Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Darlington Nurses" vs County Durham and Darlington NHS Trust Tribunal Thread 9

432 replies

ThreeWordHarpy · 16/01/2026 12:36

Thread 1, 7-Oct to 23-Oct
Thread 2, 23-Oct to 28-Oct
Thread 3, 28-Oct to 29-Oct
Thread 4, 29-Oct to 31-Oct
Thread 5, 31-Oct to 04-Nov
Thread 6, 04-Nov to 05-Nov
Thread 7, 05-Nov to 11-Nov
Thread 8, 11-Nov to 16-Jan (last thread with the schedule and abbreviations)

Five nurses working at Darlington Memorial Hospital filed a legal case against their employer, an NHS trust, for sexual harassment and sex discrimination. The nurses objected to sharing the women’s changing facilities with a male colleague, Rose, who identifies as female. The hearing was held between 20th October and 11th November and was live tweeted by Tribunal Tweets who have comprehensive information regarding this case on their substack, including archives of the twitter threads, lists of people involved and press releases.

At the time this thread was started, the judgment had not yet been published on the Courts website but was widely reported in the media that the NHS was found to have discriminated against the nurses, but the claims against Rose were not upheld.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
Madcats · 24/06/2026 13:06

If Darlington NHS has £603k legal costs and has to pay Darlington nurses £187k (their legal costs subject to a further hearing), I can’t see there being any change from £1M.

I hope there are some tough conversations going on in “NHS Legal”.

3 years this has been going on!

CassOle · 24/06/2026 12:56

impossibletoday · 24/06/2026 12:37

Nitter version: https://nitter.poast.org/CConcern/status/2069736250701992281#r

PrettyDamnCosmic · 24/06/2026 12:44

It's a pretty full & frank aploogy with substantial costs awarded but there are still some unresolved matters...

The Trust has, however, refused to rule out taking disciplinary action against the nurses for speaking about their case, despite the Tribunal ruling going to the media was ‘a protected act.’

“We call upon the Trust to immediately ensure that all NMC disciplinary action against the Darlington nurses for bringing their case is immediately withdrawn.”

christianconcern.com/ccpressreleases/darlington-nurses-legal-victory-trust-pays-out-187000-in-damages-apologises-and-commits-to-separate-changing-facilities-between-male-and-female-staff/

FarriersGirl · 24/06/2026 12:41

Brilliant news for the nurses and the trust will have to pay costs of the case on top. I assume this will reverberate around the NHS trusts and make them take notice.....or maybe not as they seem to have great difficulty coming to terms with the law.

moto748e · 21/06/2026 01:34

And so Labour give people (well, women, mostly) more reason not to trust them. I have no great hope or faith in Burnham over Starmer, but at least maybe he's a bit better at reading the room?

Not that I'm at all convinced that Labour could win the next GE anyway.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 21/06/2026 01:25

lcakethereforeIam · 20/06/2026 22:07

I'm just adding this because I don't believe I've seen it mentioned elsewhere. Wes Streeting would have met with the Darlington nurses a few days ago if he had continued in post. I read that James Murray, his replacement, did not keep the meeting and I'm not aware that he has any plans to reschedule it.

Wanker.

CassOle · 20/06/2026 22:08

Typical.

lcakethereforeIam · 20/06/2026 22:07

I'm just adding this because I don't believe I've seen it mentioned elsewhere. Wes Streeting would have met with the Darlington nurses a few days ago if he had continued in post. I read that James Murray, his replacement, did not keep the meeting and I'm not aware that he has any plans to reschedule it.

ItsCoolForCats · 06/06/2026 17:50

ickky · 05/06/2026 23:09

Interview with the Darlington Nurses on WRN

Interestingly Beth said the HR lady, the one that wanted them to be re educated by Rose, apparently cried when she heard the Judgement.

I listened to this earlier. I love that they don't hold back 😄

Shocking that the are still under investigation by the Nursing a d Midwifery Council.

ickky · 05/06/2026 23:09

Interview with the Darlington Nurses on WRN

Interestingly Beth said the HR lady, the one that wanted them to be re educated by Rose, apparently cried when she heard the Judgement.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J4maHxkgXTE

MistyGreenAndBlue · 23/01/2026 16:30

RedToothBrush · 23/01/2026 16:16

I was bloody agreeing with you in the first fucking place! Sometimes I quote and highlight a point TO BACK IT UP.

I do it a lot. It's my posting style.

It wasn't my mistake. It was yours.

And yes you did ruddy demand an acknowledgement that 'id made a mistake'.

Seriously.

I acknowledged that I had misunderstood you and apologised and accepted that you hadn't actually misunderstood me as another poster did.
There doesn't seem to be anything else to say.
Except I guess we can agree to ... er agree? 😂

RedToothBrush · 23/01/2026 16:16

MistyGreenAndBlue · 23/01/2026 16:12

Don't remember "demanding" anything. Just made a passing remark that you seemed to also have misunderstood me and had not acknowledged my reply.

I do not think that you were "out to get me" just that it appeared you had misunderstood my (admittedly badly written) post. You say you didn't. Ok I accept that.
I think if another poster hadn't jumped all over me for it, leading me to feel as if I was being misunderstood all round, I would probably have left it at that. I just wanted to explain what I actually meant - just as you have done here.
(and that I would never suggest something so horrendous).

I was definitely a bit upset at the idea that I was being thought to have said religious beliefs are a mental illness and probably overreacted to that poster who said that and dragged you into it by tagging you in my fuller explanation. So, sorry for that.

FWIW I think we agree on this which is all I originally intended to convey.

I was bloody agreeing with you in the first fucking place! Sometimes I quote and highlight a point TO BACK IT UP.

I do it a lot. It's my posting style.

It wasn't my mistake. It was yours.

And yes you did ruddy demand an acknowledgement that 'id made a mistake'.

Seriously.

MistyGreenAndBlue · 23/01/2026 16:12

RedToothBrush · 23/01/2026 15:26

You have assumed I was attacking you. I frequently post in this manner. It's a general comment on a message. You have assumed my intention. You assumed I was disagreeing and being nasty.

I was not. I did not make a mistake and I object to you assuming that I did something that I didn't.

You have then demanded that I acknowledged a mistake I didn't make! I mean like wtf. There was no need for the demanding.

Just get over yourself. It wasn't remotely about you at any point.

To then go 'if you say so'

No. You have just misinterpreted and jumped to erroneous conclusions. And if anything owe me an apology but honestly I'm not really bothered because youve already decided I was out to get you somehow.

Perhaps you would like to actually like to give people the benefit of the doubt next time when they state their intention rather than making a big fucking drama over it.

Don't remember "demanding" anything. Just made a passing remark that you seemed to also have misunderstood me and had not acknowledged my reply.

I do not think that you were "out to get me" just that it appeared you had misunderstood my (admittedly badly written) post. You say you didn't. Ok I accept that.
I think if another poster hadn't jumped all over me for it, leading me to feel as if I was being misunderstood all round, I would probably have left it at that. I just wanted to explain what I actually meant - just as you have done here.
(and that I would never suggest something so horrendous).

I was definitely a bit upset at the idea that I was being thought to have said religious beliefs are a mental illness and probably overreacted to that poster who said that and dragged you into it by tagging you in my fuller explanation. So, sorry for that.

FWIW I think we agree on this which is all I originally intended to convey.

RedToothBrush · 23/01/2026 15:26

MistyGreenAndBlue · 23/01/2026 14:29

If you say so 🙄

You have assumed I was attacking you. I frequently post in this manner. It's a general comment on a message. You have assumed my intention. You assumed I was disagreeing and being nasty.

I was not. I did not make a mistake and I object to you assuming that I did something that I didn't.

You have then demanded that I acknowledged a mistake I didn't make! I mean like wtf. There was no need for the demanding.

Just get over yourself. It wasn't remotely about you at any point.

To then go 'if you say so'

No. You have just misinterpreted and jumped to erroneous conclusions. And if anything owe me an apology but honestly I'm not really bothered because youve already decided I was out to get you somehow.

Perhaps you would like to actually like to give people the benefit of the doubt next time when they state their intention rather than making a big fucking drama over it.

MistyGreenAndBlue · 23/01/2026 14:29

RedToothBrush · 23/01/2026 09:37

Oh Jesus wept.

You can throw a bloody tantrum over nothing if you want.

It was a general comment regardless, to make a point.

I'm not going to acknowledge a mistake because I didn't make one!

It was just a generalised comment. If you are going to get upset about that, I can't help you.

If you say so 🙄

MistyGreenAndBlue · 23/01/2026 14:11

Easytoconfuse · 23/01/2026 06:36

I can see what you meant to say. I don't think that you've understood my point, which is that that is an incredibly offensive thing to say to someone who does have a religious belief and, in certain cases, it can be dangerous. Backtracking by saying 'clearly it isn't' and you didn't mean it doesn't alter the fact that you did ask it.

AFAIK it isn't compulsory to answer you and I won't be.

I wasn't asking you or anyone other than the poster I was replying to. Nor did I expect a reply from you.

I mentioned that I hadn't had a reply from the poster I asked the question of.
I didn't bring up the conflation of a belief in God with a belief in gender - which I had described as a mental illness - she did and I was refuting it - albeit clumsily. I admit I phrased my initial question badly, which is why I explained it. I wasn't neccesarily expecting a response from you. Nor was what I said meant to be a general observation or open question - although I can see it looked that way because of the way I wrote it. So I'm sorry if I accidentally offended you.

NotAtMyAge · 23/01/2026 13:17

Chersfrozenface · 23/01/2026 12:06

What I think must be difficult for any trans-identifying people whose native language has gendered nouns and adjectival endings is to make the shift from using the masculine identifiers for oneself to the feminine and vice versa because it's not just a case of using different pronouns.

Must be pretty brain-scrambling for other people who are persuaded/coerced into using wrong gendered nouns and adjectival endings, too.

I couldn't agree more.

Chersfrozenface · 23/01/2026 12:06

What I think must be difficult for any trans-identifying people whose native language has gendered nouns and adjectival endings is to make the shift from using the masculine identifiers for oneself to the feminine and vice versa because it's not just a case of using different pronouns.

Must be pretty brain-scrambling for other people who are persuaded/coerced into using wrong gendered nouns and adjectival endings, too.

NotAtMyAge · 23/01/2026 11:59

Chersfrozenface · 23/01/2026 09:43

There was this thread which dealt with the German self ID law.
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5048705-selfid-law-passed-in-german-parliament?page=1

In it, in reply to the observation "but it might have been that in German there are not separate words for sex and gender", a poster by the name of Delfin said
"Exactly. And the SBGG for the first time defines "Geschlecht". It says that it can be determined by every person itself (gender). Which basically explodes all laws that draw on the term "Geschlecht" without defining it. Which is all of the laws, including our constitution."

But there have also been conversations, I think, on how masculine nouns for jobs, for instance, had to have female equivalents coined, in order to avoid sexism. So you have adverts for "lehrer/in" = lehrer, male or lehrerin (female). But that's still male teacher and female teacher, so what about the enbies.

But there have also been conversations, I think, on how masculine nouns for jobs, for instance, had to have female equivalents coined, in order to avoid sexism. So you have adverts for "lehrer/in" = lehrer, male or lehrerin (female). But that's still male teacher and female teacher, so what about the enbies.

When I started to learn German 65 years ago, the use of "...in" at the end of the name of a trade or profession to denote a female practitioner was taken for granted and long predates any modern concept of sexism. It was certainly in use in the C19th German novels I had to read at university in the mid-60s.

What I think must be difficult for any trans-identifying people whose native language has gendered nouns and adjectival endings is to make the shift from using the masculine identifiers for oneself to the feminine and vice versa because it's not just a case of using different pronouns.

AreYouSureAskedNaomi · 23/01/2026 11:09

BezMills · 23/01/2026 10:24

Was that a Spanish woman under cx during the ERCC tribunal, iirc.

Yes, it was one of the trustees in the Roz Adams vs Edinburgh Rape Crisis Centre hearing

God I had forgotten about that shitshow tribunal

moto748e · 23/01/2026 10:43

That's the one, thanks, @Chersfrozenface . There's certainly complications there in gendered languages.

Chersfrozenface · 23/01/2026 10:42

Theeyeballsinthesky · 23/01/2026 09:57

If I remember rightly Spanish was brought into the discussion where it's non binario fir male NB and non biniria for female NB 😆

It was Italian.

The Italian for "a non-binary person" is "una persona non binaria".

'Persona' being grammatically feminine, and so also having the feminine form of the adjective, whatever the sex of the person in question.

And you have that reference in the Italian media to Eliot Sumner "l'attrice britannica non binaria".
'Actrice' being feminine and meaning 'actress' (the masculine equivalent is 'attore') and followed by the feminine forms of the adjectives meaning 'British' and 'non-binary'.

BezMills · 23/01/2026 10:24

Theeyeballsinthesky · 23/01/2026 09:57

If I remember rightly Spanish was brought into the discussion where it's non binario fir male NB and non biniria for female NB 😆

Was that a Spanish woman under cx during the ERCC tribunal, iirc.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 23/01/2026 09:57

Chersfrozenface · 23/01/2026 09:43

There was this thread which dealt with the German self ID law.
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5048705-selfid-law-passed-in-german-parliament?page=1

In it, in reply to the observation "but it might have been that in German there are not separate words for sex and gender", a poster by the name of Delfin said
"Exactly. And the SBGG for the first time defines "Geschlecht". It says that it can be determined by every person itself (gender). Which basically explodes all laws that draw on the term "Geschlecht" without defining it. Which is all of the laws, including our constitution."

But there have also been conversations, I think, on how masculine nouns for jobs, for instance, had to have female equivalents coined, in order to avoid sexism. So you have adverts for "lehrer/in" = lehrer, male or lehrerin (female). But that's still male teacher and female teacher, so what about the enbies.

If I remember rightly Spanish was brought into the discussion where it's non binario fir male NB and non biniria for female NB 😆