Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If Millenniums want to buy a house...

199 replies

ThisGreyPoster · 19/03/2024 13:33

They need to lobby the government to bring house prices down by -

  • Building more social housing
  • Having rent controls
  • Increasing taxes on holiday homes and air bnbs

You have to make housing exist to be a home and not an investment vehicle. So start lobbying to change things.

OP posts:
CroftonWillow · 19/03/2024 14:08

I honestly think all governments try their best to tackle this, it's just so incredibly difficult. You've not even mentioned the planning issues and the lack of industry labour to build the housing.

Daffodilsdaftie · 19/03/2024 14:09

BTL landlords are no longer snapping up homes. 22,000 rental properties have been removed from the market in Scotland in the past year alone, following the rent freeze policies of the Scottish government.

Yes there are too many second homes in certain places, but the main issue is not enough housing stock. We are playing musical chairs, but the chairs are being removed at pace, leaving lots of people on relatively good salaries with no where to live.

Anxiulyyy · 19/03/2024 14:10

I think the government should supply interest free mortgages for 1st time buyers with a solid job and good credit.

You see a home you want to buy and the government buys it, you move in and live there and pay the money back to the government. Every payment is a % more than you own the home, until its paid off.

Another scheme I think should happen is for social housing or key worker housing to be attached to undesirable essential jobs, such as teaching. If you are a teacher then you can get subsidised housing in the Borough that you are teaching in for example.

The council shouldn't be able to sell social housing unless they replace like for like.

Anxiulyyy · 19/03/2024 14:11

I also think they should be universities in run down areas that no one wants to live in. It will bring in international students and encourage life back into the area.

Beezknees · 19/03/2024 14:12

1offnamechange · 19/03/2024 14:06

That is exactly what I've said?

"Millennials are between 28-43 years old."

Oh, sorry! I read wrong.

ThisGreyPoster · 19/03/2024 14:16

@Daffodilsdaftie there are enough homes. But too many are rented as holiday homes.
Holiday places should be taxed heavily so that there are few. There should be an exemption for purpose built holiday complexes.

OP posts:
LolaSmiles · 19/03/2024 14:17

Well they've done nothing but penalise landlords in recent years, so that's clearly not true. If you are not already in the BTL game then you are probably finding that the figures no longer stack up, so you won't bother. If you are already in the the BTL game, chances are you are questioning whether to continue or not. But this isn't quite as great as it might first sound
What they've done is penalise smaller landlords who haven't got huge cash reserves and are possibly renting one or two properties for their pension. Or they've moved in with a partner and want the safety of still owning property in their name so they're renting their flat out.

The sorts of landlords who run large property companies are probably laughing all the way to the bank because once all the smaller landlords start selling up, there's still a need for housing and the people with huge amounts of reserves and connections will be able to fill the gap.

The Tories are rarely on the side of your average citizen, even slightly more privileged citizens.

QuiltedHippo · 19/03/2024 14:18

The only millennials I know who haven't bought a house are those in London with arts jobs

ThisGreyPoster · 19/03/2024 14:19

The small landlords I know are moving into holiday homes.

OP posts:
Twentypastfour · 19/03/2024 14:20

I am a millennial and so are pretty much everyone I see socially (sort of 30- early 40s bracket) and honestly, no, we’re not the cohort I feel sorry for.

Sure I know we all look at the houses we could have bought if only we were born 5 years earlier, but I thank my lucky starts every day that I was born when I was not ten years later.

We all had student loans on 1k or 3k a year fees, now all paid off, not the huge student loans peole in their 20s have now. Most of us feel like we got on the property ladder in difficult times albeit not as difficult as they are now.

fluffykittens208 · 19/03/2024 14:21

1offnamechange · 19/03/2024 14:03

I assume you mean millennials
If so the fact that none/hardly any of them can't afford a house is largely a london/South east fallacy.

Millennials are between 28-43 years old. A lot of them are already on the housing ladder. I'm smack bang in the middle of that and of all my peers (friends, colleagues, old uni mates, siblings, cousins and their friends) I'd say 95% own houses.

We aren't from wealthy backgrounds and I don't know anyone (of those i know well enough to know their finances) who got a huge deposit from the bank of mum and dad, mostly because mum and dad (if they own their houses) haven't made fortunes from downsizing themselves in the way people have in the South East

https://www.finder.com/uk/mortgages/home-ownership-statistics
63% of the country overall owns their home, the split by generation that would cover millenials is 54% for the older half, 35% for the younger half (albeit this goes all the way down to age 16 so the cohort of 16-34 year olds who would be counted as millennials will obviously be higher overall).

So on average nearly half of millennials already own homes, which isn't far over the country average. Of those that don't millennials are apparently going to be the generation with the largest inheritance in history so many more will inherit enough money to buy a property over the next 10-30 years.

I don't deny that its much harder to buy now than it was 20, 30 years ago. But this constant misinformation that its completely impossible is just wrong.

From the FT:
We tend to talk about the decline in young adults’ home ownership as if it were a universal phenomenon. This is wrong. The share of 25-to-34-year-olds who own their own home in the US is six percentage points lower today than it was in 1990. In Germany it’s down eight points, in France just three, but in Britain the drop is 22 points. It’s a similar story with incomes, where Britons in their thirties are tracing the same trajectories as their forebears while Americans are leaving theirs in the dust.

It is definitely worse in the uk compared to other countries. I bought in london at 27 but am the one of the few people i know who didn't get actual cash from parents (just the rent free living).

So yes i would say half of my generation own property but disproportionately it has more to do with their parents than them and we are acutely aware of that. Its not a super nice feeling.. I only bought at 27 cos i married a 4th generation Londoner!

Millennials are not as badly off as they think — but success is bittersweet

Highly educated and with earnings to match, this generation still falls behind boomers in the housing market

https://www.ft.com/content/6f7d7522-42e9-43cb-bd73-36eee6681f3e#:~:text=Britain%E2%80%99s%20millennial%20workforce%20boasts%20twice%20as%20many%20graduates%20as%20Gen%20X%20at%20the%20same%20stage%2C%20yet%20its%20incomes%20are%20tracing%20exactly%20the%20same%20path

whatkatydid2014 · 19/03/2024 14:21

I often wonder if there would be a way to set up a Government funded scheme that buys the freehold of property then sells 50/60/70 year lease to person who can’t afford to buy outright. Person buying can then either live there their entire life and by the time they die expect that the leasehold will be almost gone or if it’s sold sooner have a way to split proceeds between freeholder and leaseholder. Assume eventually have lots of housing stock owned by the scheme that you can sell a new long lease for or rent out.

Realise people would never own it in the sense of passing down to the kids but it would be a stable home that couldn’t just suddenly be sold from under you and like a freehold or long leasehold purchased property you would find it more affordable over time and if value rose a lot in early part of lease you could get some of that value out to allow you to move.

LoveSkaMusic · 19/03/2024 14:22

Just make it illegal to own any more than two residential properties. Any families must sell up when the owner dies in order to bring the number of houses down to a legal level.

Justkeepswiimming · 19/03/2024 14:25

I had the poor fortune to sit in a meeting of local councillors recently. I'm not saying which county it was, but it was a rural county, which struggles to retain young people and has large ares of high priced housing. The memo from them was basically, we don't want 1 and 2 bedroom houses in this county. This was a room full of white, reasonably wealthy people in their 60s and 70s predominantly, making decision on planning, which have huge ramifications for younger generations.

fluffykittens208 · 19/03/2024 14:28

whatkatydid2014 · 19/03/2024 14:21

I often wonder if there would be a way to set up a Government funded scheme that buys the freehold of property then sells 50/60/70 year lease to person who can’t afford to buy outright. Person buying can then either live there their entire life and by the time they die expect that the leasehold will be almost gone or if it’s sold sooner have a way to split proceeds between freeholder and leaseholder. Assume eventually have lots of housing stock owned by the scheme that you can sell a new long lease for or rent out.

Realise people would never own it in the sense of passing down to the kids but it would be a stable home that couldn’t just suddenly be sold from under you and like a freehold or long leasehold purchased property you would find it more affordable over time and if value rose a lot in early part of lease you could get some of that value out to allow you to move.

They do this in Singapore (99 years) but the big difference is all owned and maintained by government who basically charges very low maintenance fees and uses taxpayer monies to maintain and refurbish the housing estates. 85% of people live in these estates and most don't even need a deposit, they use money from their government savings funds and the mortgage is generally not more than 20% of household income (even those in bottom 30% of income distribution) which is very good for a bustling metropolis. Hence why home ownership rate is 89%.. Basically hardly any homelessness. People are pretty confident of getting stable housing. What some people even do is keep the government flat even if they can afford private housing as they move back to the government flat during their elderly years (and get healthcare subsidies)

We don't have a rich government like Singapore where they have the world's second largest sovereign wealth fund and can collect stamp duty from million dollar private property and corporate taxes to pay for these social projects.

Vanessasbag · 19/03/2024 14:29

Gymnoob · 19/03/2024 13:55

I’m not sure you mean millennials. Millennials are 30 now. Most have homes.

No. They don't.

mitogoshi · 19/03/2024 14:31

Millennials include people only 6 years younger than me, we have had ample time to buy if we chose that path (my brother didn't but that was life choices not the government's fault)

Those in their 20's have it harder but that said both my dd and dps dd are in the process of buying and neither have family handouts (apart from living rent free currently) they have saved the deposits as have their partners. All have graduate jobs

Vanessasbag · 19/03/2024 14:34

Make HMO's illegal.

mitogoshi · 19/03/2024 14:36

@Vanessasbag

HMO's are needed for many groups for many reasons, rentals are needed too. If you can't realise that you obviously haven't been in those circumstances or known/worked with groups that do.

Bookworm20 · 19/03/2024 14:37

Those in their 20's have it harder but that said both my dd and dps dd are in the process of buying and neither have family handouts (apart from living rent free currently) they have saved the deposits as have their partners. All have graduate jobs

Yes those in their 20's have it harder. But you've sort of made my point. If they have a high income and buying with a partner, and have not been paying private rents and therefore can save, of course its going to be something within reach. Average salary, buying alone, paying the stupidly high rents currently. Not a chance in many areas of the country.

QueenOfTheLabyrinth · 19/03/2024 14:37

Vanessasbag · 19/03/2024 14:34

Make HMO's illegal.

No HMO’s have their place, I’m a working class millennial & living in them is how a lot of my friends were able to save up enough for deposits on their first home.

Twentypastfour · 19/03/2024 14:40

Vanessasbag · 19/03/2024 14:34

Make HMO's illegal.

Aren’t most student housing HMOs? I don’t know where I nor most of the people I know would have lived from 18-22 without them.

Also, what’s wrong with renting somewhere cheap? I rented some right dives when I was in my early adulthood, working all hours and saving.. and then I bought. It’s kind of how things work for a huge percentage of the population isn’t it?

RedToothBrush · 19/03/2024 14:40

The oldest Millennials are 42 this year. They are largely fine. And if they've not already bought they won't be.

TwigletsAndRadishes · 19/03/2024 14:41

Yes there are too many second homes in certain places, but the main issue is not enough housing stock. We are playing musical chairs, but the chairs are being removed at pace, leaving lots of people on relatively good salaries with no where to live.

I think blaming second home owners is a bit of a red herring though. Most people who are well off enough to afford a second home buy the sorts of houses that attract a huge premium anyway. The attractive character properties in beautiful coastal or rural areas where the locals don't tend to be in high paid jobs and the local economy is built around either agriculture or tourism. The local economy benefits hugely from the influx of these affluent incomers and the money they spend in the area. That creates jobs for locals, but not jobs that pay well enough to buy houses in such desirable locations anyway.

The people prepared to pay a premium for a second home in the nicest parts of Devon or North Norfolk or the Cotswolds aren't buying an ex council semi, or a very pedestrian house on an estate built in the 90s, are they?

I think it's pretty entitled of people to expect they should be able to afford a house in a particular area just because they are originally from that area. When I bought my first two or three houses I had to compromise massively on where l lived because I simply couldn't afford to do otherwise. The London suburb where I grew up was far too expensive. I had to move to a much cheaper, much more downmarket area about 10 miles further out. It probably took me 15 years to end up somewhere I actually really wanted to live.

That can happen to anyone, not just in areas with high numbers of second home owners.

ThisGreyPoster · 19/03/2024 14:41

Most students now seem to live in purpose built student accommodation.

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread