Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to things my husbands ex wife needs to accept that we are now one family.

697 replies

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 11:36

I've been with my husband for five years. He has two children from his previous marriage and we welcomed our baby together in August.

Ever since we announced I was pregnant,his ex has been noticeably upset about the situation. I do understand that it might have been an adjustment for her, but equally, we weren't having a baby to upset anyone. It was simply the natural progression of our relationship and something we wanted together. I’m not getting any younger, I’m in my late 30s, we plan to have another child but again I am in my late 30s so not sure about that. I think 5 years with someone is enough to have a child. We’ve bought a house together, we’ve had time and believe it was part of being together and having a child was something we both wanted.

The thing is, the children absolutely adore the baby. They always want to see their dad, spend time at our house and be involved in family life here. I have always made an effort to makethem feel welcomeand included. They have their own bedrooms, their own belongings and their own space here. This is their home too.

I actually thought it would be a positive thingfor their mum that I have a good relationshipwith herchildren. Surely it's better that they feel comfortable and happy in their dad's home,rather than feeling like visitors or outsiders?

I would never try to replace their mum, and I have no desire to interfere with her relationship with them.But I also don't think we should have to make our family smaller or pretend the baby doesn't exist to make her feel more comfortable.

My husband is still their dad, they are still very much part of his life, and now they have a little brother s too.

AIBU to think she needs to accept that this is the reality now and that the children having another happy, loving home to go to is a good thing? Or am I being naive how difficult this must be for her?

His children are old enough to form their own opinions and decide if they want a relationship with their sibling and they’ve chosen to have a relationship. Surely that is a good thing.

OP posts:
QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 18:14

StockingsByTheFire · 08/11/2026 18:11

I think we're beginning to see why the situation is what it is...

Fair enough. I think we get on quite well other then this situation there’s no issues between us two personally but you know her best.

OP posts:
YourWildAmberSloth · 08/11/2026 18:15

Two things can be true OP. She does need to accept the reality of the situation, but at the same time, it can be hard for her. As another poster said, her feelings are her feelings, and she's entitled to them, as long as she doesn't weaponise the children against you/their father.

Itsthewoluff · 08/11/2026 18:15

You sound so passive as if you have no say.
You say firmly. “It’s not fair on your mum. You can’t stay here for x, y and z nights.”

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 18:16

Jetplanesmeetingintheairtobe · 08/11/2026 18:10

If their dad really wanted them to be emotionally secure he wouldn't have started a second family.

True I guess then he really doesn’t care about their wellbeing in your eyes. Anyway that’s all happened now the best thing we can do now is to navigate things and make sure they’re okay. All the checks have been done by all parties who see the children and everyone has said they’re okay no change in behaviour all they’ve even said to their grandparents is that they prefer it here.

OP posts:
theleafandnotthetree · 08/11/2026 18:16

I am seperated and once my son got towards the 16 or 17 mark, he seemed to gravitate more towards his Dad's house, whereas my daughter is more orientated towards mine. I think gender plays a huge role vs the quality of relationship. My children are close to both of us. My daughter would probably like to be here full time and I am pretty insistent that she is with her Dad most of the time she is meant to be - and she is very mindful of his feelings and agrees to that. Neither my ex or my son are as sensitive to feelings as my daughter and I are and so my ex would never do anything to encourage my son to think of me. The mum in the OP's scenario is unfortunate in having boys and also possibly in having an ex who is, as most 'good' Dad's are in seperation situations, overly pandering to his sons and not willing to say 'oy, stop being a twat and go spend a few evenings at your mums'

Moonnstarz · 08/11/2026 18:17

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 18:13

Dad things they want to move in permanently because of the things they have said to them. He hasn’t pushed them because they haven’t said it explicitly. They have said multiple times they’d rather be at dads, there’s been times where when they’re supposed to go home they say how they’d rather stay here etc. Either way they haven’t been explicit about it but they did ask for the arrangements to be changed which is what. If they change it again to spend more time at dads the way it’s currently set up that would mean they’d spend majority of their time and hardly any at their mums.

If that’s what you think they are then so be it. I can’t possible add every intricate detail to the main post as it would be too long.

Then if they want that change I would suggest they need to give a proper reason. I think you should all be sitting around together, with their mum, and for them to explain why. It all seems very vague they are telling their dad they want to be with him yet not giving a valid reason for this.

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 18:17

Itsthewoluff · 08/11/2026 18:15

You sound so passive as if you have no say.
You say firmly. “It’s not fair on your mum. You can’t stay here for x, y and z nights.”

I don’t think I’m passive considering we’ve had this same conversation with them using those words almost verbatim. I mean what do you realistically say to a 16 year old when they say “you’re not listening to me” when we’ve told them that and they insist they’d prefer to stay here and don’t want to go to the other house. We also care about their wellbeing these are important years for both.

OP posts:
HelenaWaiting · 08/11/2026 18:17

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 17:12

That’s what their father believe and has said to be based on the conversations he has had with them. They haven’t explicitly said that though so it might not even materialise. It’s up to them even in family law they’re over the age where they’d be the ones to make the decisions not really the parents it’s more the children and how they feel which is why I’m confused why people are saying “children shouldn’t get what they want” emotionally believe children should get what they want. If they want a new arrangement legally they would be entitled to that I think it’s age 11 or 12 and up the child decided which parents they would want to live work and in this case the eldest is 16 and youngest just turned 14

Wow. You've really looked into this, haven't you? I think you know exactly what you're doing, OP, and I don't believe for a second that your husband is "trying to navigate" this. He just sticks to the access arrangement and there is no navigation required. I do wonder what part of "the novelty will wear off" is played by changing the access arrangement in your husband's favour.

You also did not start this thread looking for solutions; you were looking for a bitch-fest about the ex-wife. I can't believe that "the children won't listen" is your strongest argument here. That is the worst parenting ever - you're basically using the kids to hurt the ex whilst trying to absolve yourself of guilt. Utterly vile.

PigeonsAmongstTheCats · 08/11/2026 18:18

Just seen they're 16 and 14. On that basis they should really be able to be at whichever home they want to be at, and their mother really does need to accept it provided they keep her informed about their plans.

Calliopespa · 08/11/2026 18:21

Mapletree1985 · 08/11/2026 18:14

That was my own question! Pleased to see that it was the very first response.

I'm getting a bit tired, I think, of second wives pretending they don't understand why the ex-wife get distressed by such things. If they really don't understand, then they are sorely lacking in basic empathy.

I'm sure the first wife does not think her feelings are reasonable. She may be very ashamed of feeling this way, or at the very least annoyed with herself. The logical side of her brain probably does accept the situation and has moved on. But sadly, we are not in control of our emotions. Perhaps one day something will happen to make OP feel sadly nostalgic and then she will have a better understanding.

I'm getting a bit tired, I think, of second wives pretending they don't understand why the ex-wife get distressed by such things. If they really don't understand, then they are sorely lacking in basic empathy.

I am too. But actually, the more I read these sorts of threads, there are little hints here and there that make me realise they are fundamentally driven by insecurity, a kind of driving need to diss the previous marriage and devalue both it and the ex. Ultimately, for all the bravado about the naturalness of moving on, I don't think women find it easy being a second and sometimes feel a degree of Daphne du Maurier style haunting by the reality of what preceded their own relationship, and of course that is worse where there are dc on the scene and so, in a sense, an unbreakable bond via the dc. I think it is interesting this thread has been started within 3 months of the op now having "a family" with the DH.

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 18:21

theleafandnotthetree · 08/11/2026 18:16

I am seperated and once my son got towards the 16 or 17 mark, he seemed to gravitate more towards his Dad's house, whereas my daughter is more orientated towards mine. I think gender plays a huge role vs the quality of relationship. My children are close to both of us. My daughter would probably like to be here full time and I am pretty insistent that she is with her Dad most of the time she is meant to be - and she is very mindful of his feelings and agrees to that. Neither my ex or my son are as sensitive to feelings as my daughter and I are and so my ex would never do anything to encourage my son to think of me. The mum in the OP's scenario is unfortunate in having boys and also possibly in having an ex who is, as most 'good' Dad's are in seperation situations, overly pandering to his sons and not willing to say 'oy, stop being a twat and go spend a few evenings at your mums'

Yeah I believe it’s gender that is at play here. I don’t think it’s anything personal to their mum because they can’t seem to give a reason or say if anything has happened. DH has tried many times to tell them to just go back to their mums when they’re there apprently they’re just being grumpy with her but that’s not the behaviour we get here. Even there she struggles to get them to do chores etc and always asks dh about it but here we’ve never had to ask them they’ve always just follows the rota. We have really tried to get to the bottom of it. Behaviour hasn’t changed, they just put on an act at mums, dh has talked to them plenty of times they’re not listening when they go back.

OP posts:
QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 18:22

Calliopespa · 08/11/2026 18:21

I'm getting a bit tired, I think, of second wives pretending they don't understand why the ex-wife get distressed by such things. If they really don't understand, then they are sorely lacking in basic empathy.

I am too. But actually, the more I read these sorts of threads, there are little hints here and there that make me realise they are fundamentally driven by insecurity, a kind of driving need to diss the previous marriage and devalue both it and the ex. Ultimately, for all the bravado about the naturalness of moving on, I don't think women find it easy being a second and sometimes feel a degree of Daphne du Maurier style haunting by the reality of what preceded their own relationship, and of course that is worse where there are dc on the scene and so, in a sense, an unbreakable bond via the dc. I think it is interesting this thread has been started within 3 months of the op now having "a family" with the DH.

Maybe that’s exactly what it is

OP posts:
StarDolphins · 08/11/2026 18:23

How old were the children when you met them up and how much time did they spend at yours then? Every other weekend or more/less?

Animatic · 08/11/2026 18:25

DogAnxiety · 08/11/2026 14:28

What’s with the weird obsession with vaping?!

Presumably that's OP's attempt at showing off how little she knows about what teens can do if not cooing over her baby in her perfect family unit complemented with 4 grandparents.

Calliopespa · 08/11/2026 18:26

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 18:22

Maybe that’s exactly what it is

Well it isn't entirely unnatural, but better to acknowledge it than look to blame the ex for not adjusting.

maxslice · 08/11/2026 18:26

They’re boys, also, who will soon be men,so it makes sense they’d llke to spend a lot of time with their father.

kkloo · 08/11/2026 18:28

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 18:17

I don’t think I’m passive considering we’ve had this same conversation with them using those words almost verbatim. I mean what do you realistically say to a 16 year old when they say “you’re not listening to me” when we’ve told them that and they insist they’d prefer to stay here and don’t want to go to the other house. We also care about their wellbeing these are important years for both.

Do you and your husband want them to live with you?

MsPrufrockk · 08/11/2026 18:30

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 18:13

Dad things they want to move in permanently because of the things they have said to them. He hasn’t pushed them because they haven’t said it explicitly. They have said multiple times they’d rather be at dads, there’s been times where when they’re supposed to go home they say how they’d rather stay here etc. Either way they haven’t been explicit about it but they did ask for the arrangements to be changed which is what. If they change it again to spend more time at dads the way it’s currently set up that would mean they’d spend majority of their time and hardly any at their mums.

If that’s what you think they are then so be it. I can’t possible add every intricate detail to the main post as it would be too long.

I thought 'things' was a typo in your title, but you've just repeated the mistake here.

I'm not really sure what you want from posting here - this isn't your first thread about this, is it? It just seems like you want to say 'ahaha look at how happy my family is, aha why can't the ex be happy for us?'. Don't you have friends with ears you can chew off about how happy you are? (And are you REALLY that happy, because you come across like you're seeking some kind of validation/reassurance).

And yes, yes, I know, everyone is entitled to their opinion blah blah, and if I disagree with you that's OK. Please spare me that 😂

Calliopespa · 08/11/2026 18:30

Moonnstarz · 08/11/2026 18:17

Then if they want that change I would suggest they need to give a proper reason. I think you should all be sitting around together, with their mum, and for them to explain why. It all seems very vague they are telling their dad they want to be with him yet not giving a valid reason for this.

I don't think they really understand why.

I just think they are feeling a need to check their bond is secure, but that probably isn't the way they phrase it in their mind. People are so convinced that second families are natural and easy progressions that I think some of the feelings maybe don't get acknowledged, or they don;t see there is any reason to have the feelings, when in fact, everyone understandably has their own insecurities and anxieties in the situation that need careful handling.

HelenaWaiting · 08/11/2026 18:32

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 18:21

Yeah I believe it’s gender that is at play here. I don’t think it’s anything personal to their mum because they can’t seem to give a reason or say if anything has happened. DH has tried many times to tell them to just go back to their mums when they’re there apprently they’re just being grumpy with her but that’s not the behaviour we get here. Even there she struggles to get them to do chores etc and always asks dh about it but here we’ve never had to ask them they’ve always just follows the rota. We have really tried to get to the bottom of it. Behaviour hasn’t changed, they just put on an act at mums, dh has talked to them plenty of times they’re not listening when they go back.

How is there a rota for them to follow on nights they aren't supposed to be with you?

SnipSnipMrBurgess · 08/11/2026 18:35

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 18:21

Yeah I believe it’s gender that is at play here. I don’t think it’s anything personal to their mum because they can’t seem to give a reason or say if anything has happened. DH has tried many times to tell them to just go back to their mums when they’re there apprently they’re just being grumpy with her but that’s not the behaviour we get here. Even there she struggles to get them to do chores etc and always asks dh about it but here we’ve never had to ask them they’ve always just follows the rota. We have really tried to get to the bottom of it. Behaviour hasn’t changed, they just put on an act at mums, dh has talked to them plenty of times they’re not listening when they go back.

So they get to be pricks at home to their mother but saints in your house but SHE is the problem?

letmebetheone · 08/11/2026 18:36

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 18:09

And he has spoken to them about this. It’s understandable and no one’s going to upset at them for how they’re feeling. We all want them to feel emotionally secure. Things change we thought about this before having a child and it’s something we have to navigate. We are the adults I don’t think anyone should be upset at a 16 yr old especially for wanting to see their father they’re not doing anything wrong. She had had a go at him but his dad has spoken to him I think he’s been quite blunt a few times with him mum in regards to wanting to be at dads more. She’s been upset with them but it’s just how they’re feeling right now it won’t last forever. I do understand how upsetting it must be but also they’re children

Firstly you say there is nothing wrong at mums. Now she has been having a go at them.
Its very patronising of you to say 'It's understandable and no one is going to upset them for how they are feeling' and 'She has been upset with them but its just how they are feeling right now and it won't last forever' as presumably you were not privy to what was said between the kids and the mum.
You need to step back, this is for mum and dad to sort out. As the thread has gone on you are coming across as if you know these lids better than the mum.
All through the posts you have been saying how they are old enough to decide things themselves but now you say they're just children.

Glowingup · 08/11/2026 18:37

I don’t think you need to DO anything and this seems to be the problem. It’s fine just to get on with your life and let your DH sort any issues with the living situation. You don’t need to get involved or offer opinions on why the kids prefer it at yours. You can just understand that the mum is likely coming from a place of hurt and she will never be your best mate or be delighted that you’re there. But she doesn’t have to. Life goes on and the kids are old enough to make their own choices. Just live your own life and avoid getting involved.

thepariscrimefiles · 08/11/2026 18:39

QuirkyRoseLion · 08/11/2026 17:17

They’re social they go out with friends a lot, last weekend the eldest went away with friends, now that a few of his friends the older ones in the year group drive. Younger ones is always out in central London with friends. They’re not just couped up at our house. They both invite friends over all the time.

I don’t believe they get what they want. There’s rules here, there’s a chore list that they follow, they don’t have their phones out in the evening, we don’t order takeaway but that’s nothing to do with the kids we’re just not a takeaway family. They eat the food we eat, they can both cook lunch for themselves.

I don’t see anything wrong with their father saving for them some of it has come from his family. Same way they have opened up an account for the new baby he’s also part of the family he’s not taking anyone’s money. I save for my child every month, have been saving for him from day one that’s just what parents do. I don’t want him to get to 18 and have nothing. That’s nothing special about their father, all my friends with children save for their children have various accounts for them that’s not an odd thing to do. It’s not as though their mother hasn’t been saving for them either. It goes both ways.

I asked in an earlier post about your step-sons' mum's financial situation. Your household is obviously very well off and both children attend private school. Is their mum much poorer and unable to provide them with the lifestyle that they have at their dad's? Are they embarrassed to invite their friends to their mum's house? Can their dad afford to pay for expensive hobbies that their mum could never afford?

I agree with other posters that it is very unusual for a 16 year old boy to be besotted with a new baby sibling.

BetterWithPockets · 08/11/2026 18:39

This is typical MN, @QuirkyRoseLion — if you told your DSC they weren’t welcome on a night they should be at their DM’s, you’d be the evil stepmum not making your DSC welcome. If you make them welcome, you’re not thinking about their DM’s feelings…
As for all the assumptions that your DH left his ex (rather than vice versa) or that you must be the OW, or that he will — of course! — have reduced what he pays in maintenance as soon as your DC was born… Yes, some men are complete arseholes (honestly, I read some threads and just despair at the ‘D’H or ‘D’P) but not every man is. And that does seem to be accepted UNLESS they’re in a second marriage, and have the temerity to have more children — in which case, they immediately become the devil incarnate.