Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Mechanisms of biological sex and the social consequences thereof

155 replies

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/11/2026 18:28

A placeholder thread so I don't continue to contribute to an active derail.

Will add content as it comes to me....

OP posts:
theilltemperedmonster · 04/11/2026 16:28

nicepotoftea · 04/11/2026 15:52

From a legal point of view It's the sex registered at birth.

Biological sex is so straightforward that the Supreme Court didn't even need to define it. You can prove it with a birth certificate issued before age 18. Or later, if there was a clerical error/DSD, and a marginal correction had to be applied (a maybe 1 in 20,000 occurrence). EA2010 works perfectly smoothly with DSDs too. Certificates extracted from the gender recognition register are a completely different matter. I get so sick of explaining all this, with TRAs bleating about how complex it is. It's. Not. Complex.

inkymoose · 04/11/2026 17:32

Thehorticulturalhussie · 04/11/2026 15:32

@nicepotoftea I agree and think that we are analysing the phrases used commonly by men who believe that they can become women -
' I live as a woman now'
' I have always felt like a woman'
etc

We may or may not be tomboys when we're young but as puberty looms we become aware of attracting a certain type of attention from boys and men. I was a teen in the early 70s and we suddenly became responsible for not dressing in a way likely to make us seem 'easy', for not being in certain places at certain times, for being kind, for accepting that boys will be boys. Later we would become solely responsible for not getting pregnant.

We make some of the biggest and emotional decisions around our fertility - should I have a baby now or wait until I'm older and risk leaving it too late? Should I abort the unplanned baby I'm currently carrying (unable to anticipate the lifelong guilt and regret)? We are tied to our children for life. Many men do not feel that responsibility when the going gets tough.

At any age we feel fearful when walking down a road in the dark, hearing footsteps close behind. We feel a wave of relief to find that it's a woman who's simply in a hurry.

All of the above shape our lives because we are women and cannot be acquired by men wearing our clothes.

Very much so. Well put

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 17:35

theilltemperedmonster · 04/11/2026 16:28

Biological sex is so straightforward that the Supreme Court didn't even need to define it. You can prove it with a birth certificate issued before age 18. Or later, if there was a clerical error/DSD, and a marginal correction had to be applied (a maybe 1 in 20,000 occurrence). EA2010 works perfectly smoothly with DSDs too. Certificates extracted from the gender recognition register are a completely different matter. I get so sick of explaining all this, with TRAs bleating about how complex it is. It's. Not. Complex.

You know this. I know this. They know this.

They IMO exhibit the same behaviour as the type of man who thinks if he can find a loophole to argue your rejection of his advances is not logically sound, you are bound to sleep with him. It's just so fucking icky, and so fucking relentless.

They can never win on honest terms. Bceause female people, of the boring, non-exceptional, non 1% of 1% of 1% DSD type, exist.

So either woman is the name for an adult human female, in which case male people have no right to and so no business in the rights, places and language that pertain to female people, or woman is not the name for an adult human female, in which case male people who identify as women still have no business in the rights, places and language that pertain to female people.

That literally is all that needs to be said. Female people matter enough to name.

So it's just gish gallop after gish gallop, refusal to acknowledge what they and we know they understand perfectly well as if somehow refusing to admit they know exactly what we mean will make us all decide we don't experience social and physical consequences because of the sex of our body after all.

OP posts:
ReTerf · 04/11/2026 17:41

No TIM ever had to deal with getting their first menstrual period in the middle of a lesson on their first day at a new school, and then be told by the teacher that they are not permitted to go to the loo until the end of the lesson. Nor were they ever told they were a slag for going out with lots of boys, or frigid if they didn’t go out with lots of boys. They were just boys. TIM’s have never been judged and insulted by a 60 year old doctor for accessing the morning after pill as a teenager. They have never been judged for being single mothers, or asked why on earth they are childless. Nor are they constantly told they are getting motherhood wrong—from conception onwards.
TIM’s do not experience the judgement that women face for their every decision, every moment of their lives, and the blame assigned to women for the actions of men.

TIM’s can dress up real pretty though.

inkymoose · 04/11/2026 17:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

inkymoose · 04/11/2026 18:04

@ReTerf I started a Masters a few years ago. The number of male students outnumbered the females by roughly 3 to 2. The male tutors were uninterested in what the women had to say during the taught sessions.

In an early session, a young (ish) male tutor announced that "we" needed to have "a group agreement" for our classes. He opined that we should all go to the toilet before class and not disrupt the class by leaving to use the loo.

I was very annoyed by this high-handed twaddle from someone who thought himself an "expert" in a position of responsibility as a tutor. The youngest student was 22 and the oldest was 62. I mean what the fuck?

Anyway I told him I wasn't agreeing to that and he had no right to try to impose such a rule. Group agreement my arse. Periods and bladder problems not to mention gut problems eg ibs and other nasties are common in the female population. He didn't know or care. He also didn't like being contradicted.

Sorry to mention the K-word. But it was about control and autonomy and respect, or lack of.

midnight4 · 04/11/2026 18:04

ReTerf · 04/11/2026 17:41

No TIM ever had to deal with getting their first menstrual period in the middle of a lesson on their first day at a new school, and then be told by the teacher that they are not permitted to go to the loo until the end of the lesson. Nor were they ever told they were a slag for going out with lots of boys, or frigid if they didn’t go out with lots of boys. They were just boys. TIM’s have never been judged and insulted by a 60 year old doctor for accessing the morning after pill as a teenager. They have never been judged for being single mothers, or asked why on earth they are childless. Nor are they constantly told they are getting motherhood wrong—from conception onwards.
TIM’s do not experience the judgement that women face for their every decision, every moment of their lives, and the blame assigned to women for the actions of men.

TIM’s can dress up real pretty though.

Spot on. Excellent post! The last line made me laugh. Those ‘women’ with a beard are so fetching! 😂

inkymoose · 04/11/2026 18:10

midnight4 · 04/11/2026 18:04

Spot on. Excellent post! The last line made me laugh. Those ‘women’ with a beard are so fetching! 😂

I've started to feel very queasy when seeing photos of "women" with beards. It causes a clash in my brain, I think

"it's a man"
"why are they smiling so eagerly"
"It's a man wearing a fetish outfit "
" How can they ...."

🤯

FlatCatYellowMat · 04/11/2026 19:26

Someone's fashion choices obviously don't change their sex. They can't even try to swing that one.

And we if we can't criticise fashion choices, then they'll have to shut down S&B.

solerolover · 04/11/2026 21:39

I'm just going to copy and paste one of my responses in the thread we had a few weeks back about whether one can be a fully trans-inclusive feminist, because it touches on the social consequences of our biological sex and how that relates to the aims of the feminist movement.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5586428-can-you-be-a-fully-trans-inclusive-feminist?page=14&reply=155206389&utm_campaign=reply&utm_medium=share

The refusal to acknowledge the physical and social reality of the female half of the planet, to divorce that from womanhood, and state that, no actually, womanhood is contained in the minds of male people, the historical oppressor class of female people, in the form of some metaphysical concept known as a "gender identity" and you want to call that feminism?😳Maybe it's because my family are from a global South nation, so-called feminists who champion this ideology are extremely amusing and just silly to me.

I mean, no "transwoman" has ever:

had to face female genital mutilation, had to face the horrors being cut as a child, sometimes being sewn together, only to be "opened" up by his future husband on his wedding night, because his genitalia and sexuality are inherently dirty things that must be controlled

been killed as a newborn for the sin of being the wrong sex, the female sex that is considered a burden

been voiceless and veiled and treated lower than dogshit in Afghanistan
faced the sack for being married or having kids

has been denied the right to education, while his brothers are free to go to school

been ignored and overlooked for being female, but listened to when his husband is around

been denied the vote because he was a woman

been married off and sold like cattle to a man three times his age because girls are just another mouth to feed

experienced period poverty or the shame of being relegated to a menstrual hut

had his reproductive rights and literally every aspect of his material being policed, because that's what society does to women

...the list goes on.
But yeah, TWAW right? Spinny skirts away!

Page 14 | Can you be a fully trans inclusive feminist? | Mumsnet

Inspired from another thread where it was out of place so I brought it here. Someone seemed to claim that it was possible to be both be a feminist a...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5586428-can-you-be-a-fully-trans-inclusive-feminist?page=14&reply=155206389

solerolover · 04/11/2026 21:43

This excerpt from The Transsexual Empire by Janice Raymond, fits perfectly with this discussion and so many others, I think of it as FWR distilled, if that makes sense🙂:

But in some very real senses, female biology shapes female history—a history that men don’t have because of their sex—including the history of menstruation, the history of pregnancy or the capacity to become pregnant, the history of childbirth and abortion, the history of certain bodily cycles and life changes, and the history of female subordination in a male-dominant society. Note that I keep saying history. To deny that female history is, in part, based on female biology is like denying that important aspects of Black history are based on skin color. As with biological skin color, female biology doesn’t confer an essential femininity; rather it confers a historical reality about what it means to be bom with XX chromosomes.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 21:55

By coincidence (not really, it's because we are all dealing with the same daft bollocks), I've just drafted a reply on a derailed thread that I think is better posted here which is along a similar, though less historically raging (justifed rage!) lines, inspired by Genderist philosophy along the lines of "sex might be a fact, but it's not a fact of any consequence until observed"...

Which is true (if one considers "experienced" to be within the meanings of observed in this context) but also facile. Because ones sex is almost always observed at birth and many times after by ones parents who both react to it and speak of it to other people who also react to it, and so becomes part of ones own self knowledge "girl is what I am" , and through that ones understanding that I am in certain ways like these people (be they real or fictional) but not like those people, way before one has any critical framework in which to place that.

What the facile analysis misses is that each instant of a life is not isolated from the rest of life, nor from the culture in which it is lived. The person who believes himself a woman now has a totally different relationship to that idea than the woman who grew from a girl her whole life within the knowledge and others knowledge of her.

So the facile view looks at two adults now, one with real female breasts and one with some augmented addition to mimic them (or pick another measure from the Genderist big box of what makes a woman, the logic is the same), and says "but these people both have a feature of womanhood, who knows what gametes they may or may not produce but we can all see the breasts, we react to them as people with breasts, how are they not both more alike than different?" erasing the history and journey of both people through lives shaped very differently by their sexed experiences to be at that moment.

In the facile view both are merely tye surface, but the woman reduced most of all because it is her history that is judged irrelevant to being who she is.

OP posts:
Lexibletheflexible · 04/11/2026 22:02

Thelnebriati · 03/11/2026 22:14

An example of a social consequence - although its the male gamete that determines the sex of the offspring (you don't need a biology degree to understand that we aren't clones), women are blamed if they don't produce a son.
I've said this before but if gender roles were biological they would be innate and consistent throughout time and across cultures.

Obviously now, where people understand that the sperm determines the sex of the baby, we don't still blame women for not having a son.

However, even the past, this thing where women were blamed for infertility and/or not producing a male child wasn't universal. In some cultures, they always assumed the man was the one with the issue in such cases, or they looked to outside factors like someone else cursing the family.

StealthTroublemaker · 04/11/2026 22:11

Lexibletheflexible · 04/11/2026 22:02

Obviously now, where people understand that the sperm determines the sex of the baby, we don't still blame women for not having a son.

However, even the past, this thing where women were blamed for infertility and/or not producing a male child wasn't universal. In some cultures, they always assumed the man was the one with the issue in such cases, or they looked to outside factors like someone else cursing the family.

Ummmm no. It was always the woman’s fault. I mean, just look at Henry the 8th…. In many countries women are still blamed for not producing sons.

Lexibletheflexible · 04/11/2026 22:11

Thehorticulturalhussie · 04/11/2026 15:32

@nicepotoftea I agree and think that we are analysing the phrases used commonly by men who believe that they can become women -
' I live as a woman now'
' I have always felt like a woman'
etc

We may or may not be tomboys when we're young but as puberty looms we become aware of attracting a certain type of attention from boys and men. I was a teen in the early 70s and we suddenly became responsible for not dressing in a way likely to make us seem 'easy', for not being in certain places at certain times, for being kind, for accepting that boys will be boys. Later we would become solely responsible for not getting pregnant.

We make some of the biggest and emotional decisions around our fertility - should I have a baby now or wait until I'm older and risk leaving it too late? Should I abort the unplanned baby I'm currently carrying (unable to anticipate the lifelong guilt and regret)? We are tied to our children for life. Many men do not feel that responsibility when the going gets tough.

At any age we feel fearful when walking down a road in the dark, hearing footsteps close behind. We feel a wave of relief to find that it's a woman who's simply in a hurry.

All of the above shape our lives because we are women and cannot be acquired by men wearing our clothes.

Do you think all women feel that way about pregnancy/fertility/motherhood?

StealthTroublemaker · 04/11/2026 22:14

Lexibletheflexible · 04/11/2026 22:11

Do you think all women feel that way about pregnancy/fertility/motherhood?

Dunno. Why don’t you ask them?

Totallygripped · 04/11/2026 22:15

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 21:55

By coincidence (not really, it's because we are all dealing with the same daft bollocks), I've just drafted a reply on a derailed thread that I think is better posted here which is along a similar, though less historically raging (justifed rage!) lines, inspired by Genderist philosophy along the lines of "sex might be a fact, but it's not a fact of any consequence until observed"...

Which is true (if one considers "experienced" to be within the meanings of observed in this context) but also facile. Because ones sex is almost always observed at birth and many times after by ones parents who both react to it and speak of it to other people who also react to it, and so becomes part of ones own self knowledge "girl is what I am" , and through that ones understanding that I am in certain ways like these people (be they real or fictional) but not like those people, way before one has any critical framework in which to place that.

What the facile analysis misses is that each instant of a life is not isolated from the rest of life, nor from the culture in which it is lived. The person who believes himself a woman now has a totally different relationship to that idea than the woman who grew from a girl her whole life within the knowledge and others knowledge of her.

So the facile view looks at two adults now, one with real female breasts and one with some augmented addition to mimic them (or pick another measure from the Genderist big box of what makes a woman, the logic is the same), and says "but these people both have a feature of womanhood, who knows what gametes they may or may not produce but we can all see the breasts, we react to them as people with breasts, how are they not both more alike than different?" erasing the history and journey of both people through lives shaped very differently by their sexed experiences to be at that moment.

In the facile view both are merely tye surface, but the woman reduced most of all because it is her history that is judged irrelevant to being who she is.

Edited

Absolutely. I am, always have been and always will be a natal female. And no neurocognitive recognition bla bla involved. A bloke having his "egg cracked" in an apparent epiphany will never know what that means. And no amount of surgery be it genital or facial, or hormones will change that. They do seem to retain the ability to "mansplain" though. And as for the "handmaidens"...

Lexibletheflexible · 04/11/2026 22:18

StealthTroublemaker · 04/11/2026 22:11

Ummmm no. It was always the woman’s fault. I mean, just look at Henry the 8th…. In many countries women are still blamed for not producing sons.

So you read my post which spoke about other cultures, and then referenced a King of England. Like the most famous king.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 22:22

Lexibletheflexible · 04/11/2026 22:11

Do you think all women feel that way about pregnancy/fertility/motherhood?

Do you think none do?

OP posts:
StealthTroublemaker · 04/11/2026 22:22

Lexibletheflexible · 04/11/2026 22:18

So you read my post which spoke about other cultures, and then referenced a King of England. Like the most famous king.

But then mentioned other cultures…. Now go go, give one culture where the man is always blamed….

Lexibletheflexible · 04/11/2026 22:30

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 22:22

Do you think none do?

No, but I think it's very much tied to the desire to become a parent by becoming pregnant and having a baby. Like all of those things together. The bio part was very important to me but some people seem to be all for the parent bit and less concerned about the bio bit.

So I don't think it's universal to all women. Similarly, I think that the decision not to have children is equally monumental for men and women.

Lexibletheflexible · 04/11/2026 22:32

StealthTroublemaker · 04/11/2026 22:22

But then mentioned other cultures…. Now go go, give one culture where the man is always blamed….

I'm not sure why you're talking to me like that. If you want a discussion, ask for details respectfully.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 22:38

Lexibletheflexible · 04/11/2026 22:30

No, but I think it's very much tied to the desire to become a parent by becoming pregnant and having a baby. Like all of those things together. The bio part was very important to me but some people seem to be all for the parent bit and less concerned about the bio bit.

So I don't think it's universal to all women. Similarly, I think that the decision not to have children is equally monumental for men and women.

For some men, yes, and probably some women aren't so bothered.

But society certainly frames women's decisions here as more central to her life and purpose than to those of men, and that does affect us (and them).

And certainly no man has to deal with the impact of pregnancy on his body, nor consider trade offs of more or less invasive forms of reversible contraception.

OP posts:
Lexibletheflexible · 04/11/2026 22:45

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 22:38

For some men, yes, and probably some women aren't so bothered.

But society certainly frames women's decisions here as more central to her life and purpose than to those of men, and that does affect us (and them).

And certainly no man has to deal with the impact of pregnancy on his body, nor consider trade offs of more or less invasive forms of reversible contraception.

I think varies among different cultures. In my husband's family, the older relatives would assume a man who doesn't want kids is probably gay or suffered terrible abuse. Not that different in my Irish family tbh.

I agree that if you have a baby, there are many social consequences that men do not face as well as medical risk

ScrollingLeaves · 04/11/2026 23:22

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/11/2026 21:55

By coincidence (not really, it's because we are all dealing with the same daft bollocks), I've just drafted a reply on a derailed thread that I think is better posted here which is along a similar, though less historically raging (justifed rage!) lines, inspired by Genderist philosophy along the lines of "sex might be a fact, but it's not a fact of any consequence until observed"...

Which is true (if one considers "experienced" to be within the meanings of observed in this context) but also facile. Because ones sex is almost always observed at birth and many times after by ones parents who both react to it and speak of it to other people who also react to it, and so becomes part of ones own self knowledge "girl is what I am" , and through that ones understanding that I am in certain ways like these people (be they real or fictional) but not like those people, way before one has any critical framework in which to place that.

What the facile analysis misses is that each instant of a life is not isolated from the rest of life, nor from the culture in which it is lived. The person who believes himself a woman now has a totally different relationship to that idea than the woman who grew from a girl her whole life within the knowledge and others knowledge of her.

So the facile view looks at two adults now, one with real female breasts and one with some augmented addition to mimic them (or pick another measure from the Genderist big box of what makes a woman, the logic is the same), and says "but these people both have a feature of womanhood, who knows what gametes they may or may not produce but we can all see the breasts, we react to them as people with breasts, how are they not both more alike than different?" erasing the history and journey of both people through lives shaped very differently by their sexed experiences to be at that moment.

In the facile view both are merely tye surface, but the woman reduced most of all because it is her history that is judged irrelevant to being who she is.

Edited

You are so right thank you for making it clear.