Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think extra lessons for top students isn’t fair?

775 replies

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:12

My DD’s state primary school has a “top maths club” and “great writers club” for the top performing students in yr 5 and 6 held outside of school hours. There is no charge for this - so it’s free childcare and free tutoring. You have to be invited. This has been running since the second week of the school year and is restarting on the first day of this half term.

By contrast, my dyslexic DD is in a group for those needing more support in writing, also outside of school hours. But they only managed 2 sessions last year and it hasn’t started back up this year. She gets ad hoc in school support; where it happens she misses other lessons that aren’t then caught up on, putting her further behind in the those.

I appreciate these children deserve challenging, but surely that could be done in class with different work and the teacher’s out of hours time, if available, used to help those struggling?

Is this even allowed in a state primary?

OP posts:
Ireallywantadoughnut36 · 03/11/2026 16:52

The issue here is the lack of support for your send child. It really annoys me that we always aim for the lowest option or blame a totally irrelevant group (e.g. these kids are getting something extra, and the send kids need more help, so stop the good thing). How about improving the send provision AND keeping the gifted challenge class open. It's really rare for kids in that group to be given challenge and additional stretch so that's great - be angry about the right thing, don't take away the good from a different group! It's a really common issue at the moment (e.g. stop housing for migrants because there's not enough housing for existing families - the migrants aren't the issue, it's the housing crisis). Focus on bringing up the areas things are falling over, not taking things away from others.

Studio83 · 03/11/2026 16:58

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 16:18

Do you mean, 'tier' ?

Equally, you haven't finished your sentence, 'My children' - what about them?

New to Mumsnet - I wrote a long reply and somehow it cut it off! Tried to write it again and lost steam!
what I wanted to say is that your perspective is shared both ends of the academic ability. State schools provide no additional tutoring in general for 11+ to help get into state secondary schools/grammar schools. Parents fork out thousands of pounds to tutor their kids where the state curriculum is lacking or resources are lacking. I think it’s amazing that the school offer this in your school. It is a very hot topic that you have raised and there will be polarised views. In my children’s school a huge amount of classroom time is given to those with SEN. My daughter is SEN but also top tier at a state primary. The argument could be that actually the top tier children should be helped too, especially if their secondary schools provide options are grammar or private schools. Our options are the former and our school offers nothing to help but does offer a lot of additional SEN time outside the classroom. I’d say your school are a fine rarity offering additional classes to children who may be disadvantaged but gifted in some way and to help them achieve a positive secondary school outcome is fantastic.

TheYorkshirePudding · 03/11/2026 17:03

I don’t know why people are focussing on ‘accessibility’ and acting as though everyone should be offered the exact same support. Support should be appropriate. There’s no point offering these classes for kids who can’t achieve the average levels. Horses for courses and all that.

Groothefirst · 03/11/2026 17:22

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:28

Yes, exactly. Offer these clubs fine, but why are children that need support not offered it?

The children offered this are already heavily tutored outside of school (most go to 11+ five days a week in school holidays and tutoring 2-3 sessions a week during term already).

My wife ran a maths club for kids to work towards the primary maths challenge. For 2 years it was open to all. A lot of kids turned up either because they liked my wife or their parents saw it as free childcare- they couldn't cope with the maths and ended up messing around. So now it's invitation only. Would your child cope with and/or enjoy either club were they to attend? If so then you've got a reasonable argument for their attendance.The top end kids still need challenge outside what is offered in school time (no 11+ in our area but my daughter was offered an academic scholarship at a very academic school and scored top marks in SATs but was bored stupid during year 6, she would have loved a club that stretched her mathematically).

ChangePrivacyQuestion · 03/11/2026 17:30

Well, you said it yourself - it's a grammar feeder school, so they will be keen to preserve that reputation.

From my POV, good for them. If you compare attendance to additional support groups, all too often G&T ones will far outstrip the bottom ones. So if a teacher pours extra into unpaid after school support, and experience shows the bottom set either doesn't show up or shows up for childcare - with little progress at the end, of course they'll support the G&T group.

LucieO · 03/11/2026 17:33

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 11:15

I was referring to the sentence, "we need high achievers". We certainly do but we don't need to apply these rigid labels to children at 9/10 years old as it will just result in missed potential of certain groups of children.

But you have to go on what you know at the time. You can’t ignore any children showing academic promise using the theory that it may not continue. In the same way that you can’t ignore any children struggling and assume they will just catch up at some point.

flumposie · 03/11/2026 17:39

You lost me at 'free childcare'. If this is after school teachers are giving up their time for free. Can't win whatever they do.

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 17:45

Simonjt · 03/11/2026 16:44

At our sons UK primary you could only attend the sports club for a particular sport if you were on the team. You could only join ensemble club if you were grade 3 or above.

'grade 3'? Is this in a state primary school?

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 17:47

Ireallywantadoughnut36 · 03/11/2026 16:52

The issue here is the lack of support for your send child. It really annoys me that we always aim for the lowest option or blame a totally irrelevant group (e.g. these kids are getting something extra, and the send kids need more help, so stop the good thing). How about improving the send provision AND keeping the gifted challenge class open. It's really rare for kids in that group to be given challenge and additional stretch so that's great - be angry about the right thing, don't take away the good from a different group! It's a really common issue at the moment (e.g. stop housing for migrants because there's not enough housing for existing families - the migrants aren't the issue, it's the housing crisis). Focus on bringing up the areas things are falling over, not taking things away from others.

Do you honestly believe that this a whole class of G&T children? Is that probable?

DaisyJohnson · 03/11/2026 17:49

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 17:45

'grade 3'? Is this in a state primary school?

Musical instruments are assessed on grade level.

Pinkypromise43 · 03/11/2026 17:49

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:12

My DD’s state primary school has a “top maths club” and “great writers club” for the top performing students in yr 5 and 6 held outside of school hours. There is no charge for this - so it’s free childcare and free tutoring. You have to be invited. This has been running since the second week of the school year and is restarting on the first day of this half term.

By contrast, my dyslexic DD is in a group for those needing more support in writing, also outside of school hours. But they only managed 2 sessions last year and it hasn’t started back up this year. She gets ad hoc in school support; where it happens she misses other lessons that aren’t then caught up on, putting her further behind in the those.

I appreciate these children deserve challenging, but surely that could be done in class with different work and the teacher’s out of hours time, if available, used to help those struggling?

Is this even allowed in a state primary?

Are you serious? “Is it even allowed”???!

it should be commonplace in state schools! We should be pushing forward our best and brightest.

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 17:54

DaisyJohnson · 03/11/2026 17:49

Musical instruments are assessed on grade level.

Yes, I know, I reached Grade 8 in Cello and 4 in piano by the time I was 14. What gave you the impression I didn't grtaps that?

pollyglot · 03/11/2026 17:56

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 08:01

If you work for a school you are representing the school and you have to uphold Teaching Standards where the stipulations equate to practicing equitable teaching. In a state school, a teacher can't just disregard this because they are not being paid for the teaching!

Oh dear. So I was breaking the law by coming in at 7.30 a.m. for a small group of very bright year 12 kids who begged me to teach them Latin? Mea maxima culpa...

Simonjt · 03/11/2026 17:58

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 17:45

'grade 3'? Is this in a state primary school?

Yes, what do you mean by ‘grade 3’?

DanNW2025 · 03/11/2026 18:04

Beepboobeep · 02/11/2026 21:15

Yes, but is it right to prioritise them over children who are struggling?

Edited

Yes it is because generally they are not being prioritised in the actual class because of less academically gifted children.

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 18:05

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 17:54

Yes, I know, I reached Grade 8 in Cello and 4 in piano by the time I was 14. What gave you the impression I didn't grtaps that?

Sorry, 'grasp'.

DaisyJohnson · 03/11/2026 18:05

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 17:54

Yes, I know, I reached Grade 8 in Cello and 4 in piano by the time I was 14. What gave you the impression I didn't grtaps that?

Don't know why you're confused by grade 3? Why are you questioning it if you know what it is? Why would you think children in state schools can't do it?

Electrickittens · 03/11/2026 18:06

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 17:47

Do you honestly believe that this a whole class of G&T children? Is that probable?

G&T when it was used as a designation in the past (eg. during the 2000s Labour government when there was last a national G&T programme, eg. NAGTY), was at one point up to 10 percent of children. The entire idea was to stretch what are now called “greater depth” kids — not by picking out a few geniuses, but by providing differentiated teaching to the higher ability ranges much more broadly.

Why wouldn’t there be enough children? DD’s primary had at least 20 percent of kids as potential greater depth students depending on subject. These weren’t all “tutored” middle class students by any means, but included PP kids and kids across the whole range of social backgrounds. That is the entire point.

Ofsted look specifically at the range of kids getting GD scores at SATS and the teaching that they get, just as they look at SEND provision and children at all ranges of the ability scale. (I’m a school governor so have taken part in several Ofsted inspections, and also see the anonymised baseline tracking data for kids in every year group by ability range at governance meetings.) This is something that schools are supposed to do. The fact that OP’s daughter isn’t getting promised SEND provision needs to be taken up with the school, but it doesn’t mean that therefore the school shouldn’t be offering differentiated teaching at all ability ranges.

StreetFighter16 · 03/11/2026 18:08

You’re not going to like this.

The whole school day is spent teaching the children of average attainment or under. They are now the new normal and as such the whole class are taught at their level. The ones who are actually meeting age related expectations or exceeding them get precisely nothing, a few extra questions in their book that ALL children could access if they were able to / wanted to actually. Add in all the disruptions from the children with additional needs and behavioural issues and they are basically being held back. Let them have this, they deserve it. Also, it is widely publicised that children from disadvantaged backgrounds perform less well and have poorer attendance. You can invite these children to extra support out of school until the cows come home and they still generally will not attend. That’s obviously not true for everyone (as in your case) but theee is no point teachers working for free when half the invitees won’t attend regularly. If your child is struggling then maybe you need to ask for some work to complete at home on top of the school day.

JulietteRoche · 03/11/2026 18:12

YABVU. I was a high achiever and I'd have loved something like this.

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 18:13

Simonjt · 03/11/2026 17:58

Yes, what do you mean by ‘grade 3’?

I'm just very surprised a state primary school would have that expectation. I wonder where it is because these days instrument lessons are the preserve of the affluent which clearly highlights the problems with the rigid labelling of young children.

HorseandHeron · 03/11/2026 18:16

It's good to know some schools bother with this provision. My DC attended a primary school that gave loads of extra support and accolades to any pupil who succeeded in sport but treated academic excellence as though it was some sort of embarassing social failing. It made us turn to private education for their secondary schooling.

But, they should provide similarly regular support for any child who is struggling with the core subjects. Raise it with the governors.

Morecarrots · 03/11/2026 18:16

Time and funds in schools are limited. In my view the quieter children who just get on with things and who pick up things quickly don’t get attention - they aren’t reaching their potential. By comparison support is provided for those who are struggling (I know that more is wanted and understand the tension between this and funding constraints.) There are children who go through their entire school life with no addition help to aid them to reach full potential, they could achieve so much more. In the drive to inclusive education within some situations it is the more able who are let down

FirmSnake · 03/11/2026 18:18

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 18:13

I'm just very surprised a state primary school would have that expectation. I wonder where it is because these days instrument lessons are the preserve of the affluent which clearly highlights the problems with the rigid labelling of young children.

Can hardly have an orchestra of kids who can't play instruments can you?

Simonjt · 03/11/2026 18:18

Goldenbear · 03/11/2026 18:13

I'm just very surprised a state primary school would have that expectation. I wonder where it is because these days instrument lessons are the preserve of the affluent which clearly highlights the problems with the rigid labelling of young children.

£0 if you are FSM, PP or PP+. Music lessons really aren’t the preserve of the affluent, most of the children at our sons saturday lessons weren’t at all affluent.