Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If Millenniums want to buy a house...

199 replies

ThisGreyPoster · 19/03/2024 13:33

They need to lobby the government to bring house prices down by -

  • Building more social housing
  • Having rent controls
  • Increasing taxes on holiday homes and air bnbs

You have to make housing exist to be a home and not an investment vehicle. So start lobbying to change things.

OP posts:
MouseMama · 19/03/2024 18:26

The recent abolition of the furnished holiday let tax regime is actually a significant step in the right direction for OP’s third bullet point. I would think the very significant reduction in interest deductions for mortgage payments combined with increased interest rates will necessitate plenty of holiday home owners needing to sell up.

maddening · 19/03/2024 18:28

I think this is largely a south east problem but one that any attempt to legislate to fix would cause worse outcomes elsewhere where the issue is not as acute (although from comments above changes in Scottish legislation has already impacted there and not necessarily as intended).

Overthebow · 19/03/2024 18:34

Ace56 · 19/03/2024 17:52

But technically, it does. The average age of a first time buyer now is 34, so most 34 year olds aren’t sitting in 4 bed houses, no.

No but a lot are sitting in 2 or 3 bed houses which are perfectly fine for raising a family, and working towards the next one.

Ahugga · 19/03/2024 18:36

Overthebow · 19/03/2024 18:34

No but a lot are sitting in 2 or 3 bed houses which are perfectly fine for raising a family, and working towards the next one.

Probably not working towards the next one realistically. Most are maxed out on the 2/3 bed. Loft conversion or extensions possibly. I don't know anyone under the age of 50 in anything bigger than a 3 bed semi.

Overthebow · 19/03/2024 18:45

Ahugga · 19/03/2024 18:36

Probably not working towards the next one realistically. Most are maxed out on the 2/3 bed. Loft conversion or extensions possibly. I don't know anyone under the age of 50 in anything bigger than a 3 bed semi.

I’m mid 30s in a 4 bed, south east. I have friends in 3 and 4 beds. It’s not that rare. 3 and 4 beds are the family sized houses, a 3 bed is fine to raise a family in. Starter homes are the 2 beds, most people j know started in 2 beds and worked their way up, myself included.

Meowandthen · 19/03/2024 18:49

RedToothBrush · 19/03/2024 17:55

Millennials are fine, it’s the next generations who have the problem.

I disagree to an extent.

There's a lot of houses that are 'executive' homes with just one or two people living in them. They are boomers. I think it's over 70 per cent of boomers who own their own homes - partly due to the Thatcherite years of making home ownership a big deal (and selling off council properties in the process).

They can't downsize because a) there's little suitable to downsize to b) downsizing requires millennials to be able to staircase and they can't afford to currently. So they are in the smaller family homes or starter homes so first time buyers can't get onto the market. Thus all the pressure is on the first and second tiers of the market. c) Or the financials mean there is very little financial benefit to downsizing (don't forget you are taxed to do so which you may not be if you die and your children inherit)

But boomers aren't going to live forever. There's going to be a period where they die and the property will pass to children in large numbers. And those who are tax savvy may have it in trust to grand children. So there will be a lot of people who inherit and because of the population bulge there will be a lot of houses which effectively become available.

The big issue isn't going to be that younger generations can't afford to buy. There will be plenty who receive substantial windfalls.

The problem is going to be for those young people who don't have parents or grandparents who own property or who have had their inheritance swallowed up by care fees.

This is where we will see an increasing gap between those who can and those who can't.

I also think we've invested in building a lot of the right type of home. We've built starter homes because that's where's there's been so much buzz. And the home builders built lots of executive homes chasing as much profit as possible. But this mid tier is where most of the issues are. I think as a result of people being less able to buy bigger properties we will see a lot more splitting of them because financially two medium properties will be more commercially beneficial in a refit than selling as one large property because of the distortion in the market due to demand being highest here and the supply being particularly insufficient.

So overall I think the trend will be towards smaller homes which will also mean fewer children too (especially compounded with childcare fees). Gone are the days of families with three or more kids. One is going to become the norm. Especially since it seems to be increasingly taboo for children to share rooms - this seems to be almost regarded as neglectful (another thread on MN this week really seemed to put value on this over and above non material things).

As an aside to that, younger generations are earning less. This means they have less disposable cash. The holiday cottage and second home industry is fueled by older more affluent couples and families - boomers and older Gen X's. This isn't sustainable in the long run due to aging and death so you will see the number of cottages that are financially viable reduce over time too. This will free them up for local workers to a degree.

Basically we have a housing issue which is largely tied up with generational wealth being unequal and a top heavy age demographic. As the age demographic shifts so will where the wealth is distributed. But overall the concern we should have is about inequality effectively being tied up in inheritance and there being little prospect of social mobility meaning you socio-economic class at birth with be locked for Generation Z (the one after the Millennials who are Gen Y). This is a massive shift from the last few decades where economic mobility was much more possible for Boomers, Gen X and even a fair number of Gen Y who were able to go to university unlike previous generations. This can't be undone at this point and we can only consider the implications for Generation Alpha.

FYI. You can’t put your own home in a trust to leave it grandchildren and avoid tax. That’s called a Gift sign Reservation and will not work.

BIossomtoes · 19/03/2024 18:49

Ahugga · 19/03/2024 18:36

Probably not working towards the next one realistically. Most are maxed out on the 2/3 bed. Loft conversion or extensions possibly. I don't know anyone under the age of 50 in anything bigger than a 3 bed semi.

I know a couple early 30s in a four bed detached with two kids on the M4 corridor. They first bought a two bed starter home in 2017.

Newname927 · 19/03/2024 18:51

All this does is benefit the really wealthy landlords, the ones with property portfolios who don't actually care about their properties. The more properties that come on the lower end of the market the more they'll buy further exasperating the issue.

Property portfolios need to be targeted.

phoenixrosehere · 19/03/2024 18:53

Isitovernow123 · 19/03/2024 16:47

They need to stop spending money on rubbish, save, be amenable on moving locations, and most importantly, understand that starter properties were called that for a reason.

I do think that there should be more help for key workers in specific areas though.

They need to stop spending money on rubbish, save, be amenable on moving locations, and most importantly, understand that starter properties were called that for a reason.

I heard a woman saying something similar in an interview and how she was able to do xyz because her generation worked hard only in the end to say she inherited her home from her mother. 🙄

Most of the millennials I know have mortgages, moved to areas where there were more opportunities which they had to save to do to begin with.

I also think the whole not spending money on rubbish can span many generations and it is ridiculous to single one generation out for it.

Woahthehorsey · 19/03/2024 18:54

Ahugga · 19/03/2024 18:36

Probably not working towards the next one realistically. Most are maxed out on the 2/3 bed. Loft conversion or extensions possibly. I don't know anyone under the age of 50 in anything bigger than a 3 bed semi.

I think this is something that depends on locality and social group I'm in the 'cheap' north. I live in "leafy and desirable" (the guardians words, not mine) suburb in greater Manchester. The house prices are significantly higher than the greater Manchester average. The majority of my friends and same-age acquaintances are in large 3 and 4 bed houses (not detached as that's not the local housing stock).

However I can understand that if you live elsewhere that this may not be the case, similarly people in a different socio-economic group will have very different experiences of the housing market.

I accept and understand my privilege:

  • I went to uni
  • I got a graduate job
  • I met DH when we were young

Meeting DH when young meant no pressure to marry or have kids, longer time saving available to us, no kids so could live in HMOs/less desirable areas and save. Our first home could be an unsafe building site as no kids.

But we also made some sensible financial decisions:

  • we lived in HMOs (separately and together) before buying our first house.
  • our first house was a total dive, we had no running water for several weeks at one point.
  • we bought for future value, not for where we wanted to be
  • we lived with free and second hand furniture for longer than we should have.

Again, the sensible financial decisions were greatly enable by the luck and privilege we had.

Woahthehorsey · 19/03/2024 18:59

Further to my above - I have a cousin, she balked at our first house, said she could never live somewhere so awful, had a fixed idea of the decor she wanted etc. and because of that they bought later and maxed themselves house with a house that didn't accrue value beyond market rising and they are now struggling to move up the ladder.

Their approach wasn't wrong, it was just different priorities. Similar to people who choose children or marriage first- not wrong, just different.

You can't have everything, especially not all at the same time. You make choices.

Unfortunately gen Z are going to have fewer options to choose from full stop. But for millennials, there were more choices before.

5foot5 · 19/03/2024 19:06

CuteCillian · 19/03/2024 13:59

I have 5 millennial nephews/nieces. Without exception, they all own property and have not received an inheritance.

Similar.

I have a nephew in his late 30s and three nephews and nieces in late 20s, plus DD, who at 28 just counts as a millennial. All either have their own property or, in the case of one nephew, are in the process of buying.

I guess location is a big factor.

The only one of the above who had financial help from parents was eldest nephew who was buying in South East and had help with the deposit from his mother.

The rest are in North and North West. We could afford to help DD and offered to but she said she wanted to do it for herself. In the end she let us chip in and pay her solicitor fees and removal fees.

She is not on a particularly high salary. Sone of her friends are also now seriously looking round for their own place.

LoveSkaMusic · 19/03/2024 19:09

I bought my first house aged 33. It was a 1970's, four bed semi in Essex.

It hadn't been redecorated since 1977, so we got it comparatively cheap. We bought it because it was easy to add value and we liked the area. We spent around £30k doing it up.

That allowed us to skip some rungs on the ladder.

fluffykittens208 · 19/03/2024 19:23

Woahthehorsey · 19/03/2024 18:54

I think this is something that depends on locality and social group I'm in the 'cheap' north. I live in "leafy and desirable" (the guardians words, not mine) suburb in greater Manchester. The house prices are significantly higher than the greater Manchester average. The majority of my friends and same-age acquaintances are in large 3 and 4 bed houses (not detached as that's not the local housing stock).

However I can understand that if you live elsewhere that this may not be the case, similarly people in a different socio-economic group will have very different experiences of the housing market.

I accept and understand my privilege:

  • I went to uni
  • I got a graduate job
  • I met DH when we were young

Meeting DH when young meant no pressure to marry or have kids, longer time saving available to us, no kids so could live in HMOs/less desirable areas and save. Our first home could be an unsafe building site as no kids.

But we also made some sensible financial decisions:

  • we lived in HMOs (separately and together) before buying our first house.
  • our first house was a total dive, we had no running water for several weeks at one point.
  • we bought for future value, not for where we wanted to be
  • we lived with free and second hand furniture for longer than we should have.

Again, the sensible financial decisions were greatly enable by the luck and privilege we had.

I studied law at a RG university and dh also has a masters. Am 31. We have a 2 bed flat in nw london but we only really got it due to my dh being a 4th generation Londoner who could live at home. Though admittedly back in the 1990s at our age, family friends (accountant/solicitor) couple also bought a similar flat.

Our friend who graduated from cambridge law is in a small 3 bed in romford. Our other friend who works in a small law firm and was also from a RG uni had his two bed terraced in zone 4 purchased for him by his parents or he couldn't have afforded it. We have a doctor friend who owns a 2 bed flat.

My colleague from Hk who worked in banking for years and now in fintech bought a 2 bed terrace in zone 5 and extended (though admittedly he has his eye on early retirement). The interest on his savings pays the £800 per month mortgage. Same for my ex managee whose husband is a marketing manager and she also was a manager in financial services..

Anyway none of us are in big homes but we count ourselves lucky cos it could be much worse

mumda · 19/03/2024 19:25

How many visas were given out last year.
You need to build enough houses for them too.

Migration has needs.

VolvoFan · 19/03/2024 19:28

No.
No.
And a resounding no.

Social housing is subsidised by.. the taxpayer.
Rent controls will make being a landlord/lady, accidental or not, undesirable.
Increased taxes on holiday homes and airbnbs... you really hate people trying to make some money, don't you?

Everything is taxed, and if it's not yet taxed, it will be retrospectively taxed. I'm sick of life.

Woahthehorsey · 19/03/2024 19:30

fluffykittens208 · 19/03/2024 19:23

I studied law at a RG university and dh also has a masters. Am 31. We have a 2 bed flat in nw london but we only really got it due to my dh being a 4th generation Londoner who could live at home. Though admittedly back in the 1990s at our age, family friends (accountant/solicitor) couple also bought a similar flat.

Our friend who graduated from cambridge law is in a small 3 bed in romford. Our other friend who works in a small law firm and was also from a RG uni had his two bed terraced in zone 4 purchased for him by his parents or he couldn't have afforded it. We have a doctor friend who owns a 2 bed flat.

My colleague from Hk who worked in banking for years and now in fintech bought a 2 bed terrace in zone 5 and extended (though admittedly he has his eye on early retirement). The interest on his savings pays the £800 per month mortgage. Same for my ex managee whose husband is a marketing manager and she also was a manager in financial services..

Anyway none of us are in big homes but we count ourselves lucky cos it could be much worse

Yes, it does depend on where I the country you are. Though I have a number of friends in London, Bath and Bristol who are all homeowners, in 2,3&4 bed houses or flats. I know of very few people still renting who don't want to be, but don't doubt that others will have vastly different experiences to me- I'm an adults social worker so see a wide spectrum of social groups.

DdraigGoch · 19/03/2024 19:36

Rent controls usually make the problem worse.

Holiday homes/AirBnBs are an issue in certain touristy areas but otherwise aren't present in sufficient numbers to distort the market.

AmazingBouncingFerret · 19/03/2024 19:38

Babes, I think you’re talking to the wrong generation, I’ve owned my own home since 2002 and in less than a decade I’ll be mortgage free on my five bedroom house. I’m not the odd one out amongst my peers.

Yearendjoy · 19/03/2024 19:42

Ahugga · 19/03/2024 18:36

Probably not working towards the next one realistically. Most are maxed out on the 2/3 bed. Loft conversion or extensions possibly. I don't know anyone under the age of 50 in anything bigger than a 3 bed semi.

I'm 41 and own a 4 bed detached with a lot of land in the south. Lots of my friends are in similar.

Tontostitis · 19/03/2024 19:43

My millennial are on the housing ladder. Hard work and sacrifices same as us but they've done it.

KThnxBye · 19/03/2024 19:43

I’m a millennial, I’ve owned property for nearly twenty years and I’m a (nice) landlord.

I don’t think this is the millennials problem to solve tbh

Trolleysaregoodforemployment · 19/03/2024 19:45

soscarlet · 19/03/2024 13:46

Step one: everyone stop voting Tory ffs.

Labour are so much better...

DdraigGoch · 19/03/2024 19:45

Vanessasbag · 19/03/2024 14:34

Make HMO's illegal.

Banning the most high density form of housing is going to make the shortage a whole lot worse.

Dogdilemma2000 · 19/03/2024 19:47

ThisGreyPoster · 19/03/2024 13:58

I mean younger adults.

Ah, you mean gen-Z. Most millennials have houses. Many of us are in our 40’s.

Swipe left for the next trending thread