Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the problem is not that there aren’t enough good men about

315 replies

MrsShawnHatosy · 10/11/2026 10:42

But that too many women are not attracted to the kind of man that makes a good life partner? And are given the ick by such ridiculous trivial things? (The current ick thread demonstrates this quite well.). I’ve known women who are attracted to the same type over and over - alpha male or uber laddish types - and it never works out. Or they stay together but she puts up with him going to lap dancing clubs or repeatedly coming home drunk and pissing in wardrobes or even repeatedly cheating. I’ve seen this on here too.

AIBU?

OP posts:
OutsideLookingOut · 10/11/2026 18:42

FancyKitten · 10/11/2026 18:39

Yup. My mum married my dad because he had a steady job. She wanted a house, 2 kids. A nice life. That’s what she got. Married 50 years.

My aunt ditched her sensible fiancé, ran away to NYC. She’s twice divorced, and finally married to a nice guy in her 60s. He really looks after her.

This is not foolproof though. There are lots of plain, seemingly sensible guys willing to cheat as soon as they have the option to. Especally if they become successful. Look at the latest very public example with the Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang who had an affair with a Chinese spy embarrassing his wife, his children, himself, and his entire company.

The truth is that being plain does not make someone good, nor does being handsome. You will find good and bad people in both categories.

Redbags · 10/11/2026 18:43

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 18:40

I have to be attracted to a man to be intimate with him. He could be a kind man, but if I’m not attracted to him, I would not be able to have a physical relationship with him.

Of course, but I do think it's worth doing the work to understand why you wouldn't find the kind man attractive and why you find the more superficial things attractive. It's not the way you were born, afterall, somewhere along the line you've been conditioned to it.

StarDolphins · 10/11/2026 18:43

Nope. I 100% think there aren’t enough good men about.

OutsideLookingOut · 10/11/2026 18:45

Redbags · 10/11/2026 18:43

Of course, but I do think it's worth doing the work to understand why you wouldn't find the kind man attractive and why you find the more superficial things attractive. It's not the way you were born, afterall, somewhere along the line you've been conditioned to it.

Is it conditioning to look for good genes or nature? I actually think patriarchy/capitalism is the social conditioning that prevents us from being able to really listen to our own intuition.

gannett · 10/11/2026 18:47

I haven't read this particular ick thread because it would annoy me too much but the OP is on to something, in that an alarming proportion of "icks" aren't just trivial but line up with very rigid, weird ideas of masculinity that men are encouraged to fit themselves into (by other men as well, of course) which just perpetuates the whole toxic masculinity real-men-are-like-this shitshow.

Feels like a lot of women simultaneously manage to have standards that are too high, and very toxic - men must not only be a certain height and earn a certain amount but never enjoy anything soft or risk looking silly - but also too low, because the thing I rarely see discussed as a deal-breaker or an ick is a man's morals, his ethics, his actual character. Though probably soft things like giving to charity are considered unmanly icks on that thread.

gannett · 10/11/2026 18:49

OutsideLookingOut · 10/11/2026 18:45

Is it conditioning to look for good genes or nature? I actually think patriarchy/capitalism is the social conditioning that prevents us from being able to really listen to our own intuition.

It is definitely patriarchy/capitalism and there's a reason that the loudest proponents of the absolute idiocy that is evolutionary psychology (aka blame every base instinct we have on "biology" and "we can't help it" despite all the evidence that people can and do act in different ways) are also proponents of patriarchy and capitalism.

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 18:49

Redbags · 10/11/2026 18:43

Of course, but I do think it's worth doing the work to understand why you wouldn't find the kind man attractive and why you find the more superficial things attractive. It's not the way you were born, afterall, somewhere along the line you've been conditioned to it.

I can’t be intimate with a man unless I like the way he looks, feels and smells. A man can be really kind, etc., but if I don’t find him attractive, I can’t kiss his body and have sex with him. It’s just the way I am.

OutsideLookingOut · 10/11/2026 18:53

gannett · 10/11/2026 18:49

It is definitely patriarchy/capitalism and there's a reason that the loudest proponents of the absolute idiocy that is evolutionary psychology (aka blame every base instinct we have on "biology" and "we can't help it" despite all the evidence that people can and do act in different ways) are also proponents of patriarchy and capitalism.

Generally they allow for the biology that benefits men but not women. They will promote their biology at the expense of women. I am more for women going for what they want (safely) with no shame. Our intuition, our gut, our biology, however you want to describe it, can be used to justify what we want too. Not that we even should have to justify it.

Telling women to have no physical standards is a way of ensuring most men can have a pick of women to get a wife under capitalism.

Redbags · 10/11/2026 18:54

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 18:49

I can’t be intimate with a man unless I like the way he looks, feels and smells. A man can be really kind, etc., but if I don’t find him attractive, I can’t kiss his body and have sex with him. It’s just the way I am.

Yes, I understand that, but i think it's worth understanding why you feel that way and what it's that makes you like the way he looks feels and smells.

OutsideLookingOut · 10/11/2026 18:55

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 18:49

I can’t be intimate with a man unless I like the way he looks, feels and smells. A man can be really kind, etc., but if I don’t find him attractive, I can’t kiss his body and have sex with him. It’s just the way I am.

And you really have to wonder why anyone would have a problem with that. Surely a women should want to be intimate with an intimate partner? We have had hundreds of years of conditioning telling us that this is not important, to think of England during in the act, etc etc. No thank you. I say we should be attracted to the men we may be risking a pregnancy with.

gannett · 10/11/2026 18:57

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 18:49

I can’t be intimate with a man unless I like the way he looks, feels and smells. A man can be really kind, etc., but if I don’t find him attractive, I can’t kiss his body and have sex with him. It’s just the way I am.

You say this like it's some sort of unique phenomenon that only you feel. I would say this is more like the default for most women? I just think the whole "ick" culture (in which men are mostly mocked for trivial, "unmanly" things) is a bit mean-girls and mostly shores up toxic masculinity.

Redbags · 10/11/2026 18:58

OutsideLookingOut · 10/11/2026 18:55

And you really have to wonder why anyone would have a problem with that. Surely a women should want to be intimate with an intimate partner? We have had hundreds of years of conditioning telling us that this is not important, to think of England during in the act, etc etc. No thank you. I say we should be attracted to the men we may be risking a pregnancy with.

Yes, absolutely you should, but for some women, that attractiveness always means a shitty man who will treat her badly. It's worth looking at that if you're repeating that cycle.

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 18:59

OutsideLookingOut · 10/11/2026 18:55

And you really have to wonder why anyone would have a problem with that. Surely a women should want to be intimate with an intimate partner? We have had hundreds of years of conditioning telling us that this is not important, to think of England during in the act, etc etc. No thank you. I say we should be attracted to the men we may be risking a pregnancy with.

Thanks, people obviously do have a problem with it. I had two children with my ex who never once gave me the ick. I loved his mind and his body! He was my first (and only) love!

OutsideLookingOut · 10/11/2026 18:59

Redbags · 10/11/2026 18:54

Yes, I understand that, but i think it's worth understanding why you feel that way and what it's that makes you like the way he looks feels and smells.

There are many evolutionary reasons for this, compatibility, health cues etc etc...

"Body odour may provide significant cues about a potential sexual partner's genetic quality, reproductive status and health."
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1617143/

gannett · 10/11/2026 19:03

OutsideLookingOut · 10/11/2026 18:53

Generally they allow for the biology that benefits men but not women. They will promote their biology at the expense of women. I am more for women going for what they want (safely) with no shame. Our intuition, our gut, our biology, however you want to describe it, can be used to justify what we want too. Not that we even should have to justify it.

Telling women to have no physical standards is a way of ensuring most men can have a pick of women to get a wife under capitalism.

There are standards it's good to have and standards it's good to unlearn.

As a teenager I was not attracted to men of a certain race. Doesn't matter which one and I'm not going to say. The reason was the same reason that I didn't think I was attractive, as a mixed-race girl - because 90s media pushed white men and white women at me incessantly as the default beauty standard.

I've unlearned that standard. I've learned to find myself attractive, and men of that race as well. At no point did I force myself to have sex with anyone I wasn't attracted to - this is all work I did in my own brain. It was worth it.

OutsideLookingOut · 10/11/2026 19:03

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 18:59

Thanks, people obviously do have a problem with it. I had two children with my ex who never once gave me the ick. I loved his mind and his body! He was my first (and only) love!

Aww. I'm sorry it did not work out then.

But that is another thing, if my relationship did not work out for any reason I would be glad to know I had time with someone I really wanted and loved. I am glad you had that. I also find intelligence very attractive.

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 19:04

gannett · 10/11/2026 18:57

You say this like it's some sort of unique phenomenon that only you feel. I would say this is more like the default for most women? I just think the whole "ick" culture (in which men are mostly mocked for trivial, "unmanly" things) is a bit mean-girls and mostly shores up toxic masculinity.

It probably is the default for most women. It doesn’t seem to stop people thinking you are being superficial though.

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 19:08

OutsideLookingOut · 10/11/2026 19:03

Aww. I'm sorry it did not work out then.

But that is another thing, if my relationship did not work out for any reason I would be glad to know I had time with someone I really wanted and loved. I am glad you had that. I also find intelligence very attractive.

I value intelligence too. My ex was well read. We have remained good friends, which has benefited the children immensely.

OutsideLookingOut · 10/11/2026 19:08

gannett · 10/11/2026 19:03

There are standards it's good to have and standards it's good to unlearn.

As a teenager I was not attracted to men of a certain race. Doesn't matter which one and I'm not going to say. The reason was the same reason that I didn't think I was attractive, as a mixed-race girl - because 90s media pushed white men and white women at me incessantly as the default beauty standard.

I've unlearned that standard. I've learned to find myself attractive, and men of that race as well. At no point did I force myself to have sex with anyone I wasn't attracted to - this is all work I did in my own brain. It was worth it.

We cannot ignore that we live in a society with cultural norms and biases. One thing I have noticed is that men especially are more status based though of course they project that onto women. Many men admit they won't be with a woman their peers do not think is attractive. Now to care more about your peers than your own preference to me is stupid but I see rejection as protection in that sense. Someone who does not love themselves or have the steadiness of mind to go against their peers for such a decision does not deserve who they are really attracted to.

It is good you worked on it. It would be good if we could all isolate and work on cultural biases. That is a fine aside. It is more important if you have self hate because of it. It's really amazing that you did that! However, yes, you did not force yourself to be with someone you did not find attractive at the time, your attraction changed as you began to love yourself. Perhaps it is truer to say if we love ourselves more, we can find what is right for us?

SpainToday · 10/11/2026 19:16

There have been a few comments about alpha males: I can think of two. Via a sport I am involved in. They are both very good looking, financially stable, great careers and are intelligent/charming/sociable. But neither of them seem interested in a committed relationship. They seem to spend their weekends with sport/sailing/boys weekends etc. I doubt either of them are celibate so any encounters would be very casual.

Which is probably very bruising for the women involved in such encounters. So whilst they appear to be high calibre potential partners, neither of them appear interested. So what’s going on? Are women really too much hassle?

girlygirly · 10/11/2026 19:21

I think that women are too fussy! Hear me out!
You see so many posts on here (the ick one for example, or the one about partners farting) that indicate that women are looking for men that are perfect. Which is ridiculous. Everyone is fully entitled to ignore those men that give them the ick, but they can’t then complain that there are no decent men around if you are going to discount a man for wearing socks with sandals or has a tattoo when not a fan. Perhaps what I mean is ‘the ick’ is now deemed anything you may not like, as opposed to something that is a dealbreaker.
I’m on my 2nd marriage, over 30 years now and god knows he’s got his faults, as no doubt do I, but you have to decide if it is something you genuinely can’t live with. Give and take.

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 19:22

@SpainToday “Are women really too much hassle?”

Probably! If a relationship isn’t want they want, why bother?

SpainToday · 10/11/2026 19:27

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 19:22

@SpainToday “Are women really too much hassle?”

Probably! If a relationship isn’t want they want, why bother?

It’s probably more fun, from a male perspective, to have a different woman each month …..

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 19:35

girlygirly · 10/11/2026 19:21

I think that women are too fussy! Hear me out!
You see so many posts on here (the ick one for example, or the one about partners farting) that indicate that women are looking for men that are perfect. Which is ridiculous. Everyone is fully entitled to ignore those men that give them the ick, but they can’t then complain that there are no decent men around if you are going to discount a man for wearing socks with sandals or has a tattoo when not a fan. Perhaps what I mean is ‘the ick’ is now deemed anything you may not like, as opposed to something that is a dealbreaker.
I’m on my 2nd marriage, over 30 years now and god knows he’s got his faults, as no doubt do I, but you have to decide if it is something you genuinely can’t live with. Give and take.

“but they can’t then complain that there are no decent men around if you are going to discount a man for wearing socks with sandals”

A man wearing socks with sandals would be a dealbreaker for me. I don’t think we would be compatible.

Quine0nline · 10/11/2026 19:42

I'm 70. Three times married. First was a drunk, adulterer and physically abusive. Kept me hostage for a time. Second was a childhood sweet heart. Best friend when a teenager. But he was financially abusive, an adulterer and liar. That marriage lasted two weeks.

So I was single and thought unlikely to remarry, but when a penfriend seemed to be a decent man I made a list-
Must be kind, must be tolerant, must accept me, warts and all. Good sense of humour. Financially responsible and a hard worker. Practical, politically acceptable and not a sports fan were strong as also was not a drinker.

I made it clear to prospective DH that there were my terms. No alcohol - no, if he wanted to drink than drink all you.like, only I'm not on the scene
Want a girlfriend- ok, tell me, we split and do your thing. Sexually if I say no -then NO.

He accepted. Happily married 24 years.