Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trying to understand why there is dislike towards trans people - discussion 2

1000 replies

Transperson · 10/11/2026 16:53

Cont

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
GreyskySexRealistsky · 10/11/2026 16:56

Transperson · 10/11/2026 16:53

Cont

Careful now

Shortshriftandlethal · 10/11/2026 16:57

If you are male then you should not be using facilities set aside for female people - and ignoring that boundary and wilfully transgressing it - is breaking the social contract. And it is to totally ignore the fact that we have such spaces for the privacy and dignity of female people who are preoccupied with their biological function or in a state of undress, or other condition of vulnerability.

If a male person cannot or will not accept any limitation on their personal desire in the face of the word 'No' that such boundaries represent - then they can be held publicly accountable for these violations.

callmeLoretta1 · 10/11/2026 16:59

Why bother, @Transperson , you are not going to answer any questions, you are not going to consider that you are harming women, you are not here in good faith. You've proved that last one already.

murasaki · 10/11/2026 16:59

I'm surprised 1000 posts wasn't enough to give you an answer to your goady question.

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 10/11/2026 16:59

Your own posts on the previous thread answered your question @Transperson . There is no need for a second thread.

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:00

Shortshriftandlethal · 10/11/2026 16:57

If you are male then you should not be using facilities set aside for female people - and ignoring that boundary and wilfully transgressing it - is breaking the social contract. And it is to totally ignore the fact that we have such spaces for the privacy and dignity of female people who are preoccupied with their biological function or in a state of undress, or other condition of vulnerability.

If a male person cannot or will not accept any limitation on their personal desire in the face of the word 'No' that such boundaries represent - then they can be held publicly accountable for these violations.

Edited

Being trans is already breaking a social contract, as not limiting myself to a box that was arbitrary put on me in terms of how I meant meant to present myself in society.

Breaking social constructs is kinda of the idea, so we can be more free as individual to be ourselves.

OP posts:
SingleSexSpacesInSchools · 10/11/2026 17:01

@Transperson
I’m a man and the father of a daughter. I’m not speaking on behalf of all women, but I have a responsibility to look out for my daughter and take women’s concerns about privacy, dignity and safety seriously.

OP, your respectful tone is appreciated, as is your agreement about words such as mother and breastfeeding. But listening also means accepting that women’s answer may be no.

You ask why people dislike trans people.
I do not dislike people for being trans. I object when women’s boundaries are crossed and their objections are treated as hostility. Live and let live includes respecting women’s privacy, dignity and female-only intimate spaces. These are legitimate interests, not evidence of hatred.

You say nobody has noticed or objected.
You cannot know that. Women may remain silent because they are frightened, embarrassed or unwilling to risk confrontation—particularly while undressed. The power imbalance matters. A woman may hurry, leave or avoid returning rather than challenge you. No confrontation does not mean no objection. Assuming otherwise overlooks precisely the vulnerability women are explaining.

You say you behave respectfully and wear a swimsuit.
The boundary concerns your presence as a male in a female-only intimate space, not your clothes or intentions. Covering yourself does not protect another woman’s privacy while she changes. She does not have to prove you dangerous before her privacy matters. Respecting a boundary includes accepting that it applies to you.

You argue that medical transition changes your phenotype.
Medical treatment can change sex characteristics; it does not change reproductive sex. Appearance cannot provide a consistent basis for female-only provision. The Supreme Court confirmed that “sex”, “woman” and “man” in the Equality Act refer to biological sex, while trans people retain protection against gender-reassignment discrimination. Protecting one group does not erase the other’s protections. Supreme Court summary

You use small Scottish prisoner numbers to dismiss offending concerns.
Dividing trans prisoners by Scotland’s entire population does not calculate the imprisonment rate among trans people. A small population percentage is not a confidence interval, either.
The recent England and Wales figures deserve attention. On 31 March 2024, 151 of 245 recorded transgender prisoners whose legal sex was male had sexual-offence convictions: 61.6%. That category included people identifying as women, non-binary or gender-fluid. Ministerial answer
The corresponding sentenced-male prison table recorded 14,138 sexual-offence prisoners out of 68,204: 20.7%.61.6 ÷ 20.7 ≈ 3. That is the arithmetic behind the “three times” comparison. These differently defined prisoner groups cannot establish offending rates in the wider population, but the figures warrant serious scrutiny of prison safeguarding. MoJ table 1.Q.5

You argue that individual offenders should not determine access rules.
Safeguarding considers foreseeable risks, vulnerability and opportunity before harm occurs. Sex is relevant: men accounted for 97% of sentences for sexual offences in England and Wales in the year ending June 2024. Women cannot reliably assess each stranger’s intentions while undressed, and should not have to. Ministry of Justice
Failures have real victims: Karen White sexually assaulted female prisoners. Isla Bryson was convicted of two rapes committed before transition.
Where female-only provision meets the Equality Act’s conditions and is proportionate, it can exclude all male service users, including trans women, without proving each individual dangerous. Personal assurances of good behaviour do not override a justified sex-based boundary. EHRC guidance

You cite research as settling the safety question.
The Massachusetts study found no detectable increase in police-recorded incidents following inclusive access policies. That finding should be acknowledged. But incidents were rare, some locality data were incomplete, and the records could not distinguish trans from non-trans perpetrators. It did not measure women remaining silent, avoiding facilities or losing ordinary bodily privacy. Those limitations restrict what it answers; they do not reverse its finding. Original study
A Swedish cohort covering 1973–2003 found criminal-conviction rates among male-to-female participants higher than female controls and not statistically different from male controls. That historical finding cannot establish present-day UK risk either. Neither paper settles whether women should have female-only intimate provision.Original Swedish study

You describe trans people’s vulnerability and your own experiences of harassment.
Those experiences deserve sympathy and practical protection. Harassment should be addressed. It does not establish entitlement to female-only facilities or require women to surrender their privacy, security and dignity. Additional private and unisex provision can address competing needs. Women should not automatically bear the cost of resolving somebody else’s vulnerability.

You say you want to understand women.
Then what happens when women explain their boundary and their answer remains no? Do you respect it, or continue regardless?
Entering a female-only intimate space leaves objecting women to tolerate it, confront you or leave. That puts the burden on women. Taking access and then expecting women to justify their objections gives your wishes priority over theirs.

Treating women as equals means giving women’s privacy and autonomy real weight—including when that limits what you want. Are you listening to the boundaries women are explaining, or only for an answer that permits you to cross them?

Live and let live must work both ways. Women’s boundaries do not become hatred because somebody dislikes being bound by them.

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/66784f50a7a18c1aa1a00efe/Prison-population-31-Mar-2024.ods

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:01

callmeLoretta1 · 10/11/2026 16:59

Why bother, @Transperson , you are not going to answer any questions, you are not going to consider that you are harming women, you are not here in good faith. You've proved that last one already.

I am! Ask away.

OP posts:
MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 10/11/2026 17:02

If you chose not to take on board what was said on 40 pages of one thread then you're hardly going to take on board what's said on 40 pages of a second one.

SingleSexSpacesInSchools · 10/11/2026 17:02

@lacksie I’m responding as a man and a father, not claiming to speak for all women. I agree that trans people deserve safety, dignity and respectful treatment. What your replies have not answered is how that resolves the disagreement about female-only provision.
Taking your arguments individually:

You say reasonable, humane discussion is impossible here.
Some comments are insulting, and I do not defend them. But that does not invalidate the reasoned arguments about privacy, safeguarding and sex-based boundaries. Criticising particular comments is legitimate. Treating those comments as an answer to every woman explaining why she needs female-only provision is not. An objection to somebody’s tone does not answer their substantive argument.

You dismiss these views as belonging to a small minority of women.
A forum cannot establish what all women think. Neither can your impression of it. In YouGov’s December 2024 survey, 55% of female respondents opposed allowing trans women into women’s changing rooms; 26% supported it. That does not settle policy by popularity, but it contradicts the suggestion that opposition is confined to a marginal few. Even a minority would still deserve its concerns to be addressed. YouGov results, page 13

You argue that respecting trans people requires accepting their understanding of themselves.
A person’s experience can be sincere and important without determining everybody else’s obligations. Recognising someone’s identity does not automatically establish eligibility for every sex-specific service. The Supreme Court expressly recognised biological sex under the Equality Act while preserving protection against gender-reassignment discrimination. Sex-based protections and protection for trans people can coexist. Supreme Court summary

You say the biological definition of sex closes the discussion through circular reasoning.
Simply repeating a definition would indeed be insufficient. But the argument is about why sex matters in particular circumstances: bodily privacy, intimate care, safeguarding and sporting fairness. Those reasons need answering. The law permits single-sex services where the statutory conditions and proportionality test are met, including to protect privacy, dignity and safety. Calling the definition restrictive does not explain why those protections should instead depend on identity. EHRC guidance

You say trans people’s experiences should be understood without taking priority over anyone else’s.
Then explain what that means when interests conflict. Which female-only services do you accept, and on what basis? If recognising a trans woman necessarily requires admission despite a justified female-only boundary, one person’s wishes have been given priority. If recognition does not require that, there is room to respect trans people while retaining the boundary. That is the practical distinction your replies need to address.

You say you are supplying evidence and have explained your position on other threads.
Please set out the relevant reasoning here. Which specific factual claim is wrong, what evidence corrects it, and what access rule follows? Referring to previous explanations does not answer the questions being asked in this discussion. Repeatedly describing your position as reasonable is not a substitute for explaining it.

You say sporting eligibility is a separate question from what it means to be trans.
Agreed—and that distinction matters. Acknowledging someone’s identity does not, by itself, determine eligibility. The same distinction applies to changing rooms, hospital accommodation and refuges, although each setting needs its own justification. Respect for a person does not settle every access decision in their favour.

You object to explanations that reduce trans identities to stereotypes or pornography.
Sweeping claims about strangers’ motives are not established simply by repeating them. I do not need those claims to defend female-only provision. Whatever the origins of someone’s identity, the question remains whether a particular service should be organised by sex. Rejecting an unsupported explanation of why somebody is trans does not answer that policy question.

You point out that trans people generally know their anatomy and birth sex.
There is no need to dispute that or diagnose strangers. But knowing one’s sex does not establish an entitlement to provision reserved for the other sex. It leaves the central question unchanged: when female-only provision is justified, why should identity override its eligibility rule?

Women are explaining why these boundaries matter to them. Some do so calmly; some are angry. Their case does not depend on every commenter being courteous, every woman agreeing, or every trans person presenting a danger.

The question is whether women can retain justified sex-based boundaries while trans people receive dignity, protection and suitable provision.

Repeatedly judging the women’s responses does not answer it.
Women should not have to surrender a justified boundary to prove that they are decent people.

Shortshriftandlethal · 10/11/2026 17:02

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:00

Being trans is already breaking a social contract, as not limiting myself to a box that was arbitrary put on me in terms of how I meant meant to present myself in society.

Breaking social constructs is kinda of the idea, so we can be more free as individual to be ourselves.

It is not all about you. Once again.

murasaki · 10/11/2026 17:02

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:01

I am! Ask away.

OK then, what do you think you have in common with me that i don't have in common with any man. And please don't use female stereotypes of clothing, hair or tits in your answer.

BlueLegume · 10/11/2026 17:03

The last thread unraveled to talk about consent, violation of boundaries @Transperson including the relevance that this week off the back of Russell Brands conviction and the allegations against David Walliams, women need to protect boundaries and consent matters. Consent might mean using a female only facility and understanding no man can enter.

Lots of poster son your initial thread responded in good faith. You barely, reading back acknowledged those posts explaining that ‘we do not hate or dislike trans’…..and then patiently listed their concerns.

Perhaps you could read those many posts and consider some of our thoughts?

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 10/11/2026 17:04

Breaking social constructs is kinda of the idea, so we can be more free as individual to be ourselves.

Oooh, what a little rebel you are. I bet you don't wait for the green man before crossing the road, either.

SingleSexSpacesInSchools · 10/11/2026 17:04

@MajorProcrastination, Taking your points individually:

You describe Mumsnet as overwhelmingly transphobic.
Some comments are hostile, and I do not defend them. But that does not make every objection to mixed-sex intimate spaces an expression of hatred. The Supreme Court recognised biological sex under the Equality Act while expressly preserving protections for trans people. Supporting both is entirely consistent.
Supreme Court summary

The trans people you know are ordinary people, some anxious and some happier after transitioning.
I accept your account. Nobody needs to dispute their happiness or dismiss their anxiety to support female-only provision. But positive personal encounters do not resolve competing needs in communal changing rooms. Compassion for the people you know should also extend to women explaining why those boundaries matter.

You dismiss questions about women’s spaces as “What-About Olympics”.
The OP explicitly raised using single-sex facilities. Women responding about those facilities are addressing the subject. Their boundaries are central to the discussion. Dismissing that question leaves it unanswered: when women reasonably need female-only provision, do you support it?

You say you have no particular ideology and simply want people to live their lives.
I’m not questioning your motives. But live and let live must include women who want bodily privacy from the opposite sex. They should not have to demonstrate personal dislike, or wait for misconduct, before their needs count. Your freedom to feel comfortable with a situation does not settle what others should accept.

You have experienced harassment from non-trans men, never trans people.
I do not dispute your experience. It cannot establish comparative risks across whole populations. More fundamentally, privacy does not depend on proving somebody will assault you. Official guidance recognises that a woman may reasonably object to a man’s presence while she is undressing, and permits single-sex provision where the statutory conditions and proportionality test are met.
Code of Practice, paragraphs 13.107–13.116

You ask about trans men using male-only spaces.
My principle is consistent: where provision is lawfully reserved by sex, that boundary applies whichever sex is concerned. Men’s privacy matters too. I support suitable private alternatives where needed. Difficulties with provision deserve practical solutions; they do not make women’s boundaries dispensable.

I do not dislike trans people. I want my daughter to grow up knowing that respecting somebody else does not require surrendering a justified boundary of her own.

For Women Scotland Ltd (Appellant) v The Scottish Ministers (Respondent) - UK Supreme Court

https://www.supremecourt.uk/cases/press-summary/uksc-2024-0042

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:04

Shortshriftandlethal · 10/11/2026 17:02

It is not all about you. Once again.

Wow a person being themselves! How outrageous for them to use their bodily autonomy.

OP posts:
SingleSexSpacesInSchools · 10/11/2026 17:04

took ages to write and cut and paste these into a second thread I hope the op, @Transperson will engage in each of my points...

GreyskySexRealistsky · 10/11/2026 17:05

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:01

I am! Ask away.

How do you feel about women being free as individuals to be themselves in spaces and services designated solely for them?

Margaritaaahhh · 10/11/2026 17:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 10/11/2026 17:05

You're not being yourself. You're a man larping as a woman. That's the very opposite of being yourself.

brownbootsandhats · 10/11/2026 17:06

You are not arbitrarily put in a box

your sex is assigned and as a result society puts you in a box

it’s not the sex that is wrong
it’s the arbitrary allocation of gender to that sex which is wrong

and for somethings sex not gender is what matters

I feel a little sorry that you have trouble understanding this

I am a little angry that your solution involves strengthening the gender cage

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:06

SingleSexSpacesInSchools · 10/11/2026 17:04

@MajorProcrastination, Taking your points individually:

You describe Mumsnet as overwhelmingly transphobic.
Some comments are hostile, and I do not defend them. But that does not make every objection to mixed-sex intimate spaces an expression of hatred. The Supreme Court recognised biological sex under the Equality Act while expressly preserving protections for trans people. Supporting both is entirely consistent.
Supreme Court summary

The trans people you know are ordinary people, some anxious and some happier after transitioning.
I accept your account. Nobody needs to dispute their happiness or dismiss their anxiety to support female-only provision. But positive personal encounters do not resolve competing needs in communal changing rooms. Compassion for the people you know should also extend to women explaining why those boundaries matter.

You dismiss questions about women’s spaces as “What-About Olympics”.
The OP explicitly raised using single-sex facilities. Women responding about those facilities are addressing the subject. Their boundaries are central to the discussion. Dismissing that question leaves it unanswered: when women reasonably need female-only provision, do you support it?

You say you have no particular ideology and simply want people to live their lives.
I’m not questioning your motives. But live and let live must include women who want bodily privacy from the opposite sex. They should not have to demonstrate personal dislike, or wait for misconduct, before their needs count. Your freedom to feel comfortable with a situation does not settle what others should accept.

You have experienced harassment from non-trans men, never trans people.
I do not dispute your experience. It cannot establish comparative risks across whole populations. More fundamentally, privacy does not depend on proving somebody will assault you. Official guidance recognises that a woman may reasonably object to a man’s presence while she is undressing, and permits single-sex provision where the statutory conditions and proportionality test are met.
Code of Practice, paragraphs 13.107–13.116

You ask about trans men using male-only spaces.
My principle is consistent: where provision is lawfully reserved by sex, that boundary applies whichever sex is concerned. Men’s privacy matters too. I support suitable private alternatives where needed. Difficulties with provision deserve practical solutions; they do not make women’s boundaries dispensable.

I do not dislike trans people. I want my daughter to grow up knowing that respecting somebody else does not require surrendering a justified boundary of her own.

"Boundaries"? They can have an opinion but that doesn't translate to me having to take action based on that. I am not breaking and entering.

OP posts:
SingleSexSpacesInSchools · 10/11/2026 17:07

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:01

I am! Ask away.

The most wonderful thing about no debate is threads like this and the last one, just as with others posts we can sharpen and finesse the arguments and the world of sex realism becomes more and more hardy to any sort of assault. keep up the good work everyone.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 10/11/2026 17:07

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

That's brilliant!
I thought they didn't read MN <waves>
The comments about contacting MN to complain made me 😂

Theeyeballsinthesky · 10/11/2026 17:07

murasaki · 10/11/2026 16:59

I'm surprised 1000 posts wasn't enough to give you an answer to your goady question.

Come now, surely there is a always room for more screen shots and gloating on Reddit about how you put those uppity MN b**ches in their place

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread