Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Mechanisms of biological sex and the social consequences thereof

155 replies

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/11/2026 18:28

A placeholder thread so I don't continue to contribute to an active derail.

Will add content as it comes to me....

OP posts:
Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 09:08

BackToLurk · 05/11/2026 08:45

Many is a subjective term, but what it isn’t is ‘all’. Posts like yours (regarding lesbians) are useful because they highlight the importance of having clearly defined terms in relation to sex. You used ‘lesbians who don’t want kids’ because- despite your TWAW stance - you understand it (maybe subconsciously) as meaning exclusively female people having sex with other exclusively female people. Sure, you engaged in some backpedaling, but everyone knew what you meant.

Blurring definitions makes it harder and harder to have clear debates around the issues that disproportionately impact women (old-style cunty kind), be that abortion, contraception or anything else. They also seemingly end up getting bogged down with including or not hurting the feelings of a handful of male people.

I don't have a TWAW stance. I have a TW are TW stance. So your post is entirely moot

Hedgehogforshort · 05/11/2026 09:11

Fuck sake who snook natal males in here, oh yes….

Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 09:24

Who here is a natal male?

BackToLurk · 05/11/2026 09:27

Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 09:08

I don't have a TWAW stance. I have a TW are TW stance. So your post is entirely moot

That is far from clear from your previous posts, in particular on the thread regarding whether it was possible to be a trans inclusive feminist. Apologies for having misinterpreted your posts as meaning you are a trans inclusive feminist.

Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 09:36

BackToLurk · 05/11/2026 09:27

That is far from clear from your previous posts, in particular on the thread regarding whether it was possible to be a trans inclusive feminist. Apologies for having misinterpreted your posts as meaning you are a trans inclusive feminist.

I wouldn't say my feminism focuses enough around this issue to give it that context.

If I was organising a space that I intended to be women only, I'd allow the women I intend to target to decide much of how it works including how we define women and perhaps even if we restrict it to women at all. Maybe the women I intend to target might feel it beneficial to include natal men.

But that's because I'd never be creating a space that targets women. It would be a certain demographic of woman like prisoners. I wouldn't really care if they wanted it to include or exclude trans women as long as I felt I was achieving what I set out. Facilitating their choice on this would be part of meeting that goal and it would be something to revisit as the population of the space changes over time.

Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 09:37

BackToLurk · 05/11/2026 09:27

That is far from clear from your previous posts, in particular on the thread regarding whether it was possible to be a trans inclusive feminist. Apologies for having misinterpreted your posts as meaning you are a trans inclusive feminist.

And BTW, perhaps if you didn't read everyone's posts as either for or against your cause, you'd be able to appreciate the nuance in women's opinions.

Pingponghavoc · 05/11/2026 09:40

This is trying to QED by imagined probability.

Some women will never have to think about birth control, neither will some men who identify as women. Therefore womens experiences regarding birth control is not uniquely a woman's experience.

Its missing the point about no woman can run away from a pregnancy in the same way all men can. In fact its turned around and seen as an advantage - only women can choose to continue the pregnancy. Its minimising the womens experience and turning the mens ability to run as a disadvantage.

Women have to potential to become pregnant, no man does. To say thats a minor issue, by imagining women who would never become pregnant is bonkers.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/11/2026 09:50

Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 08:34

I didnt argue that at all. Things like access to abortion should matter to everyone.

What I am saying in relation to the title thread is that some of these social consequences are either not exclusive to women, or not universal to all women. So I don't think they are social consequences of the mechanisms of our biological sex.

Some things are, and I haven't disputed those.

As the OP, you've misunderstood my point.

I'm not suggesting there's a universal set of consequences faced by every single female person, nor that nothing that is very often a consequence for female people is never faced by male.

The experiences and needs of the female half of humanity aren't a simple checklist that can be argued in a black and white way because humanity is complex and our identities and experiences are happening within the unique stories of our own lives.

However if we pretend our sex isn't significant to our choices and opportunities and limitations just because those things don't play out exactly the same way for everyone, we miss a massively significant factor in how our lives run and how we negotiate ourselves within society.

And because our society has been shaped by sexism abd patriarchy, when we pretend sex has no influence in our lives it's female people who lose out the most.

This interplay of influences needs long posts and subtle thinking, and it gets drowned out in the stupid tit for tat short post sniping that so often ends up derailing threads.

So this thread is an invitation to share thoughts more slowly and holistically about the various ways female biology shapes social role and experiences.

OP posts:
Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 09:57

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/11/2026 09:50

As the OP, you've misunderstood my point.

I'm not suggesting there's a universal set of consequences faced by every single female person, nor that nothing that is very often a consequence for female people is never faced by male.

The experiences and needs of the female half of humanity aren't a simple checklist that can be argued in a black and white way because humanity is complex and our identities and experiences are happening within the unique stories of our own lives.

However if we pretend our sex isn't significant to our choices and opportunities and limitations just because those things don't play out exactly the same way for everyone, we miss a massively significant factor in how our lives run and how we negotiate ourselves within society.

And because our society has been shaped by sexism abd patriarchy, when we pretend sex has no influence in our lives it's female people who lose out the most.

This interplay of influences needs long posts and subtle thinking, and it gets drowned out in the stupid tit for tat short post sniping that so often ends up derailing threads.

So this thread is an invitation to share thoughts more slowly and holistically about the various ways female biology shapes social role and experiences.

Yes and I have disagreed that some of what has been said is down to our female biology shaping our social role and experiences because I think it is more to do with cultural values and the limitations they put on our choices.

Any way, work now. See you soon

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/11/2026 10:13

Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 09:57

Yes and I have disagreed that some of what has been said is down to our female biology shaping our social role and experiences because I think it is more to do with cultural values and the limitations they put on our choices.

Any way, work now. See you soon

Yes. Cultural values often encode different expectations of different sexes. That's exactly the point. If you dismiss that because "it's cultural", you miss a whole set of ways being female impacts women in practice.

Otherwise you end up arguing that women in Afghanistan aren't suffering because they are female, but because it's cultural . When the obvious reality is they are suffering because they are female in that culture.

So to say "in Irish culture men are expected to want children" is interesting. (And raises questions about whether they are expected to do childcare or just find a willing wife to take all that on...). But to then conclude "so there's no point in talking about how social expectations around children impact women because some men have that as well" is missing the point.

These are the things I want to explore. The many ways being female rather than male impacts our lives. It's not black and white. And it's worth thinking about.

OP posts:
Pingponghavoc · 05/11/2026 10:24

I agree that all of trans arguments boil down to theres no universal male and female experience, therefore its of no consequence if we redefine it.

I suppose its the idea that if we dont see sex, there can be no sexism, and having sex based analysis becomes irrelevant.

But everyone has to play along for that to work. And what is this culture if not seeing sex and imposing standards to them?

Theres an assumption that as a society we have become less sexist. We can now remove sex based rights. But I dont see evidence that this is true, it just takes on different forms.

BackToLurk · 05/11/2026 10:25

Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 09:37

And BTW, perhaps if you didn't read everyone's posts as either for or against your cause, you'd be able to appreciate the nuance in women's opinions.

It really isn't about reading everyone's post as either for or against 'my cause', whatever that may be. It's about understanding how clarity is important in relation to defining what we (as a society) mean when talking about women - or indeed lesbians. You continue to illustrate that.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/11/2026 10:34

Pingponghavoc · 05/11/2026 10:24

I agree that all of trans arguments boil down to theres no universal male and female experience, therefore its of no consequence if we redefine it.

I suppose its the idea that if we dont see sex, there can be no sexism, and having sex based analysis becomes irrelevant.

But everyone has to play along for that to work. And what is this culture if not seeing sex and imposing standards to them?

Theres an assumption that as a society we have become less sexist. We can now remove sex based rights. But I dont see evidence that this is true, it just takes on different forms.

I agree that all of trans arguments boil down to theres no universal male and female experience, therefore its of no consequence if we redefine it.

Wow, I hadn't thought of it in those terms but you are exactly right, thank you. A great succinct observation.

Of course, they also say that just because trans people don't all agree what being trans means doesn't mean we can't accept being trans as real and consequential. Always with the double standards!

OP posts:
nicepotoftea · 05/11/2026 10:35

Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 08:34

I didnt argue that at all. Things like access to abortion should matter to everyone.

What I am saying in relation to the title thread is that some of these social consequences are either not exclusive to women, or not universal to all women. So I don't think they are social consequences of the mechanisms of our biological sex.

Some things are, and I haven't disputed those.

So are you arguing that things like access to abortion should be of no more interest to lesbians than they are to men?

If you live in a society where there is an assumption that women cannot or should not control their fertility, nobody is asking women about their sexual preferences.

There is just an assumption that women cannot be independent of men and should be restricted to domesticity.

nicepotoftea · 05/11/2026 10:38

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/11/2026 10:34

I agree that all of trans arguments boil down to theres no universal male and female experience, therefore its of no consequence if we redefine it.

Wow, I hadn't thought of it in those terms but you are exactly right, thank you. A great succinct observation.

Of course, they also say that just because trans people don't all agree what being trans means doesn't mean we can't accept being trans as real and consequential. Always with the double standards!

Of course, they also say that just because trans people don't all agree what being trans means doesn't mean we can't accept being trans as real and consequential. Always with the double standards!

Although I don't think that argument has worked, and the expansion of 'trans' to cover pretty much everyone on earth has made it very difficult to explain trans rights. It's a lesson on why definitions are important.

nicepotoftea · 05/11/2026 10:41

Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 08:29

Sure. I also know that many trans people (especially outside of porn) do not want to engage in acts like PIV because it enhances their feelings of dysphoria.

The many trans identifying men with multiple children suggest that this is not a problem for a substantial part of the male trans community.

nicepotoftea · 05/11/2026 10:44

Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 08:28

A trans widow is unlikely to be engaged in a healthy, consensual sex life with their trans partner.

A trans widow is likely to have thought that at one point she was engaging in a healthy consensual sex life with the father of her children.

theilltemperedmonster · 05/11/2026 11:13

Women are not oppressed by the patriarchy on the basis of whether they are individually fertile and heterosexual. They are oppressed because they belong to the class of humans that ordinarily are expected to be capable of being impregnated.

And also because men are bigger, stronger, faster, more aggressive, more criminally inclined, and more sexually indiscriminate and perverse.

So, infertile and celibate women are oppressed, and so are 46 XY individuals with a gross female phenotype. Direct control of fertility is only one part of it. Women as a class are controlled to serve the interests of men as to sexual pleasure, procreation, and political and economic power. Because they can.

PoisonCrystal · 05/11/2026 11:21

Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 09:08

I don't have a TWAW stance. I have a TW are TW stance. So your post is entirely moot

I think this is fundamental to the discussion.

Could you elaborate on what a “TW are TW stance” involves? Why do you not use any other words to describe a TW that would explain the meaning more clearly?

Pingponghavoc · 05/11/2026 11:56

Trans is basically i believe therefore I am. There are hurdles sometimes - a diagnosis is needed for nhs surgery and for a GRC too. But this diagnosis isnt much more than 'I believe'.

When society has questioned this, the government has said 'its the law' and walked away. Its been left to keen amatures to justify the whys and hows.

Its why we have a bewildering number of conflicting reasons. They are all in response to something - women are wary of men therefore tw look like women, womens healthcare needs become not all women. Its disguised as sex and gender, but it really all boils down to sex is not important, relevant or maybe doesnt even exist.

The whole concept of trans damages women far more, or at least in very different ways than it does men. As women and as women identifying as trans. But the concept itself stops that being discussed.

If men can be women, women cannot be disadvantaged by trans any differently to men.

Tallisker · 05/11/2026 13:01

My MIL told her grandson’s pregnant girlfriend that if she, the girlfriend, had a girl, she, the MIL, would never speak to her again. The girlfriend was 18 years old. It was a horrible thing to say, and this was only a few years ago, so don’t tell me women aren’t blamed for having the ‘wrong sex’ babies.

As an aside, the girlfriend is now a wife and they have three sons, so my MIL is proud of her grandson for having boys 🙄

Dontmakemethinkofanotherbloodyusername · 05/11/2026 13:15

nicepotoftea · 05/11/2026 07:10

Women have a variety of different feelings about pregnancy/fertility/motherhood, but they cannot escape the consequences of being female.

That is rather the point of sex specific rights.

There was extensive debate about the decriminalisation of abortion this year, but what ever anyone's views on the ethics, only one sex has abortions.

Whether they want to have children or not, women will be the focus of pro-natalist policies.

If a far right government took power, it would be so much easier for them if the left had already removed the concept of sex discrimination from the statute books. "Sorry, so you say some people might be more disadvantaged than others if we remove access to contraception? I don't understand - who are you talking about? The Equality Act? They don't seem to be mentioned".

I don't see that last part as realistic at all, it's perfectly possible to allow for and protect the rights of people who are pregnant or needing an abortion. It seems to be the GC side before anyone else acting faux naive that they can't understand that women can also be people. The concern would seem sincere if they weren't so aligned with the people who want to remove abortion rights but 'at least know what a woman is'.

nicepotoftea · 05/11/2026 13:44

Dontmakemethinkofanotherbloodyusername · 05/11/2026 13:15

I don't see that last part as realistic at all, it's perfectly possible to allow for and protect the rights of people who are pregnant or needing an abortion. It seems to be the GC side before anyone else acting faux naive that they can't understand that women can also be people. The concern would seem sincere if they weren't so aligned with the people who want to remove abortion rights but 'at least know what a woman is'.

Personally I think it's easier to use contraception to avoid an unwanted pregnancy and the prospect of an abortion.

Can you tell the difference between the kind of person who might have to deal with the consequences of an unwanted pregnancy and therefore might seek out contraception, and the kind of person who can simply walk away?

Do you think employers can tell what kind of person might become pregnant, and do you think that, without equality legislation, they might discriminate against such a person?

Do you think there might be a link between the people who can't walk away from an unwanted pregnancy and people who menstruate, have miscarriages, require maternity rights at work, lactate, go through menopause, have sex specific medical conditions like ovarian cancer and endometriosis and require sex specific fertility treatment? Do you think these things could happen randomly to anyone, or do you think that we can identify which people these things might affect? Do you acknowledge that this group of people (50% of the population) need rights that the other 50% don't need, and that this makes them vulnerable?

The concern would seem sincere if they weren't so aligned with the people who want to remove abortion rights but 'at least know what a woman is'.

You are confusing the US and the UK. Obvs tricky for some because they both have 'united' in the title. The UK is the country with fewer guns and more tea.

YouCanCallMeMonster · 05/11/2026 14:11

Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 08:01

No its not definitely a risk if the male in question can't get an erection or we don't have anything like PIV sex. You know you can't get pregnant if you peg someone, right?

I got pregnant (and had an abortion) thru non penetrative sexual activity.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/11/2026 14:42

nicepotoftea · 05/11/2026 13:44

Personally I think it's easier to use contraception to avoid an unwanted pregnancy and the prospect of an abortion.

Can you tell the difference between the kind of person who might have to deal with the consequences of an unwanted pregnancy and therefore might seek out contraception, and the kind of person who can simply walk away?

Do you think employers can tell what kind of person might become pregnant, and do you think that, without equality legislation, they might discriminate against such a person?

Do you think there might be a link between the people who can't walk away from an unwanted pregnancy and people who menstruate, have miscarriages, require maternity rights at work, lactate, go through menopause, have sex specific medical conditions like ovarian cancer and endometriosis and require sex specific fertility treatment? Do you think these things could happen randomly to anyone, or do you think that we can identify which people these things might affect? Do you acknowledge that this group of people (50% of the population) need rights that the other 50% don't need, and that this makes them vulnerable?

The concern would seem sincere if they weren't so aligned with the people who want to remove abortion rights but 'at least know what a woman is'.

You are confusing the US and the UK. Obvs tricky for some because they both have 'united' in the title. The UK is the country with fewer guns and more tea.

Do you think employers can tell what kind of person might become pregnant, and do you think that, without equality legislation, they might discriminate against such a person?

Just highlighting this as it's so important to my point that the social consequences of being female are cumulative and intersectional.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread