Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the problem is not that there aren’t enough good men about

116 replies

MrsShawnHatosy · Today 10:42

But that too many women are not attracted to the kind of man that makes a good life partner? And are given the ick by such ridiculous trivial things? (The current ick thread demonstrates this quite well.). I’ve known women who are attracted to the same type over and over - alpha male or uber laddish types - and it never works out. Or they stay together but she puts up with him going to lap dancing clubs or repeatedly coming home drunk and pissing in wardrobes or even repeatedly cheating. I’ve seen this on here too.

AIBU?

OP posts:
nietzscheanvibe · Today 11:12

scoutzx · Today 10:47

@MrsShawnHatosy “But that too many women are not attracted to the kind of man that makes a good life partner?”

You can’t help who you are attracted to. If I’m going to be intimate with a man, I’m going to be fussy!

But not fussy enough to rule out someone who'll treat you badly, I think is the OP's point?

SouthLondonMum22 · Today 11:12

FallingFlying · Today 11:07

I've never been attracted to the alpha make sort but was attractive in my youth so had plenty of choice. I always saw men as a project, so chose one who I thought had potential and worked on him.

This was a very common attitude, I can absolutely see why it would be seen as unacceptable these days but I think there's a lot in it.

Unfortunately lots are of men have been raised (by parents, peers and the media) the be rather self centred and lazy. There are unlikely to be sufficient 'good' ones but plenty who are capable of change. So you either say 'I shouldn't have to do the work' and stay single or select one who is capable of growth.

Edited

Or say 'I shouldn't have to do all of the work' and wait until you meet someone who doesn't require hand holding to dress himself, cook, clean or other basic things.

They are out there, I married one.

FallingFlying · Today 11:13

MrsShawnHatosy · Today 11:11

I've never been attracted to the alpha make sort but was attractive in my youth so had plenty of choice. I always saw men as a project, so chose one who I thought had potential and worked on him.

You mean like buying a doer upper house and working on it until it’s how you want it? Would you be happy if a man had the same attitude to you?

Actually yes, we both still give each other feedback . Your tastes change over 30 years, you'd be very lucky if you both happened to still like each other without some communication and compromise.

MrsShawnHatosy · Today 11:14

Redbags · Today 11:10

I was thinking about this - women are attracted to confident men. In fact I discussed it with BF, we were talking about a mutual friend who has a series of women and often isn't very nice to them.

It made me wonder why I don't find "confident" men attractive, this friend is the last man I'd want and BF couldn't be more different.

Then it occurred to me that whilst he's not confident with women, he is very secure and confident in himself and his abilities. He can talk to anyone and will have a go at anything with complete (if sometimes misplaced!) confidence. So it is true, but we need to differentiate between kinds of confidence?

Yes there are different types of confidence. I’m not at all attracted to cocky types. My DH has the confidence that comes from being an acknowledged expert in his particular, rather niche field, but he’s not arrogant about it.

OP posts:
InWithPeaceOutWithStress · Today 11:14

Redbags · Today 11:10

I was thinking about this - women are attracted to confident men. In fact I discussed it with BF, we were talking about a mutual friend who has a series of women and often isn't very nice to them.

It made me wonder why I don't find "confident" men attractive, this friend is the last man I'd want and BF couldn't be more different.

Then it occurred to me that whilst he's not confident with women, he is very secure and confident in himself and his abilities. He can talk to anyone and will have a go at anything with complete (if sometimes misplaced!) confidence. So it is true, but we need to differentiate between kinds of confidence?

Absolutely. The air of confidence from misogyny is a facade. Rather than tackle their own insecurities they build their ego by cultivating a derogatory attitude to women. It’s harmful to women and it also fails to solve their root issue.

FallingFlying · Today 11:14

SouthLondonMum22 · Today 11:12

Or say 'I shouldn't have to do all of the work' and wait until you meet someone who doesn't require hand holding to dress himself, cook, clean or other basic things.

They are out there, I married one.

That was the minimum standard for me. I didn't say take just anyone!

MrsShawnHatosy · Today 11:14

nietzscheanvibe · Today 11:12

But not fussy enough to rule out someone who'll treat you badly, I think is the OP's point?

Exactly.

OP posts:
OutsideLookingOut · Today 11:15

No. Think of all the men who raped Giselle Pelicot. The ones who participated, the ones who walked away, there was not one who reported it to the police. Think of how many men look at child abuse images or have even participated and are not caught.

I am not saying good men do not exist but I do not think there are so many that women are ignoring them as part of a preference. You cannot even truly know you have a good one.

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 11:15

nutbrownhare15 · Today 10:50

Form watching the news I am firmly of the opinion that there aren't enough good men about. And I hope my daughters pursue lesbian relationships as they will be so much safer.

I think lesbian relationships actually have higher rates of domestic violence don’t they? I could be wrong

SouthLondonMum22 · Today 11:16

FallingFlying · Today 11:13

Actually yes, we both still give each other feedback . Your tastes change over 30 years, you'd be very lucky if you both happened to still like each other without some communication and compromise.

That doesn't sound like only you doing all of the work though.

SouthLondonMum22 · Today 11:17

MarcellaGrace · Today 11:08

I’ve always been incredibly fussy about who I dated and still had options. I think many posters on the Relationships forum aren’t anywhere near fussy enough.

I agree.

Most women aren't fussy enough and generally have low standards.

nomas · Today 11:18

MrsShawnHatosy · Today 11:14

Exactly.

You're allowed to do both, rule out misogynistic men AND men who give you the ick.

Your post is effectively telling women to lower their standards.

Redbags · Today 11:18

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 11:15

I think lesbian relationships actually have higher rates of domestic violence don’t they? I could be wrong

That seemed so unlikely to me I looked it up and actually, yes it's true, by a significant margin.

MrsShawnHatosy · Today 11:20

nomas · Today 11:18

You're allowed to do both, rule out misogynistic men AND men who give you the ick.

Your post is effectively telling women to lower their standards.

No it’s not. It’s saying women should make sure they have their priorities right.

OP posts:
Apotofrealcoffee · Today 11:20

Redbags · Today 11:18

That seemed so unlikely to me I looked it up and actually, yes it's true, by a significant margin.

Yes I was surprised as well. I wonder what the logical inference there is. I can’t quite work it out.

Mommydearest40 · Today 11:21

Redbags · Today 11:18

That seemed so unlikely to me I looked it up and actually, yes it's true, by a significant margin.

No that’s been disproved as the question asked if you have experienced domestic violence. Many lesbians were previously in heterosexual relationships and experienced this then with men.

scoutzx · Today 11:22

nietzscheanvibe · Today 11:12

But not fussy enough to rule out someone who'll treat you badly, I think is the OP's point?

I don’t want a man that is ‘too nice’ and can’t stand up for himself. (I don’t mean genuine kindness).

OutsideLookingOut · Today 11:23

Mommydearest40 · Today 11:21

No that’s been disproved as the question asked if you have experienced domestic violence. Many lesbians were previously in heterosexual relationships and experienced this then with men.

Thank you for pointing this out. It is scary that misinterpreted statistics are so widespread.

scoutzx · Today 11:23

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 11:20

Yes I was surprised as well. I wonder what the logical inference there is. I can’t quite work it out.

I never knew that either!

Apotofrealcoffee · Today 11:23

Mommydearest40 · Today 11:21

No that’s been disproved as the question asked if you have experienced domestic violence. Many lesbians were previously in heterosexual relationships and experienced this then with men.

It’s not disproved as such.

43% of lesbian women report domestic abuse, and 35% of heterosexual women.

However:

‘Research tracking same-sex domestic abuse notes that roughly two-thirds to over 80% of abuse reported by lesbian women involves female partners, while a portion may also include past relationships with male partners‘

80% of 43 is 34.4%

So lesbian domestic violence perpetration is the same % as straight male domestic violence perpetration. Within 0.6% anyway

Elliesbelly · Today 11:23

I know this is just about men but personally I know tonnes of really good women and men who have very similarly aligned values and very normal maybe even a little boringly normal lives. Many of them are in very happy, healthy long term relationships.

There are a few of our friends who’ve split who are actually individually nice people but don’t make a good couple and there are a few where obviously one or the other partner is the problem and will continue to be a problem in future relationships.

I also know some deeply, deeply problematic people that go far beyond the pale but they are pretty rare. Out of the hundreds maybe thousands of people Ive met there are 3 men and 2 women I would put into that category across my whole life but we are talking psychopath/sociopath/narcisstic level.

However I do think after a certain phase of life it can be much harder to find a decent partner of either sex because people get snapped up younger and that leaves sometimes even really nice decent people single when they can’t find someone to choose from.

Scrambledomelette · Today 11:24

My unpopular opinion, I think there are plenty of good men about, they just get locked down early and so you end up with an increasingly small pool of age adjacent men with an increasing percentage of grotters.

Luckyingame · Today 11:24

@MrsShawnHatosy

Ick about a man taking a proper bath?
That doesn't bother me. 😁

scoutzx · Today 11:26

Luckyingame · Today 11:24

@MrsShawnHatosy

Ick about a man taking a proper bath?
That doesn't bother me. 😁

I don’t take baths, only showers. A man taking a bath would be a turn off. You can’t help what gives you the ick!

MagnoliaParks · Today 11:28

scoutzx · Today 10:47

@MrsShawnHatosy “But that too many women are not attracted to the kind of man that makes a good life partner?”

You can’t help who you are attracted to. If I’m going to be intimate with a man, I’m going to be fussy!

People are fussy about who they are intimate with, but from a lot of posts not fussy about who they choose as parents to their children/to build a life with - and settle massively in this regard.

My DH is an absolute king compared to MN standards (does the majority of housework etc) but was single for years before we got together. I’m grateful, but astounded that someone wouldn’t have snapped him up or even settled with him for his positive attributes. But my gain! (I do love and fancy DH, but have left other people I loved and fancied because they didn’t also have similar outlooks on life).

ETA: just read the bath ick. Maybe that was the problem, DH loves a weekend bath, I prefer a shower… mental that that would mean someone rules someone out as a partner (he doesn’t make me bath too!).

Swipe left for the next trending thread