Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to things my husbands ex wife needs to accept that we are now one family.

697 replies

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 11:36

I've been with my husband for five years. He has two children from his previous marriage and we welcomed our baby together in August.

Ever since we announced I was pregnant,his ex has been noticeably upset about the situation. I do understand that it might have been an adjustment for her, but equally, we weren't having a baby to upset anyone. It was simply the natural progression of our relationship and something we wanted together. I’m not getting any younger, I’m in my late 30s, we plan to have another child but again I am in my late 30s so not sure about that. I think 5 years with someone is enough to have a child. We’ve bought a house together, we’ve had time and believe it was part of being together and having a child was something we both wanted.

The thing is, the children absolutely adore the baby. They always want to see their dad, spend time at our house and be involved in family life here. I have always made an effort to makethem feel welcomeand included. They have their own bedrooms, their own belongings and their own space here. This is their home too.

I actually thought it would be a positive thingfor their mum that I have a good relationshipwith herchildren. Surely it's better that they feel comfortable and happy in their dad's home,rather than feeling like visitors or outsiders?

I would never try to replace their mum, and I have no desire to interfere with her relationship with them.But I also don't think we should have to make our family smaller or pretend the baby doesn't exist to make her feel more comfortable.

My husband is still their dad, they are still very much part of his life, and now they have a little brother s too.

AIBU to think she needs to accept that this is the reality now and that the children having another happy, loving home to go to is a good thing? Or am I being naive how difficult this must be for her?

His children are old enough to form their own opinions and decide if they want a relationship with their sibling and they’ve chosen to have a relationship. Surely that is a good thing.

OP posts:
QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 18:41

Animatic · 08/11/2026 18:25

Presumably that's OP's attempt at showing off how little she knows about what teens can do if not cooing over her baby in her perfect family unit complemented with 4 grandparents.

That’s my way of showing that I’ve never had children till now and I don’t know what children do. In my day we were smoking and going to underground raves.

I don’t know what teens these days do all I see is vaping so what’s what I think teens do. I never claimed to well versed on what teens do to rebel I smoked at 16 to rebel but now there’s vapes.

OP posts:
QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 18:43

kkloo · 08/11/2026 18:28

Do you and your husband want them to live with you?

We wouldn’t say no but also we think that would damage their relationship with their mother so ideally no but also it’s up to them where they would want to live. They haven’t yet asked to live here that’s just their father’s assumptions based on things they’ve said. Teens change their mind every other day.

OP posts:
QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 18:44

Calliopespa · 08/11/2026 18:26

Well it isn't entirely unnatural, but better to acknowledge it than look to blame the ex for not adjusting.

Agree I’m not going to disagree with you I think you’re perfectly entitled to perceive things how you want to

OP posts:
QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 18:46

MsPrufrockk · 08/11/2026 18:30

I thought 'things' was a typo in your title, but you've just repeated the mistake here.

I'm not really sure what you want from posting here - this isn't your first thread about this, is it? It just seems like you want to say 'ahaha look at how happy my family is, aha why can't the ex be happy for us?'. Don't you have friends with ears you can chew off about how happy you are? (And are you REALLY that happy, because you come across like you're seeking some kind of validation/reassurance).

And yes, yes, I know, everyone is entitled to their opinion blah blah, and if I disagree with you that's OK. Please spare me that 😂

I mean I’m postpartum so I am still adjusting to having a baby. I wouldn't say I’m sad but it’s adjustment

OP posts:
maxslice · 08/11/2026 18:47

HelenaWaiting · 08/11/2026 18:17

Wow. You've really looked into this, haven't you? I think you know exactly what you're doing, OP, and I don't believe for a second that your husband is "trying to navigate" this. He just sticks to the access arrangement and there is no navigation required. I do wonder what part of "the novelty will wear off" is played by changing the access arrangement in your husband's favour.

You also did not start this thread looking for solutions; you were looking for a bitch-fest about the ex-wife. I can't believe that "the children won't listen" is your strongest argument here. That is the worst parenting ever - you're basically using the kids to hurt the ex whilst trying to absolve yourself of guilt. Utterly vile.

It’s not the OP who is indulging in a bitch fest,

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 18:50

HelenaWaiting · 08/11/2026 18:32

How is there a rota for them to follow on nights they aren't supposed to be with you?

Our rota is dated so we know what days they’re meant to be here and what days they’re not. At the moment majority of it is my husband as I’ve just had a baby not too long ago but before that we just split it. Ie before baby I would load the dishwasher at night he wakes up before me for work and unloads it etc. With baby he does both at the minute as he wants to help out as he works in the day and I’m still on maternity.. this works for us now but it’ll change its consent changing who does what. I used to go the weekly food shop on a Saturday morning now he wakes up at 7 and goes and gets the weekly Sainsbury’s shop. I write the shopping list though. It’s all an adjustment he does majority of the cooking now but before that we shared it equally based on who was working from home on what day etc.

OP posts:
maxslice · 08/11/2026 18:50

Besidemyselfwithworry · 08/11/2026 17:50

@QuirkyRoseLion
the big question here is…..did he have an affair with you and then left her? Or did he meet you after they’d already separated?

She said she met him after they were divorced. Not every second wife was an affair partner.

Sassylovesbooks · 08/11/2026 18:55

Your husband's ex wife is feeling pushed out by her children. At the moment her children want to spend the majority of their time at their Dad's house. Yes,
it's because they want to see their new sibling, rather than seeing their Dad. Yes, it's likely a novelty, that will eventually wear off.

However, at this moment in time, your husband's ex is feeling side lined and quite possibly replaced...by a baby! Of course, it's her children's choice to see their Dad, and spend time with their siblings. It doesn't stop the ex from feeling the way she does.

I appreciate your husband has encouraged his children to spend time with their Mum, but they'd still rather come to his. Has your husband been honest with his children? Has he explained that their Mum is finding it upsetting that they're spending the time they should be seeing their Mum, at his home? There's ways and means of explaining in such a way, that the children understand without making them feel guilty.

Farewellsummer · 08/11/2026 18:55

IngridsLittleToe · 08/11/2026 11:50

I think you're a little wrapped up in your own loved up baby bubble to think about a discarded family. She was that family. He discarded her and moved on. Of course its going to hurt. Try not to be unpleasant about your 'win'. It could one day be you in her position.

How do you know he discarded her and moved on? The ex wife may have ended the relationship or they simply weren't the right people for each other and better off apart and hes been able to find happiness again with OP 🤷‍♀️

kkloo · 08/11/2026 18:57

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 18:43

We wouldn’t say no but also we think that would damage their relationship with their mother so ideally no but also it’s up to them where they would want to live. They haven’t yet asked to live here that’s just their father’s assumptions based on things they’ve said. Teens change their mind every other day.

It seems odd that they are hinting at it but not coming out and asking if that's what they want. I wonder if there's any truth to what previous posters have said in that they're anxious about their dad having a new child and they might be pushed out. I think teens generally would just ask straight out if they want to move in or say 'I want to live here' so the fact they're hinting at it makes me think they're afraid it might be a no.

AlexandraCarrington · 08/11/2026 18:58

You've really looked into this, haven't you.... He just sticks to the access arrangement.

It doesn't take much 'looking into'. A quick read of a few threads on MN will show that teenagers choose for themselves. A 16yo is too old for 'access arrangements'.

As the op said, what do you say to a 16 yo who says you're not listening to him?

If the reverse was happening and the boys didn't want to go to their father's, responses would be all 'they vote with their feet.... you can't force them' and never mind how the father felt about it.

Piratesue · 08/11/2026 19:00

You are getting a hard time in here for no reason at all and as usual people just jumping to the conclusion they want.
Maybe it is just a case of novelty, who knows how teenage minded works. I would just keep doing what you are doing, it's up to the ex wife to bring up any issues.she has not for you to try and mind read.

But I would step away, this isn't getting you anywhere

Itsthewoluff · 08/11/2026 19:01

You say you are not passive but If you really had sympathy for her and really wanted them to stay at hers, you’d have worded your op differently.

AIBU to allow my step children to stay at ours because they want to, even though it is hurting their mother?

As it is, the way you worded it was for everyone to agree that it’s tough luck for her because she should just accept they prefer you.

Rainingasusual · 08/11/2026 19:05

I'm curious why your DP 'thinks' they want to move in and hasn't appeared to have sat them down and discussed what they want moving forward?
I think any normal parent would want to be one million percent certain that everything is happy and safe at home and that the kids are definitely where they want to be. This whole post and your responses (and lack thereof to any reasonable and actionable advice) is... odd.

renovationchoas · 08/11/2026 19:09

I’m not sensing a lot of empathy for the mum, who only seems distressed about losing out on time with her sons, which seems odd given that you have a baby boy.

The thing about second families with wealthy men is that often these men have little time when the kids are young, so the first kids get a more stressed mum who has to
grind it out to raise them to the point at which they are fun, then she gets to see their attention being bought with cool fun activities and/or the kids of the second marriage getting a level of time and second wife getting a level of emotional support that she could not possibly have had when she had her kids, because wealthy husband no longer needs to work as hard as he did. Jealousy is an ugly shade on anyone, but it can be pretty understandable. None of this is your fault, it is circumstances and timing - I’m sure you know of someone who has been out with a bloke, broken up and been gutted when he has got engaged to someone else PDQ.
It’s the same kind of thing

Is there a big income disparity that would make it harder for her to be the fun parent and treat the kids to activities or holidays or whatever also? Teens can have expensive tastes!

None of this means you are in the wrong as such, but I think you can afford to be kinder to her and encourage her sons to consider ways in which they might be able to reassure her too. You seem to be kind of enjoying this woman’s distress at your popularity, and that’s not a great shade on you either.

Farewellsummer · 08/11/2026 19:10

Soontobe60 · 08/11/2026 12:01

Why do you find it amusing? Many ex wives may have been totally screwed over by their exes. Is that something to laugh about?

And many men have been screwed over by their ex wives, who want to keep the same standard of living they had when married and dont want to have to go back to work to play their part in supporting their own children. Its not just the father thats responsible for supporting the children, its the mother too, but then that opinion isnt convenient on mn it seems!

As a single parent I upped my hours and progressed my career (and no I didnt have outside childcare support) to ensure myself and my child could be adequately provided for. My partners ex wife on the other hand, has had every penny she could and left him with the shirt on his back when he moved out. He didnt even have a car when he left as she kept it. She has never once made sure hes ok financially but he makes sure her and his DC are. She also refuses to work more than 2 days a week because, as shes said to me 'why should I as I dont want to'. Kids are older teens so no childcare issue. Its not always the man!!!

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:14

Rainingasusual · 08/11/2026 19:05

I'm curious why your DP 'thinks' they want to move in and hasn't appeared to have sat them down and discussed what they want moving forward?
I think any normal parent would want to be one million percent certain that everything is happy and safe at home and that the kids are definitely where they want to be. This whole post and your responses (and lack thereof to any reasonable and actionable advice) is... odd.

He has sat then done plenty of times and asked them if there’s anything wrong, what they’re unhappy with and all they have said is they just prefer being at dads. He cannot sit then done everytime he says them to ask them why they say they’d rather be at his all the time. It’s not every single time but quite a few times when they’re about to go back home to their mums they say that they wish they could just stay here. He has sat down with them and their mum to find out what’s going on. All the relevant people that see them often have said their behaviour has not changed. Only towards their mother and he’s not sure why or how to navigate that he is trying his best but sadly it’s not working. There is only so much he can say, he’s told them countless of times that they need to also spent time with their mum, the youngest is more understanding but the older one just says why?what if I don’t want to, you can’t force me etc, they’re both grumpy at mums but when they’re here they’re not so we get different stories all the time, mum says one thing, school says they’re acting the same, grandparents say they’re the same, hockey club says they’re the same. We are confused. They’re acting the same with all of us but different at their mums.

OP posts:
FirmSnake · 08/11/2026 19:16

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:14

He has sat then done plenty of times and asked them if there’s anything wrong, what they’re unhappy with and all they have said is they just prefer being at dads. He cannot sit then done everytime he says them to ask them why they say they’d rather be at his all the time. It’s not every single time but quite a few times when they’re about to go back home to their mums they say that they wish they could just stay here. He has sat down with them and their mum to find out what’s going on. All the relevant people that see them often have said their behaviour has not changed. Only towards their mother and he’s not sure why or how to navigate that he is trying his best but sadly it’s not working. There is only so much he can say, he’s told them countless of times that they need to also spent time with their mum, the youngest is more understanding but the older one just says why?what if I don’t want to, you can’t force me etc, they’re both grumpy at mums but when they’re here they’re not so we get different stories all the time, mum says one thing, school says they’re acting the same, grandparents say they’re the same, hockey club says they’re the same. We are confused. They’re acting the same with all of us but different at their mums.

If neither the parents nor a counsellor can determine a reason, then they absolutely can be told to show some consideration and communicate and stick to a schedule.
It's quite normal for kids to act out for their mother. In fact it is often evidence that she is their safest space.

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:16

Itsthewoluff · 08/11/2026 19:01

You say you are not passive but If you really had sympathy for her and really wanted them to stay at hers, you’d have worded your op differently.

AIBU to allow my step children to stay at ours because they want to, even though it is hurting their mother?

As it is, the way you worded it was for everyone to agree that it’s tough luck for her because she should just accept they prefer you.

I don’t think it has anything to do with me. I think it’s more so their father they want to be with.

OP posts:
QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:19

FirmSnake · 08/11/2026 19:16

If neither the parents nor a counsellor can determine a reason, then they absolutely can be told to show some consideration and communicate and stick to a schedule.
It's quite normal for kids to act out for their mother. In fact it is often evidence that she is their safest space.

That’s good to hear she is their mother she should be their safe space that’s what we all want. We’ve told them this plenty of times. He has sat down with them individually they don’t seem to want to engage in fixing this. They can’t act out forever which is why I think the novelty will wear off. They test him when they’re at their mums asking to come back saying they don’t want to be there etc and he tells them to stay what else can be done ? Surely at a point we just let them get bored as it’s an act. Everywhere else they’re acting normal, with friends at school, at sports clubs they’re still engaging in everything.

OP posts:
LoudWriter · 08/11/2026 19:19

Ooooooof this was a tough read, OP. You're postpartum aren't you, so I'd suggest you take a breather- you're responding to everything and really this is not a healthy thing to be fixated on when you've got a baby.

It's hard to tell why you've posted at all to be honest. You're not unhappy with the situation, neither does your husband seem to be, you're unwilling to listen to anyone's posts about feeling any empathy for the kids mum, and I'm not sure we ever found out anything about what exactly that poor woman is supposed to have done other than express some displeasure that her children are being led away from her with you and your husband acting as pied pipers with your blissful, emotionally stable, 'we don't even need to ask them, they just seem to want to do chores and never eat takeaway' household.

Just so you know, children (yes, even teens) save their worst behaviours and demands for their closest attachment figure. If they act up at home with their mother, then toe the line when they spend all their time with your husband and you then actually the most likely scenario is that they feel some degree of wobbly attachment now your husband has started a new family and so are making sure to appease him, whilst taking out those complex feelings on the person they feel most comfortable with...their mum. No idea if this is the case with your situation, but it's fairly likely.

FirmSnake · 08/11/2026 19:22

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:19

That’s good to hear she is their mother she should be their safe space that’s what we all want. We’ve told them this plenty of times. He has sat down with them individually they don’t seem to want to engage in fixing this. They can’t act out forever which is why I think the novelty will wear off. They test him when they’re at their mums asking to come back saying they don’t want to be there etc and he tells them to stay what else can be done ? Surely at a point we just let them get bored as it’s an act. Everywhere else they’re acting normal, with friends at school, at sports clubs they’re still engaging in everything.

He shouldn't be letting them act like this at all. Teaching them to be considerate is an important part of parenting. He needs to tell them no sometimes, he needs to enforce that they stick with plans and he and they need to communicate well with her so she knows what is happening.
He's getting away with passive parenting because he hasn't been the primary parent until now. You need to wise up before your baby gets older.

Rainingasusual · 08/11/2026 19:23

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:14

He has sat then done plenty of times and asked them if there’s anything wrong, what they’re unhappy with and all they have said is they just prefer being at dads. He cannot sit then done everytime he says them to ask them why they say they’d rather be at his all the time. It’s not every single time but quite a few times when they’re about to go back home to their mums they say that they wish they could just stay here. He has sat down with them and their mum to find out what’s going on. All the relevant people that see them often have said their behaviour has not changed. Only towards their mother and he’s not sure why or how to navigate that he is trying his best but sadly it’s not working. There is only so much he can say, he’s told them countless of times that they need to also spent time with their mum, the youngest is more understanding but the older one just says why?what if I don’t want to, you can’t force me etc, they’re both grumpy at mums but when they’re here they’re not so we get different stories all the time, mum says one thing, school says they’re acting the same, grandparents say they’re the same, hockey club says they’re the same. We are confused. They’re acting the same with all of us but different at their mums.

So, he hasn't outright asked them if they want to move in?
And he is happy enough with just not knowing why they say they 'wish they could just stay' or why they treat their mother like shit? That would be ringing alarm bells for me as a parent no matter their ages.

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:28

Rainingasusual · 08/11/2026 19:23

So, he hasn't outright asked them if they want to move in?
And he is happy enough with just not knowing why they say they 'wish they could just stay' or why they treat their mother like shit? That would be ringing alarm bells for me as a parent no matter their ages.

There’s more to the conversations that he’s had with then individually and together and the ones I’ve been in. I don’t have alarm bells ringing. He has asked them countless of times what they want, where they want to stay, they’re not going to say because they know it’ll upset their mum, the youngest himself said he doesn’t want to upset her but he doesn’t like being there, he has asked them why they’re acting that way, their answer is the same every single time, it has not changed, he’s the one that sorted out the counselling and everything else I think he does care about them based on what I’ve seen the last 5 years.

OP posts:
Rainingasusual · 08/11/2026 19:28

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 19:19

That’s good to hear she is their mother she should be their safe space that’s what we all want. We’ve told them this plenty of times. He has sat down with them individually they don’t seem to want to engage in fixing this. They can’t act out forever which is why I think the novelty will wear off. They test him when they’re at their mums asking to come back saying they don’t want to be there etc and he tells them to stay what else can be done ? Surely at a point we just let them get bored as it’s an act. Everywhere else they’re acting normal, with friends at school, at sports clubs they’re still engaging in everything.

Interesting. So your stance has moved from blaming their mother to now blaming the kids? If this is what you think, why didn't you say that in your OP instead of saying she needs to accept it? It sounds like the kids need help accepting and adjusting to this and be taught respect, consideration and collaboration by example from your husband. He needs to work with their mother and support her effectively. How he does that is between them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread