Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Darlington Nurses" vs County Durham and Darlington NHS Trust Tribunal Thread 9

432 replies

ThreeWordHarpy · 16/01/2026 12:36

Thread 1, 7-Oct to 23-Oct
Thread 2, 23-Oct to 28-Oct
Thread 3, 28-Oct to 29-Oct
Thread 4, 29-Oct to 31-Oct
Thread 5, 31-Oct to 04-Nov
Thread 6, 04-Nov to 05-Nov
Thread 7, 05-Nov to 11-Nov
Thread 8, 11-Nov to 16-Jan (last thread with the schedule and abbreviations)

Five nurses working at Darlington Memorial Hospital filed a legal case against their employer, an NHS trust, for sexual harassment and sex discrimination. The nurses objected to sharing the women’s changing facilities with a male colleague, Rose, who identifies as female. The hearing was held between 20th October and 11th November and was live tweeted by Tribunal Tweets who have comprehensive information regarding this case on their substack, including archives of the twitter threads, lists of people involved and press releases.

At the time this thread was started, the judgment had not yet been published on the Courts website but was widely reported in the media that the NHS was found to have discriminated against the nurses, but the claims against Rose were not upheld.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 14:07

The judgment tries to draw a distinction between RH's non-harassing behaviour by being in the women's CR, and the the trusts harassing behaviour in permitting him to be there. Michael Foran drew attention to the fact that it was hard to conceive how it could be harassment to permit behaviour that wasn't itself harassing, and I came up with a counterexample. But I'm not sure that's right as a matter of law. The reasoning in para. 355 of the judgment seems weak to me. The relevant part reads:

"Given that the Claimants’ complaints can be comprehensively addressed by focusing on the conduct of the Trust itself, it is not reasonable, in our judgement, and having regard to all of the above circumstances, to conclude that as regards Rose personally, that the conduct of using the female changing room be regarded as having the proscribed effect. "

The problem there is that the clause the judge appears to rely on to avoid finding RH having harassed, the "having regard to the other circumstances of the case" clause, should by the way the act is worded properly apply only to the perception of the harassee. The law isn't structured to allow the judge to conclude that the behaviour was harassment but it wouldn't be "fair" or equitable to RH to find him responsible, that it was someone else's fault.

The judgment draws attention to this very point in 356:

We do not consider there to be a logical contradiction in a conclusion that the Trust harassed the claimants by permitting Rose to use the changing room but that, by exercising the choice to use it, Rose did not. The two conclusions are easily reconcilable. Nor is it simply a theoretical distinction without meaning. In our judgement, the distinction does justice to the facts.

I don't think the two conclusions are easily reconcilable, and saying they are doesn't make them so. As for the distinction does justice to the facts: it does justice to the outcome, but I don't think it suits the fact.

I think the judge is playing fast and loose with the law, albeit for equitable purposes. Curious whether anyone else will address that.

Catiette · 17/01/2026 14:00

ItsCoolForCats · 17/01/2026 11:03

Thanks for posting that. It's really good. This part is such a clear and powerful summary (my bold).

But this case raises a question that extends beyond policy. How did we reach a point where eight healthcare workers had to take their own employer to tribunal to secure the basic human dignity of not undressing in front of a male colleague? And how did their own unions not just fail to support them, but actively brand them as bigots?

The answer lies in the intersection of identity politics, elite institution capture, and the abandonment of materialist analysis. When subjective feelings trump objective reality, when identity claims override bodily boundaries, when administrators and union officials can dismiss women’s concerns as requiring re-education, we have created the conditions for systematic abuse dressed up as progressive inclusion.

The left, historically grounded in material analysis of power, has too often surrendered this terrain to liberals who mistake linguistic games for liberation. Renaming male people as women does not redistribute power. It erases the category on which women’s oppression is based.

As Labour Heartlands has argued consistently, any genuine left-wing politics must begin with material reality. Women exist as a biological class. Their oppression is rooted in that material existence. And their liberation requires the defence of sex-based rights and protections, not their dissolution in favour of self-declared identity.

ETA, on rereading - the phrasing of it really makes the Orwellian nature of what we're living through clear. Terrifying. Thank goodness reality is breaking through.

lcakethereforeIam · 17/01/2026 13:51

Jo Bartosch has written it up for the Critic

A victory for common sense | Josephine Bartosch | The Critic Magazine https://share.google/pYpBH0pnstAoYRmES

ProtectedlyInsufferable · 17/01/2026 13:30

I shall try to post the link to the Sex Matters discussion on the judgment, well worth a read, as clear as you would expect

sex-matters.org/posts/updates/victory-for-the-darlington-nurses/

Brefugee · 17/01/2026 13:24

have been stunned to find a few accounts over on BlueSky sharing this good news. (for sure there is pushback from the TRAs but it is encouraging that there is a bit of a dint in the echo chamber)

TRAs mostly crowing that the charges of harassment against "rose" have been thrown out. And that is fine for me - the NHS trust is in the wrong and they are the harassers. They should have offered "rose" a place to change the minute they realised he was using the women's facilities.

The unions have been anti women from the outset though, first they didn't want women in the workplace because they took men's jobs etc etc, so it is no surprise they are still anti women.

But. But. But. This is the PERFECT opportunity for a union to represent both sides of this issue. That there MUST be single sex facilities for privacy and dignity (I prefer not to say "safe" spaces - this should be basic stuff). And that where necessary they should provide a separate, appropriate place for trans colleagues - or agree that there can be unisex changing for anyone that wants to use it, and single sex for everyone who wants that.

It really isn't rocket science.

SidewaysOtter · 17/01/2026 13:24

This is one of the saddest and most anger-inducing aspects of this case - Unions abandoning women at their time of need

@AreYouSureAskedNaomi, unions have rarely given a tuppenny fuck for women’s rights. Read “One Hand Tied Behind Us” by Jill Liddington & Jill Norris - it’s a history of the suffragette movement and it shocked me how little the unions cared then. They care little more now.

lifeturnsonadime · 17/01/2026 13:14

That article is spot on.

ProtectedlyInsufferable · 17/01/2026 13:08

Ereshkigalangcleg · 17/01/2026 13:05

Brilliant article.

I just wish that I believed that any of these union leaders would read it

Ereshkigalangcleg · 17/01/2026 13:05

ItsCoolForCats · 17/01/2026 11:03

Brilliant article.

SwirlyGates · 17/01/2026 13:01

Needmoresleep · 17/01/2026 12:05

In case people are interested Claire Coutinho MP has a petition to persuade Epson NHS Trust not to sack nurse Jennifer Melle. She has sort of slipped under the radar as most of her backing has been from the church, but to me her treatment is just as shocking.

If you are interested Google. They promise you can then unsubscribe to emails from the Conservative Party. I don't know if anyone else, non-party-affiliated is running anything.

Edited

Yes, I signed this recently. That's two Tory petitions I've signed in the past week! But then I also contributed to the Christian Concern crowdfunder for the Darlington Nurses, which some left-wingers felt they couldn't possibly be associated with... If the left-wing won't support us, I'll support the people who do.

borntobequiet · 17/01/2026 12:50

Excellent article from Mr Knaggs.

ItsCoolForCats · 17/01/2026 12:45

fcktonoclingfilm · 17/01/2026 12:34

This is an absolutely brilliant article - crystal clear on how working class women have been let down and material reality ignored for luxury beliefs. Well done Paul Knaggs.

It's good to read articles like this because there aren't many people on the left or from trade union backgrounds speaking out. Paul Knaggs really gets it.

And whenever there are these type of articles on Labour Heartlands, the vast majority of comments are from people agreeing with him (and we know TRAs aren't shy about making their feelings known). It gives me hope that there is a silent majority within the trade union movement that don't agree with how women, such as the Darlington nurses, are treated, but aren't more vocal because of the intimidation tactics mentioned in the article. And these type of silencing tactics won't work in the longterm.

fcktonoclingfilm · 17/01/2026 12:34

ItsCoolForCats · 17/01/2026 11:03

This is an absolutely brilliant article - crystal clear on how working class women have been let down and material reality ignored for luxury beliefs. Well done Paul Knaggs.

fcktonoclingfilm · 17/01/2026 12:32

AreYouSureAskedNaomi · 17/01/2026 11:59

This is one of the saddest and most anger-inducing aspects of this case - Unions abandoning women at their time of need

Remember that at Darlington dozens of nurses were unhappy with sharing facilities with a man. Not all of them were able to go to court for a variety of reasons, one of which must have been lack of union support. Especially vulnerable were the international nurses that withdrew from the complaint early on, afraid that it would affect their visa status.

So many women cowered by ONE MAN, and the might of management and unions ready to do anything to grant him his wishes.

Given how the NHS has behaved towards women as a class, I feel very concerned that many nurses reliant on their employer for visa status are essentially now in a coercive relationship and being abused by their employer and forced to routinely and repeatedly get undressed in front a man (which may breach cultural and religious requirements as well as privacy, dignity and safety) as part of their employment.

And as we know the unions have sided with managers wanting to force women to undress in front of males.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 17/01/2026 12:25

SidewaysOtter · 17/01/2026 12:12

That’s just what I was going to post Grin

I’ve got a packet of beef mince in the freezer that has significantly better critical thinking skills than your average TG Redditor.

They’re just so confidently wrong it’s funny.

Conxis · 17/01/2026 12:24

AreYouSureAskedNaomi · 17/01/2026 11:59

This is one of the saddest and most anger-inducing aspects of this case - Unions abandoning women at their time of need

Remember that at Darlington dozens of nurses were unhappy with sharing facilities with a man. Not all of them were able to go to court for a variety of reasons, one of which must have been lack of union support. Especially vulnerable were the international nurses that withdrew from the complaint early on, afraid that it would affect their visa status.

So many women cowered by ONE MAN, and the might of management and unions ready to do anything to grant him his wishes.

I hope these nurses all now get together and put in a claim against the Trust

SidewaysOtter · 17/01/2026 12:13

nauticant · 17/01/2026 12:06

Costs are only awarded in Employment Tribunal cases in exceptional circumstances. The general rule is no costs awards.

Also, they haven’t decided damages/compensation yet.

SidewaysOtter · 17/01/2026 12:12

TwoLoonsAndASprout · 17/01/2026 11:00

To the mince?

That’s just what I was going to post Grin

I’ve got a packet of beef mince in the freezer that has significantly better critical thinking skills than your average TG Redditor.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 17/01/2026 12:06

Absolutely agree @needmoresleep. The details of that case are jaw dropping.

nauticant · 17/01/2026 12:06

SwirlyGates · 17/01/2026 11:41

Have they been awarded any costs? Is a decision on costs still pending? Or are they definitely not getting anything?

Costs are only awarded in Employment Tribunal cases in exceptional circumstances. The general rule is no costs awards.

Needmoresleep · 17/01/2026 12:05

In case people are interested Claire Coutinho MP has a petition to persuade Epson NHS Trust not to sack nurse Jennifer Melle. She has sort of slipped under the radar as most of her backing has been from the church, but to me her treatment is just as shocking.

If you are interested Google. They promise you can then unsubscribe to emails from the Conservative Party. I don't know if anyone else, non-party-affiliated is running anything.

AreYouSureAskedNaomi · 17/01/2026 12:00

ProfessorBinturong · 17/01/2026 11:57

Bumba was Fife, not Darlington.

It was a general reference to those who put policies together without understanding their impact

OdeToTheNorthWestWind · 17/01/2026 11:59

ProfessorBinturong · 17/01/2026 11:57

Bumba was Fife, not Darlington.

Of course! Thank you.🙄

AreYouSureAskedNaomi · 17/01/2026 11:59

moto748e · 17/01/2026 11:38

What a good piece! Couldn't agree more. If only people like that were in charge of the Labour Party.

In any just world, this is the moment where the trade unions would have stepped in. The protection of female workers from harassment and the defence of safe working conditions are, quite literally, the reason unions exist.
So, where were they? Where was the mighty machinery of Unison, the UK’s largest union with a predominantly female membership? Where were the GMB and Unite?
They were not standing on the picket line with these nurses. In a grotesque inversion of their founding principles, elements of the trade union movement were actively lining up against them.

This is one of the saddest and most anger-inducing aspects of this case - Unions abandoning women at their time of need

Remember that at Darlington dozens of nurses were unhappy with sharing facilities with a man. Not all of them were able to go to court for a variety of reasons, one of which must have been lack of union support. Especially vulnerable were the international nurses that withdrew from the complaint early on, afraid that it would affect their visa status.

So many women cowered by ONE MAN, and the might of management and unions ready to do anything to grant him his wishes.

ProfessorBinturong · 17/01/2026 11:57

Bumba was Fife, not Darlington.