Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If Millenniums want to buy a house...

199 replies

ThisGreyPoster · 19/03/2024 13:33

They need to lobby the government to bring house prices down by -

  • Building more social housing
  • Having rent controls
  • Increasing taxes on holiday homes and air bnbs

You have to make housing exist to be a home and not an investment vehicle. So start lobbying to change things.

OP posts:
midgetastic · 19/03/2024 14:43

Interesting article on the guardian today

The conclusion seems to be

We are not short of homes and don't need to build more

1 in 5 people are landlords

Loosely regulated , houses as investment , Private renting has screwed the housing market

Justkeepswiimming · 19/03/2024 14:46

@TwigletsAndRadishes I think you need to visit places like Cornwall, where mining and fishing cottages have been purchased en mass. The demand for these by second home owners is what has driven them out of the reach of local people. These are not large home, but small workers properties. The economy does benefit from tourists. But local people still need homes to live in.

Bluefell · 19/03/2024 14:49

House prices cannot fall. Too many people have large mortgages and would be trapped in negative equity. The banks will be at risk because houses will be worth less than the mortgage. People will struggle to move house or remortgage. Lots of people will default on their mortgages. It would be an absolute disaster for the country as a whole. The government will do anything to prop up house prices because it’s gone on for too long and too many people are in too deep. The best they can do is encourage prices to stagnate.

Daffodilsdaftie · 19/03/2024 14:50

I would ban foreign ownership of property. Lots of property here built but not lived in, held by overseas investors for capital appreciation.

dudsville · 19/03/2024 14:52

The assumption of your thread is that things would be better if only people spoke up.

TheHateIsNotGood · 19/03/2024 14:53

@Justkeepswiimming completely agree. I live in a quite unremarkable little terrace in the cheapest part of town (NW Devon) and next door is a 2nd home. They hardly ever come, completely look down their nose at me next door and add a big fat zero to the local community.

A home suitable for local people, gone for the past 8 years and it's people like this that push up the prices in what is mainly, a deprived town

easylikeasundaymorn · 19/03/2024 14:55

Twentypastfour · 19/03/2024 14:20

I am a millennial and so are pretty much everyone I see socially (sort of 30- early 40s bracket) and honestly, no, we’re not the cohort I feel sorry for.

Sure I know we all look at the houses we could have bought if only we were born 5 years earlier, but I thank my lucky starts every day that I was born when I was not ten years later.

We all had student loans on 1k or 3k a year fees, now all paid off, not the huge student loans peole in their 20s have now. Most of us feel like we got on the property ladder in difficult times albeit not as difficult as they are now.

Usually on threads like this people are insistent that its completely impossible for millennials to get on the housing ladder so I'm glad to see people on this one whose experience is more similar to mine where nearly all the milllennials I know own. Most with very average jobs and family backgrounds, not the "my parents gave me a £100k deposit" type.

Its not an "I'm alright Jack' pulling the ladder up behind me thing because I do care about those a generation/half a generation younger than me but it just really annoys me a) when "millennial"is used as some sort of shorthand for "young uns" (when most of us sadly really aren't that young anymore!) and when the London centric media forces this stereotype that just isn't true because its what THEY experience.

I completely understand that most people living in London (and other expensive areas of the country) can't afford to buy their home -if I was living there on my current wage I couldn't either. I turned down a job in oxford because I couldn't afford to live there. And I agree this is an issue and its not enough to say "Well just move somewhere cheaper then" when your job and family and friends are all in the south-east.

But "millennial" is used to evoke some avocado eating, responsibility free hipster struggling to pay the rent in their shared flat in Brixton whereas in 2024 on average we're more likely to be worrying about remortgaging a semi detached while also covering nursery fees in Leeds or Swansea!

ThisGreyPoster · 19/03/2024 14:57

dudsville · 19/03/2024 14:52

The assumption of your thread is that things would be better if only people spoke up.

No if people lobbied and campaigned.

OP posts:
Malarandras · 19/03/2024 14:57

Building more housing of all kinds - including social housing - is the one thing that will solve this. Housing professionals have been talking about the housing crisis for a long time now and at the core of the problem is too little supply. We need to build a LOT more homes across the UK. Hundreds of thousands more every year are needed.

Overthebow · 19/03/2024 15:00

1offnamechange · 19/03/2024 14:03

I assume you mean millennials
If so the fact that none/hardly any of them can't afford a house is largely a london/South east fallacy.

Millennials are between 28-43 years old. A lot of them are already on the housing ladder. I'm smack bang in the middle of that and of all my peers (friends, colleagues, old uni mates, siblings, cousins and their friends) I'd say 95% own houses.

We aren't from wealthy backgrounds and I don't know anyone (of those i know well enough to know their finances) who got a huge deposit from the bank of mum and dad, mostly because mum and dad (if they own their houses) haven't made fortunes from downsizing themselves in the way people have in the South East

https://www.finder.com/uk/mortgages/home-ownership-statistics
63% of the country overall owns their home, the split by generation that would cover millenials is 54% for the older half, 35% for the younger half (albeit this goes all the way down to age 16 so the cohort of 16-34 year olds who would be counted as millennials will obviously be higher overall).

So on average nearly half of millennials already own homes, which isn't far over the country average. Of those that don't millennials are apparently going to be the generation with the largest inheritance in history so many more will inherit enough money to buy a property over the next 10-30 years.

I don't deny that its much harder to buy now than it was 20, 30 years ago. But this constant misinformation that its completely impossible is just wrong.

It’s not even a southern thing. I’m a millennial in the south east, I have the same experience as you where everyone I know has bought a house, most of us on to our next houses, most of us without help. Sure, there’s some millennials who can’t buy but that’s been the same for all generations, not everyone will be able to. Millennials are fine, it’s the next generations who have the problem.

TwigletsAndRadishes · 19/03/2024 15:11

Justkeepswiimming · 19/03/2024 14:46

@TwigletsAndRadishes I think you need to visit places like Cornwall, where mining and fishing cottages have been purchased en mass. The demand for these by second home owners is what has driven them out of the reach of local people. These are not large home, but small workers properties. The economy does benefit from tourists. But local people still need homes to live in.

Well if the miners and fisherman and their families have been the very people selling those places to incomers at inflated prices in the first place, then presumably they have been able to upsize or move somewhere better on the proceeds as a result. After all, by your logic, those small worker's cottages would once have belonged to local workers, and they could only be bought by second homers if the local owners were willing to sell them.

There are still plenty of less desirable places in Cornwall where homes are very affordable. People just don't want to live in those towns because they prefer the prettier villages and market towns to the run of the mill post-industrial places, like Redruth. And they don't want to have to drive far to work.

It's totally understandable. I get it, but we can't all have what we want. Local economies change and evolve. If you want a buoyant local economy and a pleasant, desirable environment it stands to reason that property will be expensive. The money brought in by relocating Londoners who can work from home, second home owners and tourism in general has hugely regenerated areas that were previously in the doldrums because the traditional industries were dying out. If you take those affluent incomers out of the equation then bang goes your artisan sourdough bakery and your little retro cinema and your gastropub on every corner. The locals certainly won't have the money to keep them all afloat.

Jovacknockowitch · 19/03/2024 15:11

CranfordScones · 19/03/2024 13:52

Rent controls rarely work. And the other measures wouldn't do much either.

The big one you missed is reform of the planning system. What would bring prices down is increased supply, and it's the planning system that impedes that more than anything else.

The planning system is only impeding supply of starter homes where I live. It’s encouraging the construction of thousands of 4 and 5 bed places on productive farmland, so there isn’t a lack of building, just building the wrong things.

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 19/03/2024 15:16

But where are we going to build the ‘hundreds of thousands’ of new homes? Most of the empty land is in the wilder parts of the north of England, where most people don’t want to live, because there is nothing there ( and the land is not much use of agriculture, either). Every spare yard of the SouthEast is already earmarked for the endless rows of new builds, which are seldom supplied with schools, surgeries or even shops. The roads around them are crammed with traffic as the residents try to access the facilités of the nearest town or out of town shopping centre.

The realistic solution of course is to build up - but what people want, quite understandably, is low rise , preferably detached housing.

Never mind, the OP believes passionately that Angela has a solution , not unrelated to her experience in social housing, so we’ll just wait until the GE and all will be well.

ViciousCurrentBun · 19/03/2024 15:20

The other reason is single person households, that’s the rise of an ageing population but also less people cohabiting in the first place and divorce or breaking up being more socially acceptable. This is not a call to go back to the bad old days of unhappy marriages staying together but it has doubled from 15% to just over 30% persons being one person households. It is a huge societal shift in the demographic of this country. I have three friends divorcing currently. That’s 3 homes becoming 6 homes. I live in a 3 bed house and currently of my row of 8 identical houses, 3 are occupied by a single person, at one point 5 were.

We all know about the lack of social housing and crazy house prices being the main culprits but I’m just pointing out a less considered reason.

ThisGreyPoster · 19/03/2024 15:25

We have to build on green belt.

OP posts:
Yearendjoy · 19/03/2024 15:26

easylikeasundaymorn · 19/03/2024 14:55

Usually on threads like this people are insistent that its completely impossible for millennials to get on the housing ladder so I'm glad to see people on this one whose experience is more similar to mine where nearly all the milllennials I know own. Most with very average jobs and family backgrounds, not the "my parents gave me a £100k deposit" type.

Its not an "I'm alright Jack' pulling the ladder up behind me thing because I do care about those a generation/half a generation younger than me but it just really annoys me a) when "millennial"is used as some sort of shorthand for "young uns" (when most of us sadly really aren't that young anymore!) and when the London centric media forces this stereotype that just isn't true because its what THEY experience.

I completely understand that most people living in London (and other expensive areas of the country) can't afford to buy their home -if I was living there on my current wage I couldn't either. I turned down a job in oxford because I couldn't afford to live there. And I agree this is an issue and its not enough to say "Well just move somewhere cheaper then" when your job and family and friends are all in the south-east.

But "millennial" is used to evoke some avocado eating, responsibility free hipster struggling to pay the rent in their shared flat in Brixton whereas in 2024 on average we're more likely to be worrying about remortgaging a semi detached while also covering nursery fees in Leeds or Swansea!

Same. I'm a millennial and own a large home (with no family money to help us) as do all of my friends. I'm not sure it's us that need the help.

Jovacknockowitch · 19/03/2024 15:29

ThisGreyPoster · 19/03/2024 15:25

We have to build on green belt.

We don’t.

Adhdorlazy · 19/03/2024 15:31

The big problem is that the estate agent ‘industry’ clearly has some excellent lobbying done on its behalf.

Money was pumped into the housing market during Covid, which actually fuelled a boom.

If they’d left it alone, prices would probably have risen more slowly, but almost certainly wouldn’t have crashed.

there was so much pent up demand after lockdown it meant prices went up, but the government acted as if a property crash was imminent ( it never was)

Vanessasbag · 19/03/2024 15:36

mitogoshi · 19/03/2024 14:36

@Vanessasbag

HMO's are needed for many groups for many reasons, rentals are needed too. If you can't realise that you obviously haven't been in those circumstances or known/worked with groups that do.

You're 100% wrong there!

Vanessasbag · 19/03/2024 15:37

The upshot is that greed (private Landlords) has created the situation. Well! Who'd thought it eh.
Homes should have never ever been thought of as investment vehicles. Utter madness.

TwigletsAndRadishes · 19/03/2024 15:41

ViciousCurrentBun · 19/03/2024 15:20

The other reason is single person households, that’s the rise of an ageing population but also less people cohabiting in the first place and divorce or breaking up being more socially acceptable. This is not a call to go back to the bad old days of unhappy marriages staying together but it has doubled from 15% to just over 30% persons being one person households. It is a huge societal shift in the demographic of this country. I have three friends divorcing currently. That’s 3 homes becoming 6 homes. I live in a 3 bed house and currently of my row of 8 identical houses, 3 are occupied by a single person, at one point 5 were.

We all know about the lack of social housing and crazy house prices being the main culprits but I’m just pointing out a less considered reason.

This is so true, and often overlooked. Retired people in large family homes still have to pay fortunes in stamp duty if they want to downsize. That's wrong. They'd be more likely to move if it were not so expensive to do so.

Also it's so, so common to have single adult households with children these days, but all those absent or non-resident parents need somewhere to live too. It's not just divorce that causes this, it's become more and more acceptable and commonplace to have children knowing full well that you live, and will continue to live as a low-income single parent reliant to at least some degree on state help to afford housing. The simple fact is that so much social housing and a huge chunk of the more affordable private rented housing is taken up with single parent households and recent immigrant households.

We don't have enough social housing as it is, yet successive governments persist in selling them off at huge discounts to council tenants who almost always sell them on at great profit themselves. I disagree with selling council houses full stop, but if it must be done then there should be a sliding scale time limit on how soon you can sell them for profit, and you should have to pay back a portion of the profit in the form of a sort of capital gain tax, given that you have benefitted from a heavily discounted price to start with.

BoringBoris · 19/03/2024 15:44

Case study here:
Bought a house with partner age 26. £225k

She worked from age 15 all the way through uni and from age 16 saved about £200 a month into a house buying ISA- she got a £4k contribution from the government . Also all Christmas gifts etc went to savings. Sold all their old stuff as well. They both had entry level graduate jobs (so about £26k each at the time which is very slightly over the NMW from April for a full time worker)

Of course it varies but they went for a modest 1950s house that needed some work over time.

How would your strategy have made it better for her?

She could also have bought in the village she grew up in that is now 50% 2nd homes but it would have been a 2 bed and not a 3 bed.

The key is:
Having a 10% deposit- and sacrificing to get that from an early age
Having 2 working adults. Even on current minimum wage they would have been able to get the mortgage that they have now.
Being realistic- the 4 bed ensuite new build was £350- lots of their friends will only accept buying one of those.

LakeTiticaca · 19/03/2024 15:44

The top end of millennial is 43 so if they are not on the property ladder by now, what have they been doing for the last 20 years?

bonzaitree · 19/03/2024 15:45

ThisGreyPoster · 19/03/2024 13:33

They need to lobby the government to bring house prices down by -

  • Building more social housing
  • Having rent controls
  • Increasing taxes on holiday homes and air bnbs

You have to make housing exist to be a home and not an investment vehicle. So start lobbying to change things.

Im so glad you posted this.

Problem solved thanks to you.

WallaceinAnderland · 19/03/2024 15:46

Small problem OP.

The government don't build houses. At all.

It's a common misconception.