Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions
Thread gallery
13
Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 07:54

CoolforKats · 29/10/2026 07:52

Cope. The author specifically states it doesn't prove anything about offending patterns of TW. You know more than her about her own work do you?

Additionally, the study was not focused on investigating criminal behaviour, was drawn from a small cohort in one country, and only indicated a statistically significant increased risk of conviction for trans people who ‘underwent sex reassignment before 1989’:[3] a time when fewer opportunities and resources were available to trans people in Sweden, which may have resulted in increased criminalisation in a similar manner to other stigmatised groups

The Swedish study did not show that group of male people had a rate of committing crime at the same or lower than the general female rate of committing crime.

cryupmykingdom · 29/10/2026 08:04

SidewaysOtter · 28/10/2026 23:10

I will admit to not knowing an awful lot about Marxism beyond having copy of Das Kapital around somewhere but never having got round to reading it.

What would you say would be the reason for Marxists or other communists having a crap attitude to women? Surely if they’re standing for the oppressed and downtrodden that includes women by default, given historical western patriarchal attitudes? Is it a “support human for the men doing the political work” thing? Or just good old patriarchy in another guise, where the men in question are using their politics as a way of keeping their privileges while pretending they’re absolutely not doing anything of the sort? A kind of gender version of Engels’ “working class aristocracy”?

Because lord knows those attitudes still seem prevalent today.

Probably just a rephrasing of what I wrote . . . that they only pay attention to their politics and think that's helping people enough, so that they don't ever bother to look at or question their personal behavior ?

Or maybe the ethos just attracts slimebuckets since it talks about 'disrupting or overthrowing traditional values' ie, it's going to attract those who like the idea of there not being any moral standards to live up to?

I'm not an expert on them by any means. I think Marxism is a legitimate and distinct thing, but it didn't ever remotely tempt me. Perhaps I was too embedded in a Catholic worldview.

LouisTheYardTeacher · 29/10/2026 08:05

There's no reliable evidence that trans women pose a risk to cis women. In fact research in jurisdictions where laws changed to enable them access showed no increase in reports of offending.

You're talking about the Massachusetts study and what it actually showed was that police call outs remained level after the law changed- whereas you would expect them to drop significantly if males just being in women's spaces was no longer illegal.

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 08:06

It is also not just about physical risk to safety. There are many types of harms that female people need female single sex provisions to be safeguarded against:

Harms include:
-Rape and sexual assault.
-Violence.
-Sexual abuse that is not rape or sexual assault.
-Sexual abuse that also includes solo sexual acts or using the experience in future sexual acts.
-Any other abuse that may include verbal abuse, intimidation in any way etc, this includes inappropriate questions and comments.
-A male person's presence where female people need privacy and dignity.
-A male person's presence where female people need to feel safe from any male person's presence (over the age of about 8 years old).
-Female people self-excluding knowing that there may be a male person accessing that provision.
-Female people not having the freedom to discuss the issues that cause them distress, concern, or that they need to talk about because a male person is present.
-Female children (and female adults) learning to have no or too low personal boundaries because they have been taught that male people are female people and that they should ignore and overcome feelings of discomfort.

Narrowing the discussion to sex and violence offences does not remove these other harms from consideration for female single sex spaces and vice versa.

They are all important.

Of course, one of those harms is any type of physical assault.

This is from the latest IOC policy.

Magnitude of Advantage: At the elite level, the magnitude of the Male performance advantage is different depending on the sport or event:

There is a 10-12 per cent Male performance advantage in most running and swimming events.

There is a 20+ per cent Male performance advantage in most throwing and jumping events.

The Male performance advantage can be greater than 100 per cent in events that involve explosive power, e.g. in collision, lifting and punching sports.

Here is the statement:

https://www.olympics.com/ioc/news/international-olympic-committee-announces-new-policy-on-the-protection-of-the-female-women-s-category-in-olympic-sport

here is the policy

https://stillmed.olympics.com/media/Documents/International-Olympic-Committee/EB/policy/policy-on-the-protection-of-the-female-category-english.pdf

I can link you up to the reviews that the IOC drew on to make this statement. By the way, I can also link up the now many reviews for boys having greater power than girls from the age of 7 years old too.

It is not just sexual assault as you seem to focus on. It is also any violent act at all while they are in the female single sex space.

Of course, it is also not just violence, the risk of harm includes many other aspects too.

There really is no change significant enough to move a male person with a transgender identity out of the male category for safeguarding considerations. They remain male and like all male people are subject to exclusion based on being a male person. No other groups of male people get exemption from being regarded as having the same risk of harming female people as the general male population.

Male people with transgender identities remain part of the male population for the purpose of making safeguarding decisions for the safety, privacy and dignity of female people.

CoolforKats · 29/10/2026 08:32

BackToLurk · 29/10/2026 07:45

The Waldner-Haugrud study is small and suffers from problems in methodology, not least its reliance on snowball sampling. That aside, later studies have found the reverse. Most significantly Henderson (2003) which was U.K. based, larger and found that gay men were more likely to be victims of domestic abuse than lesbians. All these studies centre on domestic abuse and there may be issues anyway around male reluctance to disclose. Overall unreliable and inconsistent.

The second study is largely concerned with patterns of offending in different types of men and women - gay men offend less than straight men - rather than between gay people. The Beaver et al study referenced is the only piece of research that showed any sign that lesbians commit violent (note, not sexual) offences at a higher rate than gay men. However, this too has its problems. The research doesn’t show the same results across all 4 cohorts studied, with the cohort considered to be the most reliable in terms of accuracy of sexuality (wave 4) not showing a higher offending rate. The research is also self-reported delinquency rates rather than hard crime data.

As a whole, and certainly in relation to both the U.K. and sexual violence, there is no significant body of robust, reliable data that consistently shows lesbians commit more violent offences than gay men. To repeat and stress one statistic again. The total number of female inmates in the U.K. is less than the total (based on research) of gay men alone imprisoned in the U.K.

The sound of rationalising the data away.

The Waldner-Haugrud study is small and suffers from problems in methodology, not least its reliance on snowball sampling.

Small studies in conjuction with other studies show reproducibility of results so that's irrelevant. Please link to where this study relies on snow ball sampling.

That aside, later studies have found the reverse. Most significantly Henderson (2003) which was U.K. based, larger and found that gay men were more likely to be victims of domestic abuse than lesbians.

Its a study where the results haven't been reproduced.

All these studies centre on domestic abuse and there may be issues anyway around male reluctance to disclose. Overall unreliable and inconsistent.

Nevertheless the point is that depending on the group violence isn't exclusively male dominant. See domestic violence & child abuse as exampless.

The second study is largely concerned with patterns of offending in different types of men and women - gay men offend less than straight men - rather than between gay people.

Among females, lesbians (including only a few females with exclusively homosexual preferences) were generally more criminal and violent than heterosexuals, although they were still less so than males (except for homosexual males). Results suggest that some important differences may exist among both sexes regarding relationships between sexual orientations and criminal/violent behavior.

The Beaver et al study referenced is the only piece of research that showed any sign that lesbians commit violent (note, not sexual) offences at a higher rate than gay men. However, this too has its problems. The research doesn’t show the same results across all 4 cohorts studied, with the cohort considered to be the most reliable in terms of accuracy of sexuality (wave 4) not showing a higher offending rate.

Why is this more reliable?

The research is also self-reported delinquency rates rather than hard crime data.

Hard crime data doesn't show offending patterns only reporting & incarcerations….not the same thing. Offending being the most reliable metric relies on surveys. Its how we know most rapes of women aren't reported.

The total number of female inmates in the U.K. is less than the total (based on research) of gay men alone imprisoned in the U.K.

Violent crime comparison? Please link. In any case, incarceration is not offending & as the link on child abuse upthread shows most crimes are not reported & women get more lenient sentences anyway.

CoolforKats · 29/10/2026 08:34

LouisTheYardTeacher · 29/10/2026 08:05

There's no reliable evidence that trans women pose a risk to cis women. In fact research in jurisdictions where laws changed to enable them access showed no increase in reports of offending.

You're talking about the Massachusetts study and what it actually showed was that police call outs remained level after the law changed- whereas you would expect them to drop significantly if males just being in women's spaces was no longer illegal.

You are confused. Its trans women not cis men that were no longer illegal.

CoolforKats · 29/10/2026 08:35

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 07:54

The Swedish study did not show that group of male people had a rate of committing crime at the same or lower than the general female rate of committing crime.

It showed no comparison so we don't know is the point.

CoolforKats · 29/10/2026 08:38

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 07:53

I think it is always important to go back to the original source, which says this:

”Criminal activity, particularly violent crime, is much more common among men than women in the general population. A previous study of all applications for sex reassignment in Sweden up to 1992 found that 9.7% of male-to-female and 6.1% of female-to-male applicants had been prosecuted for a crime. Crime after sex reassignment, however, has not previously been studied. In this study, male-to-female individuals had a higher risk for criminal convictions compared to female controls but not compared to male controls. This suggests that the sex reassignment procedure neither increased nor decreased the risk for criminal offending in male-to-females. “

Rape was not studied and yet this interviewer asked Dhejne specifically to confirm rape statistics. Of course the fucking answer will be ‘no, we didn’t measure that’. It was also irrelevant because the study shows a general pattern of criminality and specifically ‘violent’ crime.

safeguarding decisions are not based on only rape statistics so this focus on it is not actually proving the point the some male people should be included in female single sex provisions over 8 years old. However, the prisoner statistics show part of the decision making critieria - which is that risk that cannot be ignored.

And again, the Swedish study did not show that group of male people had a rate of committing crime at the same or lower than the general female rate of committing crime. Meaning they should not be considered ‘female’ at all for crime risk assessment.

It was also irrelevant because the study shows a general pattern of criminality and specifically ‘violent’ crime.

No it does not according to the author given the context.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 29/10/2026 08:41

For some reason, I'm reminded of cigarette manufacturers in the 60s and 70s, and oil producers in the 90s and early 00s standing firm against all the studies showing what they were doing was very likely to be causing harm (in these cases great harm) because exact mechanisms of casual connection for each and every strongly correlated onservation hadn't been proved yet.

Meanwhile, tumours still grew. The planet still heated.

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 08:44

CoolforKats · 28/10/2026 21:51

Ok lets play 'within the group'

'Within the group' more lesbians commit violent offences that gay men. Does that mean lesbian offending is representative of all women now?

You walked straight into that one.

How many female people attack other female people is actually irrelevant for the discussion of safeguarding female people from a safety, privacy and dignity point of view and the need for legitimate discrimination that allows sex segregation.

Excluding a group of female people from a female prison based on the protected characteristic of sexual orientation would be illegitimate discrimination.

Excluding a group of male people from a female prison based on a protected characteristic of being male people is a legitimate discrimination. For that purpose, the group's (ie: male people) risk of harm has been analysed looking at a range of harms that male people can inflict on female people and found that no group of male people should not be included in that blanket exclusion.

Shedmistress · 29/10/2026 08:45

If there is someone walking round their bedroom/the world thinking that lesbians are the real problem because a study showed this to be true then I really don't know where they go from there.

I prefer the real world thanks.

BackToLurk · 29/10/2026 08:51

CoolforKats · 29/10/2026 08:32

The sound of rationalising the data away.

The Waldner-Haugrud study is small and suffers from problems in methodology, not least its reliance on snowball sampling.

Small studies in conjuction with other studies show reproducibility of results so that's irrelevant. Please link to where this study relies on snow ball sampling.

That aside, later studies have found the reverse. Most significantly Henderson (2003) which was U.K. based, larger and found that gay men were more likely to be victims of domestic abuse than lesbians.

Its a study where the results haven't been reproduced.

All these studies centre on domestic abuse and there may be issues anyway around male reluctance to disclose. Overall unreliable and inconsistent.

Nevertheless the point is that depending on the group violence isn't exclusively male dominant. See domestic violence & child abuse as exampless.

The second study is largely concerned with patterns of offending in different types of men and women - gay men offend less than straight men - rather than between gay people.

Among females, lesbians (including only a few females with exclusively homosexual preferences) were generally more criminal and violent than heterosexuals, although they were still less so than males (except for homosexual males). Results suggest that some important differences may exist among both sexes regarding relationships between sexual orientations and criminal/violent behavior.

The Beaver et al study referenced is the only piece of research that showed any sign that lesbians commit violent (note, not sexual) offences at a higher rate than gay men. However, this too has its problems. The research doesn’t show the same results across all 4 cohorts studied, with the cohort considered to be the most reliable in terms of accuracy of sexuality (wave 4) not showing a higher offending rate.

Why is this more reliable?

The research is also self-reported delinquency rates rather than hard crime data.

Hard crime data doesn't show offending patterns only reporting & incarcerations….not the same thing. Offending being the most reliable metric relies on surveys. Its how we know most rapes of women aren't reported.

The total number of female inmates in the U.K. is less than the total (based on research) of gay men alone imprisoned in the U.K.

Violent crime comparison? Please link. In any case, incarceration is not offending & as the link on child abuse upthread shows most crimes are not reported & women get more lenient sentences anyway.

The Henderson study reflects the findings of the findings of the National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey: 2010. That study was often cited by MRAs like yourself as suggesting that there was more violence in lesbian relationships. However it was self-reported and included previous intimate male partners of women who subsequently formed lesbian relationships. When these were removed the gay men reported slightly more violence.

I don’t have access to the full details of the second study and was going by the section you replicated when you first referenced it. Which wasn’t relevant.

I don’t know why you are querying the reliability of Beaver. Again you referenced it.

I suggest you try and understand the studies you reference

BackToLurk · 29/10/2026 08:53

Shedmistress · 29/10/2026 08:45

If there is someone walking round their bedroom/the world thinking that lesbians are the real problem because a study showed this to be true then I really don't know where they go from there.

I prefer the real world thanks.

It’s the MRA ‘gotcha’. Unfortunately for them it’s only found in a very small number of studies, is contradicted in others and isn’t reflected in the real world. The one everyone else inhabits.

nutmeg7 · 29/10/2026 08:54

BackToLurk · 28/10/2026 22:48

I assume he meant ‘gay people’. There is no robust, reliable data that shows lesbians commit more violent and sexual crimes than gay men though, so he needn’t have bothered.

I think I remember where this came from and is often misread by those with poor comprehension.

It was lesbians being more prone to violent acts than heterosexual women. And gay men being less prone to commit violence than straight men.

But nevertheless, gay men were still much more prone to commit violence than lesbians.

I’ve seen it cited as Kats did when a cursory reading showed it didn’t say what was claimed, it was just a comprehension problem on the part of those desperate to pretend there are not very clear stats dividing male and female interns of propensity to violence.

BackToLurk · 29/10/2026 08:55

As for’ rationalising the data’

In any case, incarceration is not offending & as the link on child abuse upthread shows most crimes are not reported & women get more lenient sentences anyway.

These are not serious people.

cryupmykingdom · 29/10/2026 09:03

BackToLurk · 29/10/2026 08:51

The Henderson study reflects the findings of the findings of the National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey: 2010. That study was often cited by MRAs like yourself as suggesting that there was more violence in lesbian relationships. However it was self-reported and included previous intimate male partners of women who subsequently formed lesbian relationships. When these were removed the gay men reported slightly more violence.

I don’t have access to the full details of the second study and was going by the section you replicated when you first referenced it. Which wasn’t relevant.

I don’t know why you are querying the reliability of Beaver. Again you referenced it.

I suggest you try and understand the studies you reference

>I suggest you try and understand the studies you reference

I think his strategy is just to fling lots of dung and hope some of it sticks. He doesn't seem to have much comprehension of any of it, there's never any follow-up.

Reminds me of the line 'the roving bowel shits, and having shat, doth move on.'

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 09:06

lenient sentences

I remember in answer to something Howse said right back last year about sentencing and persecution of people with transgender identities in the justice system I followed a list of cases up on their conviction decisions and their outcomes. It was really remarkable how many male people with transgender identities pled and were given leniency in their conviction outcomes. Too many of those who got leniency went on to commit a further crime that they were also then convicted for.

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 09:09

cryupmykingdom · 29/10/2026 09:03

>I suggest you try and understand the studies you reference

I think his strategy is just to fling lots of dung and hope some of it sticks. He doesn't seem to have much comprehension of any of it, there's never any follow-up.

Reminds me of the line 'the roving bowel shits, and having shat, doth move on.'

Often the poster simply plops down a self appointed media spokesperson's opinion which is full of misrepresentations and misinformation.

The same links are posted over and over when they have been shown to not really address the point under discussion or they discuss the point but very poorly and the poster believes they have posted some kind of gotcha.

The same pattern over the past year.

EdithStourton · 29/10/2026 09:11

I note Kats has ignored my point that women, many/most of whom have experienced sexual assault from a man/men, don't want any man in places where they are in a state of undress.

Because you can't tell by looking who is likely to come at you.

So we don't want ANY of them, even if they call themselves women, in there.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 29/10/2026 09:18

FlirtsWithRhinos · 29/10/2026 08:41

For some reason, I'm reminded of cigarette manufacturers in the 60s and 70s, and oil producers in the 90s and early 00s standing firm against all the studies showing what they were doing was very likely to be causing harm (in these cases great harm) because exact mechanisms of casual connection for each and every strongly correlated onservation hadn't been proved yet.

Meanwhile, tumours still grew. The planet still heated.

How true. I read this article this morning in the Times about Meta senior executives plotting to discredit Jonathan Haidt (author of the powerful book the Anxious Generation about the negative impact social media has on mental health of children). They wanted to “enrage” the scientific community and turn them against him. This has been revealed in a US law suit.

I'd suggest the article has significant parallels with how extreme transactivists use Mumsnet to pursue their niche anti women, anti child safeguarding views.
Short extract:

"Haidt said he was “not surprised” by Meta’s actions. He said: “It’s a company seemingly determined to keep the truth from coming out, even within its own walls. But the most damning revelation is the lengths that Meta was willing to go to manipulate the scientific process and the scientific community.
“If social manipulation was the heart of their strategy for responding to my writing, that is strong evidence that they had no way to rebut my research.”

It is not clear whether Meta enacted its plans, but Haidt has been the subject of criticism from academics who argue that he is creating a “moral panic” by overstating the causal evidence linking social media and phone use with poor mental health".

Transactivists are watching their power grab unravel as society finally understands the negative impact transactivism has, especially on the young. I'd suggest that what we see on here is likely the intense fury of this powerful lobby who leave no stone unturned to persuade others that those promoting safeguarding and women's rights must be stopped.

https://www.thetimes.com/uk/technology-uk/article/meta-take-down-bestselling-author-mxg50v22d

(sorry - couldn't get an archive link)

Verifying Device

https://www.thetimes.com/uk/technology-uk/article/meta-take-down-bestselling-author-mxg50v22d

DeanElderberry · 29/10/2026 09:20

CoolforKats · 29/10/2026 08:34

You are confused. Its trans women not cis men that were no longer illegal.

Men are men are men are all of them male. Calling themselves transwomen does not change the fact that they are men, and male.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 29/10/2026 09:21

...and can never be women

BackToLurk · 29/10/2026 09:24

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 09:09

Often the poster simply plops down a self appointed media spokesperson's opinion which is full of misrepresentations and misinformation.

The same links are posted over and over when they have been shown to not really address the point under discussion or they discuss the point but very poorly and the poster believes they have posted some kind of gotcha.

The same pattern over the past year.

They ignore many of their own claims (men under report intimate partner violence for example) or simply don’t understand the relevance to other claims they make (rate of violence in gay/lesbian relationships). They ignore the type of crimes - intimate partner violence vs assaults on strangers. They ignore sexual violence.

All of it largely irrelevant anyway as legislation and policy operates at a broad brush not granular level. For very obvious reasons.

Keeptoiletssafe · 29/10/2026 09:25

As like many of you, I post to show the absurdities that people have to go to in trying to justify spaces that have been legislated and regulated by sex for decades and sometimes centuries, instead being based on another undefinable system.

GreyskySexRealistsky · 29/10/2026 09:26

Thank you JKR

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.