Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Darlington Nurses" vs County Durham and Darlington NHS Trust Tribunal Thread 9

432 replies

ThreeWordHarpy · 16/01/2026 12:36

Thread 1, 7-Oct to 23-Oct
Thread 2, 23-Oct to 28-Oct
Thread 3, 28-Oct to 29-Oct
Thread 4, 29-Oct to 31-Oct
Thread 5, 31-Oct to 04-Nov
Thread 6, 04-Nov to 05-Nov
Thread 7, 05-Nov to 11-Nov
Thread 8, 11-Nov to 16-Jan (last thread with the schedule and abbreviations)

Five nurses working at Darlington Memorial Hospital filed a legal case against their employer, an NHS trust, for sexual harassment and sex discrimination. The nurses objected to sharing the women’s changing facilities with a male colleague, Rose, who identifies as female. The hearing was held between 20th October and 11th November and was live tweeted by Tribunal Tweets who have comprehensive information regarding this case on their substack, including archives of the twitter threads, lists of people involved and press releases.

At the time this thread was started, the judgment had not yet been published on the Courts website but was widely reported in the media that the NHS was found to have discriminated against the nurses, but the claims against Rose were not upheld.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
SexRealistic · 17/01/2026 16:07

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 14:19

That, actually, is a very interesting legal point that I would enjoy reading an appeal judgment about, even outside the context and facts of this case.

I wonder if there's a budget (and a will) to appeal that finding?

It really does boil down to the tribunal deciding "it wouldn't be right to find RH personally responsible".

Edited

My read is that Sweeney wanted to focus on those making policy and enforcing policy. He was keen it wasn’t one side versus other or personal for Rose.

He is saying those that allowed this to happen failed the nurses - calling Rose guilty muddies the waters somewhat - from my read between the lines.

Not saying it’s right. But of course these delusional people have been enabled so much that they don’t know what’s right. Their employers know better so they better control them better.

Londonmummy66 · 17/01/2026 15:54

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 14:24

Here's another interesting (positive) conclusion of the tribunal:

360. By analogy, we consider that the existence of a policy which permits a biological male who identifies as a woman to use the female changing rooms may properly be characterised as ‘conduct’ in itself.

In other words, its feasible that a woman can sue for harassment merely by the existence of a policy permitting men into women's changing rooms. She doesn't need to wait to see a man in there, nor even for there to be any trans-identifying men at her workplace.

He did go on to say that it might be the ratification and or adoption of the policy that was conduct if the policy itself wasn't conduct - might be a weasel loophole to write a policy and then not ratify it, although I imagine doing anything with it - eg sending it to someone or putting it on a website might be conduct.

ThreeSixtyTwo · 17/01/2026 15:44

Wow, the judgment is written so clearly, that I was able to read and understand it - eglish isn't my first language. It reads as a mystery novel.

I like the explanations of what kind of findings is this tribunal making and how dismissing claim doesn't mean the person is lying.

A few thoughts

  • It is incredibly difficult to prove personal level harassment.
  • The trust was so concerned with Rose's rights, potential risk of lawsuit or media involvement, that they totally failed to notice the risk of a potential lawsuit or media involvement on the nurses side - even after the nurses got a solicitor! It is frightening how relatively competent people can collectively hold such a huge blind spot.
  • Generally, no employer should ever be asking (or needing to know) about their employee trying to conceive (M or F part of it) However the wording of the policy about self declaring that one lives fully in the chosen gender made it relevant. But they didn't feel they could ask and disregard it as a rumour. It's sign of a bad policy, that it makes something like this relevant.
  • I like the indirect discrimination explanation about different effect of the same policy on men and women.

One of my favourite sentences, just from language point of view is
Although Ms Bailey ought to have known this from the emails, someone, either Theatres managers or Ms Smedley or Ms Atkinson, could have but did not make it clear. It says so much.

So now the tribunal said that the Trust is wrong, Rose personally is off the hook, Trust should move Rose to the ex-office and suggest some reasonable remedy for the nurses, preferably without a need for another tribunal hearing.
Am i right?

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 15:23

ItsCoolForCats · 17/01/2026 15:15

No I do take that point. And I think ETs should should rule that it is harassment, but they don't seem prepared to go that far because trans people seem to have a special status in that regard.

Yes, that's what the Legal Feminist blog described as this tribunal's "failure of nerve".

Partly I think the problem stems from the tribunal wrongly having absorbed that there is stigma in being a "harasser", like an abuser. The EA2010 doesn't impute moral blame to it's requirements (or else it they would be criminal offences), it (paraphrasing) just says if someone is harassed they should get money damages. Inadvertent harassment by an individual is just as serious as inadvertent harassment by an organization. The tribunal could have, and should have, in my view, said that RH had harassed the claimants, although it should be clear that it is not a moral or ethical judgment, and that RH may well have felt fully justified in his behaviour.

nicepotoftea · 17/01/2026 15:19

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 15:11

Again, it's categorically not an excuse to harassment that you - even genuinely -didn't think the person would be offended by your behaviour.

The trust genuinely thought they were doing the right thing too. It wasn't, and isn't, an exuse.

I agree with what you are saying from a legal point of view, but I suspect the nurses won't have the desire to go back to court to prove that point, as long as the hospital changes their policies and provides them with single sex spaces.

I also think that many people will think that from an ethical point of view intention is relevant and that the nurses got their single sex spaces, so it would be difficult to raise funds.

ItsCoolForCats · 17/01/2026 15:15

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 15:11

Again, it's categorically not an excuse to harassment that you - even genuinely -didn't think the person would be offended by your behaviour.

The trust genuinely thought they were doing the right thing too. It wasn't, and isn't, an exuse.

No I do take that point. And I think ETs should should rule that it is harassment, but they don't seem prepared to go that far because trans people seem to have a special status in that regard.

TriesNotToBeCynical · 17/01/2026 15:14

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 15:11

Again, it's categorically not an excuse to harassment that you - even genuinely -didn't think the person would be offended by your behaviour.

The trust genuinely thought they were doing the right thing too. It wasn't, and isn't, an exuse.

Your correction is noted and I am grateful - quick googling raises the "reasonable person" defence; that is harder to justify.

ContentedAlpaca · 17/01/2026 15:14

TriesNotToBeCynical · 17/01/2026 15:01

A possible rationale is that mens rea is required for harassment. The Trust knew or should have known that they were harassing the nurses. But perhaps Rose might be excused for assuming he would not be harassing the nurses because he was misled by trans propaganda and his employer's permission.

I am not saying I agree with this analysis (or even necessarily believe that that was Rose's honest opinion), but it at least it applies a lawful rationale to the judgment.

This reminds me of the Middlesbrough case of the 17 year old man, Ciara Watkins who didn't disclose that he was not a woman when engaging in sexual activity with another young man. Ciara was found guilty and put on the sex offenders register.

Both he and Rose were told they could be women and that anyone who said they weren't was a bigot. The man that was able to see women undress and was in a state of undress in the women's changing room has been found to be not culpable.

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 15:11

ItsCoolForCats · 17/01/2026 15:10

I think there is something in this because I think some of these men do genuinely believe they are women. Plus Rose had colleagues who were siding with him over the awful bigoted nurses (and put up the inclusive changing space poster).

If you look on the trans Reddit board, they express utter astonishment that any woman would have an issue sharing changing facilities with (as they see it) another type of woman. And that is why this issue is so intractable because they have no real understanding of how (actual) women feel. And I think that is how the tribunal viewed Rose.

ETA you also have to remember that these men are surrounded by family, friends and colleagues who are affirming them at every step. This feeds in to their belief that they are entitled to be treated as women in all circumstances. This was very apparent with Dr. Upton. Is anyone close to these men telling them the truth?

Edited

Again, it's categorically not an excuse to harassment that you - even genuinely -didn't think the person would be offended by your behaviour.

The trust genuinely thought they were doing the right thing too. It wasn't, and isn't, an exuse.

ItsCoolForCats · 17/01/2026 15:10

TriesNotToBeCynical · 17/01/2026 15:01

A possible rationale is that mens rea is required for harassment. The Trust knew or should have known that they were harassing the nurses. But perhaps Rose might be excused for assuming he would not be harassing the nurses because he was misled by trans propaganda and his employer's permission.

I am not saying I agree with this analysis (or even necessarily believe that that was Rose's honest opinion), but it at least it applies a lawful rationale to the judgment.

I think there is something in this because I think some of these men do genuinely believe they are women. Plus Rose had colleagues who were siding with him over the awful bigoted nurses (and put up the inclusive changing space poster).

If you look on the trans Reddit board, they express utter astonishment that any woman would have an issue sharing changing facilities with (as they see it) another type of woman. And that is why this issue is so intractable because they have no real understanding of how (actual) women feel. And I think that is how the tribunal viewed Rose.

ETA you also have to remember that these men are surrounded by family, friends and colleagues who are affirming them at every step. This feeds in to their belief that they are entitled to be treated as women in all circumstances. This was very apparent with Dr. Upton. Is anyone close to these men telling them the truth?

123ZYX · 17/01/2026 15:08

@TriesNotToBeCynical
I took far too long to type, and you’ve explained far more clearly what I was trying to say.

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 15:08

TriesNotToBeCynical · 17/01/2026 15:01

A possible rationale is that mens rea is required for harassment. The Trust knew or should have known that they were harassing the nurses. But perhaps Rose might be excused for assuming he would not be harassing the nurses because he was misled by trans propaganda and his employer's permission.

I am not saying I agree with this analysis (or even necessarily believe that that was Rose's honest opinion), but it at least it applies a lawful rationale to the judgment.

A possible rationale is that mens rea is required for harassment.

I'm not sure that's correct. "Mens rea" is usually applied to criminal offences. The requirements for conduct to be harassment are laid out clearly in EA2010. It's conduct that has the "purpose or effect" of creating a hostile or intimidating (etc.) environment.

The conduct has to be deliberate, sure, but only to the extent of meaning to enter the women's changing room and not, for example, having accidentally tripped over the threshold.

123ZYX · 17/01/2026 15:06

I can see the argument for Rose not harassing.

From Rose’s perspective, national charities were saying that workplaces were not a service so FWS didn’t apply, therefore Rose was allowed to be in the changing room and this was being supported by HR and other colleagues. Rose was a healthcare worker, not an HR expert or lawyer, so isn’t expected to know the detail of the law. Therefore, from Rose’s perspective, the nurses complaining were discriminating against Rose, due to Rose’s protected characteristic of gender reassignment.

Had HR said that the law said that trans women must use the changing room of their sex, or evidence had shown that Rose knew the law required Rose to use the male changing room, harassment by Rose would have been more clearly present.

I think that’s a good outcome, because it puts the pressure on employers to tell employees that changing rooms are based on sex, and the employer will be held responsible if this isn’t done.

TriesNotToBeCynical · 17/01/2026 15:01

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 14:19

That, actually, is a very interesting legal point that I would enjoy reading an appeal judgment about, even outside the context and facts of this case.

I wonder if there's a budget (and a will) to appeal that finding?

It really does boil down to the tribunal deciding "it wouldn't be right to find RH personally responsible".

Edited

A possible rationale is that mens rea is required for harassment. The Trust knew or should have known that they were harassing the nurses. But perhaps Rose might be excused for assuming he would not be harassing the nurses because he was misled by trans propaganda and his employer's permission.

I am not saying I agree with this analysis (or even necessarily believe that that was Rose's honest opinion), but it at least it applies a lawful rationale to the judgment.

nicepotoftea · 17/01/2026 14:50

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 14:19

That, actually, is a very interesting legal point that I would enjoy reading an appeal judgment about, even outside the context and facts of this case.

I wonder if there's a budget (and a will) to appeal that finding?

It really does boil down to the tribunal deciding "it wouldn't be right to find RH personally responsible".

Edited

I suspect there won't be a will to appeal, given that the judgement was clear that the hospital must comply with the H&S legislation and provide single sex changing rooms.

Unless there is a legal point of which I am ignorant, it's not clear what the nurses would gain.

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 14:47

KitWyn · 17/01/2026 14:46

As soon as Rose knew the women were upset, and kept on using the changing room regardless, for me that becomes harassment. Just because the organisation says he's entitled to be there, doesn't excuse his selfish choices. He knows he has an adult male body, and other women don't want to see him or be seen by him when undressing.

I'm guessing that the Tribunal Panel were wary that finding RH even partly liable for harassment would unleash the TRA flying, screeching and pooping monkeys. GLP would immediately start to fund raise, and an appeal by RH would be near inevitable. Money won't be a concern for him.

In contrast, the Hospital is very unlikely to appeal. It would be both very expensive, and very unlikely to succeed. Just more legal bills, more newspaper headlines and more public humiliation for them to endure.

So, hopefully, the Judgement holds, without appeals.

There's a great deal of really, really good stuff in the ruling. RH, is legally male so, should never have been in the Women's Changing Room. It says this many times over.

It's a big win.

an appeal by RH would be near inevitable. Money won't be a concern for him.

He's not a party to the case. He's not able to appeal no matter how horrible the tribunal is about him. I agree with you about the flying monkeys bit, though, even if the tribunal wouldn't put it in those terms.

KitWyn · 17/01/2026 14:46

miffmufferedmoof · 17/01/2026 14:36

Interesting. I did struggle a bit to follow the judge's reasoning on this question.

If he had found that Rose's presence in the changing room constituted harassment by Rose, would there have been any actual impact on Rose (other than to feelings), given that Rose was not a named respondent and the Trust would be held responsible?

As soon as Rose knew the women were upset, and kept on using the changing room regardless, for me that becomes harassment. Just because the organisation says he's entitled to be there, doesn't excuse his selfish choices. He knows he has an adult male body, and other women don't want to see him or be seen by him when undressing.

I'm guessing that the Tribunal Panel were wary that finding RH even partly liable for harassment would unleash the TRA flying, screeching and pooping monkeys. GLP would immediately start to fund raise, and an appeal by RH would be near inevitable. Money won't be a concern for him.

In contrast, the Hospital is very unlikely to appeal. It would be both very expensive, and very unlikely to succeed. Just more legal bills, more newspaper headlines and more public humiliation for them to endure.

So, hopefully, the Judgement holds, without appeals.

There's a great deal of really, really good stuff in the ruling. RH, is legally male so, should never have been in the Women's Changing Room. It says this many times over.

It's a big win.

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 14:45

miffmufferedmoof · 17/01/2026 14:36

Interesting. I did struggle a bit to follow the judge's reasoning on this question.

If he had found that Rose's presence in the changing room constituted harassment by Rose, would there have been any actual impact on Rose (other than to feelings), given that Rose was not a named respondent and the Trust would be held responsible?

As far as I know, only an impact on Rose's reputation. I don't think the claimants would get any more damages from the hospital, either.

I predict (based on neither authority nor expertise) that a remedy hearing will not be required, there will be no appeal, and that this point will be left hanging for another tribunal and EAT to take up.

miffmufferedmoof · 17/01/2026 14:36

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 14:19

That, actually, is a very interesting legal point that I would enjoy reading an appeal judgment about, even outside the context and facts of this case.

I wonder if there's a budget (and a will) to appeal that finding?

It really does boil down to the tribunal deciding "it wouldn't be right to find RH personally responsible".

Edited

Interesting. I did struggle a bit to follow the judge's reasoning on this question.

If he had found that Rose's presence in the changing room constituted harassment by Rose, would there have been any actual impact on Rose (other than to feelings), given that Rose was not a named respondent and the Trust would be held responsible?

AreYouSureAskedNaomi · 17/01/2026 14:32

During the hearing Rose came across as initially never having considered how the women were feeling about his presence in the changing room (perhaps a very male mindset...)

However after the nurses complained he knew without a doubt he was upsetting them by being there. It could be argued that his continued presence from that point constitutes harassment. But he was sure he had the right to be there and he was backed by management.

They thought the law was on their side so the only issue in their minds was the women's attitude, hence the infamous "they need educating and broadening their horizons".

Rose's actions would have been impossible without the trust's explicit, continuous support, and their warped policies.

AGlessandahalf · 17/01/2026 14:26

ItsCoolForCats · 17/01/2026 11:03

This is an excellent piece

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 14:24

Here's another interesting (positive) conclusion of the tribunal:

360. By analogy, we consider that the existence of a policy which permits a biological male who identifies as a woman to use the female changing rooms may properly be characterised as ‘conduct’ in itself.

In other words, its feasible that a woman can sue for harassment merely by the existence of a policy permitting men into women's changing rooms. She doesn't need to wait to see a man in there, nor even for there to be any trans-identifying men at her workplace.

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 14:19

That, actually, is a very interesting legal point that I would enjoy reading an appeal judgment about, even outside the context and facts of this case.

I wonder if there's a budget (and a will) to appeal that finding?

It really does boil down to the tribunal deciding "it wouldn't be right to find RH personally responsible".

TWETMIRF · 17/01/2026 14:15

I thought that breaking the law because your employer made you was no defence.

WandaSiri · 17/01/2026 14:12

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 14:07

The judgment tries to draw a distinction between RH's non-harassing behaviour by being in the women's CR, and the the trusts harassing behaviour in permitting him to be there. Michael Foran drew attention to the fact that it was hard to conceive how it could be harassment to permit behaviour that wasn't itself harassing, and I came up with a counterexample. But I'm not sure that's right as a matter of law. The reasoning in para. 355 of the judgment seems weak to me. The relevant part reads:

"Given that the Claimants’ complaints can be comprehensively addressed by focusing on the conduct of the Trust itself, it is not reasonable, in our judgement, and having regard to all of the above circumstances, to conclude that as regards Rose personally, that the conduct of using the female changing room be regarded as having the proscribed effect. "

The problem there is that the clause the judge appears to rely on to avoid finding RH having harassed, the "having regard to the other circumstances of the case" clause, should by the way the act is worded properly apply only to the perception of the harassee. The law isn't structured to allow the judge to conclude that the behaviour was harassment but it wouldn't be "fair" or equitable to RH to find him responsible, that it was someone else's fault.

The judgment draws attention to this very point in 356:

We do not consider there to be a logical contradiction in a conclusion that the Trust harassed the claimants by permitting Rose to use the changing room but that, by exercising the choice to use it, Rose did not. The two conclusions are easily reconcilable. Nor is it simply a theoretical distinction without meaning. In our judgement, the distinction does justice to the facts.

I don't think the two conclusions are easily reconcilable, and saying they are doesn't make them so. As for the distinction does justice to the facts: it does justice to the outcome, but I don't think it suits the fact.

I think the judge is playing fast and loose with the law, albeit for equitable purposes. Curious whether anyone else will address that.

I agree.
I've just posted this on the other thread:

I also don't understand how/why the tribunal did not conclude that Henderson harassed the nurses simply by being there, even with permission, when he knew he was not wanted, and that the question about getting changed was harassment. Legal Feminist go into this question towards the end of this TwiX thread. I think LF also doesn't think that part of the judgement makes sense, I hope I'm not just misunderstanding the thread.

https://x.com/legalfeminist/status/2012271435100643525

Legal Feminist (@legalfeminist) on X

Apologies for the hiatus while X was down and other work had to be done. A third 🧵on the Darlington Nurses judgment, skipping now to the conclusions.

https://x.com/legalfeminist/status/2012271435100643525

Swipe left for the next trending thread