Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Darlington Nurses" vs County Durham and Darlington NHS Trust Tribunal Thread 9

432 replies

ThreeWordHarpy · 16/01/2026 12:36

Thread 1, 7-Oct to 23-Oct
Thread 2, 23-Oct to 28-Oct
Thread 3, 28-Oct to 29-Oct
Thread 4, 29-Oct to 31-Oct
Thread 5, 31-Oct to 04-Nov
Thread 6, 04-Nov to 05-Nov
Thread 7, 05-Nov to 11-Nov
Thread 8, 11-Nov to 16-Jan (last thread with the schedule and abbreviations)

Five nurses working at Darlington Memorial Hospital filed a legal case against their employer, an NHS trust, for sexual harassment and sex discrimination. The nurses objected to sharing the women’s changing facilities with a male colleague, Rose, who identifies as female. The hearing was held between 20th October and 11th November and was live tweeted by Tribunal Tweets who have comprehensive information regarding this case on their substack, including archives of the twitter threads, lists of people involved and press releases.

At the time this thread was started, the judgment had not yet been published on the Courts website but was widely reported in the media that the NHS was found to have discriminated against the nurses, but the claims against Rose were not upheld.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
Londonmummy66 · 18/01/2026 17:53

ItsCoolForCats · 18/01/2026 16:29

Is the Faye Caldicott case NHS as well? I think that's due to be heard soon.

Yes it is and she is still a long way short of her target. I've just celebrated the Darlington judgement with some carrots for Faye. Just thought I'd mention it as others might be able/willing to do the same.

ItsCoolForCats · 18/01/2026 16:29

Is the Faye Caldicott case NHS as well? I think that's due to be heard soon.

ItsCoolForCats · 18/01/2026 16:28

https://www.thenorthernecho.co.uk/news/25774775.employers-told-look-single-sex-space-policies/?ref=cprfa

This comment is infuriating:

An NHS spokesman said: “We are working through the implications of the Supreme Court ruling, and we absolutely recognise the need for revised guidance on same-sex accommodation as soon as possible.
“It’s important that we wait for the Equality and Human Rights Commission to publish its statutory guidance following the Supreme Court’s judgment before final decisions about future policy are taken – but we are working closely with Government to ensure we can provide updated guidance for the health service as soon as possible.”

They are still working through the implications of the SC judgement, coming up to a year later 🤔 This judgement should be a wake up call that their policy is unlawful, but they still have to wait for the EHRC code of practice, which Bridget Phillipson is refusing to lay before parliament.

Employers told to look at single-sex space policies after Darlington nurses tribunal

Employers have been told they need to look at their policies on single-sex spaces after an employment tribunal involving nurses at Darlington…

https://www.thenorthernecho.co.uk/news/25774775.employers-told-look-single-sex-space-policies/?ref=cprfa

Ereshkigalangcleg · 18/01/2026 16:26

ScrollingLeaves · 18/01/2026 16:22

If the employer's policies are reasonable and lawful, and their enforcement of those policies is robust, that's all that's needed from a legal viewpoint, I think.

I think that has to be the point.

If the changing rooms are for women, then transwomen may not use them. That is all that matters.

If a transwoman is a kind, nice, considerate man that still does not mean he can use the women’s changing rooms. Neither may he if he looks very pretty and quite feminine, as that still does not make any difference: he is a man and men are not allowed.

I agree, it’s just a case of convincing people that men are not allowed in women’s spaces. No small matter!

ScrollingLeaves · 18/01/2026 16:22

SqueakyDinosaur · 18/01/2026 10:29

Much though I'd find it satisfying to see the likes of DrU and Rose getting a ticking-off in the judgment, it's much more important that the employer carries the can.

ETs are about disputes between employee and employer. If the employer's policies are reasonable and lawful, and their enforcement of those policies is robust, that's all that's needed from a legal viewpoint, I think.

If the employer's policies are reasonable and lawful, and their enforcement of those policies is robust, that's all that's needed from a legal viewpoint, I think.

I think that has to be the point.

If the changing rooms are for women, then transwomen may not use them. That is all that matters.

If a transwoman is a kind, nice, considerate man that still does not mean he can use the women’s changing rooms. Neither may he if he looks very pretty and quite feminine, as that still does not make any difference: he is a man and men are not allowed.

Needmoresleep · 18/01/2026 16:18

Like with failing socialist states we seem to be ending up with a nomenklatura. A bureaucratic class which forms a power elite within our government, civil service and public sector including unions. Their interest is not the working class they claim to serve but preserving their own power. What better way to ensure ordinary women know their place than by humiliating them in changing rooms. Or calling out academics for wrong speech, etc.

The NHS in particular does not seem to care about the people at the coal face. Those working nights in A&E on Christmas eve. Its not just the trans issue. Ordinary workers don't count, even consultants are thought of in terms of numbers. No wonder productivity is falling.

Until our nomenklatura starts valuing the dedicated people who contribute to our society, things will get worse.

ItsCoolForCats · 18/01/2026 16:14

SecretSquirrelLoo · 18/01/2026 16:10

Time for a discrimination case against the union?

Fiona Macdonald is suing PCS (you can Google her case) and Sandie Peggie is suing the RCN, but there really needs to be a case brought against Unison.

SecretSquirrelLoo · 18/01/2026 16:10

Time for a discrimination case against the union?

MoistVonL · 18/01/2026 16:02

Forester1 · 18/01/2026 15:59

Not even an attempt to acknowledge that there may be different and very valid views.

Because they are misogynistic shits who don't give a stuff about the working class women they are meant to protect.

Forester1 · 18/01/2026 15:59

ItsCoolForCats · 18/01/2026 14:55

Unison's statement on the judgement:

https://www.unison.org.uk/news/article/2026/01/unison-statement-on-nhs-legal-case/

Basically, we haven't read it yet because it's too long but we stand by our trans and non-binary members (but not women who want the single spaces they are entitled to in law). Bastards.

Not even an attempt to acknowledge that there may be different and very valid views.

moto748e · 18/01/2026 15:36

Useless unions.

ItsCoolForCats · 18/01/2026 14:55

Unison's statement on the judgement:

https://www.unison.org.uk/news/article/2026/01/unison-statement-on-nhs-legal-case/

Basically, we haven't read it yet because it's too long but we stand by our trans and non-binary members (but not women who want the single spaces they are entitled to in law). Bastards.

UNISON statement on NHS legal case - UNISON National

The union stands by its beliefs in the rights of our trans, non-binary and gender diverse members

https://www.unison.org.uk/news/article/2026/01/unison-statement-on-nhs-legal-case

Ereshkigalangcleg · 18/01/2026 14:09

MyrtleLion · 18/01/2026 13:06

None of the three cases are binding until the Employment Appeal Trubunal rules on them.

However, this case does correctly apply FWS, so employers should be wary of continuing as before. Even in Sandie Peggie's case, she won on harassment by Fife NHS and their costs have been considerable. The finding the Upton should have changed elsewhere while they investigated is not insignificant.

The safest form of action for employers is to find private neutral spaces for trans-identifying staff to use. If those staff complain under the Equality Act or Article 8 of the Human Rights Act, they are on much more secure footing. And we would get judgments from the different perspectives of trans Claimants.

Jolyon etc are treating it as “two out of three to us”.

Ereshkigalangcleg · 18/01/2026 14:07

WandaSiri · 18/01/2026 10:59

Much though I'd find it satisfying to see the likes of DrU and Rose getting a ticking-off in the judgment, it's much more important that the employer carries the can.

I do think there needs accountability both for the employer and for the man in question. There must be consequences for individuals. At the moment, when it comes to public services, it's virtually a free hit for the man - the taxpayer is paying and the employer is responsible for the men's actions, even when they go beyond just reasonable use of the space.

But...

26 Harassment
(1)A person (A) harasses another (B) if—
(a)A engages in unwanted conduct related to a relevant protected characteristic, and
(b)the conduct has the purpose or effect of—
(i)violating B's dignity, or
(ii)creating an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment for B.
(My bold above)
....
(4)In deciding whether conduct has the effect referred to in subsection (1)(b), each of the following must be taken into account—
(a)the perception of B;
(b)the other circumstances of the case;
(c)whether it is reasonable for the conduct to have that effect.

The Trust is Person A, Henderson is person A, the nurses are Person B.

It doesn't make sense to say that the mere presence of the man in the women's spaces is harassment by the employer because the effect of it is to violate dignity or create a degrading/hostile atmosphere, etc (exact wording above), even if the employer thought they were doing the right thing with their policy, yet the presence of the man who is causing that effect is not harassment by the man. It shouldn't matter that he thinks he's allowed to be there under the employer's policy. It would have been good to have a clear statement that just going into women's facilities, if you are a man, can be harassment in and of itself. You don't have to be acting like a creep, or masturbating in a cubicle, or filming, or committing any other criminal offence.

Agree, and the lie continues that these men are especially fragile and need to be protected, and none of them could possibly be doing it to sexually harass or deliberately create a hostile environment for women.

Personally I think a considerable number get off on those things, and until that is recognised, we are going to come up against the view that they shouldn’t be excluded, it’s possibly unlawful discrimination etc etc etc.

nauticant · 18/01/2026 13:14

And if the employers instruct their trans-identifying staff in that way, and the male staff continue to use female single-sex spaces, then the resulting cases are going to have a much better chance of holding that their Rose Hendersons did carry out harassment.

MyrtleLion · 18/01/2026 13:06

lcakethereforeIam · 18/01/2026 11:32

As this judgement has made clear that a man, of any stripe of gender, in a woman's changing room is harassment won't this mean that tw still doing this are more likely to be individually guilty of harassment? Or is the water still muddy because of Kemp's judgement and the Leonardo one, as well as this one not being binding?

None of the three cases are binding until the Employment Appeal Trubunal rules on them.

However, this case does correctly apply FWS, so employers should be wary of continuing as before. Even in Sandie Peggie's case, she won on harassment by Fife NHS and their costs have been considerable. The finding the Upton should have changed elsewhere while they investigated is not insignificant.

The safest form of action for employers is to find private neutral spaces for trans-identifying staff to use. If those staff complain under the Equality Act or Article 8 of the Human Rights Act, they are on much more secure footing. And we would get judgments from the different perspectives of trans Claimants.

WiltingAtTreadmills · 18/01/2026 12:09

Brefugee · 18/01/2026 10:35

i find it useful that Upton and Henderson don't get blame assigned - because otherwise the TRAs will spin it (even more) as victimisation and personal.

This way it is "the process is at fault, and the managers/organisations who are misinterpreting the law". Much better all round.

Yes, on balance I think this is far better overall, for where we are now.

Anyone interested in the tribunal will have formed their own opinion about RH's actions anyway.

lcakethereforeIam · 18/01/2026 11:32

As this judgement has made clear that a man, of any stripe of gender, in a woman's changing room is harassment won't this mean that tw still doing this are more likely to be individually guilty of harassment? Or is the water still muddy because of Kemp's judgement and the Leonardo one, as well as this one not being binding?

LadyBlakeneysHanky · 18/01/2026 11:10

I find it baffling & inappropriate that any attempt is made to determine whether Henderson harassed females by looking into his mind. We don’t know what’s going on in someone else’s mind. His motives could have been either benign, or depraved, or anything in between. How can we tell? (Particularly in circumstances where the only action from which intent could be inferred - invading female spaces - has been normalised to such a degree that it is difficult to infer anything at all from it.)

The sole test in these circumstances should be action. And if a male is present in a female only space, in circumstances where women have made it clear he is not welcome, that should be enough to constitute harassment, without further enquiry into his motive.

WandaSiri · 18/01/2026 10:59

SqueakyDinosaur · 18/01/2026 10:29

Much though I'd find it satisfying to see the likes of DrU and Rose getting a ticking-off in the judgment, it's much more important that the employer carries the can.

ETs are about disputes between employee and employer. If the employer's policies are reasonable and lawful, and their enforcement of those policies is robust, that's all that's needed from a legal viewpoint, I think.

Much though I'd find it satisfying to see the likes of DrU and Rose getting a ticking-off in the judgment, it's much more important that the employer carries the can.

I do think there needs accountability both for the employer and for the man in question. There must be consequences for individuals. At the moment, when it comes to public services, it's virtually a free hit for the man - the taxpayer is paying and the employer is responsible for the men's actions, even when they go beyond just reasonable use of the space.

But...

26 Harassment
(1)A person (A) harasses another (B) if—
(a)A engages in unwanted conduct related to a relevant protected characteristic, and
(b)the conduct has the purpose or effect of—
(i)violating B's dignity, or
(ii)creating an intimidating, hostile, degrading, humiliating or offensive environment for B.
(My bold above)
....
(4)In deciding whether conduct has the effect referred to in subsection (1)(b), each of the following must be taken into account—
(a)the perception of B;
(b)the other circumstances of the case;
(c)whether it is reasonable for the conduct to have that effect.

The Trust is Person A, Henderson is person A, the nurses are Person B.

It doesn't make sense to say that the mere presence of the man in the women's spaces is harassment by the employer because the effect of it is to violate dignity or create a degrading/hostile atmosphere, etc (exact wording above), even if the employer thought they were doing the right thing with their policy, yet the presence of the man who is causing that effect is not harassment by the man. It shouldn't matter that he thinks he's allowed to be there under the employer's policy. It would have been good to have a clear statement that just going into women's facilities, if you are a man, can be harassment in and of itself. You don't have to be acting like a creep, or masturbating in a cubicle, or filming, or committing any other criminal offence.

Alpacajigsaw · 18/01/2026 10:49

I don’t think they’ll appeal. It’s annoying Rose wasn’t found to have harassed them but it seems to be a decision based on the judge finding the facts the claimants alleged about him walking around in holey boxers was not established. And the loss of the victimisation claims seemed to be that the employer was already fucking up, it wasn’t because they did a protected act that happened.

Easytoconfuse · 18/01/2026 10:43

SwirlyGates · 17/01/2026 11:41

Have they been awarded any costs? Is a decision on costs still pending? Or are they definitely not getting anything?

The judge is expecting them to sort it out without coming back to court. I've ordered popcorn, Tunnocks teacakes and Tunnocks Wafers and done a spot of gardening to the brave women who've stepped up and stood up for all of us.

Brefugee · 18/01/2026 10:35

i find it useful that Upton and Henderson don't get blame assigned - because otherwise the TRAs will spin it (even more) as victimisation and personal.

This way it is "the process is at fault, and the managers/organisations who are misinterpreting the law". Much better all round.

SqueakyDinosaur · 18/01/2026 10:29

Ereshkigalangcleg · 18/01/2026 00:20

Yes, in all these cases the employer has carried the can, rightly, but they’ve been reluctant to sanction individuals and organisations who in many cases were the instigators of the harassment.

Much though I'd find it satisfying to see the likes of DrU and Rose getting a ticking-off in the judgment, it's much more important that the employer carries the can.

ETs are about disputes between employee and employer. If the employer's policies are reasonable and lawful, and their enforcement of those policies is robust, that's all that's needed from a legal viewpoint, I think.

Swipe left for the next trending thread