Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Darlington Nurses" vs County Durham and Darlington NHS Trust Tribunal Thread 9

432 replies

ThreeWordHarpy · 16/01/2026 12:36

Thread 1, 7-Oct to 23-Oct
Thread 2, 23-Oct to 28-Oct
Thread 3, 28-Oct to 29-Oct
Thread 4, 29-Oct to 31-Oct
Thread 5, 31-Oct to 04-Nov
Thread 6, 04-Nov to 05-Nov
Thread 7, 05-Nov to 11-Nov
Thread 8, 11-Nov to 16-Jan (last thread with the schedule and abbreviations)

Five nurses working at Darlington Memorial Hospital filed a legal case against their employer, an NHS trust, for sexual harassment and sex discrimination. The nurses objected to sharing the women’s changing facilities with a male colleague, Rose, who identifies as female. The hearing was held between 20th October and 11th November and was live tweeted by Tribunal Tweets who have comprehensive information regarding this case on their substack, including archives of the twitter threads, lists of people involved and press releases.

At the time this thread was started, the judgment had not yet been published on the Courts website but was widely reported in the media that the NHS was found to have discriminated against the nurses, but the claims against Rose were not upheld.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
FWSsupporter · 21/01/2026 15:07

@Easytoconfuse I agree following the law as it stands is the first step. There are then a lot of intervening steps which centre women and girls but ultimately we need a long term solution that is reasonable and proportionate for everyone.

Easytoconfuse · 21/01/2026 12:29

FWSsupporter · 21/01/2026 11:52

It is much wider than SSS. It’s about being a part of society.

The religion and belief pc provides protections for people of faith. We self identify as Christian, Jew, Muslim etc. and this is taken at face value. There is no test to prove how faithful you are before you can claim discrimination.

Being Gender Critical is also a belief which is protected. Again this is taken at face value. There is no test to prove you are GC.
Edited to add Maya did that for us all.
Sandie Peggie is gender critical but until this all blew up she may not have realised it. A lot of people are GC but probably don’t realise it until they are in a situation where sex matters. They don’t have to realise or declare it beforehand to be protected.

Whether we like it or not the GRA and EA2010 recognise gender reassignment. It is not unreasonable to think defining Gender Identity as a belief and offering similar protections is a reasonable position. The legislation can set out limitations where sex based rights take precedence e.g. SSS, sex to be recorded on passports, driving licences etc.

The principle of SSS is not complex, but working out the definition of GI and the limits of protections is.

Employers and service providers need legal clarity. What ever you think about DrU and RH, legally they were not entitled to use the women’s changing room but legally their employer was obliged to find a suitable solution for where they could get changed and their dignity and privacy was respected.

Edited

I see your point, but I think complying with the law as it stands is a good place to start. I'm afraid I'm not interested in the philosophical side. People can identify as whatever they like, but I want to be able to go to the loo or be in hospital or change my clothes without having to share the facilities with a man who may genuinely believe he's a woman, or may not.

As it stands, everything seems to be concentrated on the hurt feelings of the transgender, and I don't want to be the human equivalent of a sticky plaster and a kiss better when so few people care how I'm feeling.

Professing a religion doesn't entitle me to ignore the law and neither does disability. The disabled only get 'reasonable adjustments' to facilities, so how about if the transgender get the same thing? In this case, 300 women used the changing area at Darlington but the feelings of one man who identifies as a woman was considered to be more important than all those women's because no one ever bothered to ask how they felt, and when they spoke out they were treated appallingly. That is NOT reasonable.

MistyGreenAndBlue · 21/01/2026 12:28

FWSsupporter · 21/01/2026 11:52

It is much wider than SSS. It’s about being a part of society.

The religion and belief pc provides protections for people of faith. We self identify as Christian, Jew, Muslim etc. and this is taken at face value. There is no test to prove how faithful you are before you can claim discrimination.

Being Gender Critical is also a belief which is protected. Again this is taken at face value. There is no test to prove you are GC.
Edited to add Maya did that for us all.
Sandie Peggie is gender critical but until this all blew up she may not have realised it. A lot of people are GC but probably don’t realise it until they are in a situation where sex matters. They don’t have to realise or declare it beforehand to be protected.

Whether we like it or not the GRA and EA2010 recognise gender reassignment. It is not unreasonable to think defining Gender Identity as a belief and offering similar protections is a reasonable position. The legislation can set out limitations where sex based rights take precedence e.g. SSS, sex to be recorded on passports, driving licences etc.

The principle of SSS is not complex, but working out the definition of GI and the limits of protections is.

Employers and service providers need legal clarity. What ever you think about DrU and RH, legally they were not entitled to use the women’s changing room but legally their employer was obliged to find a suitable solution for where they could get changed and their dignity and privacy was respected.

Edited

legally their employer was obliged to find a suitable solution for where they could get changed and their dignity and privacy was respected.

Based on what exactly? A new haircut and a change of pronouns? Bullshit. No one is obliged to pander to someone else's delusions. They are men and they have a designated space that's perfectly suitable. Let them use it.

ProfessorBinturong · 21/01/2026 12:07

Whether we like it or not the GRA and EA2010 recognise gender reassignment. It is not unreasonable to think defining Gender Identity as a belief

Reassignment and identity are different things. Only the former is in legislation - and I agree that's in need of a proper definition.

Gender ideology (again, not identity) could be protected under the EA belief regulations if it could be defined in a way that passes Grainger. I don't believe that's possible in anything like its current form(s).

Is it possible.to define gender identity in a way that isn't sex (which it clearly isn't, or they couldn't diverge), sterotypes (change over time and culture, and we really don't want stereotypes enshrined in legislation), or a mental health condition (already covered by disability, and not something TRAs would accept)? We keep asking, and nobody's yet managed it.

FWSsupporter · 21/01/2026 11:52

Easytoconfuse · 21/01/2026 10:46

If it's a legally defined same sex space, then the only action then the responsibilities are to use the correct loo. If this means that people who identify as a gender rather than their biological sex get harrassed then the person doing the harassing should be dealt with under their employer's misconduct at work policies or by the police. I know this is hopelessly old fashioned but it worked well for years.

Unless someone can understand why women who don't want men in their same sex space are transphobic, mean and nasty and, quite often, Mumsnetters, but the answer to a man who identifies as a woman and says they're scared of using the gents loos is not to do anything about the presumably equally transphobic, mean and nasty blokes. There couldn't be another reason for being desperate to use the ladies, could there?

It is much wider than SSS. It’s about being a part of society.

The religion and belief pc provides protections for people of faith. We self identify as Christian, Jew, Muslim etc. and this is taken at face value. There is no test to prove how faithful you are before you can claim discrimination.

Being Gender Critical is also a belief which is protected. Again this is taken at face value. There is no test to prove you are GC.
Edited to add Maya did that for us all.
Sandie Peggie is gender critical but until this all blew up she may not have realised it. A lot of people are GC but probably don’t realise it until they are in a situation where sex matters. They don’t have to realise or declare it beforehand to be protected.

Whether we like it or not the GRA and EA2010 recognise gender reassignment. It is not unreasonable to think defining Gender Identity as a belief and offering similar protections is a reasonable position. The legislation can set out limitations where sex based rights take precedence e.g. SSS, sex to be recorded on passports, driving licences etc.

The principle of SSS is not complex, but working out the definition of GI and the limits of protections is.

Employers and service providers need legal clarity. What ever you think about DrU and RH, legally they were not entitled to use the women’s changing room but legally their employer was obliged to find a suitable solution for where they could get changed and their dignity and privacy was respected.

Easytoconfuse · 21/01/2026 10:46

MistyGreenAndBlue · 20/01/2026 23:12

I have always believed we need separate and clear legal definitions of sex and gender identity, including non-binary. Both should be PCs but legal clarity on the rights and responsibilities of each would help everyone.

Always? Or just in the last 5 years since we've been repeatedly told this utter cobblers is a real thing?

If it's a legally defined same sex space, then the only action then the responsibilities are to use the correct loo. If this means that people who identify as a gender rather than their biological sex get harrassed then the person doing the harassing should be dealt with under their employer's misconduct at work policies or by the police. I know this is hopelessly old fashioned but it worked well for years.

Unless someone can understand why women who don't want men in their same sex space are transphobic, mean and nasty and, quite often, Mumsnetters, but the answer to a man who identifies as a woman and says they're scared of using the gents loos is not to do anything about the presumably equally transphobic, mean and nasty blokes. There couldn't be another reason for being desperate to use the ladies, could there?

DontStopMe · 21/01/2026 10:24

Thanks for that link @BoreOfWhabylon
Nuala McGovern was so hostile towards Bethany, it really is shocking.

DrBlackbird · 21/01/2026 10:23

BoreOfWhabylon · 21/01/2026 04:30

I'm not at all surprised no one was available for interview on Woman's Hour, given how obnoxious Nuala McGovern was to Bethany when she interviewed her previously
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m0025479

Nuala McGovern’s sanctimonious virtue signalling is the reason that I can barely listen to WH anymore. Permeates beyond the gender issues.

ScrollingLeaves · 21/01/2026 10:16

MyThreeWords · 21/01/2026 10:05

Ironically, the most fertile source of legal protection from discrimination on the basis of 'gender' is the protected characteristic of sex. Any attempt by a dutyholder under the Equality Act to require a person to manifest the gender presentation of their sex is discrimination on the basis if sex, and unlawful.

Also, despite the arguably-inappropriate terminology , the 'disability' protected characteristic should cover 'gender reassignment' as it was actually conceived of (and publicly represented) when the GRA and the Equality Act were passed.

Receiving a gender reassignment certificate is tied to a diagnosis of gender dysphoria. The challenges of living with this diagnosis are the whole reason for allowing latitude in the recording of sex, just as the challenges of living with a disability generate the rights to (e.g.) permission to park where others can't.

Under the Equality Act, 'disability' is interpreted widely. I only learnt this relatively recently. I had thought you have to be 'registered disabled' in some way to qualify for protection, but of course all that is required is having a physical or mental condition that has a "substantial, long-term, and adverse effect on one's ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities".

I do understand that the terms 'disability' and 'impairment' (which I think may also be used in the act) are offensive to people who qualify for the GR protection. But there are lots of contexts in which they are equally offensive to people with other sorts of differences, e.g. deafness. To the extent that language generates a sense of stigma or negative judgement, that should be campaigned against in the same way as for other conditions, and perhaps different terms can be evolved (so long as this is organic and not top-down).

If, and to the extent that, gender reassignment does not involve a condition that has "substantial, long-term, and adverse effect on one's ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities", what would be the justification for the special provisions that employers, service providers, and public bodies need to make for people with this PC? The only possible answer to this question is that they must do it in order not to discriminate against them on the grounds of their beliefs. And of course, this is already baked in to the protected characteristic of belief.

I think what you say is entirely reasonable and so well explained.

MyThreeWords · 21/01/2026 10:05

Ironically, the most fertile source of legal protection from discrimination on the basis of 'gender' is the protected characteristic of sex. Any attempt by a dutyholder under the Equality Act to require a person to manifest the gender presentation of their sex is discrimination on the basis if sex, and unlawful.

Also, despite the arguably-inappropriate terminology , the 'disability' protected characteristic should cover 'gender reassignment' as it was actually conceived of (and publicly represented) when the GRA and the Equality Act were passed.

Receiving a gender reassignment certificate is tied to a diagnosis of gender dysphoria. The challenges of living with this diagnosis are the whole reason for allowing latitude in the recording of sex, just as the challenges of living with a disability generate the rights to (e.g.) permission to park where others can't.

Under the Equality Act, 'disability' is interpreted widely. I only learnt this relatively recently. I had thought you have to be 'registered disabled' in some way to qualify for protection, but of course all that is required is having a physical or mental condition that has a "substantial, long-term, and adverse effect on one's ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities".

I do understand that the terms 'disability' and 'impairment' (which I think may also be used in the act) are offensive to people who qualify for the GR protection. But there are lots of contexts in which they are equally offensive to people with other sorts of differences, e.g. deafness. To the extent that language generates a sense of stigma or negative judgement, that should be campaigned against in the same way as for other conditions, and perhaps different terms can be evolved (so long as this is organic and not top-down).

If, and to the extent that, gender reassignment does not involve a condition that has "substantial, long-term, and adverse effect on one's ability to carry out normal day-to-day activities", what would be the justification for the special provisions that employers, service providers, and public bodies need to make for people with this PC? The only possible answer to this question is that they must do it in order not to discriminate against them on the grounds of their beliefs. And of course, this is already baked in to the protected characteristic of belief.

FWSsupporter · 21/01/2026 09:56

RedToothBrush · 21/01/2026 07:51

A civil servant can't actually change the law. A law still has to pass through parliament.

Good luck.

I actually meant come up with a definition.

However, whilst they don’t change the law they do draft the legislation and make the amendments as it goes through parliament.

RedToothBrush · 21/01/2026 07:51

FWSsupporter · 21/01/2026 00:31

That’s the new grade 7 Civil Service job holders first task.😂

A civil servant can't actually change the law. A law still has to pass through parliament.

Good luck.

BoreOfWhabylon · 21/01/2026 04:30

I'm not at all surprised no one was available for interview on Woman's Hour, given how obnoxious Nuala McGovern was to Bethany when she interviewed her previously
https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m0025479

Woman's Hour - Gillian Anderson, Nurse Bethany Hutchison, Gisèle Pelicot, Film-maker Elizabeth Sankey - BBC Sounds

Actor Gillian Anderson on her book Want - a collection of women's sexual fantasies.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m0025479

MistyGreenAndBlue · 21/01/2026 03:36

FWSsupporter · 21/01/2026 00:31

That’s the new grade 7 Civil Service job holders first task.😂

Gods help us all

FWSsupporter · 21/01/2026 00:31

RedToothBrush · 20/01/2026 23:54

It's fine saying we need a legal definition of gender.

Now write one without referencing regressive sexed stereotypes which are at odds with the equality act.

Good luck with that.

And this is why no one has attempted it, because it lays it bare that gender identity is totally sexist and regressive.

That’s the new grade 7 Civil Service job holders first task.😂

SqueakyDinosaur · 21/01/2026 00:28

I genuinely think it would be impossible to establish a legal definition of non-binary. Lots of countries claim to have done it, but any competent HR/employment/human rights lawyer could drive a truck through those definitions.

FWSsupporter · 21/01/2026 00:19

MistyGreenAndBlue · 20/01/2026 23:12

I have always believed we need separate and clear legal definitions of sex and gender identity, including non-binary. Both should be PCs but legal clarity on the rights and responsibilities of each would help everyone.

Always? Or just in the last 5 years since we've been repeatedly told this utter cobblers is a real thing?

A fair point. I started to draft my post in one way and changed my mind and forgot to amend “I have always believed” to “I believe”.

RedToothBrush · 20/01/2026 23:54

Also do that without referencing sex.

Good luck with that too.

RedToothBrush · 20/01/2026 23:54

It's fine saying we need a legal definition of gender.

Now write one without referencing regressive sexed stereotypes which are at odds with the equality act.

Good luck with that.

And this is why no one has attempted it, because it lays it bare that gender identity is totally sexist and regressive.

MistyGreenAndBlue · 20/01/2026 23:12

FWSsupporter · 20/01/2026 11:44

I agree.

In addition if, as they should, the gmt and Civil Service apply the FWS SC judgment and make it clear SSS are just that. Then there is an issue to resolve and that is what is the solution for trans people.

Even the SC acknowledged a trans identifying female (transman) should use female SSS but in doing so their appearance may mean it causes distress e.g. rape crisis centres.

The debate to be had is how do we respect sex and SSS whilst treating people with the PC of gender reassignment. Trans and non-binary people need to be involved in discussions, as do women. No debate did not just harm women but also some trans people. I can see a need for this role as part of a much wider piece of work.

I have always believed we need separate and clear legal definitions of sex and gender identity, including non-binary. Both should be PCs but legal clarity on the rights and responsibilities of each would help everyone.

I have always believed we need separate and clear legal definitions of sex and gender identity, including non-binary. Both should be PCs but legal clarity on the rights and responsibilities of each would help everyone.

Always? Or just in the last 5 years since we've been repeatedly told this utter cobblers is a real thing?

tropicaltrance · 20/01/2026 18:55

BingeleyBingeleyBeep · 20/01/2026 13:14

Apologies for the delayed question.
In all these cases if the HR person is CIPD qualified aren't they supposed to be be following their code of conduct...?
https://www.cipd.org/uk/membership/professional-standards/code-of-conduct/
Including

  • Ensure that your professional judgement is not compromised nor could be perceived as being compromised because of bias, or the undue influence of others.
  • Take all reasonable steps to resolve disputes and complaints in a fair, timely and professional manner. Never allow a complaint to affect the standard of behaviour or professionalism shown to those who raise concerns, engage authentically and respectfully.
  • Take responsibility for your professional actions and decisions. Rectify issues and take all reasonable steps to mitigate loss or harm as soon as possible. Inform those affected of the potential impact

The CIPD is already known to be somewhat compromised by bias itself on this issue, but that is an interesting point.

BingeleyBingeleyBeep · 20/01/2026 13:14

Bold is by me not from website.

BingeleyBingeleyBeep · 20/01/2026 13:14

Conxis · 17/01/2026 10:23

by the views of senior HR that they needed to stay on the ‘right side of the law’

Would it be unkind to ask how that’s working out for them?

Apologies for the delayed question.
In all these cases if the HR person is CIPD qualified aren't they supposed to be be following their code of conduct...?
https://www.cipd.org/uk/membership/professional-standards/code-of-conduct/
Including

  • Ensure that your professional judgement is not compromised nor could be perceived as being compromised because of bias, or the undue influence of others.
  • Take all reasonable steps to resolve disputes and complaints in a fair, timely and professional manner. Never allow a complaint to affect the standard of behaviour or professionalism shown to those who raise concerns, engage authentically and respectfully.
  • Take responsibility for your professional actions and decisions. Rectify issues and take all reasonable steps to mitigate loss or harm as soon as possible. Inform those affected of the potential impact

CIPD | Code of Conduct and Ethics

Code of Conduct and Ethics - sets standards for all members of the CIPD.

https://www.cipd.org/uk/membership/professional-standards/code-of-conduct

ProfessorBinturong · 20/01/2026 13:03

I have always believed we need separate and clear legal definitions of sex and gender identity, including non-binary. Both should be PCs but legal clarity on the rights and responsibilities of each would help everyone.

Neither 'gender identity' nor 'non-binary' are recognised in law.

MyAmpleSheep · 20/01/2026 12:53

Comtesse · 20/01/2026 07:03

To be fair it’s just one Grade 7 role, which isn’t that senior. When govt is gearing up for new legislation, there would typically be a whole team (say 6-10 people).

But let’s wait and see. Once this person is in place, ze may find “things are worse than zir thought” and a more senior team is installed.