Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Trying to understand why there is dislike towards trans people - discussion 2

1000 replies

Transperson · 10/11/2026 16:53

Cont

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 17:21

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:21

I didn't go to Reddit.

Didn’t say you did!

kitex · 10/11/2026 17:22

@Transperson “I don't have male privilege”

You are male.

BlueLegume · 10/11/2026 17:22

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:20

I mean socially our life (from gender perspective) are probably not so different.
I don't think "any men" fits well here so I'm assuming most men fits here (otherwise we get to some overlaps where feminine men taking estrogen are taken into consideration and that's a bit blurrier lins)

Men view us as sacks of meat, we get harassed, we try to go by our own day to day life and unfortunately have increased difficulty because of misogyny, doctors don't listen to us, colleagues might brush some of our ideas, there is the social expectations for us to be caring, emotionally aware, quiet, etc.

Men can get away with horrible things because well, they are men. I don't have male privilege.

My husband, sons, nephews and male friends do not view me or other women as ‘sacks of meat’. My doctor listens to me.

@Transperson I genuinely think if that post of yours meant what you said you need to seek some help and support.

callmeLoretta1 · 10/11/2026 17:22

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:20

I mean socially our life (from gender perspective) are probably not so different.
I don't think "any men" fits well here so I'm assuming most men fits here (otherwise we get to some overlaps where feminine men taking estrogen are taken into consideration and that's a bit blurrier lins)

Men view us as sacks of meat, we get harassed, we try to go by our own day to day life and unfortunately have increased difficulty because of misogyny, doctors don't listen to us, colleagues might brush some of our ideas, there is the social expectations for us to be caring, emotionally aware, quiet, etc.

Men can get away with horrible things because well, they are men. I don't have male privilege.

Don't lie. That you violate women's boundaries is Male Privilege on steroids. Males don't lose male privilege simply because they call themselves women.

Veilsofmorning · 10/11/2026 17:22

So I was right about the tag team- been a feature of other threads - seemingly up for discussion OP, but soon shows they are not, then joined by one or more regular scolders.
Déjà vu all over again. Same arguments, no answers, misuse of statistics and incorrect interpretation of the law.

BTW, the word ‘data’ is the plural, please use correct form of verbs 😁

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 17:24

murasaki · 10/11/2026 17:08

It's been good to see so many non FWR regulars responding to the OP and telling him what he's doing is wrong. Most cheering on a cold winter's day.

It does indeed warm the cockles. TERF Island taking no bullshit.

tripleginandtonic · 10/11/2026 17:24

You are coming across as very much having make privilege, you are the only one that matters despite endless women saying keep out

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Let's ground things, all I do is use single sex spaces without people being aware of what's going on, that inherently means I am not traumatising people.

The trauma comes from when people sexually assault women, in spaces that are meant to be safe, but I am not doing that. I'm being respectful and mindful. Or at least trying my best to. I do empathise with victims of SA or otherwise been put in danger (again I experienced harassment and SA).

OP posts:
murasaki · 10/11/2026 17:25

BlueLegume · 10/11/2026 17:22

My husband, sons, nephews and male friends do not view me or other women as ‘sacks of meat’. My doctor listens to me.

@Transperson I genuinely think if that post of yours meant what you said you need to seek some help and support.

Edited

Quite.

In fact DP's doctor listens to him less than mine does to me, resulting in a delayed diagnosis. He's taken to taking me with him to appointments as I am , ahem, better at asking the right questions and not letting it go.

NorthXNorthWest · 10/11/2026 17:27

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:00

Being trans is already breaking a social contract, as not limiting myself to a box that was arbitrary put on me in terms of how I meant meant to present myself in society.

Breaking social constructs is kinda of the idea, so we can be more free as individual to be ourselves.

Whilst violating the legitimate rights of a group you do not belong to.

'They don't know' is not the same as 'doing no harm'.

murasaki · 10/11/2026 17:27

And OP, if you think you are expected to be emotionally aware, you're not showing it here.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 10/11/2026 17:27

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 17:24

It does indeed warm the cockles. TERF Island taking no bullshit.

I've lurked for ages and don't contribute much because there are so many posters so much more knowledgeable and experienced with their arguments; but sometimes I just can't resist. 😉

BegbyBoo · 10/11/2026 17:27

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:25

Let's ground things, all I do is use single sex spaces without people being aware of what's going on, that inherently means I am not traumatising people.

The trauma comes from when people sexually assault women, in spaces that are meant to be safe, but I am not doing that. I'm being respectful and mindful. Or at least trying my best to. I do empathise with victims of SA or otherwise been put in danger (again I experienced harassment and SA).

Your very presence in a single sex space makes that space no longer single sex, and opens the door to other men, making them less safe for women.
And people are aware.

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:28

BlueLegume · 10/11/2026 17:22

My husband, sons, nephews and male friends do not view me or other women as ‘sacks of meat’. My doctor listens to me.

@Transperson I genuinely think if that post of yours meant what you said you need to seek some help and support.

Edited

I mean we both know I meant from a wider perspective rather than individuals, I'm glad you are not experiencing medical neglect as result of misogyny, but many women do.

OP posts:
kitex · 10/11/2026 17:28

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:25

Let's ground things, all I do is use single sex spaces without people being aware of what's going on, that inherently means I am not traumatising people.

The trauma comes from when people sexually assault women, in spaces that are meant to be safe, but I am not doing that. I'm being respectful and mindful. Or at least trying my best to. I do empathise with victims of SA or otherwise been put in danger (again I experienced harassment and SA).

“all I do is use single sex spaces without people being aware of what's going on, that inherently means I am not traumatising people.”

How do you know that people are not aware of you and are not traumatised?

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 10/11/2026 17:29

Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 17:24

It does indeed warm the cockles. TERF Island taking no bullshit.

Yes, I was going to weigh in but then saw that loads of usernames that I have never seen on FWR had already made so many excellent points.

ChunkyMonkey36 · 10/11/2026 17:29

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:20

I mean socially our life (from gender perspective) are probably not so different.
I don't think "any men" fits well here so I'm assuming most men fits here (otherwise we get to some overlaps where feminine men taking estrogen are taken into consideration and that's a bit blurrier lins)

Men view us as sacks of meat, we get harassed, we try to go by our own day to day life and unfortunately have increased difficulty because of misogyny, doctors don't listen to us, colleagues might brush some of our ideas, there is the social expectations for us to be caring, emotionally aware, quiet, etc.

Men can get away with horrible things because well, they are men. I don't have male privilege.

This is so incredibly reductive.

I’m a woman in leadership (you’ll notice I didn’t say “female boss”) so people do listen to me in the workplace, thank you.

And absolutely nobody expects me to be some meek, ever kind and ever passive woman.

Because I’m fucking not.

GriseldaandMike · 10/11/2026 17:29

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:25

Let's ground things, all I do is use single sex spaces without people being aware of what's going on, that inherently means I am not traumatising people.

The trauma comes from when people sexually assault women, in spaces that are meant to be safe, but I am not doing that. I'm being respectful and mindful. Or at least trying my best to. I do empathise with victims of SA or otherwise been put in danger (again I experienced harassment and SA).

Are you suggesting that 'none passing' transwomen should stay out of wrong sex single sex spaces?

Nellodee · 10/11/2026 17:29

Having just selectively read through OPs comments, it seems that their position changed from “My opinion is based on facts” to “My position is based on me passing”. This happened around the point the statisticians of mumsnet started pulling out their numbers to back up arguments.

i think from a generous perspective trans activists work on the basis that inclusion is the most important consideration. It’s easy to think of that as a possible positive motivation, whether or not I agree with that perspective. Somehow, however, trans activists seems unable to conceive of potential positive motivations the gender critical person might have.

This shortcoming appears to be universal. Ironically, the unwillingness and/or inability of many trans people to place themselves in the female perspective is one of the reasons why the female perspective exists.

murasaki · 10/11/2026 17:29

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:28

I mean we both know I meant from a wider perspective rather than individuals, I'm glad you are not experiencing medical neglect as result of misogyny, but many women do.

Well you're not. You may be experiencing medical neglect due to being trans, but not medical misogyny.

MrsDanversGlidesAgain · 10/11/2026 17:30

Let's ground things, all I do is use single sex spaces without people being aware of what's going on, that inherently means I am not traumatising people.

You have no idea if that's true, and the fact that you want it to be true to justify your trampling all over women's spaces is despicable.

Not that you show any sign of caring.

Lacksie · 10/11/2026 17:30

SingleSexSpacesInSchools · 10/11/2026 17:02

@lacksie I’m responding as a man and a father, not claiming to speak for all women. I agree that trans people deserve safety, dignity and respectful treatment. What your replies have not answered is how that resolves the disagreement about female-only provision.
Taking your arguments individually:

You say reasonable, humane discussion is impossible here.
Some comments are insulting, and I do not defend them. But that does not invalidate the reasoned arguments about privacy, safeguarding and sex-based boundaries. Criticising particular comments is legitimate. Treating those comments as an answer to every woman explaining why she needs female-only provision is not. An objection to somebody’s tone does not answer their substantive argument.

You dismiss these views as belonging to a small minority of women.
A forum cannot establish what all women think. Neither can your impression of it. In YouGov’s December 2024 survey, 55% of female respondents opposed allowing trans women into women’s changing rooms; 26% supported it. That does not settle policy by popularity, but it contradicts the suggestion that opposition is confined to a marginal few. Even a minority would still deserve its concerns to be addressed. YouGov results, page 13

You argue that respecting trans people requires accepting their understanding of themselves.
A person’s experience can be sincere and important without determining everybody else’s obligations. Recognising someone’s identity does not automatically establish eligibility for every sex-specific service. The Supreme Court expressly recognised biological sex under the Equality Act while preserving protection against gender-reassignment discrimination. Sex-based protections and protection for trans people can coexist. Supreme Court summary

You say the biological definition of sex closes the discussion through circular reasoning.
Simply repeating a definition would indeed be insufficient. But the argument is about why sex matters in particular circumstances: bodily privacy, intimate care, safeguarding and sporting fairness. Those reasons need answering. The law permits single-sex services where the statutory conditions and proportionality test are met, including to protect privacy, dignity and safety. Calling the definition restrictive does not explain why those protections should instead depend on identity. EHRC guidance

You say trans people’s experiences should be understood without taking priority over anyone else’s.
Then explain what that means when interests conflict. Which female-only services do you accept, and on what basis? If recognising a trans woman necessarily requires admission despite a justified female-only boundary, one person’s wishes have been given priority. If recognition does not require that, there is room to respect trans people while retaining the boundary. That is the practical distinction your replies need to address.

You say you are supplying evidence and have explained your position on other threads.
Please set out the relevant reasoning here. Which specific factual claim is wrong, what evidence corrects it, and what access rule follows? Referring to previous explanations does not answer the questions being asked in this discussion. Repeatedly describing your position as reasonable is not a substitute for explaining it.

You say sporting eligibility is a separate question from what it means to be trans.
Agreed—and that distinction matters. Acknowledging someone’s identity does not, by itself, determine eligibility. The same distinction applies to changing rooms, hospital accommodation and refuges, although each setting needs its own justification. Respect for a person does not settle every access decision in their favour.

You object to explanations that reduce trans identities to stereotypes or pornography.
Sweeping claims about strangers’ motives are not established simply by repeating them. I do not need those claims to defend female-only provision. Whatever the origins of someone’s identity, the question remains whether a particular service should be organised by sex. Rejecting an unsupported explanation of why somebody is trans does not answer that policy question.

You point out that trans people generally know their anatomy and birth sex.
There is no need to dispute that or diagnose strangers. But knowing one’s sex does not establish an entitlement to provision reserved for the other sex. It leaves the central question unchanged: when female-only provision is justified, why should identity override its eligibility rule?

Women are explaining why these boundaries matter to them. Some do so calmly; some are angry. Their case does not depend on every commenter being courteous, every woman agreeing, or every trans person presenting a danger.

The question is whether women can retain justified sex-based boundaries while trans people receive dignity, protection and suitable provision.

Repeatedly judging the women’s responses does not answer it.
Women should not have to surrender a justified boundary to prove that they are decent people.

Did you not see my response to you on the last thread?

BlueLegume · 10/11/2026 17:30

@Transperson

Let's ground things, all I do is use single sex spaces without people being aware of what's going on, that inherently means I am not traumatising people.

No thanks. Please do not suddenly decide to tell us to ‘ground things’. You cannot suddenly decide that. In fact your statement there is really worrying as your mitigation is a) people are not aware of your deception - trust me we are and b) you do not get to decide whether we are traumatised

HenriettaSwanLeavitt3 · 10/11/2026 17:31

GriseldaandMike · 10/11/2026 17:29

Are you suggesting that 'none passing' transwomen should stay out of wrong sex single sex spaces?

Protect the Bricks

Transperson · 10/11/2026 17:31

BegbyBoo · 10/11/2026 17:27

Your very presence in a single sex space makes that space no longer single sex, and opens the door to other men, making them less safe for women.
And people are aware.

Again, no one seems my genotype when I go to the bathroom, I am not blurring any lines or making anything less safe.

However, it would be less safe me to go to the men's

Like any other public space I go to, I show basic dignity and respect to the people I interact with.

OP posts:
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.