Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions
Thread gallery
13
SidewaysOtter · 28/10/2026 23:10

cryupmykingdom · 28/10/2026 20:13

My observation was that university Marxists figured that since they are doing the 'hard yards' in terms of people in the abstract, they have a right to behave like pigs when they meet people in the particular.

If you read biographies of Mao or Lenin or whoever, women always seem to suffer the most. So ... could be another tangible link of Gramsci/Macuse Marxists to their gulag-era ancestors.

I will admit to not knowing an awful lot about Marxism beyond having copy of Das Kapital around somewhere but never having got round to reading it.

What would you say would be the reason for Marxists or other communists having a crap attitude to women? Surely if they’re standing for the oppressed and downtrodden that includes women by default, given historical western patriarchal attitudes? Is it a “support human for the men doing the political work” thing? Or just good old patriarchy in another guise, where the men in question are using their politics as a way of keeping their privileges while pretending they’re absolutely not doing anything of the sort? A kind of gender version of Engels’ “working class aristocracy”?

Because lord knows those attitudes still seem prevalent today.

Datun · 28/10/2026 23:12

I have to say, I almost admire the argument that says we should let in the subset of men who appear to commit even more sex crime than the rest of men, because something that lesbians do.

CoolforKats · 28/10/2026 23:23

BackToLurk · 28/10/2026 21:57

Citation. (If it helps the evidence isn’t ’a higher percentage of female inmates are gay than male inmates’).

"This study explores gender differences in victimization and perpetration experiences of gays and lesbians in intimate relationships. A sample of 283 gays and lesbians reported on their experiences both as victims and perpetrators of gay/lesbian relationship violence by completing a modified version of the Conflict Tactics Scale (Straus, Gelles, & Steinmetz, 1980). General results indicate that 47.5% of lesbians and 29.7% of gays have been victimized by a same-sex partner. Further, lesbians reported an overall perpetration rate of 38% compared to 21.8% for gay men. Other findings were as follows: (1) lesbians were more likely to be classified as victims and perpetrators of violence than gay men; (2) lesbians were more likely to report pushing or being pushed than gay men; (3) lesbians reported experiencing a greater number of different victimization and perpetration tactics than gay men; and finally, (4) when items were weighted to create an indicator of severity, no significant differences between lesbians and gay men were found."

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9403987/

"This study was undertaken to help determine if homosexuals and bisexuals are more or less criminal and/or violent than heterosexuals. Based upon samples of 197 male and 279 female college students, Pearson correlations revealed several significant, but weak, relationships between sexual orientation and most forms of self-reported criminal and/or violent behavior patterns. Among males, the data generally suggested that heterosexuals were more criminal and violent than homosexuals (except in the case of drug offenses), but that bisexuals were more criminal and violent than heterosexuals. Among females, lesbians (including only a few females with exclusively homosexual preferences) were generally more criminal and violent than heterosexuals, although they were still less so than males (except for homosexual males). Results suggest that some important differences may exist among both sexes regarding relationships between sexual orientations and criminal/violent behavior.

A different pattern of findings emerged for the relationship between sexual minority status and crime among males. Gay males appear to display lower levels of physical aggression and criminal behavior as compared to heterosexual males (Ellis et al., 1990; Pinhey & Brown, 2005; Sergeant et al., 2006). Furthermore, sexual minority boys, in contrast to sexual minority girls, did not appear to be overrepresented in the juvenile justice system (Jonnson et al., 2019). Though limited, at least some early evidence suggested that bisexual males tended to report more involvement in violence and crime than heterosexual males (Ellis et al., 1990)."
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/019188699090146I?via%3Dihub

"Similar associations between sexual orientation and delinquency were found in a large national sample of American respondents (Beaver et al., 2016). Bisexual respondents reported the highest levels of involvement in delinquent behavior, followed next by heterosexual males, lesbians, gay males, and heterosexual females. Arguably the most noteworthy finding was that lesbian respondents seemed to be more involved in crime than gay males (Beaver et al., 2016). The novelty here stems from the fact that one of the most replicated findings in behavioral science is sex-differentiated criminal involvement across virtually all crime types (Ellis et al., 2009; Moffitt et al., 2001)."

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10508-024-02902-9#:~:text=A%20different%20pattern%20of%20findings,et%20al.%2C%202016).

Victimization and perpetration rates of violence in gay and lesbian relationships: gender issues explored - PubMed

This study explores gender differences in victimization and perpetration experiences of gays and lesbians in intimate relationships. A sample of 283 gays and lesbians reported on their experiences both as victims and perpetrators of gay/lesbian relatio...

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9403987/

CoolforKats · 28/10/2026 23:32

Mountainlarch · 28/10/2026 21:59

https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0016885
This is a statistically sound paper.
From the analysis of the criminality it concluded: "regarding any crime, male-to-females had a significantly increased risk for crime compared to female controls (aHR 6.6; 95% CI 4.1–10.8) but not compared to males (aHR 0.8; 95% CI 0.5–1.2). This indicates that they retained a male pattern regarding criminality."

I love this episode where the author of the study had to come out & debunk the false representations of her study that was demonstrated in the UK parliament no less. 😂

"Criminality
In response to questions 38 and 39 Prof Freedman referenced “a well-known Swedish study” to imply that patterns of criminality are the same amongst trans women as they are amongst cis (non-trans) men. In her response to Q40 she alleged there were “Swedish studies” (plural). Additionally, Prof Stock referred to “male patterns” when talking about criminal behaviour in her answer to Q26.
I understand the “Swedish study” to be a single 2011 article published by Cecilia Dhejne and colleagues[1], in which the authors reported on mortality, suicidality, psychiatric care and conviction rates among individuals who transitioned in Sweden between 1973 and 2003. This study is widely but inaccurately cited by anti-trans groups on social media as evidence that trans women retain “male patterns” of criminality, an error repeated by Profs Freedman and Stock._
Dhejne herself rejected this interpretation explicitly in an interview with Cristan Williams of TransAdvocate in November 2015[2]. I attach the full relevant extract in Appendix B. A key point she makes is the study is “certainly not saying that we found that trans women were a rape risk” to cis women. Additionally, the study was not focused on investigating criminal behaviour, was drawn from a small cohort in one country, and only indicated a statistically significant increased risk of conviction for trans people who ‘underwent sex reassignment before 1989’:[3] a time when fewer opportunities and resources were available to trans people in Sweden, which may have resulted in increased criminalisation in a similar manner to other stigmatised groups. The authors therefore conclude that the best outcomes occur when individuals also receive long-term health and social care support in addition to any hormone therapy or surgery that they might require."

https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/21023/html/

Myalternate · 28/10/2026 23:38

🤔

Are the trans identifying men that claim to be Lesbian, included anywhere in the stats?

CoolforKats · 28/10/2026 23:42

Myalternate · 28/10/2026 23:38

🤔

Are the trans identifying men that claim to be Lesbian, included anywhere in the stats?

They don't need to be. They are statistically insignificant remember?

And in any case, the point is generalisations about offending aren't meaningful conclusions.

Apollo441 · 28/10/2026 23:55

CoolforKats · 28/10/2026 23:42

They don't need to be. They are statistically insignificant remember?

And in any case, the point is generalisations about offending aren't meaningful conclusions.

Oh so the fact that men commit almost 99% of sex crimes is a meaningless conclusion?
This new learning amazes me!

FFS 🙄

CoolforKats · 29/10/2026 00:00

Apollo441 · 28/10/2026 23:55

Oh so the fact that men commit almost 99% of sex crimes is a meaningless conclusion?
This new learning amazes me!

FFS 🙄

🙄

hall of fame game missed the point GIF
Catiette · 29/10/2026 00:03

CoolforKats · 28/10/2026 20:28

The problem with your thought experiment is it makes exactly the same false equivalence that' JKR's essay does in that it equates generalised crime data that presupposes all groups natal males offend equally (& they don't) with natal women's direct experience with trans women.

You are not only comparing apples & oranges in terms of group offending but also personal experience V data not to mention adding into this sharing a hotel room with a 'stranger' when the context is a busy environment with a locked cubicle.

The lengths you have to go to distort the basic fact that personal experience shapes our fears which JKR admits to herself is breathtaking.

Could I make a recommendation, if you're in good faith? If you break down your challenges to longer posts, your thinking may be clearer.

"False equivalence" and "generalised" don't really work here. It may be that you misunderstand both or that you've an interesting point to make - but without a clearer explanation, it's hard to tell.

"Presupposes... equally" makes a pretty illogical assumption - it's so obvious there are other differentiators here that it's clear my premise is rather that these differentiators have no meaningful bearing in this context. So, again, without more detail, readers wonder whether you haven't realises this - or, instead, don't feel able to tackle the point being made.

In this context, hyperbole like "breathtaking" feels confused, reinforcing a growing impression of misunderstanding.

It's also a bit unclear to which opposing groups your "apples and oranges" refers. If it's males and females, I'd agree, so I'm assuming not that! But if it's males and transwomen, the stats say otherwise, as I think posters have shared elsewhere, or could on request. Alternatively, if it's the significant difference you think class/education etc.(? unsure) makes, as this seems fundamental to quite a few of your posts, why not link these stats and explain their relevance here? Each of these interpretations deserves attention, yet in your post, they all slide by unexamined.

Lastly, what makes you think all public toilets are "busy"? And what's the relevance of this in the context of analogy and extrapolation? This part alone is worth a whole post - thread? - in itself.

My point is, if I really believed in the TRA cause and had the courage of my convictions, I'd take maybe just one of these areas and really lay into that (breathtakingly!) irrational GC post, to show just how badly argued it was. Like, I may explore the relevance of differentiators such as class etc. to safeguarding standards, with reference to stats and hypothetical contexts.

As it is, it's hard to tell if your posts are genuine misunderstanding, or sophistry, or a bit of both - and how serious you are in your posting.

I've said to TRA posters here before - if you're just trying to rile people, have at it: the women (and men) here LOVE sharpening their arguments on blunt comebacks. I think your tone suggests this is what's happening, and while this may make readers wonder about you, it makes no real odds to us.

But if this is your game and you care about trans people, even a little bit, I'd step back, as they deserve good representation.

Or, if you genuinely do want to argue the case well - there is a case to be made! - then maybe break things down a bit. Give us a challenge!

Edited for clarity.

Apollo441 · 29/10/2026 00:08

CoolforKats · 29/10/2026 00:00

🙄

Mate, you are the master of missing the point.

Catiette · 29/10/2026 00:15

CoolforKats · 28/10/2026 21:07

but within those groups men offend more than women.

Prove it. Shows us the data that says elderly men violently offend more than young women or gay men offend more than lesbians ? And keep in mind the massive under reporting of child abuse by women AND the leniency in sentencing.

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-55338745

Within trans offenders the pattern is flipped with ‘transwomen’ committing more violent and sexual offences than ‘transmen’. Can’t imagine why.

Data 101: Statistically insignificant groups can't be measured accurately.

"Between 2016 and 2019, a total of 97 sexual assaults were recorded in women’s prisons, of which seven appeared to be committed by transgender prisoners without a GRC. It is not known whether any were committed by transgender women with a GRC but the number of transgender prisoners with a GRC across all jails is thought to be in single figures.

Holroyde said the statistics were too low and had insufficient detail to provide a safe basis for conclusions, adding: “I can accept, at any rate for present purposes, that the unconditional introduction of a transgender woman into the general population of a women’s prison carries a statistically greater risk of sexual assault upon non-transgender prisoners than would be the case if a non-transgender woman were introduced. But that statistical conclusion takes no account of the risk assessment which the policies require.”

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2021/jul/02/trans-women-with-sex-offence-convictions-in-female-jails-lawful-rules-judge

OK, catching up a bit, that's more like it. But we need arguments to go with it - without this, I'm still not clear what you think.

The whole reliance on differentiators like rich/poor/young/elderly etc. seems to be an argument for dismantling sex-based safeguarding structures in their entirety... which I think takes us decisively back to the need to, as you call it, "generalise" about the male population.

Alternatively, you may be saying transwomen should be excluded from this, in which case 1) do the stats support this and 2) what distinguishes them from other similarly worthy sub-groups of males to justify said exclusion?

Lastly, there's the fundamental issue that you arguing that the available data is inadequate is itself an argument, in safeguarding terms, for not overturning the social contracts, conventions and laws (For Women Scotland) of several generations until we know more.

I'm pretty sure posters will have addressed these issues elsewhere, and I need to go now, but basically, I'd pick a stat and argue it, or pick an argument and "stat" the hell out of it (if the stats are helpful).

Edited because I'm a compulsive editor, procrastinating on the sheer effort of getting myself to bed!

MarcTheGenderSkeptic · 29/10/2026 00:29

This is so much BS. Whatever the rights and wrongs on any individual case, men across the board are more violent than women. Of course you're going to find exceptions, I'm sure there are some very angry lesbians out there and some very placid TIMs.
And of course all of this smoke and mirrors and obfuscating can't cover up that men can't become women. So it's fakery of the highest order to say TIMs are an average benign bunch, they're women really, and thus no biological woman should have any issue with allowing benign women TIMs into their spaces.
It doesn't matter, they're not women, saying they are doesn't make them as benign as the vast majority of women, and women who have issues sharing their spaces with men, or just expect their spaces by definition to be men free zones, shouldn't be obliged to share.
Sure, a heterosexual woman could enter a toilet with a lesbian and be assaulted, but this is immaterial to whether that woman should be obliged to share that toilet with a male, no matter how female they feel, no matter how benign they are.
Again, this sophistry and slicing the onion in stats on risks doesn't get past the first logical hurdle, men can't become women.
And since they can't, these so called "women" share the spectrum of male behaviour patterns.
No matter the rarity of extremes of behaviour contrary to sex based stereotypes and norms.

Keeptoiletssafe · 29/10/2026 01:44

@CoolforKats ‘when the context is a busy environment with a locked cubicle’
Really? Is this all you have in terms of design and women’s safety? No wonder you disappeared for a while when I asked you about the reality and practical designs for toilets.

You now seem to want to develop some sort of principle component analysis equation for each human entering single sex spaces, for example the women’s toilets. How’s that work? Like a barcode listing personal sexual preferences and phenotypes? Do the inputers promise to tell the truth, the whole truth?

How about a human with long hair? A human who wears eyeliner? A human who is famous and flamboyant? A human who liked dressing up, occasionally seen in traditionally women’s clothes? A human who has written he pretended to be gay to be with women and indeed tricked women into thinking he was ‘safe’ and gay? A human who has said ‘yes’ when asked if he likes sexual activity in the toilets and has done it ‘a lot’? Asked why he did not ‘fool around’ in the bar instead of toilets, a human who said: "Because it's better to do these things in private."

All those descriptors are of the same man who was in court yesterday. Would he get a pass to a woman’s toilet if he wanted one?

When the Sexual Offences Act 2003, had a special section on toilets added to it, it was argued this was discriminatory towards men. You can look it up on Hansard.

CoolforKats · 29/10/2026 02:05

Catiette · 29/10/2026 00:03

Could I make a recommendation, if you're in good faith? If you break down your challenges to longer posts, your thinking may be clearer.

"False equivalence" and "generalised" don't really work here. It may be that you misunderstand both or that you've an interesting point to make - but without a clearer explanation, it's hard to tell.

"Presupposes... equally" makes a pretty illogical assumption - it's so obvious there are other differentiators here that it's clear my premise is rather that these differentiators have no meaningful bearing in this context. So, again, without more detail, readers wonder whether you haven't realises this - or, instead, don't feel able to tackle the point being made.

In this context, hyperbole like "breathtaking" feels confused, reinforcing a growing impression of misunderstanding.

It's also a bit unclear to which opposing groups your "apples and oranges" refers. If it's males and females, I'd agree, so I'm assuming not that! But if it's males and transwomen, the stats say otherwise, as I think posters have shared elsewhere, or could on request. Alternatively, if it's the significant difference you think class/education etc.(? unsure) makes, as this seems fundamental to quite a few of your posts, why not link these stats and explain their relevance here? Each of these interpretations deserves attention, yet in your post, they all slide by unexamined.

Lastly, what makes you think all public toilets are "busy"? And what's the relevance of this in the context of analogy and extrapolation? This part alone is worth a whole post - thread? - in itself.

My point is, if I really believed in the TRA cause and had the courage of my convictions, I'd take maybe just one of these areas and really lay into that (breathtakingly!) irrational GC post, to show just how badly argued it was. Like, I may explore the relevance of differentiators such as class etc. to safeguarding standards, with reference to stats and hypothetical contexts.

As it is, it's hard to tell if your posts are genuine misunderstanding, or sophistry, or a bit of both - and how serious you are in your posting.

I've said to TRA posters here before - if you're just trying to rile people, have at it: the women (and men) here LOVE sharpening their arguments on blunt comebacks. I think your tone suggests this is what's happening, and while this may make readers wonder about you, it makes no real odds to us.

But if this is your game and you care about trans people, even a little bit, I'd step back, as they deserve good representation.

Or, if you genuinely do want to argue the case well - there is a case to be made! - then maybe break things down a bit. Give us a challenge!

Edited for clarity.

Edited

The problem with your thought experiment is it makes exactly the same false equivalence that' JKR's essay does in that it equates generalised crime data that presupposes all groups natal males offend equally (& they don't) with natal women's direct experience with trans women.

As I have said multiple times JKR wants to assert that women who don't agree with her in terms of the safety risk trans women pose must be traitorous. She justifies her own 'superior knowledge' on this issue by referencing her personal experiences with cis men whilst at the same time denying the personal experiences of the women with trans women who disagree with her. You can't have it both ways.

She goes on to use generalised crime data (which does not break down group offending) as evidence that their personal experiences with trans women are meaningless.

If you can't see the obvious false equivalence in using data about general male offending against personal experience with trans women I can't help you & at this point you either don't have the cognitive capacity to understand basic logic or are sealioning your way out of this blatant inconsistency.

Oh & your though experiment is a false equivalence unless the contexts match which they don't & weaselling your way around this by pretending public toilets aren't generally very busy places of 'business' hence the consistent queues & justified allegations of reducing availability isn't helping.

CoolforKats · 29/10/2026 02:27

Catiette · 29/10/2026 00:15

OK, catching up a bit, that's more like it. But we need arguments to go with it - without this, I'm still not clear what you think.

The whole reliance on differentiators like rich/poor/young/elderly etc. seems to be an argument for dismantling sex-based safeguarding structures in their entirety... which I think takes us decisively back to the need to, as you call it, "generalise" about the male population.

Alternatively, you may be saying transwomen should be excluded from this, in which case 1) do the stats support this and 2) what distinguishes them from other similarly worthy sub-groups of males to justify said exclusion?

Lastly, there's the fundamental issue that you arguing that the available data is inadequate is itself an argument, in safeguarding terms, for not overturning the social contracts, conventions and laws (For Women Scotland) of several generations until we know more.

I'm pretty sure posters will have addressed these issues elsewhere, and I need to go now, but basically, I'd pick a stat and argue it, or pick an argument and "stat" the hell out of it (if the stats are helpful).

Edited because I'm a compulsive editor, procrastinating on the sheer effort of getting myself to bed!

Edited

The whole reliance on differentiators like rich/poor/young/elderly etc. seems to be an argument for dismantling sex-based safeguarding structures in their entirety... which I think takes us decisively back to the need to, as you call it, "generalise" about the male population.

Not at all. The practical utility of separating toilets because of crowd logistics & different needs (urinals) will always mean its more useful to separate them.

Alternatively, you may be saying transwomen should be excluded from this, in which case 1) do the stats support this and 2) what distinguishes them from other similarly worthy sub-groups of males to justify said exclusion?

There's no reliable evidence that trans women pose a risk to cis women. In fact research in jurisdictions where laws changed to enable them access showed no increase in reports of offending. Trans women are distinguished in that their low numbers don't have any impact on access & there's no evidence of harm.

Lastly, there's the fundamental issue that you arguing that the available data is inadequate is itself an argument, in safeguarding terms, for not overturning the social contracts, conventions and laws (For Women Scotland) of several generations until we know more.

The equality act has been in over ten years where trans women had access to women's toilets & this was never identified as an issue till it became a very recent political football. Prior to that there was no law barring them not to mention many countries in Europe, Scandinavia, Asia, Canada, Australia & half the states of the US have no bans enacted so banning trans women from public toilets is not exactly a social convention. In fact there's no broad group grass roots campaigns to change laws in any of these countries which ought to signal if there's a problem.

Usually how the law works is strong identifiable harms need to be evidenced before prohibition occurs which we don't have evidence of for this issue.

CoolforKats · 29/10/2026 03:47

Keeptoiletssafe · 29/10/2026 01:44

@CoolforKats ‘when the context is a busy environment with a locked cubicle’
Really? Is this all you have in terms of design and women’s safety? No wonder you disappeared for a while when I asked you about the reality and practical designs for toilets.

You now seem to want to develop some sort of principle component analysis equation for each human entering single sex spaces, for example the women’s toilets. How’s that work? Like a barcode listing personal sexual preferences and phenotypes? Do the inputers promise to tell the truth, the whole truth?

How about a human with long hair? A human who wears eyeliner? A human who is famous and flamboyant? A human who liked dressing up, occasionally seen in traditionally women’s clothes? A human who has written he pretended to be gay to be with women and indeed tricked women into thinking he was ‘safe’ and gay? A human who has said ‘yes’ when asked if he likes sexual activity in the toilets and has done it ‘a lot’? Asked why he did not ‘fool around’ in the bar instead of toilets, a human who said: "Because it's better to do these things in private."

All those descriptors are of the same man who was in court yesterday. Would he get a pass to a woman’s toilet if he wanted one?

When the Sexual Offences Act 2003, had a special section on toilets added to it, it was argued this was discriminatory towards men. You can look it up on Hansard.

Plz save your one trick pony rants for when they are applicable if you don't mind. The context of this discussion is how women's personal experience shape their fears not dunny design.

Until then its lights out from moi. 😴

Keeptoiletssafe · 29/10/2026 06:56

CoolforKats · 29/10/2026 03:47

Plz save your one trick pony rants for when they are applicable if you don't mind. The context of this discussion is how women's personal experience shape their fears not dunny design.

Until then its lights out from moi. 😴

To quote a pp, ‘Mate, you are the master of missing the point’.

Mountainlarch · 29/10/2026 07:15

CoolforKats · 28/10/2026 23:32

I love this episode where the author of the study had to come out & debunk the false representations of her study that was demonstrated in the UK parliament no less. 😂

"Criminality
In response to questions 38 and 39 Prof Freedman referenced “a well-known Swedish study” to imply that patterns of criminality are the same amongst trans women as they are amongst cis (non-trans) men. In her response to Q40 she alleged there were “Swedish studies” (plural). Additionally, Prof Stock referred to “male patterns” when talking about criminal behaviour in her answer to Q26.
I understand the “Swedish study” to be a single 2011 article published by Cecilia Dhejne and colleagues[1], in which the authors reported on mortality, suicidality, psychiatric care and conviction rates among individuals who transitioned in Sweden between 1973 and 2003. This study is widely but inaccurately cited by anti-trans groups on social media as evidence that trans women retain “male patterns” of criminality, an error repeated by Profs Freedman and Stock._
Dhejne herself rejected this interpretation explicitly in an interview with Cristan Williams of TransAdvocate in November 2015[2]. I attach the full relevant extract in Appendix B. A key point she makes is the study is “certainly not saying that we found that trans women were a rape risk” to cis women. Additionally, the study was not focused on investigating criminal behaviour, was drawn from a small cohort in one country, and only indicated a statistically significant increased risk of conviction for trans people who ‘underwent sex reassignment before 1989’:[3] a time when fewer opportunities and resources were available to trans people in Sweden, which may have resulted in increased criminalisation in a similar manner to other stigmatised groups. The authors therefore conclude that the best outcomes occur when individuals also receive long-term health and social care support in addition to any hormone therapy or surgery that they might require."

https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/21023/html/

Edited

The response from the author (of which I was aware, I just didn't know it was from the author) still doesn't change two things

The word "pattern" was used in the paper referring to the frequency of general crimes, rather a complete analysis of the types of crimes. Still, TW offend 6.6 more times than the female population (obviously that's not a number set in stone, it has a confidence interval. So there is a huge difference between TW and females that needs to be investigated in the sphere of sexual and violent crimes more specifically

The paper also shows that an analysis of criminality can be conducted even for small groups.

Finally, the paper is old. Since then acceptance has increased, and careful assessment before treatment has been abandoned. Multiple factors playing in different directions have to be considered. Unfortunately, we have lost years of data because of the improper record of sex and gender. I wonder whether there are countries where this is still possible.

I don't think that women have to demonstrate that TW retain a pattern of sexual and violent crime more similar to male to retain single sex spaces. I think if and once the opposite is demonstrated (TW offend at a pattern similar to women), then we can start a discussion about redefining spaces.

Obviously the discussion should also touch on self id, privacy and modesty, victim of violence that can feel traumatized etc.

DeanElderberry · 29/10/2026 07:37

CoolforKats · 28/10/2026 21:07

but within those groups men offend more than women.

Prove it. Shows us the data that says elderly men violently offend more than young women or gay men offend more than lesbians ? And keep in mind the massive under reporting of child abuse by women AND the leniency in sentencing.

https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-55338745

Within trans offenders the pattern is flipped with ‘transwomen’ committing more violent and sexual offences than ‘transmen’. Can’t imagine why.

Data 101: Statistically insignificant groups can't be measured accurately.

"Between 2016 and 2019, a total of 97 sexual assaults were recorded in women’s prisons, of which seven appeared to be committed by transgender prisoners without a GRC. It is not known whether any were committed by transgender women with a GRC but the number of transgender prisoners with a GRC across all jails is thought to be in single figures.

Holroyde said the statistics were too low and had insufficient detail to provide a safe basis for conclusions, adding: “I can accept, at any rate for present purposes, that the unconditional introduction of a transgender woman into the general population of a women’s prison carries a statistically greater risk of sexual assault upon non-transgender prisoners than would be the case if a non-transgender woman were introduced. But that statistical conclusion takes no account of the risk assessment which the policies require.”

https://www.theguardian.com/society/2021/jul/02/trans-women-with-sex-offence-convictions-in-female-jails-lawful-rules-judge

The women Paddy O'Gorman interviewed said the problems of being imprisoned in the same blocks as transwomen included having to listen to foul mouthed abuse and knowing that their own home addresses, family structure, children's names etc were being observed. There was also a lack of general association with fellow prisoners.

https://paddyspodcast.ie/ https://x.com/paddyjogorman

EdithStourton · 29/10/2026 07:40

@CoolforKats referencing her personal experiences with cis men
This is the fundamental point.
Virtually all women have had experiences with men ranging from 'unpleasant and a bit scary' to 'brutal and terrifying'. I've had a fairly quiet life and I've been sexually assaulted 4 times, 2 of them by strangers - plus being flashed at twice. Only one of those experiences was seriously frightening, but the net result is that when I'm in a public toilet or changing area, I don't want any men in there. End of. There is no way of knowing if a man in a dress is dangerous or not, if he's 'true trans' or not, if he's a sexual predator or not. So the safest option, from my perspective and that of many women, is, no men. You could argue gay men pose no risk, so should be allowed in too. But you can't reliably tell by looking if a man is gay or not.

So I don't give a shit about offending rates (though confirm my opinion). I just don't want men in public spaces where I'm getting my kit off.

PS Plenty of toilets are not busy - department stores, restaurants, pubs. Our nearest small town has somehow hung onto its public loos. They're not busy.

PPS Lots of men know that other men are a risk to women. Those men understand why women don't want men in single sex spaces.

BackToLurk · 29/10/2026 07:45

CoolforKats · 28/10/2026 23:23

"This study explores gender differences in victimization and perpetration experiences of gays and lesbians in intimate relationships. A sample of 283 gays and lesbians reported on their experiences both as victims and perpetrators of gay/lesbian relationship violence by completing a modified version of the Conflict Tactics Scale (Straus, Gelles, & Steinmetz, 1980). General results indicate that 47.5% of lesbians and 29.7% of gays have been victimized by a same-sex partner. Further, lesbians reported an overall perpetration rate of 38% compared to 21.8% for gay men. Other findings were as follows: (1) lesbians were more likely to be classified as victims and perpetrators of violence than gay men; (2) lesbians were more likely to report pushing or being pushed than gay men; (3) lesbians reported experiencing a greater number of different victimization and perpetration tactics than gay men; and finally, (4) when items were weighted to create an indicator of severity, no significant differences between lesbians and gay men were found."

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9403987/

"This study was undertaken to help determine if homosexuals and bisexuals are more or less criminal and/or violent than heterosexuals. Based upon samples of 197 male and 279 female college students, Pearson correlations revealed several significant, but weak, relationships between sexual orientation and most forms of self-reported criminal and/or violent behavior patterns. Among males, the data generally suggested that heterosexuals were more criminal and violent than homosexuals (except in the case of drug offenses), but that bisexuals were more criminal and violent than heterosexuals. Among females, lesbians (including only a few females with exclusively homosexual preferences) were generally more criminal and violent than heterosexuals, although they were still less so than males (except for homosexual males). Results suggest that some important differences may exist among both sexes regarding relationships between sexual orientations and criminal/violent behavior.

A different pattern of findings emerged for the relationship between sexual minority status and crime among males. Gay males appear to display lower levels of physical aggression and criminal behavior as compared to heterosexual males (Ellis et al., 1990; Pinhey & Brown, 2005; Sergeant et al., 2006). Furthermore, sexual minority boys, in contrast to sexual minority girls, did not appear to be overrepresented in the juvenile justice system (Jonnson et al., 2019). Though limited, at least some early evidence suggested that bisexual males tended to report more involvement in violence and crime than heterosexual males (Ellis et al., 1990)."
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/019188699090146I?via%3Dihub

"Similar associations between sexual orientation and delinquency were found in a large national sample of American respondents (Beaver et al., 2016). Bisexual respondents reported the highest levels of involvement in delinquent behavior, followed next by heterosexual males, lesbians, gay males, and heterosexual females. Arguably the most noteworthy finding was that lesbian respondents seemed to be more involved in crime than gay males (Beaver et al., 2016). The novelty here stems from the fact that one of the most replicated findings in behavioral science is sex-differentiated criminal involvement across virtually all crime types (Ellis et al., 2009; Moffitt et al., 2001)."

https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10508-024-02902-9#:~:text=A%20different%20pattern%20of%20findings,et%20al.%2C%202016).

Edited

The Waldner-Haugrud study is small and suffers from problems in methodology, not least its reliance on snowball sampling. That aside, later studies have found the reverse. Most significantly Henderson (2003) which was U.K. based, larger and found that gay men were more likely to be victims of domestic abuse than lesbians. All these studies centre on domestic abuse and there may be issues anyway around male reluctance to disclose. Overall unreliable and inconsistent.

The second study is largely concerned with patterns of offending in different types of men and women - gay men offend less than straight men - rather than between gay people. The Beaver et al study referenced is the only piece of research that showed any sign that lesbians commit violent (note, not sexual) offences at a higher rate than gay men. However, this too has its problems. The research doesn’t show the same results across all 4 cohorts studied, with the cohort considered to be the most reliable in terms of accuracy of sexuality (wave 4) not showing a higher offending rate. The research is also self-reported delinquency rates rather than hard crime data.

As a whole, and certainly in relation to both the U.K. and sexual violence, there is no significant body of robust, reliable data that consistently shows lesbians commit more violent offences than gay men. To repeat and stress one statistic again. The total number of female inmates in the U.K. is less than the total (based on research) of gay men alone imprisoned in the U.K.

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 07:48

Single sex provisions were never accessible based on personal presentation. They were provided based on sex category of human as needed for safeguarding female people from a wide range of harm that is not limited to physical harm.

CoolforKats · 29/10/2026 07:52

Mountainlarch · 29/10/2026 07:15

The response from the author (of which I was aware, I just didn't know it was from the author) still doesn't change two things

The word "pattern" was used in the paper referring to the frequency of general crimes, rather a complete analysis of the types of crimes. Still, TW offend 6.6 more times than the female population (obviously that's not a number set in stone, it has a confidence interval. So there is a huge difference between TW and females that needs to be investigated in the sphere of sexual and violent crimes more specifically

The paper also shows that an analysis of criminality can be conducted even for small groups.

Finally, the paper is old. Since then acceptance has increased, and careful assessment before treatment has been abandoned. Multiple factors playing in different directions have to be considered. Unfortunately, we have lost years of data because of the improper record of sex and gender. I wonder whether there are countries where this is still possible.

I don't think that women have to demonstrate that TW retain a pattern of sexual and violent crime more similar to male to retain single sex spaces. I think if and once the opposite is demonstrated (TW offend at a pattern similar to women), then we can start a discussion about redefining spaces.

Obviously the discussion should also touch on self id, privacy and modesty, victim of violence that can feel traumatized etc.

Cope. The author specifically states it doesn't prove anything about offending patterns of TW. You know more than her about her own work do you?

Additionally, the study was not focused on investigating criminal behaviour, was drawn from a small cohort in one country, and only indicated a statistically significant increased risk of conviction for trans people who ‘underwent sex reassignment before 1989’:[3] a time when fewer opportunities and resources were available to trans people in Sweden, which may have resulted in increased criminalisation in a similar manner to other stigmatised groups

LouisTheYardTeacher · 29/10/2026 07:53

There's no peer reviewed study that says that left handed accountants called Norman are more likely to be sex offenders than average woman, therefore it is wrong to exclude Norm from his Gym's female communal changing room.
(Or maybe it's not actually necessary to prove the need to exclude males sliver by sliver)

Helleofabore · 29/10/2026 07:53

CoolforKats · 28/10/2026 23:32

I love this episode where the author of the study had to come out & debunk the false representations of her study that was demonstrated in the UK parliament no less. 😂

"Criminality
In response to questions 38 and 39 Prof Freedman referenced “a well-known Swedish study” to imply that patterns of criminality are the same amongst trans women as they are amongst cis (non-trans) men. In her response to Q40 she alleged there were “Swedish studies” (plural). Additionally, Prof Stock referred to “male patterns” when talking about criminal behaviour in her answer to Q26.
I understand the “Swedish study” to be a single 2011 article published by Cecilia Dhejne and colleagues[1], in which the authors reported on mortality, suicidality, psychiatric care and conviction rates among individuals who transitioned in Sweden between 1973 and 2003. This study is widely but inaccurately cited by anti-trans groups on social media as evidence that trans women retain “male patterns” of criminality, an error repeated by Profs Freedman and Stock._
Dhejne herself rejected this interpretation explicitly in an interview with Cristan Williams of TransAdvocate in November 2015[2]. I attach the full relevant extract in Appendix B. A key point she makes is the study is “certainly not saying that we found that trans women were a rape risk” to cis women. Additionally, the study was not focused on investigating criminal behaviour, was drawn from a small cohort in one country, and only indicated a statistically significant increased risk of conviction for trans people who ‘underwent sex reassignment before 1989’:[3] a time when fewer opportunities and resources were available to trans people in Sweden, which may have resulted in increased criminalisation in a similar manner to other stigmatised groups. The authors therefore conclude that the best outcomes occur when individuals also receive long-term health and social care support in addition to any hormone therapy or surgery that they might require."

https://committees.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/21023/html/

Edited

I think it is always important to go back to the original source, which says this:

”Criminal activity, particularly violent crime, is much more common among men than women in the general population. A previous study of all applications for sex reassignment in Sweden up to 1992 found that 9.7% of male-to-female and 6.1% of female-to-male applicants had been prosecuted for a crime. Crime after sex reassignment, however, has not previously been studied. In this study, male-to-female individuals had a higher risk for criminal convictions compared to female controls but not compared to male controls. This suggests that the sex reassignment procedure neither increased nor decreased the risk for criminal offending in male-to-females. “

Rape was not studied and yet this interviewer asked Dhejne specifically to confirm rape statistics. Of course the fucking answer will be ‘no, we didn’t measure that’. It was also irrelevant because the study shows a general pattern of criminality and specifically ‘violent’ crime.

safeguarding decisions are not based on only rape statistics so this focus on it is not actually proving the point the some male people should be included in female single sex provisions over 8 years old. However, the prisoner statistics show part of the decision making critieria - which is that risk that cannot be ignored.

And again, the Swedish study did not show that group of male people had a rate of committing crime at the same or lower than the general female rate of committing crime. Meaning they should not be considered ‘female’ at all for crime risk assessment.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.
Swipe left for the next trending thread