

MrsTerryPratchett · 10/11/2026 20:00

Transperson · 10/11/2026 18:15

As I said I am phenotypically female, so I'd argue I am going to a space for a category that I'm part of.

Biological sex isn't defined anywhere, sex is divided to phenotypic, gonadal, and genotypic sex.

This is tiresome. It's simply not true. Unless every bone in your body was reaaranged, every scent producing gland. Every muscle messed with. It's not true.

I have a friend who was in a cubicle, froze because she know a man was in the sink area. He didn't speak, she didn't see him, and she never 'batted an eyelid' as far as he was concened. But she knew.

We aren't just concerned when we're currently being attacked. Your goodwill isn't tattooed on your forehead. Every man is Schrodingers rapist. And women have to act accordingly. Including well natured small talk in a loo.

kitex · 10/11/2026 20:01

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread