Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think extra lessons for top students isn’t fair?

775 replies

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:12

My DD’s state primary school has a “top maths club” and “great writers club” for the top performing students in yr 5 and 6 held outside of school hours. There is no charge for this - so it’s free childcare and free tutoring. You have to be invited. This has been running since the second week of the school year and is restarting on the first day of this half term.

By contrast, my dyslexic DD is in a group for those needing more support in writing, also outside of school hours. But they only managed 2 sessions last year and it hasn’t started back up this year. She gets ad hoc in school support; where it happens she misses other lessons that aren’t then caught up on, putting her further behind in the those.

I appreciate these children deserve challenging, but surely that could be done in class with different work and the teacher’s out of hours time, if available, used to help those struggling?

Is this even allowed in a state primary?

OP posts:
Electrickittens · 03/11/2026 18:18

Oh and DD’s primary - 3 form entry state school with a wide range of social backgrounds, including 40 percent EAL children - had loads of after school clubs that were invitation only, including lots of the sports ones, coding club, school magazine, etc. The school had a system of applications and you weren’t guaranteed to get any of them! At various times DD was disappointed not to be able to join coding club, netball club, school magazine, Spanish club etc. because other kids were chosen. The school looked at getting a mix of kids (including PP kids) in each club, so that talented kids and kids who hadn’t had an opportunity to do the club before could have a slot. (Some of the sports ones were always for the kids who were really good at a particular sport, like football team).

It’s a bit odd that some posters are generalising their own experience to all state primaries and suggesting this never happens!

Simonjt · 03/11/2026 18:18

FirmSnake · 03/11/2026 18:18

Can hardly have an orchestra of kids who can't play instruments can you?

Imagine the awful din they would create.

Yellowbelliedsapsuckeristaken · 03/11/2026 18:26

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:15

Yes, but is it right to prioritise them over children who are struggling?

Edited

Teacher is doing this in their own free time. Maybe they wanna have nice time doing fun stuff they dont get to do in class. Feel free to take unpaid overtime to do something someone else wants you to do.

RaininSummer · 03/11/2026 18:28

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 14:28

As a country we must surely "nurture" 'all' children in state education. All children are entitled to a good education and I personally think, that provision should not only be based upon your test results as delivering a successful education requires a holistic approach.

Yes I agree but the original debate centred around not providing for the highest achievers or those with noted potential to do so

oncemoreuntothebeachdearfriends · 03/11/2026 18:39

Education isn't confined to schools.
What help is she receiving at home ?

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 18:43

Simonjt · 03/11/2026 18:18

£0 if you are FSM, PP or PP+. Music lessons really aren’t the preserve of the affluent, most of the children at our sons saturday lessons weren’t at all affluent.

Which is not going to be a high percentage of children playing an instrument. Have you missed the evident decline in opportunities to take part in the expressive arts in state schools? Have you missed the prioritising of the core subjects at the expense of expressive. Have you missed how performance data is shaping how resources are allocated in schools, further eroding access to the expressive arts?

It simply isn't the case that music lessons are affordable for a vast majority of parents, I don't understand how you can argue that it isn't when it is so blatantly not the case.

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 19:01

Electrickittens · 03/11/2026 18:18

Oh and DD’s primary - 3 form entry state school with a wide range of social backgrounds, including 40 percent EAL children - had loads of after school clubs that were invitation only, including lots of the sports ones, coding club, school magazine, etc. The school had a system of applications and you weren’t guaranteed to get any of them! At various times DD was disappointed not to be able to join coding club, netball club, school magazine, Spanish club etc. because other kids were chosen. The school looked at getting a mix of kids (including PP kids) in each club, so that talented kids and kids who hadn’t had an opportunity to do the club before could have a slot. (Some of the sports ones were always for the kids who were really good at a particular sport, like football team).

It’s a bit odd that some posters are generalising their own experience to all state primaries and suggesting this never happens!

You have literally just done the same!

I can't imagine why you think schools doing something is a persuasive argument. Labels of talent at 9 and 10 are mostly misleading, you inadvertently pointed that out with your previous definition of G&T I.e. just means working at a "Greater Depth"
At this age what people interpret as Talent is more down to frequency of exposure, the child's self confidence, the socially adept child is going to be better at unintentional self promotion, your parents level of education and your maturity. Adolescence hasn't even happened which changes things again, you certainly see late Bloomers and the opposite decline with early 'talent' as it rarely based upon innate ability when kids are very young.

poetryandwine · 03/11/2026 19:06

oncemoreuntothebeachdearfriends · 03/11/2026 18:39

Education isn't confined to schools.
What help is she receiving at home ?

OP is providing significant extra support at home, including substantial tutoring, and has said so clearly.

Stepsisterfromhell · 03/11/2026 19:11

The number of children being categorised as SEN has skyrocketed in recent years so support has become spread too thin BUT there is far more support overall for SEN students than for high achievers. I had to pull my son out of his state primary school and put him in a private school because they simply could not help him. He was finishing his work half way through the lesson and spending the rest of the time helping his classmates to catch up. As sweet as he was about it, it is not ok to use a 9 year old as an unpaid teaching assistant and offer him no challenge. The private school was amazing and able to cater to all levels (he won a full bursary - could not afford it under the new rules).

hibernatinghedgehog · 03/11/2026 19:12

The number of children being categorised as SEN has skyrocketed in recent years

There hasn’t been such a big increase in the proportion of DC with SEN as some like to believe. The most recent statistics released this year show 20.8% of pupils have SEN. In 2010, it was 20.9% or 21.1% (depending on which statistics you look at - I think it is a rounding issue adding up SA, SA+ and SSEN). In 2005, it was 18%.

hibernatinghedgehog · 03/11/2026 19:14

MushMonster · 03/11/2026 12:40

WTF OP! The problem is that your child needs more help. Not that those doing well have a chance to improve and learn more. And raise the bar, which is barely getting off the ground these days, to be honest. Well done to your school! I do hope you do understand that there would be a number of autistic and ADHD children in that group too.

If your DD has been diagnosed officialy, then she presumably gets PIP. So that money can be used for private tutoring, if your school cannot manage more support than the one you already get.

PIP is for working age adults, not children. It is DLA for children and many dyslexic DC won’t be eligible. Although some are.

MyLimeGuide · 03/11/2026 19:14

DogsandDungarees · 02/11/2026 21:14

I’m sorry OP but often schools don’t provide much challenge for pupils who are academically gifted. Let them have something.

I clicked on YANBU until I read this! (Changed it now) So right! All provisions are for low ability/sen and deprived, about time the G&T (gifted and talented) got some love!

Electrickittens · 03/11/2026 19:15

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 19:01

You have literally just done the same!

I can't imagine why you think schools doing something is a persuasive argument. Labels of talent at 9 and 10 are mostly misleading, you inadvertently pointed that out with your previous definition of G&T I.e. just means working at a "Greater Depth"
At this age what people interpret as Talent is more down to frequency of exposure, the child's self confidence, the socially adept child is going to be better at unintentional self promotion, your parents level of education and your maturity. Adolescence hasn't even happened which changes things again, you certainly see late Bloomers and the opposite decline with early 'talent' as it rarely based upon innate ability when kids are very young.

I don’t think you’ve read my post properly. My description of DD’s primary is not to say all schools are like that (where have I claimed that?) But several posters on this thread were saying this couldn’t possibly and shouldn’t be the case (invitation-only clubs).

I don’t think you quite understand the point about G&T. At one point it was an actual designation with a target percentage. “Gifted” and “Talented” actually had very specific meanings in the context of that policy. Greater depth is a different way of putting something similar in more recent education policy, though it isn’t quite the same. They have both changed meaning over time in education policy. But the idea that you couldn’t have a whole class of “G&T” students relies on your own assertion, and assumption about what you think “G&T” means.

MyLimeGuide · 03/11/2026 19:16

hibernatinghedgehog · 03/11/2026 19:14

PIP is for working age adults, not children. It is DLA for children and many dyslexic DC won’t be eligible. Although some are.

16 year olds attending college can claim PIP.

ScrollingLeaves · 03/11/2026 19:17

It is a shame they are not doing more for dyslexic children, but it is great they have this special club for those who are gifted at maths.

It could be that they would need a special needs specialist for dyslexia but have more easy to come by resources for the maths.

Stepsisterfromhell · 03/11/2026 19:20

hibernatinghedgehog · 03/11/2026 19:12

The number of children being categorised as SEN has skyrocketed in recent years

There hasn’t been such a big increase in the proportion of DC with SEN as some like to believe. The most recent statistics released this year show 20.8% of pupils have SEN. In 2010, it was 20.9% or 21.1% (depending on which statistics you look at - I think it is a rounding issue adding up SA, SA+ and SSEN). In 2005, it was 18%.

In England, the percentage in primary schools has gone up from 13% a decade ago to 19% now. That is almost 1 in 5.

hibernatinghedgehog · 03/11/2026 19:21

MyLimeGuide · 03/11/2026 19:16

16 year olds attending college can claim PIP.

16 year olds in school can claim PIP too. It isn’t just those in college. For the purpose of DLA/PIP, 16y/o’s are considered adults.

OP’s DC is in primary school and a child.

Granville82 · 03/11/2026 19:21

Why should those struggling be prioritised?

ScrollingLeaves · 03/11/2026 19:32

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 19:01

You have literally just done the same!

I can't imagine why you think schools doing something is a persuasive argument. Labels of talent at 9 and 10 are mostly misleading, you inadvertently pointed that out with your previous definition of G&T I.e. just means working at a "Greater Depth"
At this age what people interpret as Talent is more down to frequency of exposure, the child's self confidence, the socially adept child is going to be better at unintentional self promotion, your parents level of education and your maturity. Adolescence hasn't even happened which changes things again, you certainly see late Bloomers and the opposite decline with early 'talent' as it rarely based upon innate ability when kids are very young.

The children I knew who were talented at a young age all carried on that way. They did have involved parents but the encouragement they got did not mean their own capacities were not innate.

Of course there are slower developers and late bloomers too

The maths club at school is so good because the school may pick up and encourage little children who show an aptitude at school regardless of whether they get help at home as well. School should help talented children whose own parents may not have recognised their potential.

I do think though that primary schools should also be funded to hire expert dyslexia help.

TwinklySquid · 03/11/2026 19:32

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:15

Yes, but is it right to prioritise them over children who are struggling?

Edited

It’s in the teachers free time . They can choose what they want . I’m an ex teacher and also dyslexic . I’m telling you; gifted kids seldom get extra support

user1470508354 · 03/11/2026 19:35

Children who are very intelligent/gifted also need additional support and challenging more than the average. They may also be very academically gifted but struggle in other areas. So yes you are being unreasonable in that sense. Why not ask about the other club, there could be a number of reasons why it hasn't continued but that isn't the children who are gifted fault.

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 19:38

Electrickittens · 03/11/2026 19:15

I don’t think you’ve read my post properly. My description of DD’s primary is not to say all schools are like that (where have I claimed that?) But several posters on this thread were saying this couldn’t possibly and shouldn’t be the case (invitation-only clubs).

I don’t think you quite understand the point about G&T. At one point it was an actual designation with a target percentage. “Gifted” and “Talented” actually had very specific meanings in the context of that policy. Greater depth is a different way of putting something similar in more recent education policy, though it isn’t quite the same. They have both changed meaning over time in education policy. But the idea that you couldn’t have a whole class of “G&T” students relies on your own assertion, and assumption about what you think “G&T” means.

I understand what the DFE meant by G&T but I am disputing the reliability of that label when 10% of the class or more could be considered G&T. It just highlights that it is a flawed social construct. For all the reasons I listed in my last post- exposure to a subject or talent, educational level of your parents, self confidence etc. the assessment is just arbitrary, that's not just my opinion, it is self evident! Given that is the case, in the OP's scenario, all it serves to do is perpetuate inequalities.

CheeseMakesMeFart · 03/11/2026 19:42

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:15

Yes, but is it right to prioritise them over children who are struggling?

Edited

Yes, because dragging down the top performers and holding them back in some misguided notion of fairness is a waste of talent and aspiration.

School is painful tedium for the brightest kids. To the point that many go off the rails completely as teenagers.

If your kid needs more help then advocate for that, not for others to have less.

Timetoeat · 03/11/2026 19:44

My child needs to be academically challenged ,he is bored in School Those that need to be challenged and those that are struggling, both have needs that should be met. If I was you,I would chase it up with the School in regards to the group for those struggling perhaps they are run by different teachers,and the teacher that was running the group is not available at the moment?
It's upsetting when your child's need are not being.

FrippEnos · 03/11/2026 19:45

Beepboobeep

you don't say why the club was incoinsustant and why its not been started up this year.

I suspect that they are teacher led clubs and the one for your struggling child has been ill possibly leading up to the teacher leaving.

Swipe left for the next trending thread