Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If Millenniums want to buy a house...

199 replies

ThisGreyPoster · 19/03/2024 13:33

They need to lobby the government to bring house prices down by -

  • Building more social housing
  • Having rent controls
  • Increasing taxes on holiday homes and air bnbs

You have to make housing exist to be a home and not an investment vehicle. So start lobbying to change things.

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 20/03/2024 07:23

CosyKnits · 19/03/2024 13:43

Campaigns for everything you mention already exist (see Shelter's site for examples https://england.shelter.org.uk/support_us/campaigns).

But as PPs have said, the current government have no interest in doing any of those things. And I don't think it's the "Milleniums" who have been voting them in repeatedly for the last 14 years...

Oh here we go….I’ma boomer and I’ve never voted Conservative in my life.

LolaSmiles · 20/03/2024 08:04

Oh here we go….I’ma boomer and I’ve never voted Conservative in my life.
You might not have, but generational voting patterns exist.

Just like with Brexit, younger voters typically voted remain and older voters typically voted Brexit. Someone saying that isn't saying every older voter voted Brexit or every under 40 year old voted remain.

Threetimesthreeequals · 20/03/2024 08:43

RedToothBrush · 19/03/2024 22:41

Manchester is getting harder to rent in than London apparently.

What I find particularly crazy is it's more expensive to rent than get a mortgage. It's people screwed because of poor credit ratings, not because they can't 'afford' it. In theory they CAN afford the property.

Yeah that’s because the landlord needs to charge a certain amount above the mortgage to actually get the mortgage and of course, supply and demand equals profiteering and pushes house prices up, which means it takes longer to save to get a deposit so you must rent, rents go up, and the cycle elongates. It’s shit all around.

worth saying individual BTL are substantially cheaper than residential mortgages and cheaper than portfolio landlord mortgages, some of those rates are in the 3s

BIossomtoes · 20/03/2024 08:45

LolaSmiles · 20/03/2024 08:04

Oh here we go….I’ma boomer and I’ve never voted Conservative in my life.
You might not have, but generational voting patterns exist.

Just like with Brexit, younger voters typically voted remain and older voters typically voted Brexit. Someone saying that isn't saying every older voter voted Brexit or every under 40 year old voted remain.

That seems to be shifting a bit now. While those over 65 are still the most likely to vote Tory the numbers are falling. And of course the 50 to 64 age group includes seven years of boomers. What’s really striking is the proportion who have moved across to Reform. Very scary.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/1379439/uk-election-polls-by-age/

UK election polls by age 2024 | Statista

In 2024, the political party that 18 to 24 year-old's in Great Britain would be most likely to vote for was the Labour Party, at 68 percent, while among those over 65, the Conservative Party was the most popular with 33 percent intending to vote for th...

https://www.statista.com/statistics/1379439/uk-election-polls-by-age/

ThisGreyPoster · 20/03/2024 09:10

Renting used to be cheaper than a mortgage. But that is because buy to let mortgages did not exist. The only people renting out properties owned those properties outright.

OP posts:
RedToothBrush · 20/03/2024 09:20

Threetimesthreeequals · 20/03/2024 08:43

Yeah that’s because the landlord needs to charge a certain amount above the mortgage to actually get the mortgage and of course, supply and demand equals profiteering and pushes house prices up, which means it takes longer to save to get a deposit so you must rent, rents go up, and the cycle elongates. It’s shit all around.

worth saying individual BTL are substantially cheaper than residential mortgages and cheaper than portfolio landlord mortgages, some of those rates are in the 3s

Explain to me why mortgages are HIGHER where I live than rent then.

It's bullshit.

One of my best friends is a landlord. I know her figures. She doesn't need to charge more than she pays in mortgage. But she doesn't NEED to. The reason she does is so she can make enough of a profit to expand her property portfolio....

Boomer55 · 20/03/2024 09:44

VolvoFan · 19/03/2024 19:28

No.
No.
And a resounding no.

Social housing is subsidised by.. the taxpayer.
Rent controls will make being a landlord/lady, accidental or not, undesirable.
Increased taxes on holiday homes and airbnbs... you really hate people trying to make some money, don't you?

Everything is taxed, and if it's not yet taxed, it will be retrospectively taxed. I'm sick of life.

Private landlords are often subsidised to a great level than social housing.

Obviously, it would depend on whether the tenant is in receipt of benefits.

Currently, vast amounts of taxpayer mortgage is being poured into the bank accounts of private landlords.😗

BIossomtoes · 20/03/2024 09:49

Social housing isn’t subsidised at all. How many times does that have to be repeated? And somehow those who think it is fail to recognise your valid point @Boomer55.

Itloggedmeoutagain · 20/03/2024 09:51

Boomer55 · 20/03/2024 09:44

Private landlords are often subsidised to a great level than social housing.

Obviously, it would depend on whether the tenant is in receipt of benefits.

Currently, vast amounts of taxpayer mortgage is being poured into the bank accounts of private landlords.😗

Private landlord here.
Where is this subsidy that I can access? I am not subsidised by anyone.
I bought a BTL as a long term investment for when i retire. I am a couple of years in. Was almost at breaking even when the rate went up. I have increased the rent slightly after 2 years but I'm absorbing a good portion of the rise as i have good tenants.

fluffykittens208 · 20/03/2024 09:56

Itloggedmeoutagain · 20/03/2024 09:51

Private landlord here.
Where is this subsidy that I can access? I am not subsidised by anyone.
I bought a BTL as a long term investment for when i retire. I am a couple of years in. Was almost at breaking even when the rate went up. I have increased the rent slightly after 2 years but I'm absorbing a good portion of the rise as i have good tenants.

38% of private tenants receive housing benefit of some sort.. So yes a lot of landlords are subsidized by the government as tenant 's wages are too low to cover market rent. This also inflates rent.

Overthebow · 20/03/2024 10:01

Ahugga · 20/03/2024 06:56

Most millennials don't own though. Especially in Brixton. Possibly not in houseshares anymore, but most do not own. Particularly younger millennials.

I’m not sure that’s true, lots of millennials do own. I’m in the middle of the millennial generation and i don’t know anyone my age who doesn’t own. The younger millennials I know are now also buying or have already bought. We’re in the south east so not a cheap part of the country. It’s gen Z that will struggle, but millennials are generally ok.

Ahugga · 20/03/2024 10:06

Overthebow · 20/03/2024 10:01

I’m not sure that’s true, lots of millennials do own. I’m in the middle of the millennial generation and i don’t know anyone my age who doesn’t own. The younger millennials I know are now also buying or have already bought. We’re in the south east so not a cheap part of the country. It’s gen Z that will struggle, but millennials are generally ok.

There is ONS data on home ownership. Possibly in a decade most millennials might own, but currently it is not true. I do agree that gen z will struggle more.

Itloggedmeoutagain · 20/03/2024 11:18

fluffykittens208 · 20/03/2024 09:56

38% of private tenants receive housing benefit of some sort.. So yes a lot of landlords are subsidized by the government as tenant 's wages are too low to cover market rent. This also inflates rent.

I see what you mean.
My tenants are not in receipt of benefits
The problem with the price of rent is that the mortgage will only be granted if the rent is over a certain amount. Add that to the fact that you also need 25% of the price of the house as a deposit. Add that to the cost of decorating and the safety checks and the insurance. And then the landlord needs to make some profit because they're not a charity. That's why rent is as high as it is. I have arranged any repairs as soon as they've been reported. My tenants pay good money to live there. Currently under market value but still a fair amount

Twentypastfour · 20/03/2024 11:22

Ahugga · 20/03/2024 10:06

There is ONS data on home ownership. Possibly in a decade most millennials might own, but currently it is not true. I do agree that gen z will struggle more.

But I thought in the first page or two someone already cited the ONS data and actually over half of millennials do own.

The 18-34 category is obviously mostly not millennials but Gen Z but also includes a cohort still in full time education, so you’d expect it to be low.

newnamethanks · 20/03/2024 11:31

Rent controls don't work? Worked well in this country till Thatcher binned them. How do you all like the result?

fluffykittens208 · 20/03/2024 11:43

Itloggedmeoutagain · 20/03/2024 11:18

I see what you mean.
My tenants are not in receipt of benefits
The problem with the price of rent is that the mortgage will only be granted if the rent is over a certain amount. Add that to the fact that you also need 25% of the price of the house as a deposit. Add that to the cost of decorating and the safety checks and the insurance. And then the landlord needs to make some profit because they're not a charity. That's why rent is as high as it is. I have arranged any repairs as soon as they've been reported. My tenants pay good money to live there. Currently under market value but still a fair amount

That assumes you only have 20% deposit.. The average first time buyer these days has 19% deposit, i bought as a 20 something and had 15% deposit in London. I would think its better for professional landlords to go into the industry with far more equity than first time buyers... I don't see why the btl industry should be open to those with little capital, it is far more risky for the tenants if it all goes tits up and they have to pay the price too.

soscarlet · 20/03/2024 11:47

Itloggedmeoutagain · 20/03/2024 09:51

Private landlord here.
Where is this subsidy that I can access? I am not subsidised by anyone.
I bought a BTL as a long term investment for when i retire. I am a couple of years in. Was almost at breaking even when the rate went up. I have increased the rent slightly after 2 years but I'm absorbing a good portion of the rise as i have good tenants.

The value of your investment can fall as well as rise. If you’re not prepared to fully deal with that yourself maybe you should park your money somewhere much safer, such as a bank account, rather than expecting people who need a place to live to cover your losses.

Itloggedmeoutagain · 20/03/2024 12:45

soscarlet · 20/03/2024 11:47

The value of your investment can fall as well as rise. If you’re not prepared to fully deal with that yourself maybe you should park your money somewhere much safer, such as a bank account, rather than expecting people who need a place to live to cover your losses.

Where have i said i don't understand it?
As for people who need a place to live, where do you suggest they live? They don't qualify for social housing. They don't want a mortgage because they'll be moving on as they are long term contract workers at the local hospital

Itloggedmeoutagain · 20/03/2024 12:47

fluffykittens208 · 20/03/2024 11:43

That assumes you only have 20% deposit.. The average first time buyer these days has 19% deposit, i bought as a 20 something and had 15% deposit in London. I would think its better for professional landlords to go into the industry with far more equity than first time buyers... I don't see why the btl industry should be open to those with little capital, it is far more risky for the tenants if it all goes tits up and they have to pay the price too.

What assumes 20% ? Mine was 25% I've not seen one for 20%

Woahthehorsey · 20/03/2024 13:38

fluffykittens208 · 20/03/2024 09:56

38% of private tenants receive housing benefit of some sort.. So yes a lot of landlords are subsidized by the government as tenant 's wages are too low to cover market rent. This also inflates rent.

It doesn't inflate rent. HB doesn't cover the full rent if the rent is above the Local housing allowance of the area. The local housing allowance (LHA) is supposed to be set at 90% of market value, but in reality it hasn't actually moved much in the last few years, yet rents have substantially increased. So let's say a landlord is asking £1500, and LHA is £900, the tenant has to find the extra £600. Occasionally there's discretionary housing benefit which might bridge some of the gap, it's getting harder and harder to access and is only for short term (supposedly to allow the tenant to find a cheaper let or get LA housing). So landlords aren't being massively subsided by the government, yes the government pays some of some people's rents, but it won't pay the full amount of the landlord is charging over a set amount.

As for Manchester becoming harder to rent than London, I can well imagine it- I have 6 friends who are landlords, it used to be 7 and will soon be 5. As lots of small landlords (those with 1 or 2 properties) are selling up and those houses are going out of the rental market. In most cases these are family homes, 3 bed, and not first time buyer homes so it's not really helping anyone and lots of people are losing their homes.

Lots of people renting rely on housing benefit to afford their rent, if they bought, there would be no 'mortgage benefit' and therefore buying is not possible for them.

The government are penalising landlords, but not in a way that affects landlords with loads of properties - it affects the 1 or 2 properties landlords and therefore has moved lots of houses out of the rental market. This hasn't reduced house prices in Manchester at all but has caused rents to seriously hike - people are offering above the advertised rents in order to secure homes.

I don't actually have an issue with penalising private landlords, but ONLY if investment is made in social housing to replace the private rental properties that were propping up the rental shortage caused by right to buy, but it isn't doing. It's removing rental stock and not replacing it, causing demand to outstrip supply and raising rents.

Renting is necessary and social housing is necessary and we need to reduce reliance on private renting by increasing social housing. But that's not going to happen.

Threetimesthreeequals · 20/03/2024 22:30

RedToothBrush · 20/03/2024 09:20

Explain to me why mortgages are HIGHER where I live than rent then.

It's bullshit.

One of my best friends is a landlord. I know her figures. She doesn't need to charge more than she pays in mortgage. But she doesn't NEED to. The reason she does is so she can make enough of a profit to expand her property portfolio....

I dont know her lender but if she has a btl mortgage, it is a criteria of the mortgage, it’s called the ICR or an interest cover ration, it’s around 125-140%. Top slicing can be used if there is a deficit in rental income but it’s not that common. It’s why a lot of landlords, have to charge high rent or are pulling out of certain arrears because you can only do so much.

residential mortgage rates are more expensive than BTL rates, especially now people are coming off cheap fixes. Nuance here, btl rates are cheaper for individual landlords than Ltd company landlords or portfolio landlords. They may have a lower ICR too. They could also be on low long term fixes, 10 year or lifetime trackers with a small amount added to BBR, so that means rent can be cheaper. But in many circumstances it’s not

i work in mortgages

Threetimesthreeequals · 20/03/2024 22:34

Itloggedmeoutagain · 20/03/2024 09:51

Private landlord here.
Where is this subsidy that I can access? I am not subsidised by anyone.
I bought a BTL as a long term investment for when i retire. I am a couple of years in. Was almost at breaking even when the rate went up. I have increased the rent slightly after 2 years but I'm absorbing a good portion of the rise as i have good tenants.

Do you have a mortgage? speak to your broker?

prices are going up for BTL atm because it’s just not profitable for the banks, but with inflation and swaps coming down they might come back down in a bit. Hopefully you’re with a specialist lender, but there might be something you can do to improve your rate

Itloggedmeoutagain · 21/03/2024 11:54

Threetimesthreeequals · 20/03/2024 22:34

Do you have a mortgage? speak to your broker?

prices are going up for BTL atm because it’s just not profitable for the banks, but with inflation and swaps coming down they might come back down in a bit. Hopefully you’re with a specialist lender, but there might be something you can do to improve your rate

Yes i have a mortgage and a broker and I'm on the best deal. I had to change when the rate went right up. Wrong time. But these things happen

Threetimesthreeequals · 21/03/2024 11:58

Itloggedmeoutagain · 21/03/2024 11:54

Yes i have a mortgage and a broker and I'm on the best deal. I had to change when the rate went right up. Wrong time. But these things happen

Rates will come down soon, so hopefully should improve for you!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page