Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Darlington Nurses" vs County Durham and Darlington NHS Trust Tribunal Thread 9

432 replies

ThreeWordHarpy · 16/01/2026 12:36

Thread 1, 7-Oct to 23-Oct
Thread 2, 23-Oct to 28-Oct
Thread 3, 28-Oct to 29-Oct
Thread 4, 29-Oct to 31-Oct
Thread 5, 31-Oct to 04-Nov
Thread 6, 04-Nov to 05-Nov
Thread 7, 05-Nov to 11-Nov
Thread 8, 11-Nov to 16-Jan (last thread with the schedule and abbreviations)

Five nurses working at Darlington Memorial Hospital filed a legal case against their employer, an NHS trust, for sexual harassment and sex discrimination. The nurses objected to sharing the women’s changing facilities with a male colleague, Rose, who identifies as female. The hearing was held between 20th October and 11th November and was live tweeted by Tribunal Tweets who have comprehensive information regarding this case on their substack, including archives of the twitter threads, lists of people involved and press releases.

At the time this thread was started, the judgment had not yet been published on the Courts website but was widely reported in the media that the NHS was found to have discriminated against the nurses, but the claims against Rose were not upheld.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
Chersfrozenface · 23/01/2026 09:43

moto748e · 23/01/2026 00:08

I think there's quite an important point here about language. I remember reading a post on MN (I think) about the German language, which of course has masculine, feminine, and neuter nouns, and how it has adapted to the shiny new gender-filled world we live in. And the result is, it seems, that somehow German people are a bit boxed in by the grammar of their language and the way it being currently used. I'm not explaining myself at all well; I wonder if anyone else can remember the thread I was talking about. But it certainly made a broader point about the use of languages, all of them.

There was this thread which dealt with the German self ID law.
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5048705-selfid-law-passed-in-german-parliament?page=1

In it, in reply to the observation "but it might have been that in German there are not separate words for sex and gender", a poster by the name of Delfin said
"Exactly. And the SBGG for the first time defines "Geschlecht". It says that it can be determined by every person itself (gender). Which basically explodes all laws that draw on the term "Geschlecht" without defining it. Which is all of the laws, including our constitution."

But there have also been conversations, I think, on how masculine nouns for jobs, for instance, had to have female equivalents coined, in order to avoid sexism. So you have adverts for "lehrer/in" = lehrer, male or lehrerin (female). But that's still male teacher and female teacher, so what about the enbies.

RedToothBrush · 23/01/2026 09:37

MistyGreenAndBlue · 23/01/2026 01:07

Your reply:
"If you believe in God you don't have to coerce nor bully others into going along and validating your identity as a God botherer. You don't ask them to call you Sister MistyGreenAndBlue now do you?
Religions that force others into compliance are not ok within liberal society because they are coercive and therefore act in ways which are unlawful.
So why are we trying to make a false
equivalence?"

If you were not replying to me, why direct your question at me and use my username?

It definitely came across that you were speaking directly to me, having misunderstood my post

Which I have admitted was poorly phrased which is why I explained it.

I don't think I'm the only person on the thread. What a weird thing to say.

Oh Jesus wept.

You can throw a bloody tantrum over nothing if you want.

It was a general comment regardless, to make a point.

I'm not going to acknowledge a mistake because I didn't make one!

It was just a generalised comment. If you are going to get upset about that, I can't help you.

Peregrina · 23/01/2026 09:32

Years and years ago, I wrote to a foreign language dictionary asking why 'gender' was beginning to be used in the wild when the intended meaning was 'sex'.

Yes, and for those languages which only have male and female and every noun is male or female, having a word which is not sex for inanimate objects, i.e. gender, makes sense.

We have now virtually lost a useful distinction.

stickygotstuck · 23/01/2026 08:42

My own distinction -

On forms, I answer when asked what my sex is. Because it could be relevant.
When asked what my gender is, I leave it blank as it's irrelevant.

The ones that only ask about gender, and it's a mandatory field, piss me off so much I think I may give myself an aneurism.

The ones which ask both, and only sex is mandatory, almost make me faint with surprise.

Years and years ago, I wrote to a foreign language dictionary asking why 'gender' was beginning to be used in the wild when the intended meaning was 'sex'. They answered saying that they'd notice that and I wasn't the only one asking, and that they'd be issuing a note on that after some research because it was a very good question.

Unfortunately, I don't know if it ever was issued. But I took comfort form knowing I wasn't the only one.

Easytoconfuse · 23/01/2026 06:45

Peregrina · 22/01/2026 18:23

Gender for 99.9% of people actually now means ‘sex’.

Not for me, and I doubt if I am only part of 0.1. For many of us gender is still a euphemism when we are trying to be polite.

Not for me either, but I'd be interested to see the research that shows this because I think a lot of the problem is that gender is an Alice in Wonderland word that means whatever the user wants it to mean.

The Cambridge dictionary says it's a group of people in a society who share particular qualities or ways of behaving which that society associates with being male, female, or another identity:

Now all we have to do is define society and what these qualities are, which activists tend to do as 'people who agree with me' who always seem to be massively in the majority, with the implication that dissenters should shut up and do as they're told. I'm always suspicious of anyone who makes a claim like that without references to back it up.

Looking at comments pages in an unscientific sample that ranges from the Sun to the Mail, the Telegraph and the Guardian, I'd say most people think of sexual identification in terms of simple biology, using DNA tests in complex cases like intersex. Gender is a belief, and I don't think one person's beliefs should be forced on anyone else, no matter how loudly they shout or how often they say they'll kill themselves if they don't get their own way or how badly everyone is treating them.

behave

1. to act in a particular way: 2. to show particular behaviour in a particular…

https://dictionary.cambridge.org/dictionary/english/behave

Easytoconfuse · 23/01/2026 06:36

MistyGreenAndBlue · 22/01/2026 19:41

Oh ffs. Does no one read properly any more?
I am NOT suggesting any such bloody thing!
Quite the opposite in fact.

I have already explained this to @RedToothBrush and had no acknowledgement of her mistake.

Didn't either you read the quote I was answering?

In a nutshell then
@FWSsupporter asked me "is God real?" in response to me telling her that gender identity isn't a real thing and gender dysphoria isn't a belief system, its a mental illness as she is arguing for it becoming a PC.
So I countered with "is a belief in God a mental illness?"

Because clearly it isn't and is therefore not the same thing.

She hasn't answered me yet.

Perhaps the confusion lies in the fact that instead of quoting me, she tagged me on the end of a reply she made to another poster and so I answered that.
I really hope that clears this up now.

I can see what you meant to say. I don't think that you've understood my point, which is that that is an incredibly offensive thing to say to someone who does have a religious belief and, in certain cases, it can be dangerous. Backtracking by saying 'clearly it isn't' and you didn't mean it doesn't alter the fact that you did ask it.

AFAIK it isn't compulsory to answer you and I won't be.

MistyGreenAndBlue · 23/01/2026 01:07

RedToothBrush · 23/01/2026 00:29

I was addressing the thread generally. I quoted you to make a point rather than replying to you!

I don't have to acknowledge a mistake because I wasn't making one!

There's more than you on the thread.

Your reply:
"If you believe in God you don't have to coerce nor bully others into going along and validating your identity as a God botherer. You don't ask them to call you Sister MistyGreenAndBlue now do you?
Religions that force others into compliance are not ok within liberal society because they are coercive and therefore act in ways which are unlawful.
So why are we trying to make a false
equivalence?"

If you were not replying to me, why direct your question at me and use my username?

It definitely came across that you were speaking directly to me, having misunderstood my post

Which I have admitted was poorly phrased which is why I explained it.

I don't think I'm the only person on the thread. What a weird thing to say.

RedToothBrush · 23/01/2026 00:29

MistyGreenAndBlue · 22/01/2026 19:41

Oh ffs. Does no one read properly any more?
I am NOT suggesting any such bloody thing!
Quite the opposite in fact.

I have already explained this to @RedToothBrush and had no acknowledgement of her mistake.

Didn't either you read the quote I was answering?

In a nutshell then
@FWSsupporter asked me "is God real?" in response to me telling her that gender identity isn't a real thing and gender dysphoria isn't a belief system, its a mental illness as she is arguing for it becoming a PC.
So I countered with "is a belief in God a mental illness?"

Because clearly it isn't and is therefore not the same thing.

She hasn't answered me yet.

Perhaps the confusion lies in the fact that instead of quoting me, she tagged me on the end of a reply she made to another poster and so I answered that.
I really hope that clears this up now.

I was addressing the thread generally. I quoted you to make a point rather than replying to you!

I don't have to acknowledge a mistake because I wasn't making one!

There's more than you on the thread.

moto748e · 23/01/2026 00:08

ScrollingLeaves · 22/01/2026 20:58

So in Welsh ‘Gender’ is even more likely to seem much the same word as ‘Sex’.

Wales is, from what I have read on this board often, one of the worst places for pushing gender ideas to young children in schools.

I think there's quite an important point here about language. I remember reading a post on MN (I think) about the German language, which of course has masculine, feminine, and neuter nouns, and how it has adapted to the shiny new gender-filled world we live in. And the result is, it seems, that somehow German people are a bit boxed in by the grammar of their language and the way it being currently used. I'm not explaining myself at all well; I wonder if anyone else can remember the thread I was talking about. But it certainly made a broader point about the use of languages, all of them.

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 22/01/2026 23:36

AreYouSureAskedNaomi · 22/01/2026 23:27

OMG what? I'm not sure i want to hear him sing...

You don't!

AreYouSureAskedNaomi · 22/01/2026 23:27

OMG what? I'm not sure i want to hear him sing...

RapidOnsetGenderCritic · 22/01/2026 22:32

ItsCoolForCats · 22/01/2026 19:33

What an utter creep. I don't even know where to start...

https://x.com/i/status/2014358882190053533

Have you heard him "sing"?

AreYouSureAskedNaomi · 22/01/2026 21:47

ItsCoolForCats · 22/01/2026 19:33

What an utter creep. I don't even know where to start...

https://x.com/i/status/2014358882190053533

Woah way to miss the obvious issue of women's rights to single sex spaces

Come to think of it this person seems to struggle to grasp reality and facts:

Rose wasn't a respondent in the Darlington case, this video seems to imply he was

It is libellous to call the nurses trans-hostile and anti-trans

it is beyond deluded to think that the NHS can afford to replace communal changing rooms with multiple individual private cubicles at the massive scale needed

Single sex spaces are not a legitimate aim. Right.

No, the law is not a mess since the FWS and the SC ruling doesn't clash with other legislation, quite the opposite in fact

Also... don't bring up your "shiny new equipment", mate. Literally nobody is interested.

FallenSloppyDead2 · 22/01/2026 21:29

ItsCoolForCats · 22/01/2026 19:33

What an utter creep. I don't even know where to start...

https://x.com/i/status/2014358882190053533

This is interesting. If you can plough through all the trans-inclusive signalling to the brethren, he is actually suggesting the provision of 'adequate, non-gendered individual toilets and changing rooms for those who wish to have more privacy' with a hope that eventually all facilities will be like that. He's not (openly anyway) suggesting that the 'trans-hostile' women use them and actually says he would prefer them and they would work for non-binary people too.
Brave man😂

ScrollingLeaves · 22/01/2026 21:18

tropicaltrance · 22/01/2026 18:36

So you are one of those 99.9% of people then? In what way are you disagreeing with the quote?

Yes, the American euphemism ‘Gender’ has taken over the word ‘Sex’ (pertaining to male and female) for 99.9% of people. That’s my claim.

Knowing it’s a euphemism at the same time as using in speech propagates the problem. The pp may mean that they say ‘gender’ for sex just to seem more polite while all the while knowing its ‘real’ meaning. But I do not believe most people do.

The real modern meaning is a bit drummed up, academic and confusing anyway. Most people take their everyday presentation as ordinary men or women for granted. It is not normally a self-conscious state of being needing a name distinct from ‘sex’. No wonder most people think these two words are interchangeable.

ScrollingLeaves · 22/01/2026 20:58

Chersfrozenface · 22/01/2026 19:25

A word has been made up for it, yes.

Obviously words have to be coined for new inventions and concepts.

Unlike English, it's a neologism, not the term for grammatical gender repurposed. In fact it's the word for sex 'rhyw', with one of the endings often found in abstract concepts, '-edd' added to it to make 'rhywedd'.

So in Welsh ‘Gender’ is even more likely to seem much the same word as ‘Sex’.

Wales is, from what I have read on this board often, one of the worst places for pushing gender ideas to young children in schools.

lcakethereforeIam · 22/01/2026 20:27

borntobequiet · 22/01/2026 19:42

Those eyebrows are mesmerising.

And his hands are enormous.

FWSsupporter · 22/01/2026 20:02

@MistyGreenAndBlue I completely understand. 💐

MistyGreenAndBlue · 22/01/2026 20:01

FWSsupporter · 22/01/2026 19:58

@MistyGreenAndBlue sorry you got dragged into a derail and I responded to the wrong poster.

As I said my comment was cheeky. I could see where other people derailing your post was heading and wanted to move the thread away from a religious debate so didn’t respond. The short answer is no.

Edited to add you will appreciate with a lot of posters in the debate and not solely focused on Mumsnet it can be difficult to keep up.

Edited

Thank you. I suppose I quoted the question badly too. Its all got a bit metaphysical 😂
I got annoyed at being accused of saying something I would never say.

FWSsupporter · 22/01/2026 19:58

MistyGreenAndBlue · 22/01/2026 19:41

Oh ffs. Does no one read properly any more?
I am NOT suggesting any such bloody thing!
Quite the opposite in fact.

I have already explained this to @RedToothBrush and had no acknowledgement of her mistake.

Didn't either you read the quote I was answering?

In a nutshell then
@FWSsupporter asked me "is God real?" in response to me telling her that gender identity isn't a real thing and gender dysphoria isn't a belief system, its a mental illness as she is arguing for it becoming a PC.
So I countered with "is a belief in God a mental illness?"

Because clearly it isn't and is therefore not the same thing.

She hasn't answered me yet.

Perhaps the confusion lies in the fact that instead of quoting me, she tagged me on the end of a reply she made to another poster and so I answered that.
I really hope that clears this up now.

@MistyGreenAndBlue sorry you got dragged into a derail and I responded to the wrong poster.

As I said my comment was cheeky. I could see where other people derailing your post was heading and wanted to move the thread away from a religious debate so didn’t respond. The short answer is no.

Edited to add you will appreciate with a lot of posters in the debate and not solely focused on Mumsnet it can be difficult to keep up.

borntobequiet · 22/01/2026 19:42

Those eyebrows are mesmerising.

MistyGreenAndBlue · 22/01/2026 19:41

Easytoconfuse · 22/01/2026 15:27

Or is not believing in God a sign of a mental health condition? Would you ask a devout Muslim about that? I know it's fine to insult Christians but there's a teacher living in hiding who might advise you to be very very careful about asking that.

Oh ffs. Does no one read properly any more?
I am NOT suggesting any such bloody thing!
Quite the opposite in fact.

I have already explained this to @RedToothBrush and had no acknowledgement of her mistake.

Didn't either you read the quote I was answering?

In a nutshell then
@FWSsupporter asked me "is God real?" in response to me telling her that gender identity isn't a real thing and gender dysphoria isn't a belief system, its a mental illness as she is arguing for it becoming a PC.
So I countered with "is a belief in God a mental illness?"

Because clearly it isn't and is therefore not the same thing.

She hasn't answered me yet.

Perhaps the confusion lies in the fact that instead of quoting me, she tagged me on the end of a reply she made to another poster and so I answered that.
I really hope that clears this up now.

Heggettypeg · 22/01/2026 19:41

I'm trying to get my head round what would need to be covered in legislation if the law accepts the fact that sex is not gender and that gender doesn't alter sex:

Sex is stable, so should be what is recorded in official documents and databases. It shouldn't be altered, and ones that have been altered/ misrecorded should be changed back.
If gender is also recorded, it should be an additional, optional and amendable field, which would allow for detransition.

Invasion and appropriation of opposite sex spaces and sex-related language etc should be off the table.

Children and young people should be protected from life-changing medical and surgical interventions until they are of age. This should include being allowed to explore all options therapeutically with a patient without being accused of "conversion therapy"

Nobody should be penalised, in law, or under workplace rules etc, for recognising sex as a reality.

With those caveats, there should be recognition that some people need/want to live and present unconventionally for their sex. Whether this is best defined as a natural condition, or as a belief, they would need the following:

Protection from discrimination (in employment, housing etc) relative to other members of their sex/ members of the general public, and from harassment, arising from how they appear, dress and present. There's nothing unique about that; it is analogous to protecting anyone else who "looks different" e.g. because of race or disability, or who wears special clothing because of their beliefs e.g. hijab, turban.
(As with religious dress, there will be negotiations to be made in specific instances where requirements conflict with the requirements e.g. of health and safety or a workplace dress code. This would cover things like turning up to work in inappropriately suggestive clothing.)

The following would probably depend on how gender is legally defined (a condition? A belief? A choice?):

There would be a discussion to have about what kind of gender related treatments should and shouldn't be a) legal at all and b) available on the NHS.

Providing separate spaces for people uncomfortable or not easily accommodated in spaces for their sex - is this most similar to disabled "reasonable adjustments", or to providing time out and a prayer space for Moslems, or what?

What other things might need to be covered?

FallenSloppyDead2 · 22/01/2026 19:33

Chersfrozenface · 22/01/2026 19:25

A word has been made up for it, yes.

Obviously words have to be coined for new inventions and concepts.

Unlike English, it's a neologism, not the term for grammatical gender repurposed. In fact it's the word for sex 'rhyw', with one of the endings often found in abstract concepts, '-edd' added to it to make 'rhywedd'.

Thank you. That is interesting

Swipe left for the next trending thread