Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Darlington Nurses" vs County Durham and Darlington NHS Trust Tribunal Thread 9

432 replies

ThreeWordHarpy · 16/01/2026 12:36

Thread 1, 7-Oct to 23-Oct
Thread 2, 23-Oct to 28-Oct
Thread 3, 28-Oct to 29-Oct
Thread 4, 29-Oct to 31-Oct
Thread 5, 31-Oct to 04-Nov
Thread 6, 04-Nov to 05-Nov
Thread 7, 05-Nov to 11-Nov
Thread 8, 11-Nov to 16-Jan (last thread with the schedule and abbreviations)

Five nurses working at Darlington Memorial Hospital filed a legal case against their employer, an NHS trust, for sexual harassment and sex discrimination. The nurses objected to sharing the women’s changing facilities with a male colleague, Rose, who identifies as female. The hearing was held between 20th October and 11th November and was live tweeted by Tribunal Tweets who have comprehensive information regarding this case on their substack, including archives of the twitter threads, lists of people involved and press releases.

At the time this thread was started, the judgment had not yet been published on the Courts website but was widely reported in the media that the NHS was found to have discriminated against the nurses, but the claims against Rose were not upheld.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
WandaSiri · 18/01/2026 10:26

sillygoof · 18/01/2026 10:23

Couldn’t an appeal jeopardise the whole ruling? If the appeal judge was a Mr Kemp, could they lose the whole lot? And it’s legally binding at upper tribunal.

I don't think so - I think you can appeal on specific legal findings, you don't have to ask for the whole judgement to be set aside. That's what Allison Bailey did.

MoistVonL · 18/01/2026 10:25

@EmmyFr I completely agree about the difference between Henderson (entitled and uncaring) and Upton (actively seeking to destroy a woman's career)

sillygoof · 18/01/2026 10:23

WandaSiri · 18/01/2026 02:49

She would have advised an appeal, is what I meant.

Couldn’t an appeal jeopardise the whole ruling? If the appeal judge was a Mr Kemp, could they lose the whole lot? And it’s legally binding at upper tribunal.

WandaSiri · 18/01/2026 10:18

MyAmpleSheep · 18/01/2026 03:27

I don't think so. She would likely advise her clients that their monetary damages wouldn't be much higher, even if they win an appeal, and their additional costs will be very significant, win or lose. It's not an advocate's role to recommend an ideological appeal that is to the advantage of many but to the disadvantage of her clients.

As @TriesNotToBeCynical also points out, CLC may not wish or be able to fund it.

Edited

Well, we will have to agree to differ.

tropicaltrance · 18/01/2026 10:04

JustFish · 18/01/2026 06:50

The absolving of Rose of harassment is interesting, because Rose's behaviour didn't end at using the changing room, staring and inappropriate comments qnd questions - there was also a lot of information about other behaviours that the nurses found intimidating /harassing eg seeking out the nurses who had complained, making a point of being on their wards /in their workspaces when there was no reason to be there, recruiting people to his side, the possible involvement in the 'inclusive' posters that appeared. While Rose's behaviour in using and continuing to use the changing rooms could be explained by following the trusts policy, there was no trust instruction or policy that said 'act like a manipulative stalker if you don't get your way'

Same with Upton, also not found to be in any way personally responsible, with the trust policy should ring the blame - and yet the individuals behaviour is the issue, not just using the female facilities and the lack of consideration and respect for colleagues, but the manipulation of the situation, the lies and attempts to use policy to punish triangulation and drama that adds to the hostility of the situation. All because entitled males have an unreasonable demand to be seen as female and will do anything to force compliance with their unreality.

I think it is worth reading the paragraphs in the judgment which consider those allegations in detail and explain the conclusions reached.

EmmyFr · 18/01/2026 08:00

(First, even though I am late to the party, HURRAH!)

I wouldn't put Henderson and Upton in the same category. The judgement, while it errs on the side of Benevolence to RH (maybe tactically ?), is really well written and explains clearly why it does not find faulty behavior on his side. While none of the nurses are found to be lying (thank God), it explains that "normal" behavior on RH's part was genuinely felt to be malicious by the nurses because of the importance of the subject to them... While he just couldn't see the problem and just acted normally without extra precautions. The comparison with the nighttime situation is to the point. If a male crosses the street and finds himself on the same side as a female, it may be that it's just his way... But the female will genuinely and legitimately feel threatened anyway. And the male just doesn't think about it. In the judges view, RH basically did as he was told to do, doing his best to ignore the whole thing. Ditto for the fact that he contradicted Karen Danson: the incident was traumatic to her, and just non existent to him (I still remember a discussion with my mum 23 years ago that she had forgotten all about the next day...).

Upton on the other hand deliberately started proceedings to have Sandie disciplined. Hell, he deliberately fabricated the patient safety incident. That is definitely not the same level of evil.

ETA: judgment does demonstrate that, ironically, Henderson is definitely not kind.

JustFish · 18/01/2026 06:50

The absolving of Rose of harassment is interesting, because Rose's behaviour didn't end at using the changing room, staring and inappropriate comments qnd questions - there was also a lot of information about other behaviours that the nurses found intimidating /harassing eg seeking out the nurses who had complained, making a point of being on their wards /in their workspaces when there was no reason to be there, recruiting people to his side, the possible involvement in the 'inclusive' posters that appeared. While Rose's behaviour in using and continuing to use the changing rooms could be explained by following the trusts policy, there was no trust instruction or policy that said 'act like a manipulative stalker if you don't get your way'

Same with Upton, also not found to be in any way personally responsible, with the trust policy should ring the blame - and yet the individuals behaviour is the issue, not just using the female facilities and the lack of consideration and respect for colleagues, but the manipulation of the situation, the lies and attempts to use policy to punish triangulation and drama that adds to the hostility of the situation. All because entitled males have an unreasonable demand to be seen as female and will do anything to force compliance with their unreality.

MyAmpleSheep · 18/01/2026 03:27

WandaSiri · 18/01/2026 02:49

She would have advised an appeal, is what I meant.

I don't think so. She would likely advise her clients that their monetary damages wouldn't be much higher, even if they win an appeal, and their additional costs will be very significant, win or lose. It's not an advocate's role to recommend an ideological appeal that is to the advantage of many but to the disadvantage of her clients.

As @TriesNotToBeCynical also points out, CLC may not wish or be able to fund it.

WandaSiri · 18/01/2026 02:49

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 20:54

May I respectfully point out that even had Naomi (Cunningham) been conducting the case, she would still have only the status that Niazi Fetto has, and that an appeal on that point would be at the pleasure solely of the claimants, the nurses?

She would have advised an appeal, is what I meant.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 18/01/2026 00:20

WandaSiri · 17/01/2026 18:09

I am also reminded of the Allison Bailey tribunal judgement - the panel were unwilling to follow the logic of the facts and argument to the finding that Stonewall had tried to get Garden Court Chambers to discriminate against Allison Bailey. They swerved at the last minute.

Yes, in all these cases the employer has carried the can, rightly, but they’ve been reluctant to sanction individuals and organisations who in many cases were the instigators of the harassment.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 18/01/2026 00:16

DrBlackbird · 17/01/2026 16:37

I wonder if this judgement will influence Phillipson at all? She’s so deep down the bekind rabbit hole. Perhaps she won’t have to act because individual trusts will realise on the own they had better get on and act on the law as it stands and not SW law.

That poor woman / trans man being so vulnerable and then being placed with adult men with acute psychiatric conditions. That particular lawsuit cannot happen fast enough. It might be difficult to find an individual to be responsible but it might finally FFS wake up those making such decisions to actually think about what they're doing.

I’m not sure she’s “being kind”. She’s calculating what’s best for Bridget Philipson, first and the party, second. Whether she’s called it wrong is another matter.

TriesNotToBeCynical · 17/01/2026 21:14

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 20:54

May I respectfully point out that even had Naomi (Cunningham) been conducting the case, she would still have only the status that Niazi Fetto has, and that an appeal on that point would be at the pleasure solely of the claimants, the nurses?

And, in practice, the discretion of those funding such an appeal.

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 20:54

WandaSiri · 17/01/2026 17:54

So would I!

I think if it had been Naomi conducting the case, she would appeal. This part does smell a bit of the Tribunal thinking the nurses should be satisfied with the finding against the Trust and not be mean to the poor misunderstood Henderson.

May I respectfully point out that even had Naomi (Cunningham) been conducting the case, she would still have only the status that Niazi Fetto has, and that an appeal on that point would be at the pleasure solely of the claimants, the nurses?

moto748e · 17/01/2026 20:50

SqueakyDinosaur · 17/01/2026 20:08

I thought I'd share this comment, from trans reddit, as it shows the depth of (one area of) the absolute misunderstanding of the purpose and intent of equality legislation:

"All these contradictory rulings need a resolution via parliament doing its job, but I would worry they'd not act in our favour as was the intent of the original Equalities Act."

O wad some Pow'r...

MoistVonL · 17/01/2026 20:09

I would once more like to voice my thanks to the knowledgeable souls of FWR - your specific analysis of the minutiae of the ruling has been so helpful to a layperson like myself.

SqueakyDinosaur · 17/01/2026 20:08

I thought I'd share this comment, from trans reddit, as it shows the depth of (one area of) the absolute misunderstanding of the purpose and intent of equality legislation:

"All these contradictory rulings need a resolution via parliament doing its job, but I would worry they'd not act in our favour as was the intent of the original Equalities Act."

SwirlyGates · 17/01/2026 19:00

"The fault for all of this lies squarely on the government, specifically Bridget Phillipson and Keir Starmer... It is an obscene indictment of the government’s cowardice, and women will not forgive them for it."

And not just the government. I won't be forgiving any of the lunatics who have promoted this shite, to the utter detriment of women.

borntobequiet · 17/01/2026 18:58

Another excellent article.

Alpacajigsaw · 17/01/2026 18:55

Conxis · 17/01/2026 10:37

Now that the Trust have been found to have an illegal policy the Claimants I assume will be due compensation for their distress.

What about all the other signatories of the letter (the one they tried to call a petition) and anyone else who raised a concern/was forced to change elsewhere? Can they now also put forward claims for compensation based on the impact of the policy?

They’ll likely be out of time

WandaSiri · 17/01/2026 18:09

I am also reminded of the Allison Bailey tribunal judgement - the panel were unwilling to follow the logic of the facts and argument to the finding that Stonewall had tried to get Garden Court Chambers to discriminate against Allison Bailey. They swerved at the last minute.

WandaSiri · 17/01/2026 17:54

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 14:19

That, actually, is a very interesting legal point that I would enjoy reading an appeal judgment about, even outside the context and facts of this case.

I wonder if there's a budget (and a will) to appeal that finding?

It really does boil down to the tribunal deciding "it wouldn't be right to find RH personally responsible".

Edited

So would I!

I think if it had been Naomi conducting the case, she would appeal. This part does smell a bit of the Tribunal thinking the nurses should be satisfied with the finding against the Trust and not be mean to the poor misunderstood Henderson.

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 17:25

ThreeSixtyTwo · 17/01/2026 15:44

Wow, the judgment is written so clearly, that I was able to read and understand it - eglish isn't my first language. It reads as a mystery novel.

I like the explanations of what kind of findings is this tribunal making and how dismissing claim doesn't mean the person is lying.

A few thoughts

  • It is incredibly difficult to prove personal level harassment.
  • The trust was so concerned with Rose's rights, potential risk of lawsuit or media involvement, that they totally failed to notice the risk of a potential lawsuit or media involvement on the nurses side - even after the nurses got a solicitor! It is frightening how relatively competent people can collectively hold such a huge blind spot.
  • Generally, no employer should ever be asking (or needing to know) about their employee trying to conceive (M or F part of it) However the wording of the policy about self declaring that one lives fully in the chosen gender made it relevant. But they didn't feel they could ask and disregard it as a rumour. It's sign of a bad policy, that it makes something like this relevant.
  • I like the indirect discrimination explanation about different effect of the same policy on men and women.

One of my favourite sentences, just from language point of view is
Although Ms Bailey ought to have known this from the emails, someone, either Theatres managers or Ms Smedley or Ms Atkinson, could have but did not make it clear. It says so much.

So now the tribunal said that the Trust is wrong, Rose personally is off the hook, Trust should move Rose to the ex-office and suggest some reasonable remedy for the nurses, preferably without a need for another tribunal hearing.
Am i right?

Rose has had separate changing facilities and hasn't been using the women's CR since at least April 2025.

The hospital will have to redraft its policies, and the nurses will get monetary damages. If the nurses and the hospital can't agree how much they get paid or some other aspect of what the hospital has to do to put things right then there will be a remedies hearing.

DrBlackbird · 17/01/2026 16:37

RedToothBrush · 17/01/2026 10:21

Those fudges or 'waiting for the EHRC' suddenly look a lot harder to do.

It puts pressure on Phillipson and the commission to get the fuck on with it too. They look like dicks (sic) swinging in the wind.

I wonder if this judgement will influence Phillipson at all? She’s so deep down the bekind rabbit hole. Perhaps she won’t have to act because individual trusts will realise on the own they had better get on and act on the law as it stands and not SW law.

That poor woman / trans man being so vulnerable and then being placed with adult men with acute psychiatric conditions. That particular lawsuit cannot happen fast enough. It might be difficult to find an individual to be responsible but it might finally FFS wake up those making such decisions to actually think about what they're doing.

AreYouSureAskedNaomi · 17/01/2026 16:23

MyAmpleSheep · 17/01/2026 15:23

Yes, that's what the Legal Feminist blog described as this tribunal's "failure of nerve".

Partly I think the problem stems from the tribunal wrongly having absorbed that there is stigma in being a "harasser", like an abuser. The EA2010 doesn't impute moral blame to it's requirements (or else it they would be criminal offences), it (paraphrasing) just says if someone is harassed they should get money damages. Inadvertent harassment by an individual is just as serious as inadvertent harassment by an organization. The tribunal could have, and should have, in my view, said that RH had harassed the claimants, although it should be clear that it is not a moral or ethical judgment, and that RH may well have felt fully justified in his behaviour.

Edited

In an ideal world:

TIM goes to management: "I've just found out that my presence in the female changing room has been distressing my colleagues. I am mortified. How can we work together to find a solution that works for all of us?"

In reality, during questioning (I paraphrase):

"Did you ever consider how your presence in the changing room affected your colleagues?"
"Not really, no"
🙄

I agree that Rose's conduct appears to have met the definition of harassment. But I wonder (I fear) what it will take for an employment tribunal to find one of these men guilty of harassment.