Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Mechanisms of biological sex and the social consequences thereof

155 replies

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/11/2026 18:28

A placeholder thread so I don't continue to contribute to an active derail.

Will add content as it comes to me....

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Imdunfer · 06/11/2026 11:16

MarieDeGournay · 06/11/2026 10:15

This is an interesting point, as the IOC has cleared Lin Yu-Ting to box in the women's category. [ LYT is the other DSD boxer who along with Imane Khelif was allowed to box in the women's competition at the Paris Olympics because at the time, there was no eligibility criterion other than what it said on their passports.]

The IOC's new testing regime has a first layer of testing for the presence of a Y chromosome, which LYT has, but there is a second level of individualised consideration when an athlete has a Y chromosome but has a DSD which prevents 'androgenization' - which was found to be the case with LYT who I believe has CAIS.

I assume this was the IOC going out of their way to be fair to people like LYT, and maybe also a way of heading off the 'But what about intersex [sic] people who deserve to be included in sport?'

LYT has been assessed as having no unfair physical advantage over XX-women boxers, and has been cleared to box in the female category.
Imdunfer points out that height and reach may still be an advantage, and I'd also point out that a CAIS athlete doesn't have to factor periods into their training and competition schedules, which is an advantage.

Although the IOC says he is female in terms of eligibility to compete in the female category, I don't accept that this finding means that LYT is a woman.
He is a male with a DSD which makes him physically more like your average woman than your average man.
In build, anyway - I personally think that LYT could 'pass' as a man without difficulty if he wanted to, though I admit that that's just judging from photos where he looks like a slim young man to me.

As I've said elsewhere, I can't see anyone claiming that Imane Khelif's DSD has prevented androgenization😏
IK and LYT are roughly the same height but side by side, they look completely different, IK looks like a strong fit man, LYT looks slim and slight in comparison.
So a pretty good illustration of how two different male DSDs can have different physical manifestations.

Edited

I think it's astounding he's been cleared to box given what I now know. He is taller than the average MALE Thai and an order of magnitude taller than the average female Thai person.

Reach is so influential in boxing, and the IOC have cleared a person with male reach advantage to hit women.

MyAmpleSheep · 06/11/2026 10:20

StealthTroublemaker · 04/11/2026 22:22

But then mentioned other cultures…. Now go go, give one culture where the man is always blamed….

This was extensively covered on another thread.

:-)

MarieDeGournay · 06/11/2026 10:15

Imdunfer · 06/11/2026 09:26

Whilst those influences are true there is an influence on height and reach which comes purely from the possession of a Y chromosome.

It is not a level playing field to allow a CAIS boxer with superior reach and height purely by ownership of a male only chromosome to fight women.

This is an interesting point, as the IOC has cleared Lin Yu-Ting to box in the women's category. [ LYT is the other DSD boxer who along with Imane Khelif was allowed to box in the women's competition at the Paris Olympics because at the time, there was no eligibility criterion other than what it said on their passports.]

The IOC's new testing regime has a first layer of testing for the presence of a Y chromosome, which LYT has, but there is a second level of individualised consideration when an athlete has a Y chromosome but has a DSD which prevents 'androgenization' - which was found to be the case with LYT who I believe has CAIS.

I assume this was the IOC going out of their way to be fair to people like LYT, and maybe also a way of heading off the 'But what about intersex [sic] people who deserve to be included in sport?'

LYT has been assessed as having no unfair physical advantage over XX-women boxers, and has been cleared to box in the female category.
Imdunfer points out that height and reach may still be an advantage, and I'd also point out that a CAIS athlete doesn't have to factor periods into their training and competition schedules, which is an advantage.

Although the IOC says he is female in terms of eligibility to compete in the female category, I don't accept that this finding means that LYT is a woman.
He is a male with a DSD which makes him physically more like your average woman than your average man.
In build, anyway - I personally think that LYT could 'pass' as a man without difficulty if he wanted to, though I admit that that's just judging from photos where he looks like a slim young man to me.

As I've said elsewhere, I can't see anyone claiming that Imane Khelif's DSD has prevented androgenization😏
IK and LYT are roughly the same height but side by side, they look completely different, IK looks like a strong fit man, LYT looks slim and slight in comparison.
So a pretty good illustration of how two different male DSDs can have different physical manifestations.

Pingponghavoc · 06/11/2026 09:30

Hedgehogforshort · 05/11/2026 23:46

I am just having some late night thoughts. I want to sleep upon.

but a summary is when thinking about feminism, (from a none academic feminist POV).

The GC/sex realist rising is really to me, more a social than philosophical movement. It actually cuts across class in a way that i don't think i have seen before.

we seem more capable of setting aside party politics, religion, economic privilege (or lack of) and i dunno move forward with an unelected somewhat invisible strategic coordination, that is fucking fascinating.

I think as a society we historically 'managed' trans by, wherever possible, pushing male transvestites to the margins, and embracing girls as tomboys, and seeing adult women as wanting comfortable and practical clothes. There was a socially understood distinction between adult men and women and girls.

Trans ideology, via academia tried to link them, and I think what you are describing is normies rejecting a top down rewriting of a social order?

Imdunfer · 06/11/2026 09:26

theilltemperedmonster · 06/11/2026 09:08

Testosterone has a limiting effect on vertical growth during puberty, which is (one) reason why eunuchs and XY CAIS tend to be tall, and transmen short.

Boys experience androgenic changes before and shortly after birth, so will always be different from girls even if puberty is blocked (which is a bad idea anyway, just to be clear).

Some people with DSDs that affect androgen production/processing/signalling may end up androgynous but it can't be helped, and they are rare. We can treat them with kindness and respect without going mad and deciding that sex is a nebulous concept.

Whilst those influences are true there is an influence on height and reach which comes purely from the possession of a Y chromosome.

It is not a level playing field to allow a CAIS boxer with superior reach and height purely by ownership of a male only chromosome to fight women.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 06/11/2026 09:19

Some people are born without a hand, or lose a hand.

It is therefore not factually accurate to say all humans have two hands.

We accomodate those who do not.

However, because the vast majority of himans do have two hands, we still build bicycles with two handlebars, put stalks on both sides of the steering wheel, have not banned knitting, and sell gloves in pairs.

Recognising and supporting minority groups does not mean degrading the provisions of the majority unless one politically choses to do so.

OP posts:
theilltemperedmonster · 06/11/2026 09:08

Testosterone has a limiting effect on vertical growth during puberty, which is (one) reason why eunuchs and XY CAIS tend to be tall, and transmen short.

Boys experience androgenic changes before and shortly after birth, so will always be different from girls even if puberty is blocked (which is a bad idea anyway, just to be clear).

Some people with DSDs that affect androgen production/processing/signalling may end up androgynous but it can't be helped, and they are rare. We can treat them with kindness and respect without going mad and deciding that sex is a nebulous concept.

DeanElderberry · 06/11/2026 08:11

Hedgehogforshort · 05/11/2026 23:46

I am just having some late night thoughts. I want to sleep upon.

but a summary is when thinking about feminism, (from a none academic feminist POV).

The GC/sex realist rising is really to me, more a social than philosophical movement. It actually cuts across class in a way that i don't think i have seen before.

we seem more capable of setting aside party politics, religion, economic privilege (or lack of) and i dunno move forward with an unelected somewhat invisible strategic coordination, that is fucking fascinating.

'unelected somewhat invisible strategic coordination'

Our craft group and an historical working group both function that way. Both are all female. We occasionally get women who expect us to have a 'leader', but most understand perfectly that we don't do that.

Another historical group we interact with is male-dominated, very structured, and keeps losing committee members to spats.

Doesn't prove anything, but amusing to watch.

DeanElderberry · 06/11/2026 08:03

StealthTroublemaker · 05/11/2026 21:29

Well yes, yes it is. Trust me on this….

This gives me flashbacks to mid 1970s convent school religion classes and our (young, female, married) teacher telling us that getting pregnant from 'heavy petting' was possible if the male partner had an orgasm. Useful info for young girls entering their decade of peak fertility. It also came with veiled advice on how to get help if you were in a situation of non-consensual sex, including incest.

Particularly important since we were in a country where there was not only no abortion but also no access to barrier contraception and access to the pill depended on knowing a doctor who would prescribe it, a pharmacist who would dispense at, and the money to pay for it, three BIG filters.

Teenage girls - we listened that day.

Imdunfer · 06/11/2026 07:55

My list so far of gene dictated sex differences, aside from the obvious, is below (I'm not a scientist but I think it's right)

As a result of having a Y:

Size. Also influenced in a lot of other ways but the Y influence on size is irrespective of hormones and puberty blockers will not erase it, which is why CAIS people are still tall and should definitely bar them from women's competition.

Differences in the development of heart, brain and lungs and how they "housekeep" and regulate themselves.

As a result of having 2 X:

Stronger immune response and as a result up to 8 times more auto immune disease and a bigger energy requirement to run the immune system which has significant impact on athletic performance (and should imo bar CAIS athlete from women's competition).

More autism gene damping and as a result less autism.

Less disease like haemophilia and red/green colour blindness because it requires only one bad gene on X and women have backup copy.

More anxiety and neuroticism because genes driving that are on the X and women have 2 copies.

Hedgehogforshort · 05/11/2026 23:46

I am just having some late night thoughts. I want to sleep upon.

but a summary is when thinking about feminism, (from a none academic feminist POV).

The GC/sex realist rising is really to me, more a social than philosophical movement. It actually cuts across class in a way that i don't think i have seen before.

we seem more capable of setting aside party politics, religion, economic privilege (or lack of) and i dunno move forward with an unelected somewhat invisible strategic coordination, that is fucking fascinating.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/11/2026 22:30

Hedgehogforshort · 05/11/2026 21:38

I am curious to learn how an allegedly heterosexual woman would know all about what a trans woman and a biological woman get up to in their sex lives. And add to that why we had more than a couple of posts about anal sex and pegging from the same person. All on a thread about how biology effects women.
Hmm
i suppose i could just guess

What really stood out to me was the underlying assumption that PIV is off the menu for the woman with a V but she'd nevertheless be expected to strap up for the other. Seemed somewhat unfair IMO.

Though frankly the whole speculating about others sex lives thing is icky. I'm, to be clear here, speculating only about someone else's speculation. (Also I always understood, though not being a practicing lesbian myself this is second hand info, that strap ons are far less common in lesbian sex than male-targetted porn would have us believe. But I could well be wrong there.)

OP posts:
Hedgehogforshort · 05/11/2026 21:38

I am curious to learn how an allegedly heterosexual woman would know all about what a trans woman and a biological woman get up to in their sex lives. And add to that why we had more than a couple of posts about anal sex and pegging from the same person. All on a thread about how biology effects women.
Hmm
i suppose i could just guess

StealthTroublemaker · 05/11/2026 21:29

Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 07:52

Many of the trans women you are referring to don't use their penis in sex. Some because they can't due to hormones etc. Sex isn't just putting the willy in the moo moo. There are lots of things you can do that still count as sex. So I don't think pregnancy is the same risk for a woman with a TW partner as it is for say me, in a heterosexual relationship with my natal male husband.

It's honestly much better if you stick to making genuine comments about the topic rather than trying to somehow catch me out. I get that it infuriates and disgusts you that I am a woman and I don't fully agree with the GC script here, but you just come across as needlessly hostile.

Well yes, yes it is. Trust me on this….

inkymoose · 05/11/2026 21:26

Imdunfer · 05/11/2026 17:39

Another difference found between men and women related directly to the fact that women have 2 X chromosomes.

There will be more of these as the science progresses.

www.news-medical.net/news/20261104/Researchers-identify-specific-gene-linked-to-female-protection-from-autism.aspx

Very interesting read, thank you. Another article included in the journal was analysing research done on whether hospital patients treated by female physicians had better health outcomes than those treated by male physicians, and found that they did, although I don't know how statistically significant it was.

ScrollingLeaves · 05/11/2026 19:36

Imdunfer · 05/11/2026 17:39

Another difference found between men and women related directly to the fact that women have 2 X chromosomes.

There will be more of these as the science progresses.

www.news-medical.net/news/20261104/Researchers-identify-specific-gene-linked-to-female-protection-from-autism.aspx

How fascinating, thank you.

PoisonCrystal · 05/11/2026 18:14

Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 14:55

Why are my views so central to the discussion? I think trans women are trans women. That's all there is to it.

Equally, ladybirds are ladybirds. But without context it’s meaningless. What’s the context? Why do you think that?

Imdunfer · 05/11/2026 17:39

Another difference found between men and women related directly to the fact that women have 2 X chromosomes.

There will be more of these as the science progresses.

www.news-medical.net/news/20261104/Researchers-identify-specific-gene-linked-to-female-protection-from-autism.aspx

nicepotoftea · 05/11/2026 17:10

Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 16:59

That the act that got you pregnant is unlikely to be relevant to the sex life between woman and a trans woman.

Do you think that to identify as trans is to have had surgery or take medication that prevents orgasm?

This definition would contravene judgements made by the ECHR

nicepotoftea · 05/11/2026 17:06

Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 16:59

That the act that got you pregnant is unlikely to be relevant to the sex life between woman and a trans woman.

?

Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 16:59

YouCanCallMeMonster · 05/11/2026 16:56

And what exactly has that got to do with my pregnancy?

That the act that got you pregnant is unlikely to be relevant to the sex life between woman and a trans woman.

YouCanCallMeMonster · 05/11/2026 16:56

Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 16:30

Pegging. A common act between trans women and female partners

And what exactly has that got to do with my pregnancy?

DrBlackbird · 05/11/2026 16:46

Well. How quickly it goes from intellectual discussion of how biological reality impacts female experience to… what? 😳

Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 16:30

YouCanCallMeMonster · 05/11/2026 16:18

What an odd question. How does a woman perform anal sex on a man?

The point is, that pregnancy is possible without PIV.

Pegging. A common act between trans women and female partners

YouCanCallMeMonster · 05/11/2026 16:18

Lexibletheflexible · 05/11/2026 14:55

Did you get pregnant by performing anal sex on a man?

What an odd question. How does a woman perform anal sex on a man?

The point is, that pregnancy is possible without PIV.