Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

Sandie Peggie: Employment Tribunal, associated legal claims, and related matters - thread #69

23 replies

nauticant · 03/11/2026 07:50

Sandie Peggie, a nurse at Victoria Hospital in Kirkcaldy (VH), brought claims in the employment tribunal against her employer; Fife Health Board (the Board) and another employee, Dr B Upton. Ms Peggie’s claims were of sexual harassment, harassment related to a protected belief, indirect discrimination and victimisation. Dr Upton claimed to be a transwoman, that is observed as male at birth but asserting a female gender identity.

The Employment Tribunal hearing started on Monday 3 February 2025 and after a prolonged process, judgment was handed down on 8 December 2025. That judgment is being appealed and an appeal hearing is expected to take place in 2027.

A second Employment Tribunal, Sandie Peggie vs Royal College of Nursing, was heard from Wednesday 23 September 2026 to Thursday 1 October 2026. Judgment was handed down on 2 November 2026.

Additional legal claims have been raised. Sandie Peggie is taking action against three senior managers who were witnesses in the first Employment Tribunal - Dr Kate Searle, Dr Maggie Currer and Esther Davidson, against Carol Potter, the chief executive of NHS Fife, for victimisation, against NHS Fife for discrimination, and against its director of people and culture David Miller for harassment. In addition, Sandie Peggie is being investigated by the Nursing and Midwifery Council over fitness to practice.

The past proceedings were live tweeted by www.x.com/tribunaltweets. Tribunal Tweets are likely to be providing coverage in future proceedings. There's additional information on Tribunal Tweets' substack: www.tribunaltweets.substack.com/.

Links to previous threads #1 to #60 can be found in this thread: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5379717-sandie-peggie-list-of-threads-covering-employment-tribunal-and-afterwards

Thread 61: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5472628-sandie-peggie-vs-nhs-fife-health-board-and-dr-beth-upton-following-employment-tribunal-judgment-thread-61 8 January 2026 to 3 August 2026

Thread 62: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5562302-sandie-peggie-vs-nhs-fife-health-board-and-dr-beth-upton-following-employment-tribunal-judgment-thread-62 3 August 2026 to 24 September 2026

Thread 63: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5581909-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-63 24 September 2026 to 27 September 2026

Thread 64: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5583133-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-64 27 September 2026 to 29 September 2026

Thread 65: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5583663-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-65 29 September 2026 to 30 September 2026

Thread 66: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5584074-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-66 30 September 2026 to 1 October 2026

Thread 67: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5584523-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-67 1 October 2026 to 6 October 2026

Thread 68: www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5585414-sandie-peggie-employment-tribunal-associated-legal-claims-and-related-matters-thread-68 4 October 2026 to 3 November 2026

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
prh47bridge · Today 08:41

I cannot see that they will succeed in getting the third claim (Carol Potter and David Miller) thrown out completely as it is mainly about the infamous press statement. Res judicata stops you from relitigating a claim after a final judgment. It cannot be used to stop you from taking action over victimisation that occurred after your original claim was largely heard.

They stand a better chance with the second claim as the courts often treat an employer and its senior managers as sharing a "privity of interest". However, section 110 of the Equality Act allows employees to be held liable as well as their employer and strict res judicata requires the parties to be identical. Also, as the original judgment is still subject to appeal, I would expect the tribunal to be cautious about striking out these claims at this stage.

I would be very surprised if NHS Fife succeed in getting both claims struck out completely. I would hope that Sandie is allowed to take the claims forward in full, but it is possible this will be a split decision with Sandy allowed to take some parts of her claims forward but other parts being struck out.

MyAmpleSheep · Today 04:04

I believe she was refused permission to add ED, KS and MC as defendants to the previous case (when it became clear through disclosure that they were at fault) on the grounds that she could institute separate proceedings against them. It doesn't see fair now to say she can't.

HannahinHampshire · Today 01:24

https://www.thecourier.co.uk/fp/politics/5621164/nhs-fife-sandie-peggie-boot-out-claims/
I don’t think the share token always works so here’s the text -

NHS Fife is attempting to have two further Sandie Peggie legal claims booted out by arguing the case has already been decided, according to the trans row tribunal nurse’s team.
Ms Peggie took the health board to an employment tribunal last year over a 2023 changing room altercation with trans doctor Beth Upton, born male, which concluded with a ruling in December last year.
Judge Sandie Kemp found the Kirkcaldy Victoria Hospital nurse had been harassed by the health board over its botched handling of the aftermath.
Further allegations of discrimination and victimisation were rejected while all claims against Dr Upton were dismissed.
While Ms Peggie was awaiting that ruling, which is now under appeal, she launched another two claims against NHS Fife chiefs and several former colleagues.

In August 2025, legal proceedings were raised against the health board and three senior managers – Esther Davidson, Dr Kate Searle and Dr Maggie Currer.
A third case was launched last November against the health board’s retired former chief executive Carol Potter, director of people and culture David Miller and NHS Fife itself.

But Ms Peggie’s advisers claim the organisation wants the two cases thrown out at preliminary hearings this Friday and next Tuesday where arguments from both legal teams will be heard.
We have asked NHS Fife for comment.
NHS Fife argue ‘res judicata’
It’s claimed the health board believes Ms Peggie’s cases are not competent due to being ‘res judicata’, meaning a decision was already made in the previous tribunal involving the respondents.
But her legal team disputes this and argues that the parties central to the latest claims are different from those at the original tribunal.
The Glenrothes nurse is accusing NHS Fife of direct discrimination due to her “sex realist” beliefs, as well as harassment and victimisation.

She is claiming victimisation against Ms Potter over a controversial 1,700-word media statement by the health board in July 2025 at the height of the dispute
Ms Peggie also alleges victimisation and harassment against the three senior managers and harassment against Mr Miller.
Earlier this month, Ms Peggie lost a tribunal case against her trade union, the Royal College of Nurses (RCN).
She had sued the union over what she deemed to be a lack of support following her suspension by NHS Fife during the investigation into her altercation with Dr Upton.

EXCLUSIVE: NHS Fife accused of trying to boot out latest Sandie Peggie tribunal claims

Two hearings will be held in the coming days to determine if the Kirkcaldy hospital nurse has a case.

https://www.thecourier.co.uk/fp/politics/5621164/nhs-fife-sandie-peggie-boot-out-claims/

MyrtleLion · 11/11/2026 21:15

Currently claimants are not forced to have Early Reconciliation with ACAS. They have to enter the process, but they can withdraw before any meetings happen or offer is made and they get a certificate saying they attempted it. I think they must be forced to go through the process and then if they reject the outcome or the parties are at an impasse, then they progress.

I have heard of a significant case where the complainant entered then withdrew almost the next day and the employer is now forced to go to Tribunal without being in a position to try and reconcile. The complainant is still employed but the hearings are not for another year.

It can't be acceptable to not try at all.

Peregrina · 11/11/2026 20:55

What it means is that you didn't deliberately waste the time (and therefore money) of the other side by avoiding your disclosure responsibilities, changing your story, and so forth.

Many of us would argue that this was exactly what NHS Fife was doing.

Peregrina · 11/11/2026 20:54

One thing I noticed from the woman who had to take her own complex case to the ET was how quickly the Trade Union fell by the wayside. I was going to say, "where have we heard that before", but the better question would be, "how often have we heard that before"?

nauticant · 11/11/2026 18:19

Yes, you'd be looking at something very much worse case. Plus the extra unluckiness of encountering a vindictive judge. As we've seen, some judges can stray far from what might be expected.

OP posts:
MyAmpleSheep · 11/11/2026 18:14

My understanding is that it is exceptional for a good faith litigant at the ET to have a costs award against them if they lose. This is precisely to prevent people from being dissuaded from taking up a claim against their employer.

Good faith doesn't mean judged by the standard of the employer - obviously, everyone who loses at a tribunal can say the other side was wrong and therefore not acting in good faith. It's not even about some hidden purpose to the action: it's often said that SP has brought her cases not in good faith because she wants to prove some wider point. That's not bad faith. What it means is that you didn't deliberately waste the time (and therefore money) of the other side by avoiding your disclosure responsibilities, changing your story, and so forth.

If your status as a litigant in person, ignorant of the rules of evidence, ignorant of how a solicitor has to be fair to the court (and you're not) means that you cost the other side more money than if you had representation, that's a fair thing to consider in costs. But I don't think there's a magic formula that having representation means you follow, and representing yourself means you don't. You have to do the work, and act responsibly. If you do, you should be fine.

HydrangeaFig · 11/11/2026 17:53

nauticant · 11/11/2026 16:46

A quick summary of the parts most relevant to this thread:

Going into an ET means entering a complex arena and complex area of law. You really should have legal representation. If your case has some complexity, you might be looking at your own costs being around £100,000.

If you as an employee go into an ET without representation you're likely to lose. However, if things were to go really bad for you, you could be looking at, very unusually, being hit with the employer's costs. See the £100,000 figure above.

There are terrible delays. If you file a claim today you could be looking at being heard in 2030.

This means that the ET system isn't fit for purpose. One solution might be to have a two-track system, simple cases within the existing framework and more complex cases being more like the High Court.

As you say, it is unusual for a losing claimant to have costs awarded against them. And when a judge does award costs it is often for only a proportion of the Respondent's costs. Judges can also take a Claimant's ability to pay into account when awarding costs.

nauticant · 11/11/2026 16:46

A quick summary of the parts most relevant to this thread:

Going into an ET means entering a complex arena and complex area of law. You really should have legal representation. If your case has some complexity, you might be looking at your own costs being around £100,000.

If you as an employee go into an ET without representation you're likely to lose. However, if things were to go really bad for you, you could be looking at, very unusually, being hit with the employer's costs. See the £100,000 figure above.

There are terrible delays. If you file a claim today you could be looking at being heard in 2030.

This means that the ET system isn't fit for purpose. One solution might be to have a two-track system, simple cases within the existing framework and more complex cases being more like the High Court.

OP posts:
nauticant · 11/11/2026 15:05

Of general interest about ETs on Radio 4, started a few minutes ago:

https://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0033zgd

How employment law changes could affect you

Workers' rights across Great Britain have just changed as more of the Employment Rights Act 2025 comes into force. But what does it mean for workers and their employers?

OP posts:
DrBlackbird · 10/11/2026 23:10

Following

NoWordForFluffy · 10/11/2026 20:04

Reminds me of this...

Bill Murray Well Its Groundhog Day Again GIF
Peregrina · 10/11/2026 16:28

I sincerely hope that this same person doesn't bother to come back to say exactly the same things again on this thread.

WFTCHTJ · 10/11/2026 16:04

In fairness a significant chunk of the last couple of threads has been certain people wanging on repeatedly.

AMansAManForAllThat · 10/11/2026 15:47

#69! I pop in at intervals as life doesn’t allow me to pay the same attention as when this started. 68 threads ago!

SlackJawedDisbeliefXY · 10/11/2026 15:42

prh47bridge · 10/11/2026 15:26

@SlackJawedDisbeliefXY - FPT, I am sure you will be amazed to hear that there is still no GC merchandise available from RCN.

Wha.. what? but they ... said

prh47bridge · 10/11/2026 15:26

@SlackJawedDisbeliefXY - FPT, I am sure you will be amazed to hear that there is still no GC merchandise available from RCN.

Kirschcherries · 10/11/2026 13:20

@nauticant I think the latest judgement has helped us run of steam for a while.

Enjoy the peace.

nauticant · 10/11/2026 13:14

I regret to inform the thread that since the team failed to meet the target set out on thread #68, the planned distribution of bonus hampers will not be occurring.

OP posts:
Ereshkigalangcleg · 10/11/2026 13:13

Brilliant, new thread now the other one has filled up.

AlwaysExtraHot · 10/11/2026 12:37

Thank you for the thread

nauticant · 03/11/2026 07:52

Please would posters continue to post on thread #68 until that one's full before posting on here. Thanks.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread