Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that the problem is not that there aren’t enough good men about

315 replies

MrsShawnHatosy · 10/11/2026 10:42

But that too many women are not attracted to the kind of man that makes a good life partner? And are given the ick by such ridiculous trivial things? (The current ick thread demonstrates this quite well.). I’ve known women who are attracted to the same type over and over - alpha male or uber laddish types - and it never works out. Or they stay together but she puts up with him going to lap dancing clubs or repeatedly coming home drunk and pissing in wardrobes or even repeatedly cheating. I’ve seen this on here too.

AIBU?

OP posts:
SpainToday · 10/11/2026 19:43

MrsShawnHatosy · 10/11/2026 14:39

I remember a discussion in the office about why women like bad boys. Most of them thought bad boys weren’t inherently a bad thing. One of them married a guy, they didn’t make it to the first anniversary before he left her for someone else.

Yes I think we can all think of someone who bagged the exciting guy, only to find his overnight disappearances etc not quite so exciting when she’s his wife

MrsShawnHatosy · 10/11/2026 19:48

OutsideLookingOut · 10/11/2026 18:53

Generally they allow for the biology that benefits men but not women. They will promote their biology at the expense of women. I am more for women going for what they want (safely) with no shame. Our intuition, our gut, our biology, however you want to describe it, can be used to justify what we want too. Not that we even should have to justify it.

Telling women to have no physical standards is a way of ensuring most men can have a pick of women to get a wife under capitalism.

I’m not saying women should have no physical standards (even though it’s a bit shallow to set standards about things a man can’t help - personal hygiene and weight are different in that regard. But - and I know no one has done this on this thread but I have seen it often enough elsewhere on here - there is no need to be mean and sneery about things that can’t be helped, like height). For some women though fancying the pants off someone seems to be more important than that he treats them well and generally shares the same values. They are thinking with their vags basically.

OP posts:
scoutzx · 10/11/2026 19:52

@MrsShawnHatosy “even though it’s a bit shallow to set standards about things a man can’t help -“

If I’m not physically attracted to certain things about a potential partner, I won’t embark on a relationship.

5128gap · 10/11/2026 20:24

MrsShawnHatosy · 10/11/2026 19:48

I’m not saying women should have no physical standards (even though it’s a bit shallow to set standards about things a man can’t help - personal hygiene and weight are different in that regard. But - and I know no one has done this on this thread but I have seen it often enough elsewhere on here - there is no need to be mean and sneery about things that can’t be helped, like height). For some women though fancying the pants off someone seems to be more important than that he treats them well and generally shares the same values. They are thinking with their vags basically.

Or maybe the men who have less desirable traits they can't help, could be a bit less shallow themselves and stop whinging that they can't get any woman they might like the look of? Because women have preferences too, and they are not going to be every woman's choice.
This doesn't mean no woman will have them, simply that they may not be able to get the woman they consider the hottest in the room. But hey, let's not be superficial! A woman's looks dont matter if she has a nice personality and could be an excellent wife. So if they just stopped thinking with their penis they'd probably have more luck.

Bedheadbeachbum · 10/11/2026 20:30

Redbags · 10/11/2026 18:58

Yes, absolutely you should, but for some women, that attractiveness always means a shitty man who will treat her badly. It's worth looking at that if you're repeating that cycle.

I have to agree, it's been what I've found.

The men I was attracted to were - literally all of them - no good for me.

So I went for the nice guy and those feelings of attraction grew once I'd given him the chance.

Best thing I ever did. I also did this experiment knowingly. I knew I had to go against my old pattern to change what was a horrible time. He's given me this steady life, albeit with one very rough patch when we became parents but he was a good guy who stuck through that bad time.

He's also got some nice guy friends too, was glad to see one finally get married in his 50s after being steadily dumped for years.

OutsideLookingOut · 10/11/2026 20:40

MrsShawnHatosy · 10/11/2026 19:48

I’m not saying women should have no physical standards (even though it’s a bit shallow to set standards about things a man can’t help - personal hygiene and weight are different in that regard. But - and I know no one has done this on this thread but I have seen it often enough elsewhere on here - there is no need to be mean and sneery about things that can’t be helped, like height). For some women though fancying the pants off someone seems to be more important than that he treats them well and generally shares the same values. They are thinking with their vags basically.

Fundamentally we may have different definitions of dating. Mine is an exclusionary and discriminating process to find someone I am compatible with. Not everyone is eligible. I exclude women, I have preferences for intelligence and looks - many of which will never be in a persons sole control.

I must inform you that many men are the same. They happily state “No black woken” “only Asians” “no fat women” on their profiles. Many many men have physical preferences and other preferences besides. I feel no guilt for my own.

My only criteria and I would suggest any other sovereign woman’s criteria should be that which promotes her own happiness and well being.

I am doubly discriminating in that I don’t tolerate disrespect and must find a partner physically and intellectually compatible. I enjoy the peace and comfort of my own company too much to disrupt it for anything less. Any person coming into my life must elevate it in some way.

Trottersup · 10/11/2026 20:41

Some women seem to like bad boys. I don't understand it.

scoutzx · 10/11/2026 20:45

OutsideLookingOut · 10/11/2026 20:40

Fundamentally we may have different definitions of dating. Mine is an exclusionary and discriminating process to find someone I am compatible with. Not everyone is eligible. I exclude women, I have preferences for intelligence and looks - many of which will never be in a persons sole control.

I must inform you that many men are the same. They happily state “No black woken” “only Asians” “no fat women” on their profiles. Many many men have physical preferences and other preferences besides. I feel no guilt for my own.

My only criteria and I would suggest any other sovereign woman’s criteria should be that which promotes her own happiness and well being.

I am doubly discriminating in that I don’t tolerate disrespect and must find a partner physically and intellectually compatible. I enjoy the peace and comfort of my own company too much to disrupt it for anything less. Any person coming into my life must elevate it in some way.

Edited

“I have preferences for intelligence and looks”

Same, I know what I find attractive.

SpainToday · 10/11/2026 21:23

even though it’s a bit shallow to set standards about things a man can’t help -“

But men often have very definite standards about women!

SemiRetiredLoveGoddeess · 10/11/2026 21:23

Even if you think your man is OK

Try before you buy. You don't have to live with them but just stay at each others places a few nights a week.

A short holiday or weekend away can also be a real eye opener.

The Ick factor is endless. Depends on the person. Very subjective. What some women would put up with is a real red flag to others.

Simple as that.

DecafCoffeeIsPointless · 10/11/2026 21:32

MrsShawnHatosy · 10/11/2026 19:48

I’m not saying women should have no physical standards (even though it’s a bit shallow to set standards about things a man can’t help - personal hygiene and weight are different in that regard. But - and I know no one has done this on this thread but I have seen it often enough elsewhere on here - there is no need to be mean and sneery about things that can’t be helped, like height). For some women though fancying the pants off someone seems to be more important than that he treats them well and generally shares the same values. They are thinking with their vags basically.

I'm fine with thinking with your vag but woman needs to have a standard of what they will and won't accept. First red flag and move on. It's about your own self worth.

I've dated some 'bad', some 'dangerous' some really attractive. If they don't respect me and treat me right they are gone.

If they don't call out their friends being a dick, they are gone.

We need to set the standards.

Dont settle. Dont accept less and challenge ALL men to have better morals for themselves, their friends and their family.

Too many 'good' men do nothing and say nothing so they are not really good after all.

SpainToday · 10/11/2026 22:41

My Grandmother’s generation didn’t seem to have this amount of trouble with dating, where did it all go so wrong?

Firefly1987 · 11/11/2026 00:25

5128gap · 10/11/2026 17:46

I don't think its hypocrisy because being short in a woman isn't seen as a negative, as in 'I can't get past your shortness, but you should get past mine', because her height isn't seen as less desirable.
As a 5' 4" woman I've been told I don't 'need' a tall partner because even short men are taller than me. So basically provided I'm an appropriate number of inches shorter than him, that's apparently all that matters, regardless of my preferences.

As a 5' 4" woman I've been told I don't 'need' a tall partner because even short men are taller than me. So basically provided I'm an appropriate number of inches shorter than him, that's apparently all that matters, regardless of my preferences.

Well why do you need a man a foot taller than you? Obviously you can have your preferences and that's fine but what is it about a man that you need him to not just be taller than you but massively taller than you? If you were a woman of 6 foot you wouldn't have that option unless maybe you happened to know a professional basketball player! It just seems such a random thing to focus on. How on earth can a few inches affect attraction that much? And what would be our view of men if overnight the majority decided they no longer found petite women attractive?

corduroyseason · 11/11/2026 00:39

MoreDangerousThanAWomanScorned · 10/11/2026 11:07

I’ve known women who are attracted to the same type over and over - alpha male or uber laddish types - and it never works out.

I've spent my whole life socialising with and working with the nerdy/arty, academic sort of man who is the opposite type to that. I can assure that plenty of them are misogynistic dicks, too.

I do think that some women choose abusive/unpleasant men over and over again. I also think that there are complex psychological reasons for this, and that it isn't as easy as saying 'oh well, you just go for the wrong type'.

I couldn't agree more. It's not just the so-called alpha male or laddish types. I did engineering at school and still play a fair amount of video games. The casual and hateful misogyny I hear from men in their 30s/40s in those spaces go way beyond anything I've heard from laddish types. The worrying part of it all is that the worst comments are coming from younger and younger men and boys. It's sad when you go on a Twitch stream and read comments about how attractive women should just shut up and get on OF because that's the only thing they're good for anyway. Grim.

Cuttertheduck · 11/11/2026 00:58

SpainToday · 10/11/2026 22:41

My Grandmother’s generation didn’t seem to have this amount of trouble with dating, where did it all go so wrong?

Maybe they had different standards. And being single was less acceptable.
Women these days often don't accept men who don't share housework equally or are misogynistic. A lot of them rather stay single and not depending on a man.

5128gap · 11/11/2026 06:57

Firefly1987 · 11/11/2026 00:25

As a 5' 4" woman I've been told I don't 'need' a tall partner because even short men are taller than me. So basically provided I'm an appropriate number of inches shorter than him, that's apparently all that matters, regardless of my preferences.

Well why do you need a man a foot taller than you? Obviously you can have your preferences and that's fine but what is it about a man that you need him to not just be taller than you but massively taller than you? If you were a woman of 6 foot you wouldn't have that option unless maybe you happened to know a professional basketball player! It just seems such a random thing to focus on. How on earth can a few inches affect attraction that much? And what would be our view of men if overnight the majority decided they no longer found petite women attractive?

That's not the point. The short man who told me I didn't need to be with a man as tall as my partner thought that as long as a man was taller than me that's all that mattered.
So, firstly telling me that my preference didn't matter as long as the aesthetics were OK, and I made a man look 'tall' by comparison, but also colluding with the idea that men should be taller than women. Yet only to the extent that suited his interests.
Of course I don't 'need' a tall man. But my partner is tall and I find that attractive.
If men decided petite women weren't attractive I suppose it would be no different from the men who don't find tall women or small breasts or big bums or women over 35 or whatever attractive. We'd get by.

SmokeyRidge · 11/11/2026 07:00

SilenceInside · 10/11/2026 10:43

This makes the problem the behaviour of women, rather than the behaviour of men, which seems unreasonable to me.

Surely there has to be a combination of common sense, though? Otherwise, you get two bad decision makers and come on here trying to figure out where life went wrong when it's pretty blatantly obvious to everyone else.

Thepeopleversuswork · 11/11/2026 07:07

I think the biggest problem is women becoming financially dependent on men (any kind of men) in the first place.

Enable and encourage women to be self sufficient as far as possible and the “type” of man they choose becomes largely irrelevant.

Whatafustercluck · 11/11/2026 07:26

I'm afraid I have to disagree, when you consider that 1 in 4 women has experienced some form of sexual assault in their lifetime. This isn't the same, small and insignificant number of men committing all these offences, is it?

I recently came to the realisation that I was sexually assaulted first as a 16yo and then again when I was 18. Both times by older men. At the time I didn't recognise what they did to me as serious sexual assault. I won't go into details, but the second was particularly painful, and violating. I did not consent to the escalation involved.

High profile cases recently in the news all point to a similar pattern - usually older predatory men, pursuing younger inexperienced women for their own sexual gratification. No regard for boundaries: their defence is that a woman consented to a kiss, or sex, and that gave them free rein to do whatever they wanted.

I am now married to a wonderful man who respects boundaries. He is warm, kind, loving and thoughtful. In fact, most sexual relationships I've had since then have been with men who respect boundaries. But the fact it happened to me, twice and with different men, when I was so young is indicative of the scale of the problem.

I have learned the hard way that consent needs to be explicitly taught to girls and boys, and that agreeing to one thing does not mean you are agreeing to everything. Men cannot be allowed to continue to feign ignorance.

scoutzx · 11/11/2026 08:45

Firefly1987 · 11/11/2026 00:25

As a 5' 4" woman I've been told I don't 'need' a tall partner because even short men are taller than me. So basically provided I'm an appropriate number of inches shorter than him, that's apparently all that matters, regardless of my preferences.

Well why do you need a man a foot taller than you? Obviously you can have your preferences and that's fine but what is it about a man that you need him to not just be taller than you but massively taller than you? If you were a woman of 6 foot you wouldn't have that option unless maybe you happened to know a professional basketball player! It just seems such a random thing to focus on. How on earth can a few inches affect attraction that much? And what would be our view of men if overnight the majority decided they no longer found petite women attractive?

“How on earth can a few inches affect attraction that much?”

I find that an extra few inches definitely makes a man more attractive, provided he has other great attributes.

scoutzx · 11/11/2026 08:50

Thepeopleversuswork · 11/11/2026 07:07

I think the biggest problem is women becoming financially dependent on men (any kind of men) in the first place.

Enable and encourage women to be self sufficient as far as possible and the “type” of man they choose becomes largely irrelevant.

I agree. Never become financially dependent on a man.

When my ex and I split up, we were both financially independent, we both support our children fairly.

SpainToday · 11/11/2026 09:07

“How on earth can a few inches affect attraction that much?”

At the risk of sounding shallow: if those few inches made him shorter than me, than yes, that would affect attraction. My preference is for a man to be at least the same height as me.

scoutzx · 11/11/2026 09:12

SpainToday · 10/11/2026 22:41

My Grandmother’s generation didn’t seem to have this amount of trouble with dating, where did it all go so wrong?

Plenty of women were deeply unhappy in their marriages, though they often had to endure these situations in silence due to severe social, legal, and economic limitations.

Rubydobydo · 11/11/2026 09:27

FallingFlying · 10/11/2026 11:07

I've never been attracted to the alpha make sort but was attractive in my youth so had plenty of choice. I always saw men as a project, so chose one who I thought had potential and worked on him.

This was a very common attitude, I can absolutely see why it would be seen as unacceptable these days but I think there's a lot in it.

Unfortunately lots are of men have been raised (by parents, peers and the media) the be rather self centred and lazy. There are unlikely to be sufficient 'good' ones but plenty who are capable of change. So you either say 'I shouldn't have to do the work' and stay single or select one who is capable of growth.

Edited

I am older and admit that maybe I’ve lived enough life to be hazy about how I thought 40 years ago. But I know that I’d known enough sketchy men before I met my DH of 35 years that there was more to look for than physical attraction and earning power (seemingly key nowadays).
He does still drive me potty with some habits as well as having a different sense of the importance of some things, but he is kind, sociable, able, a good father, an indulgent grandparent, will cook, clean, and do
anything if need be despite having an all consuming job as a farmer. We do talk all the time, discuss news, allow each other a differing opinion and so on.
It takes work, effort being the other trait seemingly missing amongst many younger people.

PollyBell · 11/11/2026 09:30

You mean the ones that go from a walking red flag to the next, rinse and repeat

Some men can have 'warning stay away' tattooed on their forehead and they will be lining up

Swipe left for the next trending thread