Please or to access all these features

Feminism: Sex and gender discussions

"Darlington Nurses" vs County Durham and Darlington NHS Trust Tribunal Thread 9

432 replies

ThreeWordHarpy · 16/01/2026 12:36

Thread 1, 7-Oct to 23-Oct
Thread 2, 23-Oct to 28-Oct
Thread 3, 28-Oct to 29-Oct
Thread 4, 29-Oct to 31-Oct
Thread 5, 31-Oct to 04-Nov
Thread 6, 04-Nov to 05-Nov
Thread 7, 05-Nov to 11-Nov
Thread 8, 11-Nov to 16-Jan (last thread with the schedule and abbreviations)

Five nurses working at Darlington Memorial Hospital filed a legal case against their employer, an NHS trust, for sexual harassment and sex discrimination. The nurses objected to sharing the women’s changing facilities with a male colleague, Rose, who identifies as female. The hearing was held between 20th October and 11th November and was live tweeted by Tribunal Tweets who have comprehensive information regarding this case on their substack, including archives of the twitter threads, lists of people involved and press releases.

At the time this thread was started, the judgment had not yet been published on the Courts website but was widely reported in the media that the NHS was found to have discriminated against the nurses, but the claims against Rose were not upheld.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
19
Londonmummy66 · 20/01/2026 12:32

lcakethereforeIam · 20/01/2026 09:28

Victoria Smith has written a good article in the Critic

Does women’s discomfort matter? | Victoria Smith | The Critic Magazine https://share.google/0kdOlvgGH9cB2lQ1x

It is an excellent article. It highlights how female discomfort is seen as subordinate to male satisfaction - exactly what played out in Darlington. However I do think that the judgement didn't entirely grasp how deep seated the discomfort was. The afternoon where the 2 male counsel and the male judge discussed "normal" behaviour in a female changing room was deeply uncomfortable as it was clear that they had no idea - women in a changing room generally spend as little time as possible in the underwear and pass that as discreetly as possible (facing away from the room etc) both to preserve their own privacy and that of others. Yet the 3 men didn't understand that Rose prancing around in his boxers was not normal behaviour in a female changing room and this was probably the basis for the finding in the judgement that his behaviour was basically normal and just that the women perceived it as abnormal as their senses were heightened to his presence anyway.

Needmoresleep · 20/01/2026 12:02

Presumably they will have cleared any statement with their LBGTQ++ people/groups who will have pointed out that the use of the word "woman" is problematic.

FWSsupporter · 20/01/2026 11:44

Comtesse · 20/01/2026 07:03

To be fair it’s just one Grade 7 role, which isn’t that senior. When govt is gearing up for new legislation, there would typically be a whole team (say 6-10 people).

I agree.

In addition if, as they should, the gmt and Civil Service apply the FWS SC judgment and make it clear SSS are just that. Then there is an issue to resolve and that is what is the solution for trans people.

Even the SC acknowledged a trans identifying female (transman) should use female SSS but in doing so their appearance may mean it causes distress e.g. rape crisis centres.

The debate to be had is how do we respect sex and SSS whilst treating people with the PC of gender reassignment. Trans and non-binary people need to be involved in discussions, as do women. No debate did not just harm women but also some trans people. I can see a need for this role as part of a much wider piece of work.

I have always believed we need separate and clear legal definitions of sex and gender identity, including non-binary. Both should be PCs but legal clarity on the rights and responsibilities of each would help everyone.

JustPlainStanfreyPock · 20/01/2026 10:54

Seems like they are trying to score some petty point by deliberately avoiding the w word, certainly no change of heart or lesson learnt whatsoever.

weegielass · 20/01/2026 10:01

wow how many times do the trust say 'colleagues'? Very clear they have an issue with the word 'women'.

lcakethereforeIam · 20/01/2026 09:28

Victoria Smith has written a good article in the Critic

Does women’s discomfort matter? | Victoria Smith | The Critic Magazine https://share.google/0kdOlvgGH9cB2lQ1x

borntobequiet · 20/01/2026 07:58

BBC website this morning (the newspapers).

Can they be bothered to report accurately? Of course, No.

(Complaint duly submitted.)

"Darlington Nurses" vs County Durham and Darlington NHS Trust Tribunal Thread 9
lifeturnsonadime · 20/01/2026 07:16

i wonder if the mealy mouthed wording 'all our colleagues' is an attempt to avoid an acknowledgement that they have failed a group of 'colleagues' who share the protected characteristic of being female?

In other words are they trying to avoid being accused of sex discrimination? I haven't fully followed this case but was that allegation actually made by the nurses?

Comtesse · 20/01/2026 07:03

nauticant · 19/01/2026 19:47

The Supreme Court judgment can be overruled by a change in the law, for example to the Equality Act 2010. I would expect that someone doing the advertised role in the Cabinet Office who, depending on how they view things, might take it upon themselves to lobby for trans rights, could have discussions with senior people in the government to this end.

To be fair it’s just one Grade 7 role, which isn’t that senior. When govt is gearing up for new legislation, there would typically be a whole team (say 6-10 people).

borntobequiet · 20/01/2026 05:39

Every time the nurses open their mouths their honesty and generosity shines through, especially towards RH, who, according to what we heard in court, really did behave very badly towards them, whatever the conclusion arrived at by the panel. The Trust, totally the opposite.

Brainworm · 19/01/2026 22:53

The term ‘colleagues’ is notably overused and their failure to acknowledge the issue at hand - single sex provision is ridiculous.

It comes across to me as them being brittle and resentful about the judgement

Raquelos · 19/01/2026 22:44

Theeyeballsinthesky · 19/01/2026 20:23

Wow, they really have worked incredibly hard to not mention women at all in that statement. Twats.

sillygoof · 19/01/2026 20:25

Theeyeballsinthesky · 19/01/2026 20:23

Not really an apology!

DrBlackbird · 19/01/2026 20:12

impossibletoday · 19/01/2026 13:44

https://x.com/i/status/2013186563664982216

The Kathleen Stock interview

Ed to Dr Stock: "What is it that you’re going to say that provokes this kind of reaction"

Uh, that men can’t magically transform into women. Something humans have ‘known’ for several hundred thousand years, but which some people have decided to argue otherwise in the last few decades.

It just beggars belief that our rights to sss’s relies on the integrity of so few judges as we found to our detriment that can’t rely on medical, educational, sports, corporate, or social professionals or politicians.

Hedgehogforshort · 19/01/2026 19:51

nauticant · 19/01/2026 19:47

The Supreme Court judgment can be overruled by a change in the law, for example to the Equality Act 2010. I would expect that someone doing the advertised role in the Cabinet Office who, depending on how they view things, might take it upon themselves to lobby for trans rights, could have discussions with senior people in the government to this end.

That point is not unreasonable but i doubt it will happen

nauticant · 19/01/2026 19:47

The Supreme Court judgment can be overruled by a change in the law, for example to the Equality Act 2010. I would expect that someone doing the advertised role in the Cabinet Office who, depending on how they view things, might take it upon themselves to lobby for trans rights, could have discussions with senior people in the government to this end.

Hedgehogforshort · 19/01/2026 19:17

moto748e · 19/01/2026 19:07

Yes i have, the Supreme Court cannot be undermined in any way. So nobody knows what the actual job will involve it is hard to imagine it being anything other than a made up job to appease the TRA’s in the Labour Party.

I also believe that aside from a time issue, there is no way that the government will amend or introduce a new Act to allow males in to women's spaces.

progress is going to be slow i agree

moto748e · 19/01/2026 19:07

Hedgehogforshort · 19/01/2026 18:56

The reverse ferreting has well and truly begun now the trans desk has been locked in the broom cupboard

I wouldn't be too sure about that. Have you seen the thread about the new civil servant in the Cabinet Office?

www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/5478346-new-trans-equality-civil-servant-at-the-cabinet-office-to-focus-on-the-implications-of-2025s-supreme-court-judgment?reply=149973446

Hedgehogforshort · 19/01/2026 18:56

The reverse ferreting has well and truly begun now the trans desk has been locked in the broom cupboard

CarefulN0w · 19/01/2026 18:47

Ed is in the JM position of needing to be a true believer though. At least publicly.

April1625 · 19/01/2026 17:54

How long has Ed Balls known what a woman is? My jaw was on the floor with his performance "it's just common sense" / "why is everyone so afraid?" - compared to the hard line of "TWAW" the Labour Party has taken all these years.

There was a thread on Mumsnet many years ago about how the "peaking" would unfold; those who were against women's rights, would all suddenly be on board, as though they always had been. If anyone can point to it, I'd be grateful.

KittyWilkinson · 19/01/2026 16:57

nauticant · 19/01/2026 15:43

I'm still working my way through the judgment but this part gave me a smile:

We estimate that it would have taken about 10 seconds for Mrs Danson to get to her locker. She was not aware of anyone else in the changing room at the time. Rose was stood facing Rose’s own locker. When Mrs Danson reached her locker and stood facing it, her view of Rose (to her left) was of Rose’s back.

I'd like to commend the judge's excellent use (and non-use) of pronouns.

Well now, that's interesting.

lcakethereforeIam · 19/01/2026 15:50

Also makes clear who is being referred to. GI notwithstanding using 'her' for both may have caused confusion as to who the judge was talking about.

nauticant · 19/01/2026 15:43

I'm still working my way through the judgment but this part gave me a smile:

We estimate that it would have taken about 10 seconds for Mrs Danson to get to her locker. She was not aware of anyone else in the changing room at the time. Rose was stood facing Rose’s own locker. When Mrs Danson reached her locker and stood facing it, her view of Rose (to her left) was of Rose’s back.

I'd like to commend the judge's excellent use (and non-use) of pronouns.

Swipe left for the next trending thread